Exploration of the Impact of Religious Activities on Waste Management
Behavior: An Analysis of the Understanding of Environmental Ethics
SITI SOEKISWATI, RIZKA RIZKA, ERNA HERAWATI, AZHAR ALAM, ARIEF BUDIONO*,
KELIK WARDIONO
Faculty of Law,
Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta,
Jalan Ahmad Yani, Mendungan, Pabelan, Kec. Kartasura, Surakarta, Central Java, 57169,
INDONESIA
*Corresponding Author
Abstract: - Waste management is a serious problem in Indonesia. The government is unable to handle around
36% of waste problems. These problems demand serious public attention. The concrete form of the public’s
serious concern is the emergence of ethical environmental behavior in waste management. This research aims
to explore the impact of religious observance activities on waste management and its comparison with the
behavior of the public. This research used a sociological descriptive qualitative approach with an ethnographic
method. This research compared the waste management behaviors of two respondent groups. The first group
consists of women who have received mentoring and training in waste management with economic value. The
comparison group is women who are members of the Jamaah Ummahat Islamic organization of Qur’an
recitation in a mosque. The results show that there is consistency and continuity in forming an understanding of
environmental ethics in their teachings that is capable of changing environmentally ethical behavior in waste
management. The religious sermon material is delivered with effective communication that is easily understood
by the Jamaah Ummahat members.
Key-Words: - environmental ethics, behavior, waste management, religious event.
Received: April 27, 2022. Revised: November 15, 2023. Accepted: December 13, 2023. Published: January 15, 2024.
1 Introduction
The environment is a place of all elements of life
including all artificial materials that support human
activities, [1]. Various environmental damages
occur due to the lack of public awareness and
participation in behavior and ethics toward the
environment. The disturbance of balance in the
environment due to human’s bad ethical behavior
towards the environment can lead to natural
disasters. Among this inappropriate behavior is
improper waste management, resulting in the
siltation of rivers and causing floods, [2]. Plastic
waste that is carried by rivers in the waters of the
earth's surface with its microplastics has a high risk
of polluting the environment, and in turn,
endangering human health, [3].
Waste management is a subject that still requires
substantial attention in numerous countries. For
cities in developing nations like Indonesia, one of
the toughest challenges is to encourage citizen
involvement in the municipal waste management
system, [4]. According to the Republic of
Indonesia’s Ministry of the Environment in 2014,
waste is a potential source of environmental
pollution, [5]. Data from the Indonesian Ministry of
Health show that 240 cities have faced waste
management problems since 2013, [5].
According to data on waste management from
the Ministry of Environment and Forestry in 2022,
the amount of waste from 232 regencies/cities
throughout Indonesia reaches 19,326,673.40
tons/year. The government’s efforts to carry out
waste management still leave around 34.62% of
unmanageable waste, which means that there is still
a need to increase waste management awareness in
the community, [6].
Waste management is a fundamental problem for
the government and society as waste producers. In
addition, research by, [7], showed that Indonesians
who have health insurance facilities are more likely
to behave irresponsibly in waste management.
Common habits of clean and healthy living, such as
correctly disposing of waste are one of the external
factors to prevent environmental damage. It is not
easy to manage waste properly, but if it is done
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
46
Volume 20, 2024
continuously over an extended period, it will create
a good habit in society, [8].
Among the ways to pursue environmental ethical
behavior is by educating the community, [9].
Environmental ethics education is an effort to
change experiences, perspectives, and behavior
towards the environment so that humans think,
realize, and act considerably and responsibly in
resolving environmental problems, [10].
Environmental ethics education aims to form six
things, namely awareness, knowledge, attitude
(behavior), skills, participation, and evaluation, [11].
Environmental awareness is the first goal of
environmental ethics education. Environmental
awareness is an effort to involve every citizen in
growing and fostering awareness of preserving the
environment based on environmental values with
the philosophy of peaceful living with the natural
environment, [12]. The environment is biocentric as
there is life other than humans. So it is ecocentric as
all existing elements are the completeness of the
means of life systems and regeneration of all
creatures, [13]. Ethical awareness of the
environment is crucially required to change societal
behavior to initiate environmental awareness, [14].
The next goal of environmental ethics education
which is expected from the community is
participation. Participation is a person's mental and
emotional involvement that can encourage
contributing and sharing responsibility for
environmental ethics, especially in waste
management, [15]. Citizen participation is
particularly crucial to solving environmental
problems, including those linked to waste
management, [16]. Household waste, which
generally dominates the composition of municipal
waste, shows the important role of citizen
participation in overcoming waste problems, [17].
According to Naess (in his Deep Ecology
concept), awareness and understanding of
environmental ethics must be built based on
religious/spiritual awareness because the human
soul is understood as a pattern of consciousness that
belongs to something, [18]. The human soul has
interdependence with the cosmos and its Creator,
[19]. Islamic ecology is not just about preserving the
environment but is very concerned about scientific
research activities and upholding social justice. It
offers the concept of a spiritual dimension to
environmental management issues, [20].
Textually, Islamic teachings have incorporated
very strong basic laws of environmental ethics. But
at the practical level, there is no evident
manifestation. Rules concerning ethics are not only
rote (textual) but they must be applied to everyday
facts (contextual). Religious teachings about ethics
towards the environment should be realized in
Muslims’ behavior in daily waste management,
[21]. Previous research has revealed that the current
available instructional approaches are neither
successful nor sufficient to bring about enduring
changes in population behavior, [4]. This fact
confirms the need for other strategies in instilling an
orderly behavior of waste management, including
prioritizing the planting of environmental ethics
based on Islamic transcendental values in
community groups.
Based on the explanation above, changes in
environmental ethical behavior in waste
management have a high chance of being realized
through religious activities that are applied with
effective, consistent, and sustainable communication
based on transcendental Islam. Desired behavior
related to environmental awareness varies among
urban people and community groups in various
locations and economic classes, [22].
This made researchers interested in undergoing
research linked to waste management behavior in
general group women of Family Welfare Movement
(FWM/Pemberdayaan Kesejahteraan Keluarga,
abbreviated as PKK in Indonesian), a societal
organization that empowers women to participate in
Indonesia’s development) and a women’s Islamic
religion organization of Qur’an recitation in a
mosque (Jamaah Ummahat).
