Proposed the use of non-intrusive technology to ticketing of public
transport vehicle passing integrating modes
FABRICIO FERREIRA CINTRA 1, CAIO FERNANDO FONTANA2, ANTONIO GIL DA SILVA
ANDRADE4, CLEDSON AKIO SAKURAI3,
1,2,3Departamento Ciências do Mar (DCMAR)
Universidade Federal de São Paulo (UNIFESP)
Av. Almirante Saldanha da Gama, 89 Santos/SP
BRAZIL
4Departamento de Tecnologia da Arquitetura
Faculdade de Arquitetura e Urbanismo (FAU)
Universidade de São Paulo (USP)
Rua Lago, 876 - Butantã, São Paulo/SP
BRAZIL
Abstract: - The urban public transport, in addition to transporting several people in a single vehicle, has the
purpose of offering an alternative mean of transportation to the car, reducing traffic jam and environmental
pollution. The main complaints from users of this mean of transportation are the long waiting times in terminal
stations, lack of agility during boarding and extended travel time. An alternative for solving such problems
would be the implementation of RFID technology in buses ratchets, which is a technology composed by a
RFID tag and a reading portal with the purpose of exchanging data using radiofrequency. This feature allows
data to be exchanged even when the tag is in motion. The aim of this research is to propose the implementation
of radiofrequency identification (RFID) technology in the public transport system in order to decrease boarding
and disembarking time at every stop, reducing total travel time.
Key-Words: - Urban public transportation, RFID, BRT, ITS, Santos, Brazil
1 Introduction
The metropolitan area ofSantos has a population
of 1,731,400 inhabitants, distributed in nine counties
(Bertioga, Cubatao, Guaruja, Itanhaem, Mongagua,
Peruibe, Praia Grande, Santos and São Vicente). In
this region, EMTU / SP is responsible for the
operation of 62 lines, with planned fleet of 529
buses that transport 5.7 million passengers per
month. Daily average users is 218 000 [1].
To meet passenger demand in these
municipalities, the region has a fleet of 529 buses,
which are transported every month a total of 5.6
million passengers in the metropolitan lines. As
there is no metropolitan terminals installed in
Santos, the lines use assigned stalls in municipal
terminals, they are: Tactical terminals and Tude
Bastos (Big Beach), Valongo (Santos), Ferry Boat
(Guaruja), Bus Terminal Guaruja, Bus Terminal
Peruíbe, Itanhaém Bus station, Bus Terminal
Mongaguá and Road Cubatao Terminal. [2][3]
Among the main manifestations of the users
regarding the service of this kind of public
transportation is the reduction of the waiting time at
the terminal platforms, greater flexibility in loading
and reduced travel time. The city of São Paulo, for
example, to meet such claims, tested the operation
Pre-shipment, during peak hours, in line with
increased demand for faster boarding and ensure
matches at the scheduled times, as determined in
Operation Work Order after an on-demand analysis,
boarding time in major terminals and time of
passage through the turnstile in vehicles of more
EARTH SCIENCES AND HUMAN CONSTRUCTIONS
DOI: 10.37394/232024.2022.2.4
Fabricio Ferreira Cintra,
Caio Fernando Fontana,
Antonio Gil Da Silva Andrade, Cledson Akio Sakurai
E-ISSN: 2944-9006
24
Volume 2, 2022
loaded lines.
In the implemented project it was registered an
improvement in boarding time users and compliance
with scheduled departures. Another positive point is
the comfort and safety for special passengers
boarding through the front door that is positioned
outside the pre-boarding area, they get preferred
entry and use of the first guaranteed seats. This
comfort extends to users who embark on collective
along the way also have the advantage of finding the
free front hall. The result of the operation was a gain
of time 10 minutes. [1], Figure 1.
Fig.1: Single Ticket System Using Mifare Card
Type (Source: SPTrans)
Another study by SPTrans with two turnstiles on
buses allowed a 38% reduction in the loading and
unloading time, and there is approximately 73 m bus
with this configuration operating in nine lines in the
south, southeast and north. The buses are articulated
and bi-articulated that provide greater interior space.
[3].
