Highly Accurate Technique for CO-OFDM Channel Estimation
Technique Using Extreme Learning Machine (ELM)
NISHA MARY JOSEPH, PUTTAMADAPPA C.
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Dayananda Sagar University,
Kudlu gate, Hosur, Bangalore,
INDIA
Abstract: - In wireless systems, channel estimation is considered a problematic technology, due to the fact of
the difference in time between wireless channels and the noise effect. Orthogonal frequency-division
multiplexing (OFDM) is a promising candidate for future optical communications and has received wide
concern. The article proposed a Coherent Optical (CO) orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM)
scheme, which gives a scalable and flexible solution for increasing the transmission rate, being extremely
robust to chromatic dispersion as well as polarization mode dispersion. Nevertheless, both coherent detection
and OFDM are prone to phase noise due to the phase mismatch between the laser oscillators at the transmitter
and receiver sides and the relatively long OFDM symbol duration compared to that of single carrier
communications. An Extreme Learning Machine (ELM) with Pilot Assisted Equalization (PEM) is proposed
for compensation of impairments caused by fibre nonlinearity in coherent optical communication systems.
Channel estimation using ELM and the value of distortion is sent to the OSTBC receiving end based on the
distortion information the data is decoded and pilot data is removed. FFT is applied to the data and QPSK
demodulation is done in the data to get its original form. In addition, the article utilized a free-space optical
communication system of multi-input multi-output orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (MIMO-
OFDM) with a modified receiver structure. Simulation reveals that the proposed model exhibits significant
BER (0.0112) performance and provides better spectral efficiency as compared with conventional systems and
less computational complexity. This suggested that the proposed method shows better performance by using the
CO-OFDM-FSO-MIMO-ELM-based channel estimation technique for high-speed data communication
networks in real-time scenarios respectively.
Keywords: - Optical Networks, Coherent Optical Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing, Channel
Estimation, Extreme Learning Machine, Bit Error Rate and Channel Equalization.
Received: April 4, 2022. Revised: January 6, 2023. Accepted: February 12, 2023. Published: March 9, 2023.
1 Introduction
Over the past few decades, global network traffic
has grown explosively due to the demands for
higher bandwidth and faster connections of various
multimedia and data services (e.g. big data, cloud
computing, streaming video, Internet of Things,
machine-to-machine communication, and remote
surgery), [1]. Conventional cable-based
transmission approaches cannot meet the enormous
data transmission requirements. With the advantages
of low loss, large bandwidth, and anti-
electromagnetic interference, optical fibres have
replaced cables and have been widely used as the
transmission medium in fiber-to-the-home (FTTH)
networks, metropolitan area networks (MANs),
backbone networks, and transoceanic
communications, [2]. Due to the wide application of
fibre-optic networks, optical fibres exist anywhere
in modern society, and fibre can be exploited for
more functions than data transmission. In addition to
acting as the transmission medium in fibre-optic
networks, optical fibre can also act as the sensing
medium in optical fibre sensors, [3]. The fibre
channel model plays an essential role in the
simulation and design of optical fibre
communication systems. However, it is difficult for
conventional model-driven modelling to balance
accuracy and efficiency, especially in optical
orthogonal frequency division multiplexing
(OFDM) systems with complex and long-haul
transmission, [4]. Orthogonal frequency-division
multiplexing (OFDM) is a widely used
modulation/multiplexing technology in wireless and
data communications. With recent advances in high-
speed CMOS technologies and optical modulation
and detection technologies, optical OFDM at 40-
Gb/s or even 100-Gb/s information rate becomes
feasible. Together with digital coherent detection,
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
7
Volume 14, 2023
coherent optical OFDM (CO-OFDM) brings similar
benefits such as high spectral efficiency and high
receiver sensitivity as coherent single-carrier
transmission, [5]. A key feature of CO-OFDM is its
capability to insert training symbols (TS’s) at the
transmitter to facilitate channel estimation, which
provides crucial information about the transmission
channel and enables efficient digital compensation
of optical transmission impairments such as
chromatic dispersion (CD) and polarization-mode
dispersion (PMD). High peak-to-average power
ratio (PAPR) remains the main challenge of
coherent optical orthogonal frequency division
multiplexing (CO-OFDM) systems. Due to the
strong properties of selective frequency fading
channels, the research attention has been admired by
the OFDM transmission, [6].
Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing
(OFDM) technology and multi-input multi-output
(MIMO) technology are widely used in wireless
communication systems, improving spectral
efficiency, data transmission quality, and system
capacity, [7]. In MIMO-OFDM wireless
communication systems, the channel state
information (CSI) obtained by channel estimation
techniques is critical, as it has a significant impact
on the accurate implementation of coherent
detection and decoding and directly guides the
configuration of analogue and digital beam formers,
[8]. Currently, complex and extensive application
scenarios and exponentially growing data volumes
are placing increasingly high demands on the data
transmission rate and latency of the systems (e.g., 5
G requires 10-Gbits/s 20-Gbits/s peak rate and
sub-1 ms round-trip latency), [9]. Especially in
channel estimation, an increasing number of channel
coefficients and long pilot sequences need to be
trained, and increasingly stringent latency
constraints are imposed. These pose growing
challenges to existing channel estimation based on
electronic processors in terms of computing power
proportional to parallelism, data storage, and data
transmission, [10]. Specifically, channel estimation
entails large-scale complex matrix computations,
which in turn, requires a large number of transistors
working together and additional scheduling
procedures to coordinate the movement of data
involving weights, resulting in an overall latency on
the order of milliseconds. Besides, in other electrical
signal processing associated with channel estimation
(e.g., serial-to-parallel conversion and fast Fourier
transform), there is additional latency of
microseconds in signal access, processing, storage,
and transmission, [11]. Thus, key performances of
channel estimation still have room for improvement
in terms of computational speed, latency, and
parallelism and our research aims to reduce the
latency of the entire channel estimation process and
improve the computational speed and parallelism of
channel estimation.
Channel estimation schemes based on the
interference approximation method (IAM) have
been proven to be effective in suppressing the IMI
with low complexity, [12]. For the IAMs, increasing
the power of the pseudo pilot could decrease the
effects of amplified spontaneous emission (ASE)
noise and other frequency domain residual errors on
the channel estimation accuracy. In most of the
previously reported IAM works, pilot blocks were
designed according to the structure of the centre
pilot block loaded, while the two side pilots nulled
for simplicity. However, the power of the pseudo
pilot under this method did not reach the maximum,
resulting in non-optimal channel estimation
accuracy. Recently, Xi Fang suggested the channel
estimation model based on the combined phase
offset (CMPO). For the CMPO method, the first and
the third pilot blocks are also loaded with pilots.
With this consideration, a pilot structure called E-
IAM-C was proposed for OFDM/OQAM,
improving the pseudo pilot power compared with
the IAMs and PHO, [13]. However, for the E-IAM-
C method, matrix inversion is required due to the
restriction for time domain channel estimation
approaches, leading to high computational
complexity (Ling Yang, 2021). CO-OFDM has
many advantages, including scalability to the ever-
increasing data rate and transponder adaptability,
high receiver sensitivity and spectral efficiency, and
robustness against dispersion. However, the impact
of the optical channel is a major limiting factor in
CO-OFDM systems when the speed rate is up to
100 Gbit/s or higher. Therefore, it requires to use of
effective channel estimation methods to track the
channel changes. Accurate channel estimation is the
key factor to improve the receiver quality, and it is
also the main requirement to improve the
transmission performance of CO-OFDM systems,
[14]. Nevertheless, channel estimation has attracted
limited attention in the field of CO-OFDM systems
in recent years. Many channel estimation methods
were reported in the CO-OFDM system, such as
least square (LS), maximum likelihood (ML), linear
minimum mean square error (LMMSE) algorithms,