The contribution of this study is that this research
analyzes which waste management and processing
methods are suitable for Muslim ladies. It provides
information on what type of waste management
makes them interested. This research maps out the
interest in the management of waste processing.
Through this research, after such information is
found, the waste processing management can be
suited to the subject. So far, compared to other
research, the researcher found patterns of waste
management in religious communities that cannot
be found in any previous research. Other research
mapped out waste processing management in non-
religious communities. Meanwhile, there has not
been research on waste processing among religious
women. These findings can provide better
illustration and it can inspire further research.
The researchers compared the two to explore the
impact of religious activities that have Islamic
transcendental ideals. The research aims to fill in the
current gaps about the influence of Islamic
transcendental ideals in waste management
behavior. This research is also expected to
contribute a more comprehensive approach by
involving Islamic transcendental values regarding
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
47
Volume 20, 2024
environmental ethics to create behavioral changes
for better waste management.
1.1 State of the Art
Waste management is a management effort with
various approaches and procedures designed and
implemented to identify, control, and handle various
wastes. It avoids environmental impacts as much as
possible by considering both direct effects (such as
emissions) and indirect effects on the environment
such as depletion of natural resources, [23]. Waste
management behavior is a manifestation of how a
person is ethical towards their environment.
Theoretically, the more favorable consequence
one expects a behavior can result in, the more
intention one may have to perform the behavior, and
hence, the more likely he or she would perform the
behavior, [24]. Interventions should target people's
behavior control over waste management practices
so that they can gain confidence in their ability to
overcome external barriers, and then take action.
Environmental knowledge also offers an important
cognitive basis for developing moral motives in
waste management behavior, [25].
PKK stands for Pemberdayaan Kesejahteraan
Keluarga (Family Welfare Empowerment/FWM), a
community organization that empowers women to
participate in the development in Indonesia, [26].
The definition of jamaah (congregation) according
to KBBI (Kamus Besar Bahasa Indonesia/The Great
Indonesian Dictionary), [27], is a group of
worshipping people. It also means a large crowd or
the public. Etymologically, jamaah (congregation)
means “gathering”, for example, the market
jamaah/congregation is a gathering of people in the
market. The term ummahat comes from Arabic,
meaning mothers”. Therefore, the term jamaah
ummahat means “the gathering of mothers”.
2 Method
This research used ethnography comprising in-depth
descriptions, investigations based on participant
observations, data collection and evaluation of
documents, interviews, and interactions with the
investigated informants, [28]. This research
examined changes in environmental ethical behavior
in waste management based on an understanding of
environmental ethics, in other words this is also
sosiologic methods, [29]. in this research there
aretwo social groups, namely the women of the
Family Welfare Movement in the village and the
women who attend the Qur’an recital classes in SF
mosque (Jamaah Umaahat).
The researcher created a complex description,
examined words, reported detailed views of the
respondents, and conducted the research in a natural
setting, [30]. Researchers conducted documentation
and analysis of the culture formed by the behavior
that became the habit of a community group, the
women of the FWM group, and the women of the
Jamaah Ummahat organization of the SF mosque.
This research placed a greater emphasis on meaning
and it was bound by value in community behavior,
[31]. This ethnographic study approach required
long-term fieldwork, integration of local events,
interactions between parties, and sociocultural
patterns that evolve, [32], [33].
Besides the ethnography method, there is the
normative descriptive method. However, the
researcher chose the former, namely the
ethnographic method. The choosing of the
normative research method will influence the
results, as it cannot map out the behavior and
empirical facts in waste management from the
respondents. Research with the normative type is
not suitable for this research.
Researchers observed the behavior of people in
their environment and interacted with them. The
researchers also tried to understand their language
and interpretation of the management of the waste
they produce, [34]. Researchers contacted and
interacted with people associated with waste
management to seek to understand and investigate
their ideas and experiences. This was carried out to
obtain the information/data needed that were
empirically related to waste management behavior.
This research was conducted in Jetis village. The
researcher chose Jetis village as the research
location as it has a traditional market which is found
next to Daleman River. The area is also next to a
market in Babatan Village, Wonosari District,
Klaten Regency. The Daleman River is a landfill for
waste by the people of these two villages, namely
Jetis and Babatan. These conditions result in the
silting of the river which is prone to causing floods
when the water current is high. The majority of the
Jetis village population is Muslim. This village has
several mosques where people, especially women,
regularly attend religious recitations, namely SY
mosque, SF mosque, Al F mosque, Al B mosque,
and Al I mosque.
The location and the typology of the respondents
were suitable for the ethnographic method and the
qualitative approach. This method was a field
research method. The data were collected through
direct observation and participation in the activities
of the two studied groups.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
48
Volume 20, 2024
The researchers conducted systematic
observation and recording of the studied symptoms.
This methods also known as sociologic methods.
[35]. The observation was conducted undercover
and naturally during the research, [36]. Observation
data is supported by direct interviews with several
members of the studied group, [37]. The researchers
conducted interviews with group members, namely
the women who were members of the FWM and SF
mosque attendees, especially the women who are
members of the Qur'an recitation organization
(Jamaah Ummahat). In addition to interviews, the
researchers documented the process by taking
photographs, the sociologic method was carried out
with several considerations, Firstly, it is carried out
when facing a double reality, in this case, the
behavior formed in the group of women in FWM
and that in the group of women of the Jamaah
Ummahat religious recitation group of the SF
mosque. Second, this method presents a direct
relationship between researchers and respondents.
Third, this method is more sensitive and adaptable
to the sharpening of many combined influences as
well as to the value patterns encountered, namely
the transcendental values that underlie ethics
towards the environment. Then, environmental
ethics shape the behavior of a group of people in
managing the waste they produce, which is not only
measured by pre and post-tests. But it is also
measured from the results of observations during
joint activities and interviews, [38].
There are four characteristics of research
according to, [39], namely: natural, descriptive data
(non-numbers), inductive data analysis, and
“meaning” which are very important. Researchers
observed the behavior of the two groups without
conditioning and any orders or sanctions against
their behavior in waste management. Social
phenomena often cannot be understood based on
what someone says and does. All person’s words
and actions often have a certain meaning. To
identify the significance of each action, it is
explored using qualitative approaches, with in-depth
interview techniques and participation observation
in the sense that the researcher is involved in the
activities of the two groups studied, [40].
