WSEAS Transactions on Applied and Theoretical Mechanics
Print ISSN: 1991-8747, E-ISSN: 2224-3429
Volume 22, 2027
Bi-Objective Optimization of Two-Stage Helical Gearboxes with Dual-Gear First Stage: A Comparative NSGA-II– MCDM Framework
Authors: , , , ,
Search Articles
Abstract: The bi-objective optimization of two-stage helical gearboxes involves inherent trade-offs between structural compactness and transmission efficiency, particularly when a dual-gear first-stage configuration is adopted. In such cases, selecting a representative optimal design from a Pareto-optimal solution set remains a critical challenge. This paper proposes a comparative NSGA-II–MCDM framework for the bi-objective optimization of two-stage helical gearboxes with a dual-gear first stage, aiming to minimize the bottom area of the gearbox while maximizing its efficiency. First, the NSGA-II algorithm is employed to generate a diverse set of Pareto-optimal solutions across different transmission ratios. Subsequently, three multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) methods – TOPSIS (The Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution), MARCOS (The Measurement Alternatives and Ranking according to Compromise Solution), and MABAC (The Multi-Attributive Border Approximation Area Comparison) - are independently applied to rank the Pareto-optimal solutions and select representative optimal designs. A regression-based analysis is then conducted to characterize the relationship between the overall transmission ratio and the first-stage transmission ratio associated with each MCDM method, providing insight into the structural tendencies induced by different decision-making strategies. Furthermore, a Spearman rank correlation analysis is performed to evaluate the consistency of ranking results among the considered MCDM methods. The results indicate strong and stable agreement between TOPSIS and MARCOS across the investigated transmission-ratio domain, whereas the rankings produced by MABAC exhibit lower correlation with the other methods, reflecting a distinct decision-making behavior rather than numerical inconsistency. Overall, the proposed framework not only enables effective identification of optimal gearbox designs but also offers a systematic approach for comparing decision-making strategies and assessing ranking consistency. The findings provide practical guidance for robust decision-making in multi-objective gearbox design and highlight the importance of method selection in MCDM-based optimization.
Keywords:
Two-stage helical gearbox, Dual-gear first stage, Bi-objective optimization, NSGA-II, MABAC, Gearbox bottom area, Efficiency, Multi-criteria decision-making
Pages: 16-26
DOI: 10.37394/232011.2027.22.3