and deep neural network, [15]. Recently, a neural
network, [5] was used as a nonlinear model to
approximate the relationship between the channel
impulse response and its corresponding subcarrier
index. Most semi-blind estimation algorithms
mentioned above are based on conventional
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
8
Volume 14, 2023
feedforward neural networks. However, the
conventional feedforward neural networks are
trained by using gradient-based learning algorithms
extensively, so their learning speed is in general far
slower than required and these learning algorithms
exist local minimum problems.
Extreme Learning Machine, [16], as emergent
technology which overcomes some challenges faced
by other techniques has recently attracted more and
more attention. Consequently, the article presented
an improved channel estimation based on the ELM
algorithm with CO-OFDM with MIMO optical
communication model. The simulation results show
that the system performance of CO-OFDM is
improved by using the channel estimation presented
and it has relatively low complexity. A main
drawback of the Coherent Optical Orthogonal
Frequency Division Multiplexing (CO-OFDM)
system is its sensitivity to fibre nonlinearity. Pilot
Assisted Equalization model with ELM has been
demonstrated capable of compensating fiber
nonlinear distortion in a QPSK optical
communication system. Increasingly extensive
application scenarios and exponentially growing
data volumes of MIMO-OFDM systems have
imposed greater challenges on the speed, latency,
and parallelism of channel estimation based on
electronic processors. However, in optical
transmission, the accuracy of channel estimation is
often limited by the presence of optical noise. To
increase the accuracy of channel estimation, the
article proposes an ELM architecture to evaluate the
channel distortion with a simulated channel
response and predict the actual channel response
from the receiver.
The organization of the article is as follows. In
section 2, the literature survey of the study is
defined. The problem definition and motivation of
the work are described in division 3. In section 4,
the proposed research methodology is described. In
section 5, experimentation and result discussion are
defined. In division 6, the conclusion of the work is
described.
2 Literature Review
To know about the estimation, an Extreme Learning
Machine (ELM) technique which is based on
channel estimation has been introduced for the
execution of the CO-OFDM channel.
[17] proposed MIMO Coherent OFDM (CO-
OFDM)-based multi-beam FSO communication
system operating at 40 Gbps. The modified
GammaGamma (MGG) turbulence modelling has
been utilized for channel turbulences. The designed
communication system shows considerable
improvement in transmission distance by 3 km with
a previously used WDM-based multi-beam FSO
system. It performs better in all respects with BER
10E−11 and SNR 50 dB at a longer transmission
distance of 7 km under atmospheric turbulences at
35 dB attenuation. Further, a significant reduction in
geometric loss has been achieved for a given
distance in varying turbulence fluctuations and the
numeric values have been substantiated with Rytov
variance.
[18] discussed the frequency-domain channel
transmission model for PDM CO-OFDM/OQAM
systems. With the analysis of the correlation of the
ASE noise, we propose a combined intra-symbol
frequency-domain averaging (CISFDA) channel
estimation method for PDM OFDM/OQAM
systems. Compared with the full-loaded frequency-
domain channel estimation (FL-FD) method, the
CISFDA method promotes the system robustness
against the ASE noise and fibre nonlinear effect
significantly. The proposed method is validated by
numerical Monte Carlo simulations of the PDM
CO-OFDM/OQAM system. Our new algorithm
outperforms the FL-FD method in the 36 Gb/s PDM
OFDM CO-OFDM/OQAM system, and the
transmission distance is improved by 500 km with
the bit-error-rate (BER) target at 3.8x10-3.
[19] proposed an artificial neural network least
squares channel estimation algorithm (ANN_LS-
CEA). Firstly, the algorithm fits the time domain
waveform by ANN. Secondly, estimates the channel
transfer function (TF) in the frequency domain by
LS to effectively reduce IMI. Through a series of
simulation test data, it can be found that this
algorithm can effectively improve the overall
performance of the system. Compared with the
ANN-CEA, this algorithm can reduce the bit error
rate (BER) performance by 50%.
[20] proposed OSSB generation can provide a
tunable optical carrier-to-sideband ratio by adjusting
the polarization controller and the mathematical
principle is also discussed. Security of the system is
improved by employing matched filter before DSP
which has the property of noise rejection i.e.
waveforms can be detected in presence of a jammer.
Further, a comparison of the proposed system is
performed with QPSK-IsOWC, DP-QPSK-IsOWC,
and DP-QPSK-CO-OFDM-IsOWC systems in terms
of log BER, error vector magnitude, received power,
and optical signal to noise ratio. It is observed that
the proposed system can cover 15,900 km at 100
Gbps at a targeted log BER of 2.42 and provides
enhanced performance. As per the author’s best
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
9
Volume 14, 2023
knowledge, an IsOWC system with such bandwidth
efficient spectrum, high performance, and security
has not been reported in the past.
[21] proposed a Machine Learning (ML)-based
scheme to detect and locate physical-layer
eavesdropping. To improve the efficiency and
accuracy of eavesdropping detection, both Optical
Performance Monitoring (OPM) data and eye
diagrams are adopted as input data. Three different
ML classifiers are designed and tested to realize
eavesdropping detection, location, and split ratio
recognition, respectively. To demonstrate the
feasibility of the proposed scheme, an experiment is
conducted in an end-to-end fibre transmission
system with Coherent Optical Orthogonal
Frequency Division Multiplexing (CO-OFDM). The
eavesdropping is simulated and performed by
placing the optical coupler in different positions. In
addition, different splitting ratios are considered,
including 95/5, and 90/10. Results indicate that the
ML scheme achieves 100% and 92.76% accuracy in
eavesdropping detection and location, respectively.
Short-reach intensity-modulation and direct-
detection (IM/DD) optical Fast-OFDM systems
were examined by [22], and they developed
combined channel estimation and digital
linearization schemes. To transmit the 2PAM
signals, the odd SCs of the training sequences were
used. For 10 and 22 km length 12.5 Gbit/s SMF
lines, the combined compensation technique helps
to reduce BER. For the recommended IM/DD Fast-
OFDM system, 3 dB at a bit error ratio (BER) of
103, after 22-km SMF transmission is used to
increase the receiver sensitivity in comparison with
the conventional IM/DD Fast-OFDM. A least mean
square (LMS) algorithm has been proposed by [23],
to evaluate the phase noise. The advantage of this
algorithm is, the bit error rate is improved and the
issue of phase ambiguity occurring by cycle slip has
also been avoided.
A simple phase noise (PN) model has been
proposed by [24], based on the channel effect of
OFDM/OQAM and the distribution feature of
intrinsic interference. An adaptive extended Kalman
filter (AEKF) blind scheme has been developed
based on the theory of the Kalman filter and the PN
model to achieve flexibility in dynamic networks. A
change in the identification of blind phase with a
feedback loop has a temporal complexity that is just
1/3 that of a commercial laser with a linewidth of
200 kHz.
[25] proposed a method to estimate the blind
channel approach using fast independent component
analysis based on the weight function (FICA-WF)
for blind interference cancellation. The existing
models such as parallel factor analysis, joint parallel
factor analysis, STBC-m-MIMO-OFDM, and
MMSE-CMA-DFCE obtained SNR ranging from 10
to 20 dB, whereas the proposed model obtained
better SNR of 9.02 dB for the FastICA-WF. [26]
proposed a novel blind CE method for vehicular
VLC to improve CE accuracy based on the
exploitation of the channel statistics derived, by
utilizing an extensive amount of data collected for
different communication angles, distances, and
ambient light conditions. First, the normalized
channel frequency response (CFR) of the V2LC
channel is demonstrated to be invariant of inter-
vehicular distance, relative transmitter/receiver
zenith angle, and ambient light. Then, this channel
characteristic is exploited in the blind CE to
improve its accuracy with a two-step estimation of
the normalization factor. Extensive simulations at
different vehicle speeds show that the proposed
method outperforms the pilot-based and
superimposed training-based CE methods in terms
of spectral efficiency both for all modulation
schemes and at all relative speeds. The proposed
blind channel estimation (CE) method provides a
9.77% increase in the spectral efficiency, compared
to the second best method, superimposed training-
based CE, at 20 dB signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and
160 km/h relative speed, for 64-Quadrature
Amplitude Modulation (QAM) Direct Current-
Biased Optical Orthogonal Frequency Division