The type of qualitative research used in this study
is ethnography, which focuses on giving an
overview and making interpretations of a culture
and social group, namely the group of women of the
FWM community and the women of the Jamaah
Ummahat community of the SF mosque with
different backgrounds, [40]. Observations and
primary interviews in the field were carried out by
researchers over a relatively long period, namely ten
months, from March 2022 to December 2022.
3 Results
This ethnographic research was conducted on two
groups. The first group was the general group,
consisting of 15 women who were members of the
FWM community in J village. These women have
high school, vocational, diploma, and bachelor’s
degree education levels. The second group is
women who attend the Qur’an teaching at the SF
mosque (Jamaah Ummahat). Researchers provided
interventions in the form of mentoring and training
in waste management into goods of economic value,
with the hope that it would affect the participants’
behavior. Mentoring and training were carried out
with the facilitator team for three consecutive
months.
During the mentoring and training stage,
stimulant tools and materials were given to create
products of economic value from household waste.
Organic household waste, like pieces of fresh fruit
and vegetable peels, can be made into eco-enzymes
or compost by fermenting Biowash which is
commonly called one-minute finished compost. If
the organic matter is a bit rotten, regular compost
can be made by adding a fermented place for at least
2 weeks. Inorganic waste like plastic packaging,
grocery bags, and bottles can be made into Eco-
bricks, commonly called plastic bricks. Meanwhile,
waste in the form of cooking oil can be made into
washing soap for kitchen utensils or room cleaning.
In addition, all participants were taught about the
correct behavior in waste management and the
impact of waste on the environment. Specific
teaching material on behavior towards waste
management was presented twice: at the beginning
session and the end of observation, with an interval
of six months.
The interval of six months was the waiting period
needed to test the seriousness of the participants.
During the mentoring and training provided by the
facilitator team, the researchers observed the
behavior and progress of the FWM women in J
village towards waste management. From a total of
15 members who participated, only 3 people took
serious concerns about the waste management
behavior, namely Mrs. Rb (elementary school
teacher), Mrs. E (kindergarten teacher), and Mrs.
Sm (elementary school teacher). Other participants
did not take the mentoring and training seriously
without stimulus.
Finding this, the researchers offered stimulants
by giving honorariums to each FWM woman who
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
49
Volume 20, 2024
was willing to teach the knowledge and skills from
mentoring and training programs to the community
surrounding their home. It was hoped that by giving
the honorariums, their behavior in managing waste
would improve. It was also hoped to encourage their
engagement in the program and motivate them to
become role models in their neighborhood.
The next stimulus was that the researchers gave
one thousand rupiahs per gram for each Eco-brick
they made. Apart from the “selling Eco-bricks”
stimulus, they also had the right to freely use the
Eco-bricks. So, they used the bricks to decorate the
village in celebrating the Indonesian Independence
on August 17th in J village. It was hoped that this
activity may provide benefits by increasing the
skills of participants. Therefore, they can make eco-
bricks and utilize or sell them. Meanwhile, the
incentive only acted as a stimulus.
Researchers found a slight change in behaviors.
Residents who were taught by some FWM women
actively made Eco-bricks. Mrs. R, the chief of the
Family Welfare Movement of Ng Hamlet (RT
02/RW 05) said that the women around them
competed to collect plastic waste after being taught
about waste management by the FWM group to
make Eco-bricks. Later, it was discovered that the
behavioral change in women of the FWM group
towards plastic waste was due to the “selling Eco-
bricks” stimulus.
The sales of Eco-bricks generated additional
income for the family. Participants had a high
interest as it is easy to do and is prospective. The
incentive of 1000 rupiahs (USD 0.064) for every
eco-brick is far from attractive. But the making of
eco-bricks is deemed as interesting as “bricks” are
highly needed and the prospects are great.
The researchers also provided training on making
soap from cooking oil waste to the women of FWM.
However, their knowledge and skills did not
improve and were not taught to other people as they
had to buy reagent materials. The high cost was an
obstacle in the waste management of cooking oil
waste. It is different from eco-bricks that do not
require a great amount of capital, unlike the activity
of making soap that requires reagents to cook the oil
waste and turn it into soap. Participants were more
interested in collecting oil waste from their
households and directly selling it if anyone was
interested.
The researchers made eco-enzymes that were
developed together with FWM members during
training. The eco-enzyme products were used for
diverse benefits. However, when followed up, it was
shown that the knowledge and skills they obtained
were not practiced and improved. The reason was,
once again, it was costly because they had to use
cane brown sugar to activate the process. Such a
result was predicted, considering that the
participants were housewives who had minimum
income. Thus, the cost needed to make brown sugar
was not in their budget allocation.
Through further observation, it was known that
the knowledge and skills in making compost using
several types of waste through waste separation
were abandoned. This was due to the cost dan the
complexity of this activity. The participants
preferred to directly throw waste in the trash bag
and pay IDR 30,000.00 per month for transport
service to landfills. Alternatively, they burn the
trash in the garden behind their house. Paying
30,000 rupiahs (USD 1.92) a month (1000
rupiahs/USD 0.064 a day) is certainly very cheap
and economical compared to processing waste into
compost which is certainly difficult to sell.
Then, the researchers tried to provide stimulants
again to increase motivation. The researchers visited
PH village, Bantul, Yogyakarta in June 2022. PH
Village is a role model village for waste
management. Its Village-Owned Enterprise won the
best national income in 2021. In an interview with
the Head of PH Village, to raise the awareness of its
citizens, the village government’s serious efforts
were crucially needed. They were crucial both to
awakening residents' behavior and to providing
various waste management facilities. This requires
rather large funds, so the Village-Owned Enterprise
tried to make profits from their waste management
to finance these activities.
However, according to the researchers’
observations during the visit, it turned out that the
behavior of the PH village residents was different
from what was expected. There were still scattered
trash cans which the local authority also recognized.
This condition lowered the motivation of the
members of the FWM in J village. Some of them
even said,
”...those who won the award of the best national
Village Owned Enterprise on waste management
are still like that. Then what do you expect of our
village? How can we do that...”
This quote was conveyed by Mrs. Y, who was
the chief of the FWM working group in J village.
This statement was approved by Mrs. Sm and Mrs.