Fig. 2: Bus with two ratchets (Source: SPTrans)
With the increasing number of passengers and
demand for public transportation over the years in
this region, there is a need to reduce loading and
unloading time of these passengers to avoid
congestion on the roads and reduce the total travel
time, increasing transport efficiency. One solution
would be to implement the radio frequency
identification technology system (RFID) the ratchets
of the bus, which is composed of TAG RFID portal
and reading that will exchange data via RF even
with GAD in motion, causing there is a reduction of
approximately 30% of the total journey time.
Another important factor to reduce congestion is
to understand the bus users' profile, identifying the
origin and destination of each user and their
respective schedules. With this information you can
estimate the amount of passengers on each line,
facilitating the management of public transport, it
may readjust the bus lines, increasing the fleet at
certain times, change location of bus stops, among
other things. [8]
Thus, this paper carried out an evaluation of non-
intrusive technologies required for billing the
passage of public transport vehicles in the
metropolitan area of Santos, in order to reduce
shipping time and landing on the bus, at all
locations, reducing the total time of the trip, offering
the best operating and technological model to meet
these demands in the region. [5][6]
2 Methodology
The research method uses a qualitative method
and quantitative. The qualitative method is adopted
the multiple case study technique, the analysis of
similar projects in urban transport area (mobility).
To do so will be raised scientific articles relevant to
the subject to identify the problems in question, thus
qualifying the problem.
In the qualitative survey will be identified the
main characteristics of the problem under study and
thus allow for modeling of the system required to
perform efficiently the entry of users on the bus and
the acquisition of origin information and the user's
destination.
Through qualitative survey will be possible to
realize the problem formulation in question through
knowledge bases: Bibliographic Search;
Documentary research; and search Existing
Legislation and Regulations.
In the quantitative method is evaluated
quantitatively through the statistical techniques,
with the purpose of the organization and summary
of the data and the search for an overview of the
sample and the behavior variable, by use of relative
and percentage frequencies.
As proposed schedule, the beginning of the work
is a literature review to understand the operation of
public transport in the metropolitan area of Santos
and identify technologies that can be applied to
achieve the objectives of this course conclusion
EARTH SCIENCES AND HUMAN CONSTRUCTIONS
DOI: 10.37394/232024.2022.2.4
Fabricio Ferreira Cintra,
Caio Fernando Fontana,
Antonio Gil Da Silva Andrade, Cledson Akio Sakurai
E-ISSN: 2944-9006
25
Volume 2, 2022
work.
The main items identified are presented in
bibliographic references and serve as a basis for the
development work and achieve the expected result.
The result of the completion of course work is to
develop a proposal for an operational and
technological model that reduces boarding time and
disembarking of passengers, and record the location
of these passengers, in order to allow the
responsibility for the management of public
transport urban the possibility of readjustment of the
bus lines in accordance with the observed data
3 Operating Model Development
Initiatives to reduce the queues are being
researched, meanwhile solve problems in specific
conditions, ie in the terminal boarding or bus with
two turnstiles. The terminal solution reduces
boarding time by 10 minutes as shown in SPTrans,
2005 [1], however the landing time and shipping
outside the terminals do not change. In the case of
buses with two ratchets, there is a clear reduction,
but reduces the users of transport capacity on the
buses.
Therefore, there is a solution that meets all the
needs of passengers, in the pursuit of reducing the
time of shipment and landing in all conditions. In
this context, it comes an interesting opportunity to
research and propose solutions that meet the needs
of users.
This research project presents the application of
non-intrusive technology necessary to reduce the
boarding time and disembarking the bus,
everywhere, in order to reduce the total time of the
trip.
In addition, there is a need to understand the bus
user profile, thus this project allows us to identify
origin and destination of each user and the analysis
of this information will be possible to estimate the
number of users on each line and where. Thus, the
manager of public transport can readjust the bus
lines, increase the fleet at certain times, change the
location of bus stops, among other things.
[9][10][11]
3.1 General Objectives
This project has the overall objective to propose
the use of non-intrusive technology to ticketing for
public transport passing vehicle (bus), to reduce
shipping time, besides registering the place of
embarkation and disembarkation user (passenger).
This shipment record (source) and landing (landing)
allows for the management of urban public transport
to assess the use of each bus line and offer
consistently readjustment of them, including the
points of departure.
The specific objectives of this study we have:
identify the passenger volume at each point
of embarkation;
assess each user's travel times;
identify and assess the user profile.