Multiplexing (DCO-OFDM). [27] examine the deep
neural network (DNN) layers created from long-
short-term memory (LSTM) for detecting the
signals by learning the received signal as well as
channel information. We investigate the
performance of the system under various conditions.
The simulation results show that the signal bit error
(SER) is equivalent to and better than that of the
minimum mean squared error (MMSE) and least
square (LS) methods. From the aforementioned
survey, the study utilized the Optical fibre
transmission using coherent OFDM with FSO
optical communication in the means of MIMO
networks using an Extreme Learning Machine
(ELM). Table 1 shows the comparative analysis of a
recent work based on optical fibre communication.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
10
Volume 14, 2023
Table 1. Comparison Analysis of Recent Survey Based on Optical fibre Communication
References
Objectives
Communication
Source
Results
Luis Carlos
Vieira et al
2021
2PAM-Fast-
OFDM sequences
are used for
training a
memoryless
polynomial-based
adaptive post-
distorter
Optical Fast-OFDM
systems
The receiver
sensitivity of
the proposed
IM/DD Fast-
OFDM system
is improved by
about 3 dB at a
bit error ratio
(BER) of 103,
after 22-km
SMF
transmission.
Xiaobo Wang
et al 2020
The simplified
phase noise (PN)
model for
OFDM/OQAM
under channel
effect is deduced
according
to the distribution
feature of intrinsic
interference.
Orthogonal
frequency-division
multiplexing offset-
quadrature
amplitude
modulation
(OFDM/OQAM)
The laser
linewidth is
200 kHz, and
its time
complexity is
only 1/3 of that
of a modified
blind phase
search with the
feedback loop.
Xi Fang et al
2022
Frequency-domain
channel
transmission
model for PDM
CO-
OFDM/OQAM
systems
Multiplexed
coherent optical
OFDM
Transmission
distance is
improved by
500 km with
the bit-error-
rate (BER)
target at
3.8x10-3.
Xiaoyu Wang
et al 2022
Artificial neural
network least
squares channel
estimation
algorithm
(ANN_LS-CEA)
Multiplexing/offset
quadrature
amplitude
modulation
(OFDM/OQAM)
passive optical
network (PON)
Reduce the bit
error rate
(BER)
performance by
50%.
Simarpreet
Kaur et al
2022
Proposed OSSB
generation to
provide a tunable
optical carrier-to-
sideband ratio
Optical single
sideband (OSSB)
modulation-based
dual polarized (DP)
MachZehnder
Modulators and
polarizer
15,900 km at
100 Gbps at a
targeted log
BER of -2.42
3 Research Problem Definition and
Motivation
The key technique is channel estimation is
considered in which the performance gets affected
greatly in coherent optical Fiber-optic
communication systems. The original signals can be
recovered, by transmitting the known information
from the transmitter to the receiver and by adjusting
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
11
Volume 14, 2023
some effects like dispersion, nonlinearity, loss, etc.
The orthogonality is destructed present in between
the subcarriers and hence the signals found in the
sub-channels may interfere with each other in the
OFDM system. The OFDM system's vulnerability to
frequency deviation is one of its fundamental flaws.
Some advantages of the optical IMDD-OQAM-
OFDM system over the intensity modulation and
direct detection (IMDD) method include high
spectrum efficiency due to a higher side lobe
suppression ratio provided by a specially designed
filter bank, the viability of asynchronous
transmission and cost-effectiveness due to the use of
simple transceivers. Also, OQAM-OFDM has the
same symbol timing faults and carrier frequency
offset compared to another type of multicarrier
modulation scheme. In addition, since the OQAM-
OFDM signal is transmitted in a complex channel
and has real field orthogonality built in, the phase
noise is made trickier and more challenging to
reduce by intrinsic imaginary interference (IMI).
The prediction of the channel has been
considered an essential module, to enhance the
orthogonal frequency division multiplexing
(OFDM) system execution. The high spectral
efficiency can be acquired because there is no need
for the time-frequency domain well-localized pulse
shapes and CP. The frequency offset and robustness
of the system are high due to the small leakage of
out-of-band power in OFDM/OQAM. The
benchmark pilot-assisted equaliser the fully-real
ELM outperforms the RC-ELM and nearly matches
the ELM well-defined in the common phase error
(CPE) and the complex domain (C-ELM)
compensation in terms of the BER over an additive
white Gaussian noise channel and several laser
oscillators. Some disadvantages were categorized
based upon both techniques namely: An extra
prelude is essential for channel estimation purposes
whereas the transmission rate is reduced by the
compensator, and the C-ELM needs finite and
activation function which would be identifiable. The
CPE compensator and C-ELM are more competitive
than the unique ELM algorithm in this case for the
quadrature amplitude modulation with 16-ary.
4 Proposed Research Methodology
Multicarrier techniques have attracted much interest
in high-speed optical communication systems, due
to their higher spectral efficiency and enhanced
tolerance to dispersion. Coherent optical orthogonal
frequency-division multiplexing (CO-OFDM) has
been recently proposed to combat fibre chromatic
dispersion and polarization-mode dispersion (PMD).
CO-OFDM offers the advantages of high electrical
and optical spectral efficiency, dispersion
insensitivity, high optical signal-to-noise ratio
(OSNR) sensitivity, and computation efficiency.
Channel estimation and equalizations are the most
important process on the receiver side of all kinds of
communication networks to estimate the
characteristics of the channel. In this work, a new
technique is proposed to perform the channel
estimation technique to improve the BER
performance for high-speed data communication
networks based on coherent optical orthogonal
frequency division multiplexing (CO-OFDM). The
proposed work investigates an Extreme Learning
Machine-based channel estimation model, which
varies in terms of performance, complexity, and
tolerance to system impairments, to find out the
optimal design. Figure 1 illustrates the block
diagram of the proposed work.
Channel
Estimation
Coherent Optical Orthogonal
Frequency Division
Multiplexing (CO-OFDM)
FOS Optical
Communication
System
Multi-Input Multi-Output
Orthogonal Frequency
Division Multiplexing (MIMO-
OFDM)
Fast Fourier
Transform (FFT)
Quadrature Phase-
Shift Keying (QPSK)
Demodulation
Mitigate Atmospheric
Turbulence Effects
High-Speed Trans
Impedance
Amplifiers (TIAs)
Coherent
detection
Optical Fibre
Transmission OSTBC
Extreme Learning Machine
(ELM) With Pilot Assisted
Equalizer (PAE)
Reduced BER
with High Spectral
Efficiency
Fig. 1: Block Diagram of the Proposed Work
A coherent optical (CO) orthogonal frequency
division multiplexing (OFDM) scheme gives a
scalable and flexible solution for increasing the
transmission rate, being extremely robust to
chromatic dispersion as well as polarization mode
dispersion. Further, the research utilized coherent
multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) architecture
for optical wireless communications (OWCs) to
mitigate atmospheric turbulence effects. The beam
intensity profile was measured for investigating the
temporal nature of atmospheric turbulence on the
optical beam. Transmitter optical signals operate at
distinct carrier frequencies to allow the received
optical signals to be separately processed. It
increases the channel capacity of the system almost
linearly with the number of transmitting antennae.
High-speed Trans Impedance Amplifiers (TIAs)
used at the front end of optical fibre receivers
present design challenges in the form of trade-offs
between input noise current, speed, trans-impedance
gains, power dissipation, and supply voltage.
Coherent detection is usually considered necessary
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
12
Volume 14, 2023
to alleviate this trade-off. Accordingly, the study
utilized quadrature phase-shift keying (QPSK) with
coherent detection, this has the same sensitivity as
binary phase-shift keying (BPSK) but doubles the
spectral efficiency. However, it has been shown that
OFDM is sensitive to phase noise. Specifically, the
phase noise will cause common phase error (CPE)
noise and inter-carrier interference (ICI). The CPE
can be estimated by the pilot-assisted (PA)
approach. At the CO-OFDM receiver after
removing CP and implementing the FFT operation,
it is followed by a channel estimation operation.
The study utilized Extreme Learning Machine
(ELM) for channel estimation, which improves the
BER performance and reduces the signal peak-to-
average ratios when the fibre nonlinearity becomes
significant. The simulation results illustrate that the
proposed CO-OFDM-ELM system has better BER
performance with high spectral efficiency and less
computational complexity.
4.1 Coherent Optical OFDM Network
The optical domain OFDM coherent identification
and modulation are used to accomplish CO-OFDM.
It has good receiver sensitivity and spectral
efficiency performance. A coherent optical OFDM
system's block diagrams are shown in Figure 2. The
random sequence generator will generate the
random sequence in the proposed system. To
produce padding bytes and blinding values, a vital
role is performed in cryptography algorithms like