R in an interview on November 12th, 2022. This
disappointment was highly reasonable considering
that this village was the best village for waste
processing on a national scale.
At the same time, while conducting the research,
the researcher made observations on the teaching
attendees of the mosque community, especially the
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
50
Volume 20, 2024
Jamaah Ummahat community at the SF mosque, J
village. The researcher took part in the teaching
activity with the Jamaah Ummahat.
Two types of teaching were attended by the
Jamaah Ummahat where researchers can take part
in the activities as well, namely the Sunday morning
teaching for general participants, on Monday
morning from 6.30 to 8.00 AM, and the An-Nisaa
teaching especially for the women on Wednesday
afternoon from 3.30 to 5.00 PM. Researchers have
taken part in a joint study by the Jamaah Ummahat
of the SF mosque since April 2022. It was the same
time as the implementation of waste management
mentoring and training for the FWM group in J
village.
There were differences between the two groups.
The researchers found that during the activity, the
Jamaah Ummahat members were very disciplined
in participating in the session about managing waste
or food packages. Each Sunday morning session
was attended by 250 to 300 adults and children.
Snacks, sweet hot tea (on dish glass), and breakfast
(on dishes/bowl dishes) were served. Snacks were
served wrapped in plastic and small boxes.
After there was the mentoring and training on
waste management, they changed them into
washable small plastic plates (saucers). The
drinking water was also originally served in
disposable cups, but they were later replaced with
non-disposable cups or glasses. Drinking glasses for
Qur’an learning were kept in the kitchen of the SF
mosque and are presented in Figure 1.
Fig. 1: Drinking glasses for Qur’an learning were
kept in the kitchen of the SF mosque
Mentoring and training on behavior relating to
waste management and cleanliness were delivered
multiple times, both during the Sunday morning
teaching and the An-Nisaa teaching. Researchers
attended 8 courses; most of the lessons were about
cleanliness and waste management.
The researcher conducted six interviews with six
different Jamaah Ummahat members and four times
with the mosque administrator. According to one of
the Jamaah Ummahat members, Mrs. Shr (60 years
old, owner of a beauty salon), they often received
lessons about cleanliness in the SF mosque.
Personally, Mrs. Shr is the coordinator of the
Logistic Division who is responsible for the serving
of snacks and meals for attendees and managing the
waste. Apart from Mrs. Shr, the researcher also
asked the chairperson of the mosque administrator,
Mr. Hm (28 years old, doctor) about hygiene and
morals towards the environment and health. From
the interviews, it was known that the material was
delivered several times by several scholars as part of
the study material related to the morals of a Muslim.
Researchers more often attend Sunday morning
lessons where more people join. At the Wednesday
afternoon lessons, the attendees were only women,
and there were around 100 to 120 people from
different age groups. The researcher asked one of
the attendees, Mrs. M (50 years old, a hairdresser
for women), about what happens if an attendee
litters. During an interview with Mrs. M on
November 15th, 2022, she said that if an attendee
fails to clean up their trash or litter, another attendee
will remind them. The researcher asked the
administrator of the mosque, Mr. Wd (58 years old,
caretaker of the mosque) and he gave a similar
answer. As the person who is responsible for
keeping the mosque clean, he usually kindly
reminds the attendees to maintain cleanliness. If he
couldn’t do so, then other attendees would
participate in cleaning up. In line with this answer,
from an interview with Mrs. Skr (61 years old, soup
seller) at the An-Nisaa class on an afternoon on
November 18th, 2022, researchers asked the same
thing. She answered that waste management in the
mosque area is a shared responsibility of all
attendees. They remind and recommend each other
on the right behavior towards waste to maintain the
cleanliness of the mosque, as added by Mrs. A (58
years old, grocery seller).
On another occasion, the researcher asked how to
remind people who litter. Mrs. Yl (46 years, tailor,
in an interview on November 18th, 2022) answered
that they will be reminded that they must maintain
cleanliness as the scholars said in their teaching that
cleanliness is a part of faith. Mrs. Yn (52 years old,
State Civil Apparatus, laboratory worker at a health
center, an interview on November 18th, 2022) stated
that cleaning up trash is rewarded if the intention is
to seek the pleasure of Allah. On the other hand,
littering, according to scholars, is a minor sin. If
someone continues doing minor sins, they will
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
51
Volume 20, 2024
become bigger sins, said Mrs. Yn. The researcher
heard about what Mrs. Yn said from a scholar who
taught the Sunday morning class, namely ustadz
(teacher) Hsn.
The researcher observed that at the back of the
south side of the SF mosque, there was a little
kitchen and a place for washing dishes for the meals
that were served. After the teaching programs
(Qur’an recitation), the mosque becomes clean
again from waste. All waste was collected and they
were sorted into two: organic and inorganic waste.
Organic waste can be used for compost. Then, the
inorganic (plastic) and organic paper waste were
collected and burned by the mosque caretaker, at the
mosque's waste burning site after the attendees
returned home. Organic waste such as food
residues/rice was collected and brought by some
attendees to feed livestock (poultry) or fish at home.
Organic and inorganic waste bins in the courtyard of
the SF mosque are presented in Figure 2.
Fig. 2: Organic and inorganic waste bins in the
courtyard of the SF mosque
The principle is that the cleanliness of the
mosque is a shared responsibility. Thus, before
leaving the place, attendees must ensure that the
place is clean. If there are new attendees who are
not used to this, other attendees will remind them of
this principle. The mosque cleaning officers are only
responsible for cleaning the mosque during events
or preparation. In an interview on November 6th,
2022 with the administrator of the mosque, Mr. R
(36 years), it was found that the SF mosque is also
often used for marriage events (walimatul ‘ursy).
There is no fee to rent the place, but the event
organizer must be responsible for the cleanliness of
the mosque after the event is held. The same thing is
also applied during the month of Ramadan when the
mosque is used for iktikaf (where the congregation
stays in the mosque to do extra worship). The
cleanliness and tidiness of the mosque must be
considered. If not, the administrator of the mosque
will not hesitate to kindly remind the attendees to
take care of the cleanliness.
