Common Fixed Point Results of Suzuki-type Rational Z󰄢-contractions
PAIWAN WONGSASINCHAI, CHATUPHOL KHAOFONG
Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science and Technology
Rambhai Barni Rajabhat University, Chanthaburi 22000, THAILAND
Division of Mathematics, Faculty of Science and Technology,
Rajamangala University of Technology Krungthep (RMUTK),
2 Nang Linchi Rd., Sathorn, Bangkok 10120, THAILAND
Abstract: -In this paper, we combine the 󰄌󰄍-admissible mappings and the simulation function in this paper to
create the generalized version of Suzuki - type rational Z󰅶-contraction mapping. This notion is also employed in
the setting of metric spaces to get some common fixed point theorems. Appropriate examples are also provided
to validate the results acquired.
Key-Words: Suzuki - type rational, 󰄌󰄍-admissible mappings, Z-contraction mapping, metric spaces
Received: October 5, 2022. Revised: December 8, 2022. Accepted: January 6, 2023. Published: February 2, 2023.
1 Introduction
Samet et al., [1], proposed 󰄌-󰄢-contractive type map-
ping and 󰄌-admissible mappings. Karapinar and
Samet, [2], take the concept further by introducing
generalized 󰄌-󰄢-contractive type mapping broaden
the Banach contraction principle, Khojastesh et al.,
[3], presented simulation function and the notion of
Z-contraction with respect to simulation function. Ar-
goubi et al., [4], extend the results of Joonaghany et
al., [5]. In this paper, we introduce Suzuki - type ra-
tional Z󰅶-contraction.
For more results in rational type contractions and
Z-contractions, we refer to the papers in, [6], [7], [8],
[9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15], and references
therein.
2 Preliminaries
Throughout this article, the term refers to the set of
all nonnegative integers. Furthermore, represents
real numbers, and 
Samet et al., [1], defined the class of 󰄌- acceptable
mappings in 2012.
Definition 2.1. [1] A mapping is called
󰄌-admissible if for all 󰄝󰄏 we have
󰄌󰄝󰄏 implies 󰄌󰄝󰄏 
where 󰄌  is a given function.
Definition 2.2. [1] Let be a nonempty set, 
and 󰄌󰄍  The two
mappings is called a pair of 󰄌󰄍-admissible
mappings, if
󰄌󰄝󰄏 and 󰄍󰄝󰄏 implies
󰄌󰄝󰄏 and 󰄍󰄝󰄏 and
󰄍󰄝󰄏 and 󰄌󰄝󰄏 for all 󰄝󰄏 
Khojasteh et al., [3], introduced the simulation
function class in 2015. Furthermore, Argoubi et al.,
[4], modified the simulation function definition and
defined it as follows.
Definition 2.3. [4] A simulation function is a function
󰄑   that satisfies the following
conditions
(i) 󰄑󰄏󰄝 󰄝 󰄏 for all 󰄝󰄏 
(i) if 󰄏and 󰄝are sequences in  such
that 
󰄏 
󰄝 then

 󰄑󰄏󰄝 
Joonaghany et al., [5], proposed a new concept
of the 󰄢-simulation function, and with it, the Z󰅶-
contraction in the standard metric space. The con-
cept of the Z󰅶-contraction encompasses several dis-
tinct types of contraction, including the Z-contraction
defined in, [3].
Denote that 󰄢 󰄢 is continuous
and nondecreasing, and 󰄢 
Definition 2.4. [5] We say that 󰄑 is a
󰄢-simulation function, if there exists 󰄢 such that
(󰄑)󰄑󰄏󰄝 󰄢󰄝󰄢󰄏 for all 󰄝󰄏 
(󰄑)if 󰄏and 󰄝are the sequences in 
such that 
󰄏 
󰄝 then

 󰄑󰄏󰄝 
Let Z󰅶is a collection of all 󰄢-simulation func-
tions. Take note that “simulation” becomes “simu-
lation function” in sentence, [3].
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on MATHEMATICS
DOI: 10.37394/23206.2023.22.11
Paiwan Wongsasinchai, Chatuphol Khaofong
E-ISSN: 2224-2880
93
Volume 22, 2023
Example 2.5. [5] Let 󰄢
(i) 󰄑󰄏󰄝 󰄢󰄝 󰄢󰄏 for all 󰄝󰄏 
where 
(ii) 󰄑󰄏󰄝 󰄩󰄢󰄝󰄢󰄏for all 󰄝󰄏 
where 󰄩  so that 󰄩 and
for each 󰄝  󰄩󰄝 󰄝

