An Empirical Investigation of the Twin Deficit Problem and the
Feldstein-Horeka Hypothesis:
A Case Study of Jordan
KHALED MOHAMMED AL-SAWAIE
Department of Economics,
Zarqa University,
Zarqa,
JORDAN
ORCiD: 0000-0002-9866-2736
Abstract: - This study explores the correlation between budget deficits and current account deficits, as stated by
the twin deficit hypothesis, in the specific setting of Jordan's economy. The Keynesian view proposes that
budget deficits lead to current account deficits, whereas the Ricardian equivalence theory disputes this idea.
Additionally, the research examines the Feldstein-Horioka hypothesis from 1980 about the connection between
saving and investment. By using cointegration analysis, this study demonstrates a lasting connection between
budget deficits and current account deficits, providing evidence for the Keynesian perspective. The findings
support the twin deficit theory's applicability to Jordan's economic situation and strengthen the Keynesian view
on the relationship between the current account, budget deficit, and investment. Moreover, the existence of a
negative correlation coefficient of less than 1 linking investment and saving supports the Feldstein-Horioka
hypothesis, pointing to Jordan's inclusion in international capital markets.
Key-Words: - Twin Deficit, Budget Deficits, Current Account Deficit, Feldstein-Horioka Hypothesis,
Keynesian absorption theory, Ricardian equivalence hypothesis, Jordan.
Received: April 21, 2024. Revised: September 13, 2024. Accepted: October 15, 2024. Published: November 18, 2024.
1 Introduction
The term "twin deficit" was coined in the early
1980s to depict the phenomenon of transitioning
between budget deficits and current account deficits
in the United States. This literature review reveals
that the causal connections between budget deficits
and current account deficits are not confined solely
to the United States but extend to other regions as
well. During the 1990s, certain European nations,
including Germany and Sweden, confronted
analogous scenarios. The escalation of budget
deficits coincided with a depreciation in the real
value of their domestic currencies, exerting adverse
effects on current accounts. Emerging economies
exhibited parallels to these nations in the expansion
of both budget and current account deficits.
However, the dynamics of transitioning from
equilibrium to disequilibrium states within a
specified timeframe vary between advanced and
developing economies.
The relationship between the budget deficit and
the current account deficit, known as the "twin
deficit," has prompted academic discussion and
research since the 1980s and early 1990s. According
to traditional Keynesian absorption theory, a budget
deficit increase at full employment levels can lead to
a strain on the balance of payments due to the rise in
demand for goods and services, including imports.
This traditional perspective believes that the size
and longevity of budget deficits have significant
effects on savings, capital accumulation, price
levels, income distribution, exchange rates, and
international trade dynamics. The ongoing
discussion and disagreement revolve around the
possible effects of budget deficits on the current
account deficit. Even with progress in using
complex time series techniques, the understanding
of research findings on this issue is still unclear.
Although there is a possible link between the two
shortcomings, this connection is especially
noticeable within the Jordanian economy, which is
suffering from ongoing budget and current account
deficits. Therefore, it is necessary to examine the
connection between fiscal policy and the current
account balance in Jordan.
Since the current account deficit is a barrier to
enhancing external solvency in the event of a
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
602
Volume 20, 2024
decline in capital flows (foreign direct investment)
owing to a potential economic recession, this paper
seeks to investigate the effects of budget deficits on
current account imbalances, independent of other
factors that influence the current account. The
sustainability of the external situation is
considerably worsened by further budgetary
increases.
Conversely, studies on the relationship between
the current account deficit and the budget deficit are
based on the theories of Keynesian and Ricardian
equivalence. Based on the twin deficit theory,
fluctuations in the fiscal balance lead to fluctuations
in the current account balance, but further research
will determine whether these fluctuations are pro-
cyclical or counter-cyclical. Therefore, this study
aims to elucidate the impact of fiscal policy on
Jordan's management of its external balance.