Researchers also observed the cleanliness of the
toilet area and ablution area of the SF mosque. The
result showed that these places were exceptionally
clean even though the location of the mosque is on
the edge of a major road and is often used by people
as a transit area. In an interview on November 18th,
2022 with the caretaker of the mosque, Mr. Srj (63
years, a military veteran), the SF mosque is a place
of prayer and transit (bathing, relieving oneself, or
defecation) for traders in the Daleman market and
Babatan market, who come from out of town. Some
came from Tawangmangu, southern Klaten, Ampel-
Boyolali, and southern Sukoharjo. They come
before dawn to drop their goods to the market and
then pray at the mosque. According to Mr. Srj, there
was even a husband of Babatan market traders, who
came from Ampel-Boyolali. This man regularly
attends Sunday morning classes while waiting for
his wife to finish selling beef.
Throughout the researcher's observations in the
cooking area, ablution area, and toilet, there were
written reminders to maintain cleanliness,
supplemented by evidence in the form of hadith
(sayings or actions of Prophet Muhammad).
Including a reminder not to be wasteful in using
water. Reminder inscriptions are also found on
cupboards where prayer objects, mukenas (dresses
worn by women for praying), and/or sarongs are
put, as well as where the Quran is placed. They
remind people to put these items back neatly. A
reminder posted on the wall of the SF mosque's
toilet, reminding people to clean well after relieving
themselves is presented in Figure 3. The
categorization of waste management behaviour
during observational activities is presented in Table
1. Similarly, the categorization of motivations that
underlie the action of the interview is presented in
Table 2.
Fig. 3: A reminder was posted on the wall of the SF
mosque's toilet, reminding people to clean well after
relieving themselves.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
52
Volume 20, 2024
Table 1. Categorization of waste management
behavior during observational activities.
Women of Family
Welfare Movement of J
Village
Women of Jamaah
Ummahat Community of SF
Mosque
Consumable preparations
They use snack boxes
and plastic (for practical
reasons) and they use
glass bottled water.
They use snack plates
(saucers), the glasses to drink
hot tea are reusable, and they
use reusable dishes/bowls
that are rewashed before use.
Activity waste
The waste is
immediately wrapped
into one, put in the
Village Hall trash, and
transported to the
landfill.
The waste is separated.
Organic waste becomes
animal feed, and inorganic
waste goes to the trash and is
burned in the mosque’s
incinerator.
Waste clean-up after the activity
Janitor’s responsibility
Shared responsibility
Table 2. Categorization of motivations that underlie
the action of the interview
Women of Jamaah
Ummahat of SF Mosque
Cleaning up trash after the activity
The spirit that cleanliness is
part of faith (interview with
Mrs. Yl, 46 years old, tailor)
and cleanliness is the
responsibility of all
congregation (interview
with Mrs. Skr, 61 years,
Soto/traditional chicken
soup seller)
The motivation for the action
Cleaning up trash is part of
maintaining health and
getting a reward from Allah
Warning for littering violators
They are reminded to
protect the environment
with shared obligations and
remember about sins when
littering. They are reminded
that Muslims have
responsibility for the
environment.
4 Discussion
Researchers tried to test cognitive-related data in the
form of pre and post-tests for the two groups. These
tests showed different results. The average result on
the pre-test of 15 women from the FWM group in J
village was 60. Meanwhile, on average post-test
result was 75. For the Jamaah Ummahat community
of SF Mosque, the researcher distributed the same
questions to 30 attendees who had attended Qur’an
recitation for at least one year. The results showed
that the average score was 85. This illustrates that
behavior is not exactly formed by knowledge and/or
economic motivation.
Mentoring and training on waste management by
creating products with economic value were not
enough to motivate the community to change their
behavior towards waste. The various stimulants
given failed to change the behavior of the FWM
women. This was in line with the research of, [41],
which showed that temporary counseling and
assistance provided to FWM groups only provided
temporary changes in attitude (behavior). Falah's
research focused on local wisdom and community
education through counseling. Research by, [42],
also showed that there was no significant influence
between the level of knowledge and
environmentally friendly behavior, including waste
management behavior, [42].
According to, [43], the urge to act is not only
determined by environmental factors. But it is also
influenced by mental processes. The relationship
between mental processes and environmental factors
will form a reciprocal pattern, i.e., they influence
each other. Thus, there is a desire to preserve the
environment with proper waste management.
It is also known as the triadic reciprocity.
Reciprocal determinism is a model composed of
three factors that influence behavior: the individual
(including how they think and feel), their
environment, and the behavior itself, [44].
According to Bandura, not only does the
environment influence a person’s thinking, but their
subsequent behavior influences their environment,
[45]. In other words, the environment influences
how a person thinks and feels, which in turn
influences their behavior, which impacts the
environment, and so on, [46].
The three components that influence each other
in the formation of behavior are knowledge,
attitude, and behavior. The interaction of these three
components forms a reciprocal pattern or mutual
influence, where knowledge will give birth to
feelings, and from feelings, the urge to act is born.
This is what is called a complete action. The habit
of maintaining the environment, because one likes
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
53
Volume 20, 2024
and understands environmental sustainability based
on divine concepts, is an example of a complete
action. This action will last a long time. So that
wherever the person is, he or she will undergo the
same action, [47].
Efforts that can improve people’s awareness are
consistent awareness with a divine motive, a
transcendental/divinity base which is the basis of
action. Materials are offered that can enhance
awareness of everyone’s duty for each of their
respective acts for environmental cleanliness, which
was directed by the Creator. This is in line with the
God-Spot invention concept which states that every
human being has a sense of divinity in his/her brain,
[48]. When that point is stimulated, the sense of
God will be activated. That’s how the transcendental
base plays a role in changing a person’s behavior in
waste management or in exhibiting good ethics
towards the environment. It is not just about soulless
environmental cleanliness and its impact on
humanity.
Natural resources and the environment are God’s
gifts that must be utilized for the good of society,
[49]. In utilizing natural resources and the
environment, both of which are gifts from God, one
must always prioritize ethics and morality which are
the core of the transcendentalist philosophy, [49].
Indonesia still lacks laws that carefully govern
environmental preservation, [50]. Therefore, the
active role of the community in educating each other
instilling a spirit of environmental awareness, and
relying on religious values will have a positive
impact on environmental sustainability, [51],
including waste management. Law enforcement in
regulating waste management behavior can be
implemented both preventively or repressively. Law
enforcement that focuses on prevention over
prosecution is considered more humanitarian,
considering the difficulties of altering the culture of
society in addressing waste, [52].