󰅣󰅱 󰄩󰄏 󰄝
(ii) 󰄑󰄏󰄝 󰄢󰄝 󰄩󰄝 󰄢󰄏 for all 󰄝󰄏
where 󰄩  is a mapping
such that, for each 󰄝 

󰅣󰅱 󰄩󰄏 
It is clear that 󰄑󰄑󰄑Z󰅶
Lemma 2.6. [16] Let  be a metric space, and
let 󰄝be a sequence in such that

󰄝󰄝 
If 󰄝numbers is not a Cauchy sequence. Then,
there exists an 󰄤and monotone increasing se-
quences of natural and such that
and 󰄝󰄝 󰄤and
(i) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
(ii) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
(iii) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
(iv) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
Motivated by the all above results, we develop the
concept of Suzuki-type rational Z󰅶-contraction and
demonstrate several typical fixed point results in met-
ric spaces. We also provide an example that supports
our primary theorem.
3 Main Result
Now we state our main results.
Definition 3.1. Let  be a metric space. Let
 be two mappings. we call the pair
is Suzuki - type rational Z󰅶-contraction if for
all 󰄝󰄏 and such that
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏 󰄝󰄏 implies
󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄏  (1)
where 󰄑 Z󰅶,
󰄝󰄏 󰄍󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏
and
󰄝󰄏 󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏
󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄏
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄏
󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝
which 󰄝󰄏 󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄏
and 󰄝󰄏 󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄝
Theorem 3.2. Let be a complete metric space,
and let  be two mappings and 󰄌󰄍
 Suppose that the following condi-
tions are satisfied
(i) is pair of 󰄌󰄍- admissible mappings
(ii) there exists 󰄝 such that 󰄌󰄝󰄝
and 󰄍󰄝󰄝 
(iii) the pair  is Suzuki - type rational Z󰅶-
contraction
(iv) either, and are continuous or for every se-
quence 󰄝in such that 󰄌󰄝󰄝 and
󰄍󰄝󰄝 for all  and 󰄝
󰄜 we have 󰄌󰄝󰄝 and 󰄍󰄝󰄝 
Then and have a unique common fixed point in

Proof. By condition (ii), there exists 󰄝 such that
󰄌󰄝󰄝. Define the sequence 󰄝in by
letting 󰄝 such that
󰄝 󰄝 󰄝 󰄝 󰄝 󰄝 󰄝 󰄝
continuing in this manner, we obtain
󰄝 󰄝 and 󰄝 󰄝
From is a pair of 󰄌󰄍-admissible, we have
󰄌󰄝󰄝 󰄌󰄝󰄝 
󰄌󰄝󰄝 󰄌󰄝󰄝  and
󰄌󰄝󰄝 󰄌󰄝󰄝
continuing this process, we get
󰄌󰄝󰄝 for all 
In the same way, we get
󰄍󰄝󰄝 for all 
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on MATHEMATICS
DOI: 10.37394/23206.2023.22.11
Paiwan Wongsasinchai, Chatuphol Khaofong
E-ISSN: 2224-2880
94
Volume 22, 2023
If 󰄝 󰄝 for some  then 󰄜 󰄝is a
common fixed point for or . Consequently, we
assume that 󰄝 󰄝 for all 
Because
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
from (1), we have
󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
and
󰄢󰄝󰄝󰄢󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝

So,
󰄢󰄝󰄝 󰄢󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
Because 󰄢is strictly increasing, we have
󰄝󰄝 󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
(2)
where
󰄝󰄝 󰄍󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
(3)
and
󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
(4)
which
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝(5)
and
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
(6)
From (4), (5) and (6), we obtain
󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
If 󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄝 then by (2)
becomes
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄝
which is a contradiction. Thus we conclude that
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄝 (7)
By (2), we get
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄝
As a result, we can conclude that the sequence
󰄝󰄝 is nonnegative and nonincreasing.
Therefore, there exists such that