private key pairs or authentication protocols.
Fig. 2: Block Diagram of Coherent Optical OFDM
System
Further, QPSK modulation is performed on the
sequence that is generated by the random sequence
generator. By swapping the stage of a constant
frequency reference signal, the data can be carried
out in a digital modulation process. The modified
signal is employed by the IFFT as the signal from its
original domain is transferred by Fourier analysis
transforms, which is frequently time or space, to a
portrayal in the frequency domain and vice versa. In
the next step add pilot data to the original data.
Every polarization consists of training symbols
which are data and each training symbol contains a
special pilot structure to evaluate the channel
distortion and IQ mismatch factors. Data along with
the pilot is sent to the OSTBC encoder and the
encoded data is sent to the optical channel.
At the receiving end from the channel, the
distortion
'
d
is identified by the special block
channel estimation using ELM and the value of
distortion
'
d
is sent to the OSTBC receiving end
based on the distortion information the data is
decoded and pilot data is removed. FFT is
implemented in the data and QPSK demodulation is
done in the data to get its original form.
In the
E
P
data pipes, the serial data input is
transmitted at the transmitter end and it is depicted
to corresponding constellation symbols. Following
the data streams, the
q
P
pilot subcarriers, pilot
subcarriers were inserted gradually. To establish the
digital time-domain signal, the inverse FFT is used,
which is then merged with a cyclic prefix (CP) to
reduce the interruption of the inter-symbol caused
by multipath channels. By employing an ideal
digital-to-analogue converter (DAC) with a correct
sampling rate, such as an OFDM transmitter the
real-time waveform is then produced. For the
OFDM symbol, the baseband signal is described in
equation (1).
ugjmeua m
P
l
t
2exp
1
0
1
(1)
Where,
me
and
m
g
denotes the data that is
transmitted and the frequency of subcarrier at the
m
subcarrier and number of subcarriers are shown
by
qEt PPP
. The subcarrier index
me
needs
to be modulated
meE
or unmodulated
meq
. As
indicated, reference tones
meq
are gradually
attached along with the data subcarriers
meE
through the OFDM symbols for clarification
purposes.
1
1
mm ggU
shows the differences
between the nearby subcarriers which will be
orthogonal, in which the time taken by the one
OFDM symbol is denoted
U
.
Because of the presence of a laser oscillator,
there was a difference noted in the phase noise in
which the optical-up conversion stage has been
optimised. By a single-frequency laser, the
modulated signal
uFN
is stated in equation (2).
uauFua N12
(2)
Therefore,
ua2
can be rewritten as
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
13
Volume 14, 2023
ugjmeuugjRua m
P
l
NN
t
2exp2exp 1
0
12
(3)
Equation (3),
N
R
denotes the optical tone
amplitude,
N
g
denotes the optical carrier frequency,
and
dxu u
11
the noise present in the
laser phase.
ux1
is the noise of frequency with
the values of autocorrelation and zero mean function
equals to
1
2y
, were
1
y
, and
are
considered as the Dirac delta method and laser
linewidth framework. At the coherent receiver, an
optical OFDM signal and a local oscillator are
integrated through fibre optics. 󰇛󰇜 can be
rewritten in equation (4) as
uausua 23
(4)
With
and
us
refers to the impulse reaction
of the convolution process and optical channel. Each
fibre span confined a chromatic dispersion, several
stages of high birefringence devices, and
polarization dependent on loss components. The
final result of fibre chromatic dispersion leads to the
generation of phase error which must be considered
that concludes a time-invariant phase rotation which
can be removed by a critical multiplication in the
OFDM receiver and hence the channel response is
assumed as,
ugjmeuugjRuauua m
P
l
NN
t
2exp2exp 1
0
123
. In
the optical domain, if the OFDM signal bandwidth
is less than the RF it might be taken as a strict sense
which is most common in the OFDM signals. The
laser phase noises mainly damage the execution of
the CO-OFDM and hence to improve the ELM our
study mainly focuses on it. Since the effects of fibre
nonlinearities and chromatic dispersion on BER
depend upon the subcarrier position, the results of
optical channel models with linearities and
nonlinearities exist must be noted. The coherent
detection should be noted which defines
heterodyning the optical signal in which the
photodetector holds the continuous-wave optical
field
uFNV
and hence the electrical current is
given in equation (5).
uvuauFTua NV 2
34
(5)
The above equation can be derived as
ui
uuggmeRR
ugjmeRR
Tua
WGmwG
P
l
NNV
m
P
l
NNV
t
t
2exp2
2exp
1
0
2
1
0
22
4
(6)
Where, the responsivity of the photodiode is
represented by R, where
NV
R
,
NV
g
and
u
2
denotes the local oscillator’s amplitude, frequency,
and phase.
is the function of the real part,
NVNwG ggg
implies the RF and the phase
noise of RF is
uuu
WG 21
, with
linewidth
WG
z
which again is seen through the
subcarriers with Lorentzian spectra and is produced
by the laser linewidth and local oscillator linewidth.
Additionally,
ui
refers to the AWGN signal
which is still found in the receiver and used to detect
the thermal and shot noises. If the low frequencies
have been hidden, the Hilbert transform has been
used to convert the signal to an analytical
representation, and the baseband frequency has been
applied, for the OFDM demodulator the is given in
equation (7).
uiugjmeujua m
P
l
GW
t*2expexp 1
0
5
(7)
Where,
ui*
represents the baseband AWGN
signal, and through the SNR the frequency domain
is determined.
To pretend the ADC process, the symbol of
OFDM is sampled using a fixed sampling rate and
by using the demodulation process, time and
frequency synchronization are assumed, hence the
CP is rejected and FFT is executed. The
m
th
arrived information symbol can be stated in
equation (8).
mPmKmeme *0
(8)
Where,
0
represents the RF phase noise dc
portion, called CPE term,
1
,0
t
P
mnn
nmnemK
denotes the coefficient
of ICI coupling in between two subcarriers with a
distance
m
, and
mI *
represents AWGN on the
m
th subcarrier.
n
is described in equation (9)
as
1
0
2exp
1t
P
itGW
t
Pinij
P
n
(9)
With
i
GW
being the RF phase variation is
obtained from discrete time. All the subcarriers of
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
14
Volume 14, 2023
the OFDM symbol must be taken into account and
hence equation (9) was represented in a compact
matrix form as:
111 tttt PPPPt PRPR
(10)
In the OFDM spectrum, for the estimation of
time-varying channels, a particular number of
subcarriers are allocated. In the PAE methodology,
the values were given by the pilots which are used
in the linear interpolation for the detection of the
output of channel frequency for the data subcarriers
as described in the introduction. High performance
and low complexity can be defined through this
equalization method. The average power of the
constellation derives from the strength of pilot
subcarriers and for the sake of simplicity, the pilot’s
quadrature component is set to 0. In the PAE
technique, in a single constellation point, all the
other reference tones are present. The phase noise
for OFDM symbols can be decreased by the
equalizer especially when ICI dominates the CPE.
4.2 MIMO-Based Optical Communication
The MIMO-based optical communication system is
demonstrated as the transmitter consists of
b
antennas, the receiver contains
c
antennas, where
all the symbols that were transmitted share
m
subcarriers. Figure 3 shows the MIMO-based
communication in optical channels. The sequence of
frequency-domain transmitted from the
l
ll ,,1
transmit antenna is represented by
mBl,
, where
mm ,,1
represents the
m
subcarrier of OFDM. The received signal of OFDM
is stated in equation (11) as
L
lcbmlmlbcb DHD
1,,,,,
(11)
Where the response of frequency in the channel
between
b
transmit antenna and the
c
receive antenna for the
l
subcarrier is
mlb
H,,
, the
frequency response of zero-mean additive white
Gaussian noise (AWGN) with a one-side power
spectral density is denoted by
cb,
.
T
lmlBmBmBB ,,,,2,,1
denotes the
signal transmitted on the
l
subcarrier from all the
L
transmit antennas, where
T
represents transpose.
The CSI matrix
c
D
of the received can be defined
in equation (12) as
lb
T
T
N
TTY bHDDDDD ,,,, 321
(12)
Where
H
represents the block diagonal axis.
Fig. 3: MIMO-Based Optical Communication
To clarify the whole photodetector array, an
assumption is made as on the receiver side the beam
spots are viewed as wide. The issue of transmitter-
receiver pointing has been resolved by this
approach. Furthermore, in a Trans impedance
amplifier (TA), a positive-intrinsic-negative (p.i.n.)
photodetector is set up for the receiver's
implementation. By the recurrence of MIMO, the
photodetector output scheme
p
can be represented
in equation (13).
lzIlxly n
M
mnmn
1
,
,0lx
(13)
The pulse intensity during the absence of
scintillation is represented by K and at the th period,
the data symbol is denoted by
lx
. In between the
m
th
Mm ,,2,1
optical source and the th
photodetector
Nn ,,2,1
nm
I
denotes the
intensity channel coefficient. The gamma-gamma
probability density function is described in equation
(14).
IIIf