3.2 Description of Technology Non Intrusive
The purpose of using a non-intrusive technology
is to allow the public transport users feel more free,
ie without the need of having to remove the card
from the electronic bus ticket or money purse,
pocket, wallet, etc. It is expected that this need
without boarding passes to be more effective
because the user simply get on the bus. To enable
this condition is proposed the use of a radio
frequency identification tag (RFID) that will be
installed on a card and that you will carry in your
bag, pocket, wallet, etc; but no one picked up the
same to validate the payment of your bus ticket is
required. [17][18][19]
The RFID (Radio Frequency Identification) is a
technology used to capture data using radio
frequency signals to accomplish this task, enabling
the identification, tracking and management
products, documents, animals or individuals without
the need for contact or visual field. One of the first
RFID passive systems emerged during the Second
World War, when aircraft were detected over long
distances by radar, but without the distinction if the
plane was an ally or enemy. Later, in the 1980s, the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)
initiated studies on the creation of technology based
on radio waves serving as benchmarks for the
development of new applications of tracking and
tracing products.
RFID systems consist of three basic components:
antenna, reader and transponders (tags or tags),
figure 3.
Fig.3: RFID Solution Components
The antenna via a radio signal, is the medium
that enables the RFID tag to exchange / send
information. They can be manufactured in various
EARTH SCIENCES AND HUMAN CONSTRUCTIONS
DOI: 10.37394/232024.2022.2.4
Fabricio Ferreira Cintra,
Caio Fernando Fontana,
Antonio Gil Da Silva Andrade, Cledson Akio Sakurai
E-ISSN: 2944-9006
26
Volume 2, 2022
shapes and sizes with different configurations and
features according to your application. The reader
through the transceiver transmits radio frequencies
that are dispersed in several directions in space, with
a variation of distance according to power output
and the radio frequency used, as shown in Figure 4.
Fig. 4: Components of RFID Solution
The RFID tags may have various formats (ring
pads, cards, etc.), sizes and materials used for their
packaging (plastic, glass, epoxy, etc.), and such
characteristics defined according to the application
environment of use and performance See the figure
5. It is the device that carries the actual data of the
RFID system, typically consisting of an antenna for
communication and an electronic microchip for
storage and computation. There are two types of
tags: active or passive. Passive tags operate without
battery, with power supplied by the reader itself
over the air waves. Already active tags have an
internal battery and typically allow reading and
writing processes.
Fig. 5: RFID Tags (Source: Texas Instruments)
RFID systems are also defined according to the
frequency range in which they operate, which can
be classified as: low frequency and high frequency
systems. The low frequency (30 kHz to 500 kHz)
are used for short reading distances, often in access
controls, traceability and having low operating
costs.
Since the high frequency (850 MHz to 950 MHz
and 2.4 GHz to 2.5 GHz) are used for averaging
readings and long distance and high speed readings
is typically used in reading tags in vehicles and
automatically collecting data.
3.3 Solution Description
In the case of the metropolitan area of Santos, the
technology can be used as follows:
1) Each user will have an electronic bus ticket
in card format that has a high-frequency
RFID tag;
2) The bus will have three RFID portals:
One located at the gateway;
Another at the output port; and
Third at the turnstile. Initially
considered keeping the ratchet in order
to ensure recovery of the passage,
however, will not have the collector and
no apparent reader.
3) The card with the RFID tag will have stored
a single and a loaded value identifier
(virtual money);
4) When the user enters the bus, the portal
recognizes the card and reads the same and
currently writes on the bus location card
obtained via the GPS (Global Positioning
System);
5) When you pass through the turnstile, the
portal reads the card and cut the amount
corresponding to passage and releases the
ratchet;
If you do not size the card or it is
fraudulent, the ratchet is not released, in
this case the user is asked to make the
payment directly to the driver.
6) When leaving the bus the portal recognizes
the card, reads the same and write on the
card the location of the bus at the location
where the user is coming down, in a similar
way when he gets on the bus.
It is noteworthy that all above operations are
carried out without the need to bring the card to a
reader, and he may meet with you in your pocket,
purse, etc.
The information recorded on the card is history
so that the user can control the use of it further when
I record the information on the card, this
information is stored in the portal and then
transmitted to the bus utility control center and / or
the responsible agency in government.