󰄝󰄝
We assert that Assume, on the other hand, that


󰄝󰄝 
󰄝󰄝 (8)
For each we have
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
from (1), we have
󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝 
where
󰄝󰄝 󰄍󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
and hence

 󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝

WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on MATHEMATICS
DOI: 10.37394/23206.2023.22.11
Paiwan Wongsasinchai, Chatuphol Khaofong
E-ISSN: 2224-2880
95
Volume 22, 2023
By condition 󰄑of Definition 2.4, we have

 󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝 
which is a contradiction. Thus we conclude that

󰄝󰄝 
󰄝󰄝  (9)
Now we will demonstrate that 󰄝is a Cauchy
sequence. Assume, on the other hand, that 󰄝
is not a Cauchy sequence. Then, there exists an
󰄤 and monotone increasing sequences of nat-
ural numbers and such that and
󰄝󰄝 and
(i) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
(ii) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
(iii) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
(iv) 
󰄝󰄝 󰄤
As a result of the definition of 󰄝󰄏, we have

󰄝󰄝

󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝 (10)
which
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
(11)
and
󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝 (12)
From (10), (11) and (12), we obtain

󰄝󰄝
󰄤󰄤󰄤
󰄤
(13)
and hence

󰄝󰄝 
󰄝󰄝
󰄤 
By condition 󰄑of Definition 2.4, we have

󰄝󰄝 
󰄝󰄝
󰄤  (14)
In contrast, we assert that for sufficiently large 
if  then
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝 (15)
When we let as in (15), we get the 󰄤 
contradiction. Therefore,
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
and from (1), we have
󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝

where
󰄝󰄝
󰄍󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
Therefore,

 󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝  (16)
which contradicts (14). This contradiction proves that
󰄝is a Cauchy sequence, and since is complete,
there exists 󰄜 such that 󰄝 󰄜 as 
We assert that 󰄜is a fixed point shared by and
Because and are continuous, we can conclude
that 󰄜 
󰄝 
󰄝

󰄝 󰄜
and 󰄜 
󰄝 
󰄝

󰄝 󰄜
Hence, 󰄜 󰄜 󰄜 that is, 󰄜is a common fixed
point of and From (iv), we have for every se-
quence 󰄝in such that 󰄌󰄝󰄝and
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on MATHEMATICS
DOI: 10.37394/23206.2023.22.11
Paiwan Wongsasinchai, Chatuphol Khaofong
E-ISSN: 2224-2880
96
Volume 22, 2023
󰄍󰄝󰄝for all  and 󰄝 󰄜 as
this implies 󰄝 󰄜and 󰄝 󰄜as
 Now we show that 󰄜 󰄜 󰄜Assume
󰄜 󰄜Now we assert that, for each  at least
one of the following statements is true.
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄜
or
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄜
Assume, on the other hand,
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄜
and
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄜
For some we have
󰄝󰄝 󰄝󰄜󰄜󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄝
󰄝󰄝
which is a contradiction, and thus the claim is true.
From (1), we have
󰄝󰄝󰄜󰄜 󰄝󰄜
implies
󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄜󰄝󰄜
󰄢󰄝󰄜󰄢󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄜
So,
󰄢󰄝󰄜 󰄢󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄜
Because 󰄢is strictly increasing, we have
󰄝󰄜 󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄜 (17)
where
󰄝󰄜 󰄍󰄜󰄜󰄝󰄜 (18)
and
󰄝󰄜
󰄝󰄜󰄝󰄝󰄜󰄜
󰄝󰄜󰄝󰄜
󰄝󰄝󰄜󰄜
󰄝󰄜󰄝󰄜
󰄝󰄜󰄜󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄜󰄜󰄝󰄜
󰄜󰄝 (19)
which
󰄝󰄜 󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄜 (20)
and
󰄝󰄜 󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄝 (21)
Letting in (19), we obtain