The author recommends that future research
focus on waste management that may generate
financial incentives for housewives. After
conducting this research, it was known that the
making of eco-bricks provides concrete incentives,
as eco-bricks are needed by many people, meaning
that the market is clear. The making of eco-bricks
relatively does not require money. Thus, it is highly
economic. Such training is interesting for
housewives and ladies who join recitation classes in
the mosque.
Other waste management training that requires a
large budget, such as the processing of oil waste,
seems to be uneconomic as there is a need to buy
reagents. Therefore, a unit that collects and buys
waste from the housewives and processes it should
be provided. Household oil waste processing is
profitable if it reaches a certain volume (that is
almost impossible to be reached in a matter of
months by the oil waste of one household)
The support of various communities including
Qur’an recital groups which have advantages in
transcendental (religious) values related to
environmental ethics is urgently needed in
environmental preservation. The activities and
active participation of various community groups
can inspire other communities to care more about
waste management, [53].
The researchers carried out various efforts to
influence behavior in waste management, including
offering mentoring and training in processing trash
into assorted items of economic worth, training on
fermenting organic waste into eco-enzymes,
creating compost from organic waste, making eco-
bricks from plastic waste, and making soap from
cooking oil waste. The stimulus is in the form of
honorariums that are given to those who influence
the community on waste management behavior.
These attempts were not able to generate the
intended results. On the other hand, the continuous
and consistent delivery of materials on waste
management in the form of classes that were
presented with effective communication proved to
affect the attendees’ God-spot area. This can raise
awareness of God in daily life which can be noticed
in changes in the people’s conduct in waste
management. They also formed the habit of
reminding and advising each other about the right
behavior towards waste.
Religion-based changes in the environmental
ethics behavior in waste management which
occurred among the attendees of the SF mosque can
hopefully become an inspiration for this country’s
waste management efforts. Religions such as Islam
always teach cleanliness and good waste
management. But in reality, this religious teaching
is not applied by the female congregation in the SF
Mosque. Therefore, many people still litter and they
lack good waste management. The incompliance
with this religious teaching is ironic as the
environment that should be clean becomes dirty and
full of pollution. There should be positive changes
to apply the teaching to preserve the environment
and not carry out destructive actions such as
littering. Such changes are religion-based changes in
environmental ethics.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
54
Volume 20, 2024
5 Conclusion
Efforts have been made by researchers by providing
assistance and training in processing waste into
various kinds of goods of economic value, such as
training and assistance in fermenting organic waste
into eco-enzymes, making compost from organic
waste, eco-bricks from plastic waste, and making
soap from used cooking oil waste. Unfortunately,
such efforts have not been able to create positive
behavioral changes in waste management in a group
of FWM cadres in Jetis village.
Waste management materials were delivered
continuously/consistently with effective
communication that is easy to understand to the SF
mosque’s ummahat congregation. Such efforts were
able to influence the God-spot area of the
congregation. This fosters awareness of God’s role
in their daily actions. This condition caused changes
in the congregation’s behavior in managing waste.
They formed the behavior of reminding and
advising each other about waste management.
Changes happened in environmental ethics behavior
in waste management based on God’s awareness. It
was formed by the consistent delivery of material
and the condition where worshippers constantly
remind each other.
Acknowledgement:
The authors would like to thank Universitas
Muhammadiyah Surakarta, Indonesia.
References:
[1] S. A. Keraf, Environmental Ethics (Etika
Lingkungan Hidup), Jakarta: PT Kompas
Media Nusantara, 2010.
[2] K. Wardiono, K. Dimyati, S. Sapto Nugroho,
H. Santoso W. Nugroho, J. R. Acob, A.
Budiono, Philosophy, Law, and Ethics of
handling Covid-19 Pandemic in Indonesia,
Open Access Macedonian Journal of Medical
Sciences, Vol. 9, 2021, pp.1104-1108.
DOI: 10.3889/oamjms.2021.7107
[3] A. Rosatto, M. Z. F. Arlindo, M. S. de Morais,
T. D. de Souza, and C. S. Ogrodowski,
Microplastic in Aquatic Systems: A Review of
Occurrence, Monitoring and Potential
Environmental Risks, Journal Environmental
Advance, Vol. 13, 2023.
[4] A. Ghazali, J. H. Tjakraatmadja, S. Sunarti,
and E. Y. D. Pratiwi, Resident-based Learning
Model for Sustainable Resident Participation
in Municipal Solid Waste Management
Program, Global Journal of Environmental
Science and Management, Vol. 7, No. 4, 2021,
pp.599-624, DOI: 10.22034/gjesm.2021.04.08
[5] A. Absori, T. Hernanda, A. Fitriciada Azhari,
K. Wardiono, A. Budiono, Analysis of the
Issues on Bengawan Solo River Basin
Management Policies, WSEAS Transactions
on Environment and Development, Vol. 19,
2023, pp.25-32,
https://doi.org/10.37394/232015.2023.19.3
[6] A. Absori, S. Sapto Nugroho, A. Budiono, E.
Ellyani, S. Nurani Syahida, M. Fadlillah,
Indonesia as an ecocracic country: The state’s
responsibility and the people’s participation in
preserving and in managing the environment
quality, Quality-Access to Success, Vol. 21,
No. 179, 2020, pp.140-143.
[7] B. Y. Gitaharie, R. Nasrudin, A. P. A. Bonita,
L. A. M. Putri, M. A. Rohman, and D.
Handayani, Is there an ex-ante moral hazard
on Indonesia’s health insurance? An impact
analysis on household waste management
behavior, PloS One, Vol. 17, No. 12, 2022,
pp.1-21, DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0276521.
[8] Perkumienė, D. Atalay, A. Safaa, L. Grigienė,
J, Sustainable Waste Management for Clean
and Safe Environments in the Recreation and
Tourism Sector: A Case Study of Lithuania,
Turkey and Morocco. Recycling, Vol. 8, No.
56. https://doi.org/10.3390/recycling8040056
[9] W. Yuspin, K. Wardiono, Islamic banking
trajectories of Indonesia: Dealing with the
present and shaping the future, International
Journal of Economic Research, Vol. 14, No.
16, 2017, pp.29-42.