2 Theoretical Foundations of the
Twin Deficit Hypothesis
The Theoretical Underpinnings of the Twin Deficit
Hypothesis: The relationship between budget
deficits and current account deficits can be
elucidated through various theoretical lenses:
1. Embedded within the Mundell-Fleming
framework: In scenarios characterized by a
flexible exchange rate regime and optimal
capital mobility between a nation and other
global entities, the emergence of a budget
deficit triggers upward pressure on interest
rates, fostering capital inflows and consequent
appreciation of the exchange rate. The
adjustment in exchange rates serves to
reinstate external equilibrium. Conversely,
under a fixed exchange rate system
accompanied by exchange rate controls, the
restoration of external equilibrium does not
occur automatically. Financing a current
account deficit entails international reserve
outflows, indicative of governmental
intervention, with persistent budget deficits
resulting in enduring current account deficits.
Empirical analyses reveal that financing
mechanisms for the current account deficit
involve financial portfolio inflows and direct
investments, thereby augmenting tangible
resources. Financing methods encompass the
utilization of international reserves and
foreign borrowing, both of which fail to
stabilize the current account.
2. The second perspective emanates from the
monetary approach to the balance of payments
in the context of a small nation operating
under a fixed exchange rate system. Drawing
upon Keynesian absorption theory and the
monetary approach, any augmentation in the
budget deficit engenders an expansion in
aggregate demand, leading to a shift in
demand towards foreign goods and services,
thereby amplifying imports and exacerbating
the current account deficit.
3. The third viewpoint hinges upon the Ricardian
equivalence hypothesis, positing an absence of
correlation between budget deficits and
current account deficits due to the negligible
impact of transitions from taxation to budget
deficits on real interest rates, investment
levels, or the current account deficit.
The twin deficit hypothesis has been empirically
tested to assess the connection between budget
deficit and current account deficit in advanced
economies like the United States. Evidence has
consistently shown that budget deficit causes current
account deficit in one direction. Still, there is no
agreement among scholars about the interdependent
connection between the current account deficit and
the budget deficit. Multiple studies have suggested
that these factors are cointegrated, showing a
propensity to move together in the long run.
Research conducted by [1] and [2] on the economies
of the United States and Canada found no clear link
between the budget deficit and the external deficit.
These researchers suggested the possible use of the
"Ricardian equivalence hypothesis," indicating that
financing the budget shortfall through tax increases
changes spending habits to maximize long-term
welfare by increasing current savings instead of
present consumption. As a result, this method is said
to have no noticeable impact on interest rates,
savings, investments, prices, or income in the area.
[3], examined the association between the
budget deficit and the current account deficit in the
United States, assessing whether this relationship is
unidirectional, bidirectional, or independent.
Employing the Granger causality methodology,
quarterly data spanning from 1971:1 to 1989:4 were
analyzed. The findings revealed a correlation
between the budget deficit and the trade deficit, thus
corroborating the conventional assertion that "an
increase in the budget deficit leads to an increase in
the trade deficit."
In the context of emerging and developing
nations, [4] undertook an investigation into the twin
deficits of the Greek economy. Annual data
covering the period 1948-1993 for the budget deficit
and the trade balance were utilized. Utilizing the
cointegration test, error correction modeling, and
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
603
Volume 20, 2024
Granger causality, Vamvoukas concluded that the
causal linkage from the budget deficit to the trade
deficit aligns with Keynes's proposition in both the
short and long term.
The results [5] highlight that the twin deficits
hypothesis is present in the MENA region in the
medium-term and diminishes slowly over time,
backing the traditional Keynesian belief that fiscal
deficits negatively impact the current account
balance. Splitting the entire sample reveals that
increasing fiscal deficits only result in a decrease in
the Current Account Balance in oil-producing
countries. The findings support the common belief
that government spending growth reduces private
investment, also refuting the presence of the
FeldsteinHorioka hypothesis in the MENA region.
Crucially, MENA governments need to lower
internal interest rates promptly to enhance the CAB.
Increasing the interest rate for private savings is
crucial to prevent negative impacts on their
economies from chronic fiscal deficits and current
account downturns. This assertion is additionally
supported by the research of [6] and [7].
Various results have been found in previous
research on the relationship between the budget
deficit and the trade deficit, showing differences
among various countries. Some research supports
the Ricardian equivalence theory, indicating that the
budget deficit does not impact the trade deficit,
while other studies agree with the Keynesian view,
proposing a link between these deficits, where the
budget deficit causes the trade deficit. The current
study aims to clarify the fundamental dynamics
controlling the interaction of deficits in the
Jordanian economy and to explain the theoretical
framework relevant to this situation.