󰄝󰄜 󰄜󰄜
From (17), we have
󰄝󰄜
󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄜
󰄝󰄜 (22)
where
󰄝󰄜 󰄍󰄜󰄜󰄝󰄜
Letting in (22), we obtain
󰄜󰄜 󰄜󰄜
which is a contradiction. Therefore, 󰄜 󰄜 In the
same way, we can find that 󰄜 󰄜 Therefore, the
pair  has a common fixed point 󰄜 󰄜
󰄜
We claim and have a unique common fixed
points 󰄜󰄜  Therefore 󰄜 󰄜 󰄜 󰄜
󰄜 󰄜and 󰄜󰄜  Therefore,
󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜

󰄜󰄜
and from (1), we have
󰄑󰄌󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄢󰄜󰄜󰄢󰄌󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
Because 󰄢is strictly increasing,
󰄜󰄜 󰄌󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜 󰄜󰄜 (23)
where
󰄜󰄜 󰄍󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
and
󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜
(24)
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on MATHEMATICS
DOI: 10.37394/23206.2023.22.11
Paiwan Wongsasinchai, Chatuphol Khaofong
E-ISSN: 2224-2880
97
Volume 22, 2023
which
󰄜󰄜 󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜(25)
and 󰄜󰄜 󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜 (26)
From (24), (25) and (26), we obtain
󰄜󰄜 󰄜󰄜  (27)
From (23) and (27), we have
󰄜󰄜 󰄌󰄜󰄜󰄍󰄜󰄜󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜
󰄜󰄜
which is a contradiction. Therefore, and have a
unique common fixed point.
Corollary 3.3. Let be a complete metric space,
and let be a mapping and 󰄌󰄍
 Assume that the following conditions
are satisfied
(i) if for all 󰄝󰄏 ,
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏 󰄝󰄏 implies
󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄏  (28)
where 󰄑 Z󰅶,
󰄝󰄏 󰄍󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏
and
󰄝󰄏
󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄝
󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝
(ii) is 󰄌󰄍admissible mapping
(iii) there exists 󰄝 such that 󰄌󰄝󰄝 
(iv) either, and are continuous or for every se-
quence 󰄝in such that 󰄌󰄝󰄝 and
󰄍󰄝󰄝 for all  and 󰄝
󰄜 we have 󰄌󰄝󰄝 and 󰄍󰄝󰄝 
Then has a unique fixed point in 
Proof. The proof follows from Theorem 3.2 by taking
.
Example 3.4. Let  and let
be defined by
󰄝󰄏 󰄝󰄏 if 󰄝 󰄏
if 󰄝 󰄏
We define  by 󰄝 󰅰
and 󰄝
󰅰
for all 󰄜 . Let and are continuous self-
mappings on and 󰄌󰄍  are two
mappings defined by
󰄌󰄝󰄏 if 󰄝󰄏 
otherwise
and
󰄍󰄝󰄏 if 󰄝󰄏 
otherwise
We now define 󰄑    by
󰄑󰄏󰄝
󰄢󰄝 󰄢󰄏 for all 󰄝󰄏  and
󰄢󰄏 󰅣
. Now
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏 󰄝󰄏 implies
󰄑󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄍󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄏
󰄢󰄝󰄏󰄢󰄌󰄝󰄝󰄍󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏
󰄢󰄝󰄏󰄢󰄝󰄏
󰄝󰄏
󰄝󰄏 
where 󰄑 Z󰅶and
󰄝󰄏
󰄝󰄏󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏
󰄝󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄏󰄝
󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝
󰄝󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝󰄏󰄏󰄝
Therefore, for 󰄝󰄏 and the pair 
is a Suzuki - type rational Z󰅶contraction. In either
case 󰄌󰄝󰄏 and 󰄍󰄝󰄏 then pair 
is a Suzuki - type rational Z󰅶contraction.
As a result, the presumptions of Theorem 3.2 are
all met, and and have a common fixed point in

WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on MATHEMATICS
DOI: 10.37394/23206.2023.22.11
Paiwan Wongsasinchai, Chatuphol Khaofong
E-ISSN: 2224-2880
98
Volume 22, 2023
Acknowledgment
Paiwan Wongsasinchai (paiwan.w@rbru.ac.th)
was financially supported by the Research and
Development Institute of Rambhai Barni Rajab-
hat University. Finally, Chatuphol Khaofong
(Chatuphol.k289@hotmail.com) was financially
supported by Rajamangala University of Technology
Krungthep (RMUTK).
References:
[1] B. Samet, C. Vetro, P. Vetro, Fixed point Theo-
rems for 󰄌-󰄢- contractive type mappings, Non-
linear Anal., 75:2154-2165, 2012.
[2] E. Karapinar, B. Samet, Generalized 󰄌-󰄢-
contractive type mappings and related fixed
point theorems with applications, Abstr. Appl.
Anal., 2012:17 pages, 2012.
[3] F. Khojasteh, S. Shukla, S. Radenović, A new
approach to the study of fixed point theory for
simulation functions, Filomat, 29:1189-1194,
2015.
[4] H. Argoubi, B. Samet, C. Vetro, Nonlinear con-
tractions involving simulation functions in a
metric space with a partial order, J. Nonlinear
Sci. Appl., 8:1082-1094, 2015.
[5] Gh. Heidary J, A. Farajzadeh, M. Azhini, F.
Khojasteh, A New Common Fixed Point The-
orem for Suzuki Type Contractions via General-
ized 󰄢-simulation Functions, Sahand Commu-
nications in Mathematical Analysis, 16(1):129-
148, 2019.
[6] S. Radenović, S. Chandok. Simulation type
functions and coincidence points. Filomat,
32(1):141-147, 2018.
[7] D. Kitkuan, P. Bunpatcharacharoen, Coinci-
dence point theorems for multi-valued mapping
b-metric spaces via digraphs. Advances in Math-
ematics: Scientific Journal, 10(6):2785-2797,
2021.
[8] A. Padcharoen, J.K. Kim, Berinde type results
via simulation functions in metric spaces. Non-
linear Functional Analysis and Applications,
25(3): 511-523, 2020.
[9] S. Chandok, A. Chanda, L.K. Dey, M. Pavlović,
S. Radenović, Simulation Functions and Ger-
aghty Type Results, Bol. Soc. Paran. Mat.
39(1):35-50, 2021.
[10] A. Padcharoen, P. Kumam, P. Saipara,
P. Chaipunya, Generalized Suzuki type
-contraction in complete metric spaces,
Kragujevac J. Math. 42(3):419-430, 2018.
[11] D. Kitkuan, S. Saelee, Generalized contractions
via -contraction, Nonlinear Functional Analy-
sis and Applications, 27(3):587-601, 2022.
[12] X. Liu, A.H. Ansari, S. Chandok, S. Radenović,
On some results in metric spaces using auxiliary
simulation functions via new functions, J. Com-
put. Anal. Appl., 24:1103-1114, 2018.
[13] M.A. Kutbi, W. Sintunavarat, On new fixed
point results for 󰄌󰄢󰄑-contractive multival-
ued mappings on 󰄌-complete metric spaces and
their consequences, Fixed Point Theo. and Appl.
2015.
[14] N. Hussain, M.A. Kutbi, P. Salimi, Fixed point
Theory in 󰄌-complete metric spaces with ap-
plications, Abstract and Applied Analysis 2014,
Article ID. 280817.
[15] A. Padcharoen, P. Kumam, D. Gopal, Coinci-
dence and periodic point results in a modular
metric space endowed with a graph and appli-
cations, Creative Mathematics and Informatics,
26(1):95-104, 2017.
[16] S. Radenović, Z. Kadelburg, D. Jandrlixex, A.
Jandrlixex, Some results on weak contraction
maps, Bull. Iran. Math. Soc., 38:625-645, 2012.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on MATHEMATICS
DOI: 10.37394/23206.2023.22.11
Paiwan Wongsasinchai, Chatuphol Khaofong
E-ISSN: 2224-2880
99
Volume 22, 2023
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
The authors equally contributed in the present
research, at all stages from the formulation of the
problem to the final findings and solution.
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare
that are relevant to the content of this article.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
Paiwan Wongsasinchai (paiwan.w@rbru.ac.th)
was financially supported by the Research and
Development Institute of Rambhai Barni Rajab-
hat University. Finally, Chatuphol Khaofong
(Chatuphol.k289@hotmail.com) was financially
supported by Rajamangala University of Technology
Krungthep (RMUTK).