2
212
2
(14)
Where the signal intensity is denoted by
I
, the
gamma function is denoted by
.
and the second
kind of modified Bessel function is denoted as
.
. For the order
, the parameters of the
scintillation experienced by plane waves and for
zero inner scales can be denoted by
and
.
The transmitted symbols of different types may
meet various atmospheric turbulence conditions and
based upon that the optical sources were located.
For the TA thermal noise, the
n
th receiver is
represented as
n
z
in which the double-side power
spectral density
2
0
N
was modelled by zero-mean
Gaussian process.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
15
Volume 14, 2023
Atmospheric Turbulence Channel
The atmospheric turbulence for the vertical FSO
link becomes weaker as the altitude of transmissions
increases, consequently, the model assumed the log-
normally distributed channels for the weak
turbulence regime is stated in equation (15) as
  (15)
Where,  is a Gaussian random variable with
the mean  and the variance 
. Assume
that  and 
for all
󰇝󰇞 and 󰇝󰇞 for the independent
and identically distributed channels. The Rytov
variance
for each transceiver to ensure
󰇝󰇞 is (equation 16)

󰇛 󰇜
󰇛󰇜󰇡
󰇢
󰇡
󰇢

(16)
Where, 
 and are the wavelength,
the altitude of the photodetector, and the ground.
The perpendicular environment is assumed to make
the transmission distance equal to the altitude of the
photodetector for the vertical link. Note that the
atmospheric channels for all diversity channels are
independent of the distance between the transmitters
or receivers and larger than the coherence length.
Therefore, the detected misalignments for the N
receivers are also independent. The sum of the log-
normal random variable of received powers could
be approximated to a single log-normal random
variable using Wilkinson’s method. Further, the
averaged centroid can be approximated in equation
(17) 



(17)
Where is the Gaussian distributed statistical
misalignment model with a zero mean and the
variance 
of aggregated centroid . The
detected centroids for each receiver are independent,
the mean of the averaged centroid is zero, and the
variance of the overall detected misalignment error
can be expressed in equation (18) as


󰇡
󰇢
󰇡
󰇢
(18)
The pointed direction of the transmitted beam is
assumed to aim at the centre of the receiver
distributions. The channel gain for M×N MIMO-
based FSO transmissions can be expressed in
equation (19) as


 


(19)
Where and  are the beam width and the
radial displacement of the mth transmitted beam at
the n-th receiver due to a pointing error. The outage
of the transmitted signal is defined as the received
power becoming less than the receiver sensitivity.
4.3 Channel Model of CO-OFDM
The Spatial sub-channels were presumed,
independent. The assumed condition is reasonable if
the spacing of the antenna is larger than half of the
carrier wavelength.
An exponential power-delay profile has been
designed in IEEE 802.11. The difficult 3D
environments can be designed by the Optic studio
which is the advantage of this method. The output of
the ray-tracing method contains the database file in
brief of the created rays, in which the strength and
length of the optical path preceding each reflection
are also contained in it. In CIR,
th
, can then be
determined in equation (20)
rays
N
i
i
o
r
rays c
d
tlP
N
th
1
,
1
(20)
Here, c denotes the speed of light and the total
distance is denoted by
i
d
whereas before getting
into the detector the
i
th ray has been traveled, 󰇛󰇜
denotes the Multi Carrier Modulation (MCM)
transmitted signal, defines the symbol period. To
analyse the retrieved simulation results, several
metrics were used in which the DC of channel profit
and delay spread is also given. The DC expansion
0
H
is stated in equation (21) as
dtthH0
(21)
0
H
denotes the frequency of the subcarrier,
Also, the spread
0
of the channel is delayed by the
root means squared (RMS) delays is represented
in equation (22).
0
2
2
2
0
0
dtth
dttht
(22)
Where,
r
denotes the mean excess delay,
described by (23).
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
16
Volume 14, 2023
0
2
0
2
dtth
dttht
r
(23)
To fit the histogram of the network gains to a
certain probability density function (PDF), such as
lognormal, Nakagami, Rayleigh, Weibull, etc.,
statistical modelling for the dynamic WBAN
channels must take this into account. AIC denotes
the Akaike Information Criterion which is expressed
in equation (24) as
1
12
2log
pN
pp
pxLAIC
p
(24)
Where, the log-likelihood of the predicted model
with the parameter
of size
p
is represented by
xL log
, the limitation on the models of data
x
of size
p
N
. The method that fits the data
corresponds to the smallest AIC score. The time
interval for which the autocorrelation function
(ACF) is below a particular threshold is defined as
channel coherence time, to define channel time
fluctuations.
4.4 Channel Estimation Using ELM
ELM-based channel estimation is a very efficient
calculation for the distortion in optical channels,
better accuracy is obtained while using this kind of
method. The input parameters are given to the ELM
machine by using this parameter for training and
testing. There is a correlation between different
parameter levels so all the factors of the direct
communication network have to be configured,
which makes direct transmission neural network
prediction accurate. The ELM is a learning
algorithm for feed-forward artificial neural networks
characterized by a single hidden layer. The ELM
tends to minimize the training error with the
adoption of the smallest norm of the output weights.
In addition, the ELM has a fast learning speed, as
the only parameters that need to be optimized are
the output weights between the hidden neurons and
the output layer. The computational time required
for training can be considered negligible in
comparison with traditional feed-forward neural
networks and support vector machines. The ELM
refers to an attractive learning algorithm for SLFNs,
which has fast training speed together with good
generalization performance. It is characterized by
the random assignment of the weights of the input
layer as well as the threshold values in the hidden
layer and, hence, the training problem is translated
into finding the minimum norm least-squares
solution of a linear system. The basic ELM may be
written as follows (25).
󰇛󰇜󰇛󰇜 󰇛󰇜