In addition, [8] analyzed annual time series data
from 1970 to 2012 to investigate the twin deficit
theory, the Ricardian equivalence hypothesis, and
Feldstein-Horioka puzzle in India. The empirical
findings from vector autoregressive modeling and
ARDL have refuted the twin deficit theory and the
Feldstein-Horioka dilemma. It proved that the
Ricardian equivalence hypothesis, stating that the
budget deficit does not affect the current account
deficit, is accurate.
[9], analyzed Turkey's fiscal balance and current
account with quarterly data from 2006:1 to 2020:2,
finding that the two variables are cointegrated even
when there are discontinuities in the series. The twin
deficit theory is backed by the fact that enhancing
fiscal balance also enhances current account
balance. To ensure strength, a causality analysis was
conducted. It was found that fiscal balance
influences external balance in a one-way direction.
Even with [10] resistance, he carried out
research using non-linear time series analysis to
investigate the connection between the budget
balance and the current account in the Turkish
economy. Also, annual data from 1994 to 2021 was
subjected to non-linear unit root and cointegration
tests. During the period analyzed in the Turkish
economy, it was determined that the negative
reverse causality hypothesis is more probable than
the twin deficit theory. In other words, a negative
correlation exists between the budget balance and
the current account balance in both the long term
and short term.
[11], investigated if a greater budget deficit in
Serbia has a negative effect on the country's current
account balance, as proposed by the twin deficit
theory. Contrary to the Ricardian equivalence
theory, the budget deficit does not impact the
current account balance. This research confirms the
twin deficit theory in Serbia by analyzing quarterly
data from 2005 to 2020, using a multivariate
autoregressive (VAR) model, and a short-term
structural autoregressive model. To be more precise,
raising the budget deficit by one percentage point
(as a percentage of GDP) leads to a 0.31 percentage
point increase in the current account deficit (as a
percentage of GDP).
The basis for analysis in this research is rooted
in the national income identity, where the Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) in an open economy is
expressed as the sum of consumption (C),
investment (I), government expenditure (G), and net
exports (X-M), as shown in equation (1).
(1)M)(XGICY
without taking into account income balance and
government expenditure balance, the current
account can be described in the following way:
(2)M)(XCA
If a country's imports exceed its exports,
causing a deficit in its current account, it will need
to borrow externally for financial support. The
increase in the current account deficit leads to a
proportional rise in the country's net foreign debt,
matching the deficit. A country with a current
account deficit is essentially using imported capital
goods to fund current consumption and/or
investments while sacrificing future consumption
and/or investment expenditures through exports. In
a global economy, local savings can be described as
the following:
(3)CAGCYS
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
604
Volume 20, 2024
The equation depicted above can be expressed as
follows, where S represents savings.
The expression of investment, denoted as 'I,' may be
formulated as follows:
(5)GCYI
Hence, the delineation of the current account
balance can be articulated as follows:
(6)T)R(GISCA
In the context of government transfers,
represented as R, and taxes, represented as T, there
is an interesting connection that can be made
regarding the relationship between savings and
investment. Although more international capital is
flowing in, the close relationship between domestic
savings and investment indicates that changes in the
budget deficit and current account deficit are
happening at the same time. The research conducted
by [12] emphasizes the connection between fiscal
and economic dynamics about savings and
investment behavior.
(7)BISCA
The phenomenon denoted as Ricardian
equivalence manifests when alterations in the
budget deficit do not engender augmented
consumption expenditure or a shortfall in the current
account, owing to the absence of correlation
between savings and investment. Should private
savings equate to private investment, Equation (7)
elucidates a straightforward association between
foreign trade and the public budget. Consequently,
twin deficits materialize, evolving concurrently and
incongruence in terms of magnitude and direction.