[10] A. M. Hudha, Husamah, and A. Rahardjanto,
Environmental Ethics: Theory and Practice
(Etika Lingkungan: Teori dan Praktik
Pembelajarannya), Malang: Penerbit
Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang, 2019.
[11] P. Utomo, Environmental Science Learning
Using Gumuk as a Source of Learning
(Pembelajaran Pengetahuan Lingkungan
Menggunakan Gumuk Sebagai Sumber
Belajar), Journal of Biology and Biological
Learning (Jurnal Biologi dan Pembelajaran
Biologi), Vol. 1, No. 1, 2016, pp.14-28.
[12] Lehtonen, T., & Heikkurinen, P, Sufficiency
and Sustainability: Conceptual Analysis and
Ethical Considerations for Sustainable
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
55
Volume 20, 2024
Organisation. Environmental Values, Vol. 31,
No. 5, 2022, pp.599-618.
https://doi.org/10.3197/096327121X16328186
623878
[13] Neolaka, Environmental Awareness
(Kesadaran Lingkungan), Jakarta: Rineka
Cipta, 2008.
[14] O. W. Osawe, G. Grilli, and J. Curtis,
Community Funded Behavioural Change
Initiatives: Water Quality in Ireland, Journal
of Environmental Development, Vol. 47, 2023.
[15] N. I. Sagita, People’s Participation in the
District Performance endidikan in Bandung
City (Partisipasi Warga Masyarakat dalam
Penilaian Kinerja Kecamatan di Kota
Bandung), Journal of Environmental
Education and Sustainable Development
(Jurnal Pendidikan Lingkungan Dan
Pembangunan Berkelanjutan), Vol. 16, No. 2,
2016, pp.101-114.
[16] S. Sunarti, R. S. Y. Zebua, J. H.
Tjakraatmadja, A. Ghazali, B. Rahardyan, K.
Koeswinarno, S. Suradi, N. Nurhayu, and R.
H. A. Ansyah, Social learning activities to
improve community engagement in waste
management program, Global Journal of
Environmental Science and Management, Vol.
9, No. 3, 2023, pp.403-426,
DOI: 10.22035/gjesm.2023.03.04.
[17] R. S. Y. Zebua and Sunarti, The
Implementation of Character Building to
Improve Resident Participation in Waste
Management, IOP Conference Series: Earth
and Environmental Science, Vol. 810, No. 1,
2021, doi: 10.1088/1755-1315/810/1/012025.
[18] N. Ekawati, Deep Ecology as a Basis for
Handling Illegal Logging in Indonesia (“Deep
Ecology” sebagai Dasar Mengatasi Illegal
Loging di Indonesia), Yogyakarta: Fakultas
Filsafat UGM, 2009.
[19] S. Wibowo, K. Dimyati, Absori, K. Wardiono,
T. M. Ramon, and A. Budiono, Islamic
Nomocracy: from the Perspectives of
Indonesia, Spain and Russia, Legality, Vol. 31,
No. 1, 2023, DOI: 10.22219/ljih.v31i1.25358.
[20] Sukarsono, Islamic Ecology in Conservation
Practice and Conservation Education in
Indonesia (Ekologi Islam dalam Praktek
Konservasi dan Pendidikan Konservasi di
Indonesia), Malang: UMM Press, 2016.
[21] T. M. Sudarwati, Implementation of
Environmental Education Policy at State
Senior High School 11 Semarang Towards
Adiwiyata School (Implementasi Kebijakan
Pendidikan Lingkungan Hidup Sekolah
Menengah Atas Negeri 11 Semarang Menuju
Sekolah Adiwiyata), Universitas Diponegoro
Semarang, 2012.
[22] A. Brotosusilo and D. Handayani, Dataset on
waste management behaviors of urban
citizens in large cities of Indonesia, Data in
Brief, Vol. 32, 2020,
DOI: 10.1016/j.dib.2020.106053.
[23] D. A. Vallero and V. Shulman, Introduction to
Waste Management, InWaste: A Handbook for
Management, No. 1 2019,
DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-815060-3.00001-3.
[24] A. Budiono, W. Yuspin, S. S. Nurani, F.
Fairuzzaman, S. W. A. Pradnyawan, and S. D.
Sari, The Anglo-Saxon System of Common
Law and the Development of the Legal
System in Indonesia, WSEAS Transactions on
Systems, Vol. 22, 2023, pp.207-213,
https://doi.org/10.37394/23202.2023.22.21.
[25] L. Wu, Y. Zhu, and J. Zhai, Understanding
Waste Management Behavior Among
University Students in China: Environmental
Knowledge, Personal Norms, and the Theory
of Planned Behavior, Frontiers in Psychology,
2022.
[26] G. G. Giantika, I. W. Utomo, A. Munanjar,
and S. Susilowati, Public Speaking for the
Cibubur Village Family Welfare Development
Team, Jakarta to Support Presentations
(Public Speaking bagi Tim Penggerak
Pembinaan Kesejahteraan Keluarga Kelurahan
Cibubur Jakarta untuk Menunjang Presentasi),
Journal of Community Service and
Empowerment Innovation (Jurnal Inovasi
Pengabdian Dan Pemberdayaan
Masyarakat), Vol. 3, No. 1, 2023, pp.383-392.
[27] Language Development and Development
Agency (Badan Pengembangan dan
Pembinaan Bahasa), The Great Indonesian
Dictionary (Kamus Besar Bahasa Indonesia),
KBBI Daring, 2022.
[28] N. S. Utami, Nanik Prasetyoningsih, Arief
Hidayat, Nikmatul Huda, Suteki, Retno
Saraswati, and Arief Budiono, Equality of the
Political Rights of People with Mental
Disorders (PWMD) in General Elections,
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
56
Volume 20, 2024
Indian Journal of Forensic Medicine and
Toxicology, Vol. 13, No. 4, 2019, pp.1571-
1575.
[29] M. Hammersley and P. Atkinson,
Ethnography: Principles in Practice,
Routledge, Vol. 15, No. 3, 1986.
[30] Aspers, P., Corte, U. What is Qualitative in
Qualitative Research. Qual Sociol Vol. 42,
2019, 139–160
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11133-019-9413-7
[31] H. Wijaya, Spradley Model Qualitative Data
Analysis (Ethnography) (Analisis Data
Kualitatif Model Spradley (Etnografi)),
Sekolah Tinggi Theologia Jaffray, 2018.