With this you can perform the necessary
analyzes for readjustment of bus lines and better
meet the user's profile.
All information will be sent via the
communication system to a centralized server, and it
will be possible to access the data and make the
necessary analysis, as shown in Figure 6.
Another identified problem is related to the
payment of the passage currently coaches have
Antena Antena
Rede
Sistema de identificação
e monitoramento
Leitor
EARTH SCIENCES AND HUMAN CONSTRUCTIONS
DOI: 10.37394/232024.2022.2.4
Fabricio Ferreira Cintra,
Caio Fernando Fontana,
Antonio Gil Da Silva Andrade, Cledson Akio Sakurai
E-ISSN: 2944-9006
27
Volume 2, 2022
collector, ie, if the user does not have the card it can
make the payment on the bus. This no longer occurs
on the bus, leaving it to the driver. However, if you
have many passengers without the card, the driver
can get overwhelmed and result in problems or
delays. This situation must be evaluated more
carefully during continuity.
One possibility is the site of expansion for
buying and selling card, not just limited seasons,
using automatic machines, Figure 7, and local sales
(kiosks) or in the local market, thereby removing the
driver's billing function .
Fig. 6: Centralized information (Source: CanryTek)
Fig. 7: Credit Sales Equipment (Source: Bilhete
Único)
4 Conclusion
The first stage of the work consisted in
understanding the activities of the current situation
of public transport and identification of relevant
technologies. With the large number of public
transport users and the total time of high trip,
consider the use of a non-intrusive technology as a
solution to reduce the time of shipment and
unloading of each passenger, and consequently the
total travel time. The implementation of a radio
frequency identification (RFID) technology is a
possibility for such activity.
With the understanding of each element was
identified that the high-frequency RFID tags are the
most suitable for allowing to perform high-speed
reading, plus the possibility of reading at greater
distances, about 20 meters.
It is expected that with the use of this
technology, there is a reduction in the shipment time
because that way the user moves the ratchet without
having to present the card and thus reduces this
time. In addition, the technology will identify the
origin and destination of each user allowing thus
conduct an evaluation of the routes used and thus
make a better planning of bus lines.
Upcoming Activities
The first step consisted of only the definition of a
conceptual model applying non-intrusive technology
to reduce user boarding time, and allows verify the
origin and destination of the same and thus
reprogram the bus lines. Thus it is understood as
future activities are:
Implement a proof of concept in some
buses to validate aspects relating to
system usability;
Evaluate its results for the reduction
achieved time due to the use of non-
intrusive technology;
Evaluate the acceptance by users.
References:
[1] SPTRANS. Relatório Técnico dos Serviços de
Pré-Embarque. 2005. Disponível em:
http://www.sptrans.com.br/pdf/biblioteca_tecni
ca/RELATORIO_TECNICO_PREEMBARQU
E.pdf Acessado em: 19.11.2014.
[2] ONIBUSBRASIL. Duas catracas reduzem em
38% o tempo de embarque e desembarque.
Disponível em:
http://onibusbrasil.com/blog/2013/11/14/duas-
catracas-reduzem-em-38-o-tempo-de-
embarque-e-desembarque/. Acessado em:
25.05.2014.
[3] G1. Ônibus com duas catracas diminuem tempo
de embarque em SP. Disponível em:
http://g1.globo.com/sao-
paulo/noticia/2011/06/onibus-com-duas-
catracas-diminuem-tempo-de-embarque-em-
sp.html. Acessado em 25.05.2014.
EARTH SCIENCES AND HUMAN CONSTRUCTIONS
DOI: 10.37394/232024.2022.2.4
Fabricio Ferreira Cintra,
Caio Fernando Fontana,
Antonio Gil Da Silva Andrade, Cledson Akio Sakurai
E-ISSN: 2944-9006
28
Volume 2, 2022
[4] DENATRAN. Portaria Denatran 570/11. 2010
Disponível em:
http://www.denatran.gov.br/siniav.htm
Acessado em: 19.11.2014
[5] SAKURAI, C. A, DIAS, E.M. MELO, V.Z.