[13] delineated a theoretical framework to elucidate
the twin deficits, positing the following model:
(8)IβG)(TββM)(X 321
In the current analysis, denoting (X-M) as the
current account, (T-G) as the budget balance, and I
as the investment rate, it is anticipated that a
positive sign characterises the budget balance, while
a negative sign typifies investment. Consequently, a
rise in both budget deficit and investment rates is
posited to exacerbate the current account. Under
complete integration of the state into the global
economy, with budget and investment expenditures
being financed from the global financial market, the
combined coefficients are anticipated to sum to
unity. Deviation from this expectation, wherein one
coefficient falls below unity, is indicative of the
Feldstein–Horioka puzzle. Moreover, a negative
budget coefficient entails the rejection of the twin
deficit hypothesis. [8], explicated that the
correlation between investment and savings gauges
the extent of international capital mobility, whereby
investment can be underwritten by foreign savings
in the presence of accessible capital markets,
denoted by a low correlation. Their empirical
inquiry, conducted on cross-sectional data spanning
the period 1960-1974 across 16 OECD countries,
operationalized the model as delineated below:
(9)uYSβαYI
The variables (I/Y) and (S/Y) denote investment
and savings rates as a percentage of income,
respectively. The coefficient β is assigned to
savings, while ε represents the error term. A
noteworthy observation emerges when examining
the estimated savings coefficient: its magnitude is
notably elevated in instances devoid of international
capital flow, suggesting that local savings
predominantly finance domestic investment.
Conversely, when capital mobility is unhindered,
the coefficient approaches zero, indicative of local
investment being predominantly funded by foreign
savings. Hence, any statistically significant
deviation of the savings coefficient from zero
implies a state of complete capital mobility, wherein
an upsurge in savings within one nation triggers a
corresponding increase in investment across all
nations, thereby rendering local savings independent
of local investment. This inference denotes a lack of
capital movement. Notably, [12] substantiated this
deduction by uncovering a coefficient value of
0.887, thereby laying the groundwork for their
theory elucidating the relationship between
investment and savings, positing a scenario where
capital remains largely stationary among OECD
countries. In a closed economic system, investments
necessarily draw from local savings, while the
possibility of leveraging foreign savings for certain
investments fosters an environment where
investment and savings diverge autonomously.
However, subsequent empirical observations,
influenced by factors such as the integration of
financial markets, absence of capital restrictions,
dissemination of information, liberalization of
financial markets, and disparities in interest rates
among nations, have yielded results contrary to
those postulated by Feldstein–Horioka, commonly
referred to as the Feldstein–Horioka puzzle.
Consequently, the standard model, as proposed by
[12], is longitudinally estimated as follows:
(10)εBDβIββCA 210
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
605
Volume 20, 2024
Where ε is the error term.
3 Econometrics Analysis
The analysis employed in this study utilizes annual
data made available by the Central Bank of Jordan
through its official website (www.cbj.gov.jo),
supplemented by data sourced from the World Bank
(www.worldbank.org), with the natural logarithm
(Ln) applied to all variables. Given that the trade
balance entails the disparity between exports and
imports, and often encompasses negative values
unsuitable for logarithmic transformation, the
logarithm of the export-to-import ratio was adopted,
following the methodology outlined by [14], to infer
its elasticity. Similarly, for negative figures, the
budget deficit was calculated by dividing revenues
by expenditures and then applying the natural
logarithmic transformation to obtain the budget
deficit's natural logarithm.
3.1 Stationarity Test
The first step of this investigation involves assessing
the stationarity level of all variables through the
application of the Dickey-Fuller test [15] to
ascertain their stationary status. The findings
presented in Table 1 demonstrate that the budget
deficit, current account deficit, and investment
exhibit a stationary behavior, denoted as I(0).
Table 1. Unit Root Test Results
Unit Root test (Dickey-Fuller)
model
Augmented Dickey-
Fuller test statistic
Variables
Level
log
intercept and trend
-6.028464
bd
intercept and trend
-5.121123
ca
intercept and trend
-5.182697
i
3.2 Cointegration Methodology
Given that the variables under investigation in this
research exhibit an integrated series of order zero
(I(0)), and considering the assertion made by [16]
and [17] regarding the necessity for all variables to
possess congruent degrees of integration for
cointegration methodologies, cointegration analysis
was employed in this investigation. The outcomes
obtained are detailed as follows:
Table 2. Cointegration Test Results
Unrestricted Cointegration Rank Test (Trace)
Hypothesized
No. of CE(s)
Eigenvalue
Trace
Statistic
0.05
Critical Value
Prob.