[32] S. Larsson, Ethnography in action. How
ethnography was established in Swedish
educational research, Ethnography and
Education, Vol. 1, No. 2, 2006, pp.177-195,
DOI: 10.1080/17457820600715406.
[33] D. Beach, Identifying and comparing
Scandinavian ethnography: Comparisons and
influences, Ethnography and Education, Vol.
5, No. 1, 2010, pp.49-63,
DOI: 10.1080/17457821003768455.
[34] Iskandar, Qualitative Research Methodology
(Metodologi Penelitian Kualitatif), Jakarta:
Galung Persada Press, 2009.
[35] Brown, C., & Lloyd, K, Qualitative methods
in psychiatric research, Advances in
Psychiatric Treatment, Vol. 7. No. 5, 2001,
350-356. doi:10.1192/apt.7.5.350
[36] S. Arikunto, Research Procedures, A Practical
Approach (Prosedur Penelitian Suatu
Pendekatan Praktik), Jakarta: Rineka Cipta,
2010.
[37] Arief Budiono, Yogi Prasetyo, Kelik
Wardiono, Wardah Yuspin, Khudzaifah
Dimyati, Dewi Iriani, Legal Conscience and
the Pressure of the Formal Law System,
Wisdom, Vol. 22, No. 2, 2022, pp.223-233,
DOI: 10.24234/wisdom.v22i2.790
[38] Moleong. L. J, Qualitative Research
Methodology (Metode Penelitian Kualitatif),
Bandung: Remaja Rosdakarya Press, 2000.
[39] Bogdan, R.C. & Biklen, S.K. Qualitative
Research for Education: An Introduction to
Theory and Methods. 5th Edition, Boston:
Allyn & Bacon, 2007
[40] E. Mardiyanto, Qualitative Research: Theory,
Application, and Exemplary Proposals
(Penelitian Kualitatif: Teori dan Aplikasi
Disertai Contoh Proposal), Yogyakarta: UPN
Veteran Yogyakarta Press, 2020.
[41] M. Falah, Environmental Ethics Education
Based on Local Wisdom in PKK Groups in
Sumbersari Village, Sumbersari District,
Jember Regency (Pendidikan Etika
Lingkungan Berbasis Kearifan Lokal pada
Kelompok PKK di Kelurahan Sumbersari
Kecamatan Sumbersari Kabupaten Jember),
Jember: Universitas Jember, 2020.
[42] Y. Septian, R. Mamat, and S. Lili, Eco-
Friendly Behavior of High School Students in
Bandung City (Perilaku Ramah Lingkungan
Peserta Didik SMA di Kota Bandung),
Journal of Geography Education (Jurnal
Pendidikan Geografi), 2016.
[43] Ajzen, I. The theory of planned
behavior. Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis.
Process. Vol. 50, 1991, 179–211. doi:
10.1016/0749-5978(91)90020-T
[44] B. F. Skinner, “A behavioral analysis of value
judgments,” in The Biopsychology of
Development, Academic Press, E. Tobach, L.
R. Aronson, and E. Shaw, Eds. 1971, pp.543-
551.
[45] A. Bandura, Social Learning Theory, United
Kingdom: Prentice Hall, 1977.
[46] E. Sarin and S. S. Lunsford, How female
community health workers navigate work
challenges and why there are still gaps in their
performance: a look at female community
health workers in maternal and child health in
two Indian districts through a reciprocal
determinism framework, Human Resources
Health, Vol. 15, No. 1, 2017, p.44.
[47] Muhaimin, Developing Ecological Awareness
(Membangun Kecerdasan Ekologis),
Bandung: Alfabeta, 2015.
[48] Danah Zohar and I. Marshal, Spiritual Capital:
Empowering SQ in the Business Sector
(Spiritual Capital: Memberdayakan SQ di
Dunia Bisnis), Bandung: PT. Mizan Pustaka,
2005.
[49] H. Turmudi and M. Iksan, Village
Development: Transcendental-Based Natural
Resources and Environment Utilization
Policy, Journal of Transcendental Law, Vol. 4,
No. 2, 2023, pp.124-133,
DOI: 10.23917/jtl.v4i2.18876.
[50] T. Hernanda and U. Giyono, Environmental
Legal Protection of Rivers in the Perspective
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
57
Volume 20, 2024
of Sustainable Development, Journal of
Jurisprudence (Jurnal Jurisprudence), Vo l.
11, No. 1, 2022, pp.100-113.
[51] Pratama A, Kamarubiani. N, Shantini. Y, &
Heryanto, Community Empowerment in
Waste Management: A Meta Synthesis.
Conference: First Transnational Webinar on
Adult and Continuing Education, 2021,
DOI: 10.2991/assehr.k.210508.015.
[52] F. I. Febriansyah, A. W. Yudistiya, and
Surjanti, The Indonesian Journal of Legal
Thought (IJLETH) Online, The Indonesian
Journal of Legal Thought, Vol. 2, No. 1, 2022,
pp.26-34.
[53] G. Anggasta and W. Widiastuti,
Environmental Conservation Ethics carried
out by the Environmental Lovers Community
in Bali (Etika Pelestarian Lingkungan yang
dilakukan oleh Komunitas Pecinta
Lingkungan Di Bali), Sinektika: Architectural
Journal (Sinektika: Jurnal Arsitektur), Vol.
19, No. 1, 2022, pp.82-90,
DOI: 10.23917/sinektika.v19i1.16679.
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
- Siti Soekiswati: Conceived the research, provided
an original idea of the study, and provided
materials and data for the research.
- Azhar Alam and Erna Herawati: Designed the
methods, selected research data, analyzed and
interpreted the data, and wrote the paper.
- Rizka Rizka and Arief Budiono: Analyzed the
data, provided a description, wrote the paper, and
reviewed the paper.
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
This article was funded by the Integrated Tridharma
Grant of Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta,
Indonesia.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT
DOI: 10.37394/232015.2024.20.6
Siti Soekiswati, Rizka Rizka, Erna Herawati,
Azhar Alam, Arief Budiono, Kelik Wardiono
E-ISSN: 2224-3496
58
Volume 20, 2024