FONTANA, C. LIGO, A.K. Technological
Model for Application of Internet of Things to
Monitor Trucks. In: 8th ITS European
Congress, 2011, Lyon. (Páginas 445 a 461)
[6] SAKURAI,C.A., LIGO, A.K., VENDRAMIN,
V.L., DIAS, M.L.R.P., DIAS, E.M. Proposal of
Integrated System for Vehicle Monitoring with
Emphasis on Goods Operations. In 18th World
Congress on Intelligent Transport Systems,
201, Orlando. (Páginas 462 a 475)
[7] BRASIL-ID. Especificações do Sistema de
identificação, Rastreamento e Autenticação de
mercadorias. Versão 1.1. 2013.
[8] BRASIL-ID. Identificador de Veículo e Carga
Eletrônico IVC-e. Versão 1.0. 2013.
[9] SAITO, H. OHARA, H. SATOH, D.
Development of real-time simulator using
traffic monitoring. IEEE International
Conference on Communications, 2000. p.195-
199.
[10] PIRKER, M. SLAMANIG, D. A Framework
for Privacy-Preserving Mobile Payment on
Security Enhanced ARM TrustZone Platforms.
IEEE 11th International Conference on Trust,
Security and Privacy in Computing and
Communications (TrustCom). 2012. p1155-
1160.
[11] VAN DER SPIEGEL, B. Railway Energy
Measuring, Managing and Billing. 6th
International Conference on the European
Energy Market. 2009. p1-8.
[12] P. KHALI, C.W. MICHAEL, H. SHAHRYAR
“Toll Collection Technology and Best
Practices”, Project 0-5217: Vehicle/License
Plate Identification for Toll Collection
Application, January 2007
[13]
[14] WOLF-RUEDIGER HANSEN. RFID for the
Optimization of Business Processes. AIM
Global, Germany. Frank Gillert. UbiConsult,
Germany.
[15] GUDYMENKO, I; KERSCHBAUM, F.; LIM,
HOON. A Privacy-Preserving E-Ticketing
System for Public Transportation Proceeding
WPES '13 Proceedings of the 12th ACM
workshop on workshop on privacy in the
electronic society pages 143-154
[16] KAUR, M.; SANDHU M.; MOHAN, N.;
SANDHU, P. RFID Technology Principles,
Advantages, Limitations & Its Applications.
International Journal of Computer and
Electrical Engineering, Vol.3, No.1, February,
2011
[17] GUBII, J.; BUYYA, R.; MARUSIC, S.;
PALANISWAMI, M. Internet of Things (IoT):
A Vision, Architectural Elements, and Future
Directions. Journal Future Generation
Computer Systems Volume 29 Issue 7,
September, 2013 Pages 1645-1660
[18] WEINSTEIN, R. RFID: A Technical
Overview and Its Application to the Enterprise.
Published by the IEEE Computer Society, JUN
2007. Pages 27-33
[19] MEZGHANI, M. Study on electronic ticketing
in public transport. MAI 2008
[20] HASAN, M.F.M. Core Network Planning,
Robi (Axiata), Dhaka, Bangladesh Tangim, G. ;
Islam, M.K. ; Khandokar, M.R.H. ; Alam, A.U.
RFID-based ticketing for public transport
system: Perspective megacity Dhaka. Computer
Science and Information Technology (ICCSIT),
2010 3rd IEEE International Conference on
(Volume:6 ). Pages 459 462
[21] LAGHARI, A.; MEMON S.; PATHAN A.
RFID Based Toll Deduction System. I.J.
Information Technology and Computer
Science, 2012, 4, pages 40-46
[22] PUHE, M.; EDELMANN.; REICHENBACH
M. Integrated urban e-ticketing for public
transport and touristic sites. Science and
Technology Options Assessment European
Parliamentary Research Service January 2014
[23] DHARANI, P.; LIPSON B.; THOMAS, D.
RFID Navigation System for the Visually
Impaired. APRIL, 2012.
[24] WEIS, S. RFID (Radio Frequency
Identification): Principles and Applications
[25] Benjamin Davis and Tony Dutzik, Frontier
Group; Phineas Baxandall, U.S. PIRG
Education Fund. Transportation and the New
Generation: Why Young People Are Driving
Less and What It Means for Transportation
Policy. APRIL, 2012.