(25)
Where the weight of the resultant matrix is
denoted by
, T represents the target output
matrix,
.g
which represents the activation
function. Figure 4 shows the network structure of
ELM.
Fig. 4: ELM Network Structure Model
Since the nodes hidden in the ELM training
parameters are randomized and remain unchanged
during the training procedure, ELM may not reach
the optimal classification limit. ELM has been able
to improve sorting performance, reduce the
misclassified samples, and reduce variation between
different implementations.
xhxf L
iiiL
1
(26)
Where the output weight of the
i
th has hidden
node is represented by
i
and
L
f
denotes the
hidden layer of the output function in (26). Here, for
the ELM the secret layer has been shown,
i
th
resultant hidden node is , the parameters of the
i
th has hidden node is and . The fundamental
ELM can be written in equation (27) as
T
N
T
T
L
T
LNLN
jij
LL
t
t
bxwgbxwg
bxwg
bxwgbxwg
11
11
1111
..
.
..
(27)
Where is the output matrix of the hidden layer,
is the output weight matrix, is the matrix of the
target output, 󰇛󰇜 refers to the activation function,
T
jnjjj wwww ,,, 21
defines the weight vector
in between the
j
th input and the hidden nodes,
n
T
i
n
ii
ixxxx ,,, 21
denotes
i
th information
for n-dimensional input data, the inner product
between
j
w
and
i
x
is defined by a term, the bias of
the
j
th hidden neuron is
j
b
,
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
17
Volume 14, 2023
T
jmjjj
,,, 21
which refers to the weight
of resultant vector lies in between the
j
th has
hidden node and the output neurons and
m
T
i
m
ii
itttt ,,, 21
represents the
m
-
dimensional target vector ensured from
i
x
. The
ELM training approach creates a model for single
hidden layer sigmoid neural networks as a
particular case is defined in equation (28).
x
WWY 12
(28)
Where,
1
W
the matrix of input-to-hidden-layer
weights is represented by,
denotes the activation
function, and the matrix of hidden-to-output-layer
weights is represented by
2
W
.
In the ELM algorithm, input weights and bias
are randomly generated according to a probability
distribution and are related by the inner product
operator. Generally, for a given training set with Nm
instances󰇝󰇞󰇝󰇞
, where
 is an input sample and
is its corresponding output
(the input dimension and output dimension
are not necessarily equal),
The training process of the ANN can be
expressed as a linear regression problem for the
ELM algorithm, where a zero training error between
the target output and the actual output

can be determined as follows (29).
 (29)
The optimal solution to the ELM can be computed
in equation (30).

(30)
Where is the Moore-Penrose generalized
inverse of . If we consider zero training error,
over-fitting could appear in the ELM algorithm. To
avoid this problem, calculations are done by
minimizing the final weights  with the
inclusion or a regularization parameter. In other
words, the mean square error is given by equations
(31, 32).




(31)
s.t 󰇛󰇜

(32)
Where, 󰇛󰇜 represents an 󰇛󰇜 vector
of the matrix in expression, is the error
vector concerning the  input sample, and C
corresponds to the penalty coefficient, which must
be any real positive number. Here, denotes the
actual output and defines the target output.
Finally, its solution when F has more rows than
columns ( > ), can be written as follows (33).

󰇡
󰇢
(33)
Where, is an identity matrix with dimension
. denotes the number of hidden neurons. On
the other hand, in the case, that has fewer rows
than columns ( > ), the previous solution can
be written in equation (34) as

󰇡
󰇢
(34)
Where, 
signifies the optimal solution of
ELM. Thus to improve the accuracy of the
predictions model, the expressions for  shown
above are obtained when modifying the problem on
equation (31), this depicts that