None *
0.407134
30.21693
29.79707
0.0447
At most 1
0.170794
9.305469
15.49471
0.3379
At most 2
0.044338
1.814025
3.841465
0.1780
Trace test indicates 1 cointegrating eqn(s) at the 0.05 level
* denotes rejection of the hypothesis at the 0.05 level
**[18] p-values
The test results show the presence of
cointegration among the study variables.
3.3 Long-Run Coefficient Estimation
The study analyzed the lasting relationship between
the current account deficit and specific
macroeconomic factors outlined in Table 3, finding
a consistent link between the current account deficit
and investment. The results were obtained by using
the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) technique to
estimate outcomes.
Table 3. Twin Deficits Results
Dependent
Variable: CA
Coefficient
Std. Error
t-Statistic
Prob.
BD
2.497792
0.537428
4.647679
0.0000
I
-0.805392
0.269665
-2.986639
0.0047
C
-1.754736
0.358613
-4.893114
0.0000
R-squared
0.438015
Mean dependent var
-1.088364
Adjusted R-squared
0.410601
S.D. dependent var
0.501420
S.E. of regression
0.384951
Akaike info criterion
0.994347
Sum squared resid
6.075694
Schwarz criterion
1.115997
Log likelihood
-18.87564
Hannan-Quinn criter.
1.039461
F-statistic
15.97782
Durbin-Watson stat
0.384426
Prob(F-statistic)
0.000007
The model's estimation results indicate that
variables BD and I met expectations (BD = 2.5 and I
= -0.80) and showed statistical significance.
Moreover, proof of the twin deficit phenomenon
was discovered, as well as the inefficacy of the
Ricardian equivalence hypothesis in the Jordanian
economic setting. These results support the
traditional Keynesian view, which suggests a
correlation between the budget deficit and the
current account deficit, with the budget deficit
causing the current account deficit, as indicated in
[5] study. The worsening of the budget deficit and
the current account deficit is emphasized by the
trade deficit caused by the budget deficit. This
situation plays out in the following way: a budget
deficit leads to a trade deficit, causing an increase in
income which results in increased demand for
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
606
Volume 20, 2024
imports, worsening the trade imbalance and
ultimately leading to a deficit. Moreover, an
increase in the budget deficit boosts overall demand
and raises the real interest rate, attracting more
foreign capital, which could lead to a strengthening
of the currency, higher imports, and a worsened
trade balance.
Furthermore, the investment coefficient seen in
Table 3 displays a negative value and is found to be
less than one, as expected. This finding confirms the
Feldstein-Horioka hypothesis, showing that Jordan's
economy is not fully integrated into global markets
(with a coefficient of one indicating complete
integration and 100% dependence on foreign
funding). During the investigation, around 80% of
investment activities in the Jordanian economy
relied on foreign savings. As a result, an increase of
1% in investment in the long run leads to a
corresponding rise of 0.80% in the current account
deficit. Additionally, a 1% increase in the budget
shortfall results in a 2.5% growth in the current
account shortfall, as funds for both spending and
investments are obtained from the international
financial market. This discovery shows that the
budget deficit and investment impact the current
account deficit as expected, with the budget deficit
having a stronger effect on the balance of the
current account.
Table 4. Estimation of the Feldstein-Horioka
Equation for the Relationship between Savings and
Investment
Dependent Variable: I/Y
Variable
Coefficient
Std. Error
t-Statistic
Prob.
S/Y
0.335812
0.096549
3.478165
0.0012
C
-0.760038
0.154180
-4.929542
0.0000
According to the findings presented in Table 4,
the value of β deviates significantly from unity,
registering at 0.33. This departure implies an
implicit lack of close association between domestic
investment and domestic savings. Such a disparity
can be attributed to the pronounced degree of
international capital mobility. A β value
approximating unity would suggest a stronger
connection between domestic investment and
domestic savings, indicative of diminished
international capital mobility. A heightened
estimated coefficient for savings emerges in
scenarios devoid of international capital flow,
signifying the reliance of domestic investment on
domestic savings. Under such circumstances, a
coefficient of unity denotes complete integration,
whereby investment is supported by foreign savings.