[26] CHATTERJEE, S.; TIMANDE, B. Public
Transport System Ticketing system using RFID
and ARM processor Perspective Mumbai bus
facility B.E.S.T. International Journal of
Electronics and Computer Science Engineering
[27] YOSHIOKA, L. R. ; OLIVEIRA, M. C. ;
MARTE, C. L. ; FONTANA, C. F. ;
SAKURAI, C. A. ; YANO, E. T. . Framework
for designing automotive embedded systems
based on reuse approach. International Journal
Systems Applications, Engineering &
Development, v. 8, p. 9-17-17, 2014.
EARTH SCIENCES AND HUMAN CONSTRUCTIONS
DOI: 10.37394/232024.2022.2.4
Fabricio Ferreira Cintra,
Caio Fernando Fontana,
Antonio Gil Da Silva Andrade, Cledson Akio Sakurai
E-ISSN: 2944-9006
29
Volume 2, 2022
[28] SAKURAI, C. A.; MARTE, C. L. ;
YOSHIOKA, L. R. ; FONTANA, C. F. .
Integrating Intelligent Transportation Systems
Devices Using Power Line Communication.
international journal of energy, v. 8, p. 36-42,
2014.
[29] FONTANA, C. F. ; PAPA, F. ; MARTE, C. L.
; YOSHIOKA, L. R. ; SAKURAI, C. A. .
Intelligent Transportation System as a Part of
Seaport Terminal Management System.
international journal of systems applications,
engineering & development, v. 8, p. 41-46,
2014.
[30] YOSHIOKA, L. R. ; MARTE, C. L. ;
MICOSKI, M. ; COSTA, R. D. ; FONTANA,
C. F. ; SAKURAI, C. A. ; CARDOSO, J. R. .
Bus Corridor Operational Improvement with
Intelligent Transportation System based on
Autonomous Guidance and Precision Docking.
international journal of systems applications,
engineering & development, v. 8, p. 116-123,
2014.
[31] FERREIRA, M. L. ; MARTE, C. L. ;
MEDEIROS, J. E. L. ; SAKURAI, C. A. ;
FONTANA, C. F. . RFID for Real Time
Passenger Monitoring. Recent Advances in
Electrical Engineering, v. 23, p. 170-175, 2013.
[32] SAKURAI, C. A.; MARTE, C. L. ;
YOSHIOKA, L. R. ; FONTANA, C. F. .
Optical Character Recognition Technology
Applied for Truck and Goods Inspection.
Recent Advances in Electrical Engineering, v.
23, p. 207-214, 2013.
[33] MARTE, C. L. ; YOSHIOKA, L. R. ;
MEDEIROS, J. E. L. ; SAKURAI, C. A. ;
FONTANA, C. F. . Intelligent Transportation
System for Bus Rapid Transit Corridors
(ITS4BRT). Recent Advances in Electrical
Engineering, v. 23, p. 242-249, 2013.
[34] SAKURAI, C. A.; FONTANA, C. F. ;
YOSHIOKA, L. R. ; MARTE, C. L. ;
SANTOS, A. S. . License Plate Recognition as
a tool for Fiscal Inspection. In: 21st World
Congresso n Intelligent Transport Systems and
ITS America Annual Meeting, 2014, Detroit.
Reinventing Transportation in our Connected
World. Red Hook, NY: Curran Associates INc.,
2014. v. 1. p. 360-371.
[35] MARTE, C. L. ; FONTANA, C. F. ;
SAKURAI, C. A. ; YOSHIOKA, L. R. ;
PERON, L. ; FACIN, P. L. M. . Deploying ITS
Sub architectures over IMS (4G NGN). In: ITS
World Congress 2013, 2013, Tolyo.
Proceedings of the 20th World Congress on
Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS), 2013.
[36] SAKURAI, C. A.; FONTANA, C. F. ;
MACCAGNAN, C. M. . Smart Grid as an
infrastructures for Intelligent Transport
Systems. In: 19th ITS World Congress, 2012,
Viena. 19th ITS World Congress, 2012.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en_US
EARTH SCIENCES AND HUMAN CONSTRUCTIONS
DOI: 10.37394/232024.2022.2.4
Fabricio Ferreira Cintra,
Caio Fernando Fontana,
Antonio Gil Da Silva Andrade, Cledson Akio Sakurai
E-ISSN: 2944-9006
30
Volume 2, 2022