󰇛
󰇜
(35)
s.t 󰇛󰇜

Finally, the last step is to perform MIMO
combining with the trained ELM output weight
vector illustrated in equation (36).
  (36)
Where, 󰇝󰇟󰇠󰇟󰇠󰇞 denotes the
detected data symbols at the output layer of the
ELM network. It is worth noting that and in
(27) are fixed after the ELM training and reused for
further processing.
5 Experimentation and Result
Discussion
The channel estimation in a coherent optical OFDM
network is imposed in MATLAB 2021a in an i5
system with storage of 4 GB RAM is defined in
Table 2. The model execution is computed in terms
of BER by varying the number of the antenna on the
transmitting side and the receiving side. The
existing method and ANN were analysed for the
analysis purpose of this method. By making use of
the Extreme Learning Machine (ELM) network
suggested in this work, performance is improved,
but security is severely compromised. Based on the
accuracy, the system's performance is evaluated.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
18
Volume 14, 2023
Table 2. Simulation System Configuration
MATLAB
Version R2021a
Memory Capacity
4GB DDR3
Operation System
Windows 10 Home
Processor
Intel Core i5 @
3.5GHz
The accuracy graph is generated to determine
the performance, as shown in Figure 5 by
employing both the suggested method ELM and the
existing ANN (Artificial Neural Network). The
same number of channels and users as in the
proposed way is supplied for both implementations.
The performance graphs that resulted are provided
below.
Fig. 5: BER Results Using ANN-Based Channel
Estimation
According to the channel estimation method
which uses the ANN method, the output of the bit
error rate is deployed in Figure 5. It consists of four
levels of samples, one receiver and two transmitters,
two transmitters and two receivers, four transmitters
and two receivers, and four transmitters and four
receivers. The percentage of affected samples is
approximately 10%.
Fig. 6: Bit Error Rate without Channel Estimation
Figure 6 depicted the BER performance without
channel estimation methods, i.e., there is a chance of
5% getting affected if the BER is 0.2. Then for the
second and third samples, the percentage of affected
samples is approximately 6. The final samples
produce the percentage of affected samples are 18.
Fig. 7: BER Based On ELM Based Channel
Estimation
The graph for bite error rate using an Extreme
Learning Machine is illustrated in Figure 7, which
consists of four transmitter and receiver samples.
These samples produce the percentage of affected
sample values like 13%, 16.8%, 17%, and 19%
when the bit error rate is 10-1, respectively.
Fig. 8: BER for Two Transmitters and One Receiver
Figure 8 demonstrates the bit error rate graph
using two transmitters and one receiver. Which is
compared with the prevailing ANN-MIMO-DF-
based methods. The proposed CO-OFDM-CE-ELM
method performs better than the other methods like
the existing and the ANN-MIMO-DF, respectively.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
19
Volume 14, 2023
Fig. 9: BER for Two Transmitters and Two
Receivers
Figure 9 depicted the bit error rate graph when it
has two transmitters and two receivers. The existing
method and the ANN method were compared with
the developed method. When the BER is 0.2, the
existing method has 0.6%, the ANN has 19.6% and
the proposed method has a 25% of affected samples.
While comparing to it, the proposed method has a
better performance.
Fig. 10: BER for Four Transmitters and Two
Receivers
Figure 10 shows the bit error rate values for the
four transmitters and two receivers. It is compared
with the already available ANN method. When the
BER is 0.1, the percentage of samples affected is
0.2% for existing, 14% for ANN, and 18% for the
proposed method, respectively.
Fig. 11: BER for Four Transmitters and Four
Receivers
Figure 11, reveals the bit error rate of the
developed method for four transmitters and four
receivers. It compares the proposed method with the
existing ANN methods. For the existing method,
there is a chance of 8% getting affected and for the
proposed method there will be 19.5 % damage if the
BER is 0.1.
6 Discussion
The channel estimation in a coherent optical OFDM
network is implemented in MATLAB 2021a
software. Performances of the model are measured
in terms of bit error rate by varying the number of
the antenna on the transmitting side and the
receiving side. For analysis purposes, this method is
analyzed with the existing method and ANN. [28]
identified the minimum bit error rate (BER) for the
16-QAM modulation with varying fibre length. The
OFDM-RoF system can be able for realizing a fibre
length of 100 km with a restricted decrease in the
received power so that the constellation noise
becomes greater despite applying electrical
amplification and optical amplification. [29]
suggested the performance of OFDM with
Companding is described in the Free space optical
(FSO) link. The atmospheric turbulence in the FSO
system is described by the Gamma-Gamma channel
model. The BER performance is done with OFDM
scheme with and without A-law and µ-law
companding scheme in FSO medium. [30] verify the
stability of the tri-directional fibre transmission
system. The design of transmission methods is
different wavelengths modulated in the electrical
signal of 10 Gbit/s and 2.5 Gbit/s based on the
corresponding architectures. BER results for
different wavelengths, depicting the power penalty
values at different distances from left to right, which
are 0.304 dB, 0.595 dB, and 1.173 dB, respectively.
It indicates that the effect of different wavelengths is
much less than that of the same wavelength. [31]
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
20
Volume 14, 2023
illustrate that the proposed CO-OFDM-IM system
has better BER performance when the proposed
CO-OFDM-IM system and the CO-OFDM system
have similar spectral efficiency. Also, the CO-
OFDM-IM system can provide better spectral
efficiency than the CO-OFDM system at low-to-
medium order modulation such as BPSK, QPSK,
and 16QAM. [32] results show that by reasonably
setting the negotiation bit position, the consensus
key could be obtained through negotiation, and the
requirements of transmission performance could be
met. When the negotiation bit position was set to
seven, the Q-factor of the system was nine, which
met the error-free condition of the 7% forward error
correction (FEC) limit.
[33] present an Extreme Learning Machine
(ELM)-based channel estimation (CE) approach
aiming at minimizing the effective bit-error-rate
(BER) for a two-user NOMA downlink system. This
technique has Improved spectral efficiency (SE) and
energy efficiency (EE) values can be observed for
the proposed L2-norm ELM, and thus, it is proved
that the ELM and L2-norm ELM-based NOMA
schemes achieve a large sum capacity than other
existing algorithms. [34] have the satisfactory
outcome produced during the design phase is further
improved by the iterative supervised learning
approach. From the above discussion, it proclaims
that the present article provides higher spectral
efficiency with reduced BER (0.002, 0.147, 0.0316,
0.0112), (0.050, 0.0316, 0.025, 0.010) and low
computational complexity with CO-OFDM-MIMO-
ELM, [35].
7 Conclusion
The OFDM produced as the outcome of polarization
and chromatic-mode dispersion may readily manage
a high inter-symbol interference (ISI) (PMD). The
OFDM can be made as a systematic technology by
high spectral flexibility and spectral efficiency for
the later fibre-optic links. The direct-detected and
coherent optical Fast-OFDM were some other
spectral-efficient modulation techniques were also
presented. A new technique for channel estimation
technique is proposed for CO-OFDM using ELM in
this work. QPSK modulation technique is employed
to perform the modulation process for the high-
speed data transmission process. ELM is trained by
using received data and piolet data which are used
to perform the encoding process. The channel
response value is predicted for each packet based on
the trained elm model. Using MATLAB software,
the proposed method is evaluated. To examine the
proposed technique performance concerning varying
probability values for SNR, the BER performance
metrics are used. While the performance is
compared with the already available ANN technique
and found that the proposed method provides
reduced BER ((0.002, 0.147, 0.0316, 0.0112) when
compared to the conventional methods. Therefore,
the outcome of this proposed method depicted that
the execution of the proposed method is higher than
the other methods, and this will useful for efficient