4 Conclusion
The purpose of this study was to investigate the twin
deficit theory, which includes the current account
deficit and budget deficit, as well as to analyze the
Feldstein-Horioka hypothesis, using yearly data
from 1976 to 2019 focused on the Jordanian
economy. After finding evidence of no integration
(I(0)) through unit root testing, the model was then
estimated using the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS)
methodology.
The findings revealed the existence of a
protracted interrelationship among the variables, as
evidenced by the affirmative coefficient associated
with the budget deficit, signifying the presence of
the twin deficit dilemma within the Jordanian
economy. Consistent with expectations, the
coefficient of investment, which remained below 1,
substantiated the validity of the Feldstein-Horioka
hypothesis. The model elucidated that a substantial
proportion, amounting to 80%, of Jordanian
investments is underwritten by foreign savings,
thereby positioning Jordan within the framework of
international capital markets owing to its
pronounced dependence on external savings. The
outcomes lent credence to the Keynesian
perspective, affirming a robust and affirmative
correlation between the current account deficit and
savings investment, alongside the budget deficit,
throughout the period spanning from 1976 to 2019
within the Jordanian context. A surge in the
disparity between savings-investment or the budget
deficit precipitates a commensurate escalation in the
current account deficit. Hence, ameliorating the
budget deficit and/or narrowing the savings-
investment gap in Jordan may serve to alleviate the
current account deficit. Nonetheless, the realization
of such objectives necessitates the implementation
of sweeping reforms across the trade and financial
sectors to engender market efficiency. The
enhancement of external competitiveness mandates
policy interventions aimed at bolstering production
and augmenting exports, thereby capitalizing on the
benefits accrued from trade liberalization policies
through production specialization. This inquiry
advocates for financial reforms geared towards
curtailing government expenditure and galvanizing
domestic production and foreign direct investment.
Additionally, it underscores the imperative of
enhancing the investment climate by streamlining
and consolidating investment protocols through the
establishment of a unified investment platform,
curtailing customs declaration timelines, and
expanding the utilization of customs facilitation
mechanisms to expedite the exportation and market
access of goods to foreign jurisdictions. The
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
607
Volume 20, 2024
findings of this research aligned with [19], [20] and
[21].
References:
[1] Evans, P., and I. Hasan, Are Consumers
Ricardian? Evidence for Canada, Quarterly
Review of Economics and Finance, 34, 1994,
25–40. https://doi.org/10.1016/1062-
9769(94)90051-5.
[2] Evans, P., Is the Dollar High Because of
Large Budget Deficits?, Journal of Monetary
Economics, 18(3), 1986, 227-249.
https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-3932(86)90038-
3.
[3] Nazma Latif Zaman and Maria N. DaCosta,
The Budget Deficit and the Trade Deficit:
Insight into this Relationship, Eastern
Economic Journal, 16(4), 1990, 349-354,
[Online].
https://www.jstor.org/stable/40325309
(Accessed Date: October 15, 2024).
[4] Vamvoukas, G., The Twin Deficits
Phenomenon: Evidence from Greece, Applied
Economics, 31, 1999, 1093-1100.
https://doi.org/10.1080/000368499323571.
[5] ALShammary, M. D, Khalid, N., Abdul
Karim, Z., Ahmad, R. Twin Deficits and the
Feldstein-Horioka Hypothesis in the MENA
Region: New Evidence Using Panel VAR
Analysis, Int. Journal of Economics and
Management, 14(3), (2020), 311-329.
https://doi.org/10.3390/economies8040102.
[6] Al-Sawaie, K. M., Jubran, A.M., Abbas, N.A.,
Al-Momani, M. M., Abu-Saleem, TH. A.,
Khrais , I. M., AlBasha, M.H., AlHunaity, M.
(2023), Jordanian Imports: Income and Price
Elasticity of Demand. In: Alareeni, B.A.M.,
Elgedawy, I. (eds) Artificial Intelligence (AI)
and Finance. Studies in Systems, Decision and
Control, vol 488. Springer, Cham.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-39158-
3_69.
[7] Saleem, T.A.A., Abbas, N.A., Al-Sawaie,
K.M., Jubran, A.-H.M. (2021), The impact of
digital trade on Jordan's economic growth,
2021 22nd International Arab Conference on
Information Technology, ACIT 2021.
https://doi.org/10.1109/acit53391.2021.96772
78.