channel estimation, respectively. The limitation of
this study is that study only utilizes the BER for the
analysis part. In the future, the study focuses on
coherent radio signals with the OFDM visible light
communication model for channel estimation. This
optical fibre communication has high-speed data
transmission, data security, and data reliability with
various applications.
References:
[1] A. H. Ali, A. Hj, and B. S. Hassen, “Design
analysis and performance evaluation of the
WDM integration with CO-OFDM system for
radio over fiber system,” Indonesian Journal of
Electrical Engineering and Computer Science,
vol. 15, no. 2, 2019, pp. 870878.
[2] D. Zabala-Blanco, M. Mora, C. A. Azurdia-
Meza, A. Dehghan Firoozabadi, P. Palacios
Játiva, and I. Soto, “Relaxation of the radio-
frequency linewidth for coherent-optical
orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing
schemes by employing the improved extreme
learning machine,” Symmetry (Basel), vol. 12,
no. 4, 2020, p. 632.
[3] L. Wang, C. Gao, X. Deng, Y. Cui, and X.
Chen, “Nonlinear channel estimation for
OFDM system by wavelet transform based
weighted TSVR,” IEEE Access, vol. 8, 2020,
pp. 27232731.
[4] J. W. Kim, J. Yoon, and S. C. Kim, “Header
Information Based Channel Estimation for
Highly Modulated Orthogonal Frequency-
Division Multiplexing Transmissions in IEEE
802.11 ad,” Wireless Personal
Communications, vol. 115, 2020, pp. 2081
2092.
[5] L. Ge et al., “Deep neural network based
channel estimation for massive MIMO-OFDM
systems with imperfect channel state
information,” IEEE Syst. J., vol. 16, no. 3,
2022, pp. 46754685.
[6] X. Liu et al., “Low complexity partition-
recombined SLM scheme for reducing PAPR
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
21
Volume 14, 2023
in coherent optical OFDM systems,” Opt. Eng.,
vol. 61, no. 12, 2022.
[7] O. O. Oyerinde, “Frequency domain channel
estimation schemes for PDM-coherent optical
OFDM-QPSK-based communication systems,”
in 2018 IEEE 87th Vehicular Technology
Conference (VTC Spring), 2018.
[8] J. He, J. Shi, R. Deng, and L. Chen,
“Experimental demonstration of
OFDM/OQAM transmission with DFT-based
channel estimation for visible laser light
communications,” in Optics and Photonics for
Information Processing XI, 2017.
[9] Z. A. Abbasi and Z. A. Jaffery, “A weighted
neuro-fuzzy hybrid algorithm for channel
equalisation in the time-varying channel,”
International Journal of Business Intelligence
and Data Mining, vol. 17, no. 2, 2020, pp.
237257.
[10] X. Fang, Z. Suo, L. Zhang, Q. Zhang, and F.
Zhang, “Combined phase offset channel
estimation method for optical OFDM/OQAM,”
Opt. Fiber Technol., vol. 61, no. 102390, 2021,
p. 102390.
[11] S. Liang, F. Zhao, F. Zhao, Y. Huang, and C.
Wang, “ANN-based channel estimation
algorithm of IM/DD-OFDM/OQAM-PON
systems with mobile fronthaul network in 5G,”
Opt. Fiber Technol., vol. 59, no. 102310, 2020,
p. 102310.
[12] K. Ss, “Performance Analysis of Nonlinear
Fiber-Optic in CO-OFDM Systems with High
Order Modulations,” IEEE Photonics
Technology Letters, vol. 30, no. 8, 2018, pp.
696699.
[13] D. Zabala-Blanco, M. Mora, C. A. Azurdia-
Meza, A. Dehghan Firoozabadi, P. J. Palacios
Jativa, and S. Montejo-Sanchez, “Multilayer
extreme learning machine as equalizer in
OFDM-based radio-over-fiber systems,” IEEE
Lat. Am. Trans., vol. 19, no. 10, 2021, pp.
17901797.
[14] J. Liu, Y. Wang, Y. Yuan, and Y. Zhang,
“Channel estimation optimization algorithm
based on OFDM system,” in Proceedings of
the ACM Turing Celebration Conference -
China, 2019.
[15] Y. Sun and H. Ochiai, “Performance analysis
and comparison of clipped and filtered OFDM
systems with iterative distortion recovery
techniques,” IEEE Trans. Wirel. Commun., vol.
20, no. 11, 2021, pp. 73897403.
[16] D. Zabala-Blanco, M. Mora, C. A. Azurdia-
Meza, A. Dehghan Firoozabadi, P. Palacios
Játiva, and I. Soto, “Relaxation of the radio-
frequency linewidth for coherent-optical
orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing
schemes by employing the improved extreme
learning machine,” Symmetry (Basel), vol. 12,
no. 4, 2020, p. 632.
[17] Payal, D. Sharma, and S. Kumar, “Performance
enhancement of multi-beam FSO
communication system with the application of
MIMO with CO-OFDM,” J. Opt., 2022.
[18] X. Fang, Y. Xia, J. Jin, M. Zhu, Z. Suo, and L.
Zhang, "Combined Intra Symbol Frequency
Domain Averaging Channel Estimation for
Polarization Division Multiplexed Coherent
Optical Ofdm/Oqam Systems," Oqam Systems.
[19] X. Wang, X. Wang, and H. Cao, “ANN LS-
based Channel Estimation Algorithm of
IM/DD-OFDM/OQAM-PON systems with
SDN Mobile Fronthaul Network in 5G,” in
2022 IEEE International Conference on
Communications Workshops (ICC Workshops),
2022.
[20] S. Kaur, “Performance analysis of DP-QPSK
with CO-OFDM using OSSB generation,”
Wirel. Netw., vol. 28, no. 4, 2022, pp. 1719
1730.
[21] H. Song et al., “Experimental study of
machine-learning-based detection and location
of eavesdropping in end-to-end optical fiber
communications,” Opt. Fiber Technol., vol. 68,
no. 102669, 2022, p. 102669.
[22] L. C. Vieira, S. Hussein, I. Darwazeh, C.-P.
Liu, and J. Mitchell, “A combined digital
linearization and channel estimation approach
for IM/DD fast-OFDM systems,” Opt. Fiber
Technol., vol. 67, no. 102725, 2021, p. 102725.
[23] M. Bharti, “Performance enhancement of
coherent optical OFDM system using LMS
algorithm,” J. Telecommun. Inf. Technol., vol.
1, no. 2020, 2020, pp. 15.
[24] X. Wang, L. Yang, F. Luo, S. Yang, and Y. Du,
“Adaptive EKF based estimation method for
phase noise in CO-OFDM/OQAM system,”
IEEE Access, vol. 8, 2020, pp. 204931
204940.
[25] R. Sindhuja and A. R. Shankar, “Massive
MIMO Channel Estimation Using FastICA
Weighted Function for VLC in 5G Networks,”
in Series B, India, 2023, pp. 18.
[26] G. Gurbilek, M. Koca, and S. Coleri, “Blind
channel estimation for DCO-OFDM based
vehicular visible light communication,” Phys.
Commun., vol. 56, no. 101942, 2023, p.
101942.
[27] K. J. Wong, F. Juwono, and R. Reine, “Deep
Learning for Channel Estimation and Signal
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
22
Volume 14, 2023
Detection in OFDM-Based Communication
Systems,” ELKHA, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 5259.
[28] M. M. Kareem, S. A. S. Lafta, H. F. Hashim,
R. K. Al-Azzawi, and A. H. Ali, “Analyzing
the BER and optical fiber length performances
in OFDM RoF links,” Indones. J. Electr. Eng.
Comput. Sci., vol. 23, no. 3, 2021, p. 1501.
[29] A. H. Malini and M. Selvi, “BER Performance
Analysis of OFDM Based Free Space Optical
Communication System using µ-Law and A-
Law Methods,” in 2022 13th International
Conference on Computing Communication and
Networking Technologies (ICCCNT), IEEE,
2022, pp. 14.
[30] H.-C. Lee, Y. Liu, S.-K. Liaw, Y.-L. Yu, and
C.-H. Yeh, “Design and analyses of BER
performance in a tri-directional optical
transmission system,” Opt. Commun., vol. 532,
no. 129255, 2023, p. 129255.
[31] A. Güner, "Coherent optical OFDM with index
modulation for long-haul transmission in
optical communication systems," IEEE
Access, vol.10, 2022, pp.46504-46512.
[32] X. Yang et al., “Combined Optical Fiber
Transmission System Based on QNSC and
BER-LM,” In Photonics, vol. 10, no. 2, 2023.
[33] M. Sarkar, S. Sahoo, and S. Nanda, “Channel
estimation of non-orthogonal multiple access
systems based on L 2-norm extreme learning
machine,” Signal, Image and Video
Processing, vol. 16, 2022, pp. 921929.
[34] G. Borraccini, A. D’Amico, S. Straullu, F.
Usmani, A. Ahmad, and V. Curri, “Iterative
supervised learning approach using transceiver
bit-error-rate measurements for optical line
system optimization,” J. Opt. Commun. Netw.,
vol. 15, no. 2, 2023, p. 111.
[35] L. Liu, L. Cai, L. Ma, and G. Qiao, “Channel
state information prediction for adaptive
underwater acoustic downlink OFDMA
system: Deep neural networks based
approach,” IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol., vol. 70,
no. 9, 2021, pp. 90639076.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ELECTRONICS
DOI: 10.37394/232017.2023.14.2
Nisha Mary Joseph, Puttamadappa C.
E-ISSN: 2415-1513
23
Volume 14, 2023
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
The authors equally contributed in the present
research, at all stages from the formulation of the
problem to the final findings and solution.
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
No funding was received for conducting this study.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare
that are relevant to the content of this article.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US