[8] S. Badaik and P. K. Panda, “Ricardian
equivalence, <scp>Feldstein–Horioka</scp>
puzzle and twin deficit hypothesis in Indian
context: An empirical study,” Journal of
Public Affairs, vol. 22, no. 1, Sep. 2020,
https://doi: 10.1002/pa.2346.
[9] M. E. BİLMAN, Türkiye’de Bütçe ve Cari
İşlemler Açıkları İkiz Mi? Kalıntı Temelli
Fourier Eşbütünleşme ve Fourier Nedensellik
Analizlerinden Kanıtlar, Sosyoekonomi, vol.
29, no. 49, pp. 199–215, Jul. 2021. https://doi:
10.17233/sosyoekonomi.2021.03.10.
[10] O. M. Telatar, The Twin Deficits or Negative
Reverse Causality? A Nonlinear Approach to
the Turkish Budget And Current Account
Balances, Uluslararası İktisadi ve İdari
İncelemeler Dergisi, no. 36, pp. 1–20, Aug.
2022. https://doi:
10.18092/ulikidince.1124266.
[11] J. Raskovic, Ricardian equivalence or twin
deficits hypothesis? Evidence from Serbia,
Ekonomski anali, vol. 68, no. 238, pp. 87–
113, 2023, https://doi: 10.2298/eka2338087r.
[12] Feldstein, M., and Horioka, C., Domestic
Saving And International Capital Flows,
Economic Journal, 90(358), 1980, 314-329.
https://doi.org/10.2307/2231790.
[13] Johansen, S. and K. Juselius, Maximum
Likelihood Estimation and Inference on
Cointegration with Applications for the
Demand for Money, Oxford Bulletin of
Economics and Statistics, 52 (2), 1990, 169-
210. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-
0084.1990.mp52002003.x.
[14] Fidrmuc, J., The Feldstein-Horioka Puzzle
and the Twin Deficits in Selected Countries,
Economic Planning, 36, 2003, 135-152.
https://doi.org/10.1023/b:ecop.0000012256.88
112.c2.
[15] Koray F and Mcmillin W., Monetary Shocks,
the exchange rate and the trade balance,
Journal of International Money and Finance,
18, 1999, 925-940.
https://doi.org/10.1016/s0261-5606(99)00031-
5.
[16] Dickey, D.A. and Fuller, W.A., Distribution
of the estimators for autoregressive time series
with a unit root, Econometrica, 49:, 1981,
1057-72. https://doi.org/10.2307/1912517.
[17] Johansen, S., Statistical Analysis of
Cointegration Vectors, Journal of Economic
Dynamics and Control,12, 1988, 231–254.
https://doi.org/10.1016/0165-1889(88)90041-
3.
[18] MacKinnon, J. G., Haug, A. A., and Michelis,
L. Numerical distribution functions of
likelihood ratio tests for cointegration,
Journal of Applied Econometrics, 14(5), 563–
577, 1999. doi: 10.1002/(sici)1099-
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
608
Volume 20, 2024
1255(199909/10)14:5<563::aid-
jae530>3.3.co;2-i.
[19] Hussain, I., Hayat, U., Alam, Md Sh., Khan,
U., A Dynamic Analysis of the Twin-Defcit
Hypothesis: the Case of a Developing
Country, Asia-Pacifc Financial Markets, 31,
(2024), 25–52,
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10690-023-09405-y.
[20] Ahmad, I., Hassan, M., Nawaz, M. A., Twin
Deficit Hypothesis in Pakistan: A Non-Linear
Approach With Structural Break, Ilkogretim
Online - Elementary Education Online, 20(5),
(2021), 5888-5900, https://doi:
10.17051/ilkonline.2021.05.662.
[21] Fouzdar, A. S., Saxena, S. P., Cogency of
Twin and Triple Deficit in India, Scholedge
International Journal of Business Policy &
Governance, 10(7), (2023), 65-79,
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.19085/sijbpg100701
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
I, Khaled Al-Sawaie, contributed fully to the present
research, at all stages from the formulation of the
problem to the final findings and solution.
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
This research is funded by Zarqa University-Jordan.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.57
Khaled Mohammed Al-Sawaie
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
609
Volume 20, 2024