Effect of Human Resource Management Practices on Employee
Performance of Quoted Commercial Banks in Nigeria
MARYAM MA’ARUF YAKUBU, HADIZA SAIDU ABUBAKAR, CROSS OGOHI DANIEL
Department of Business Administration, Faculty of Management Sciences,
Nile University of Nigeria,
Plot 681, Cadastral Zone C-OO Research & Institution Area Nigeria, Airport Rd, Jabi 900001, Abuja,
NIGERIA
Abstract: - This study analyzed the impact of human assets the board rehearses (estimated by execution
evaluation, the balance between serious and fun activities variety, and progression anticipating) worker
execution of cited business banks in Nigeria. The review embraced an overview research plan. The review
covered 13 cited Business Banks in Nigeria. The example size of 481 was resolved utilizing Cochran's (1963)
example size recipe and a helpful examining strategy was utilized to choose the respondents. An adjusted poll
was utilized as the instrument for information assortment. The information gathered for the review was
dissected utilizing Fractional Least Square Underlying Condition Demonstrating (PLS-SEM) in deciding the
estimation, primary models, and speculations testing through SmartPLS 3.0 programming. The investigation
discovered that exhibition evaluation and progression arranging affect the representative execution of cited
business banks in Nigeria. While balance between serious and fun activities variety affects the representative
execution of cited business banks in Nigeria. The review, in this way, reasons that presentation examination
and progression arranging decidedly and altogether impact worker execution of cited business banks in Nigeria.
While the balance between fun and serious activities varies decidedly yet unimportantly impacts the
representative execution of cited business banks in Nigeria. Thus subsequently suggested among others cited
business banks in Nigeria ought to further develop their balance between serious and fun activities variety
practice via abstaining from clashing the functioning hours with representatives' hours to have powerful worker
obligation to their positions.
Key-Words: - Performance Appraisal, Work-life Balance Variation, Succession Planning, Employees
Performance, Quoted Commercial Banks
Received: September 27, 2022. Revised: August 19, 2023. Accepted: September 17, 2023. Published: October 9, 2023.
1 Introduction
Employees’ performance is an attempt to analyze the
performance of the workers and all the related
psychological and physical characteristics, technical
skills, and behavior, to identify the strengths and
weaknesses. It tries to strengthen the strengths and
address the weaknesses to achieve the effectiveness
of the institution now and in the future. Employees
are a primary source of competitive advantage in
service-oriented organizations. In other words,
employees are resources or assets to organizations.
The performance of employees plays an important
role in organizational performance. It is originally
what an employee does or does not do. The
performance of employees could include the
quantity of output, quality of output, timeliness of
output, presence at work, and cooperativeness.
Individual employee performance could improve
organizational performance as well as legal, [1].
The human asset the executives (HRM) practice in
an association is viewed as in the different area's
managerial levels and specialized disciplines that are
the genuine point of support on which the
association is based. This asset likewise addresses
the genuine apparatus to accomplish the
administration targets and add to the
accomplishment of the general goals of the
association. They are the wellspring of improvement
and they can utilize the other material assets
accessible to the establishment since it is viewed as
the genuine wellspring of seriousness, [2]. HRM
rehearses incorporate work examination, bearing,
execution evaluation, progression arranging, work
relations, the balance between fun and serious
activities variety, determination, enlistment,
remuneration, correspondence, and preparing
improvement, [3]. In any case, the HRM rehearses
worried in this study are execution evaluation, the
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
415
Volume 11, 2023
balance between fun and serious activities variety,
and progression arranging.
All through the drawn-out delegates' show in the
monetary region in Nigeria has transformed into a
subject of stress as they stay key to the organization
of the banks and various accomplices, this leads the
banks to continually search for and embrace the best
HR practices to secure competent and capable
employees that will ceaselessly work really to get
along with their presumptions by performing at the
most raised level so that offers a high ground to the
bank and protect the premium of the financial
backers and client, [4]. However, the quoted
Nigerian commercial banks' employee performance
continues to fall short of expectations, which causes
concern for bank management. This has made the
attitude of this review to examine the adequacy of
HR the board rehearses (HRMP) embraced by the
cited business banks in Nigeria.
Besides, a few past researchers have made
various entries with respect to HR executive
rehearses (HRMP) and worker execution. For
example, [5], presented that business banks plan to
raise the degree of execution of their representatives
to meet the degree of rivalry in the area,
notwithstanding this earnest need to work on the
workers' presentation, numerous signs demonstrate
the shortcomings in the practical execution of
employees in business banks. In, [5], the authors
presented that because of the fast development,
profoundly serious challenges in the financial area
by and by, the area set out on sound managerial
approach, steady HR rehearses, worker work
fulfillment, and authoritative responsibility all with
the desire to acquire top representative execution,
however regardless of this work, representative’s
execution in the area isn't steady. The study, [6],
confirmed that representatives' lackluster showing in
an association is a consequence of poor HRMP set
up by the associations, for example, unsatisfied
prosperity as far as remunerations like
compensation, wages, and advantages, new to the
exhibition assessment process, incapable approaches
to retaining workers into the association and the
means accessible for them to improve their abilities
and information.
Be that as it may, a few investigations led zeroed
in more on HRM practice and hierarchical execution
with less accentuation on worker execution, while
others zeroed in on a solitary variable or mix of a
couple of factors of HRM Practice. For example, [6],
zeroed in on the effect of human asset the board
practices of supervisors on saw authoritative
execution in Sri Lanka, [7], led a concentrate on the
effect of HR the executives rehearses on hierarchical
responsibility, Execution, [8], zeroed in just on the
impact of pay on representatives' exhibition in
Specialized College, [9], zeroed in on human asset
the executives and hierarchical execution; while,
[10], zeroed in just on balance between serious and
fun activities and worker execution in the service of
money and financial preparation in Kenya. The
study, [11], zeroed in just on the effect of enrolment
and determination methodology on representatives'
presentation, [12], and zeroed in just on the impact
of progression anticipating worker execution. As a
result, no other study has been conducted that
employs the combination of the variables used in
this study (performance evaluation, work-life
balance variation, and succession planning). It is
considering the above issues and the longing to fill
the distinguished holes that this study tries to look at
the impact of human assets the board rehearses on
worker execution of cited business banks in Nigeria.
As needs be the principal objective of this study
is to take a gander at the effect of human resource
the board practices on specialist execution of
referred to business banks in Nigeria. To achieve
this objective, the audit was coordinated by the
going with unequivocal targets: examine the impact
of execution examination on workers' exhibition of
cited business banks in Nigeria;
i. examine the impact of balance between
serious and fun activities minor departure from
representatives' exhibition of cited business banks in
Nigeria; and
ii. assess the impact of progression anticipating
representative execution of cited business banks in
Nigeria. The following hypotheses were formulated
as a result of the study's objectives:
HO1: Execution examination significantly affects
workers' exhibition of cited business banks in
Nigeria.
HO2: Work-life balance variation does not have a
significant effect on employees' performance of
quoted commercial banks in Nigeria.
HO3: Progression arranging affects workers'
presentation of cited business banks in Nigeria.
2 Literature Review
2.1 Human Resource Management Practice
HRMP, according to, [13], can be considered
essential human resources practices, such as
representative staffing, staff development, executive
execution, board compensation, and empowering
worker contribution in dynamic organizations.
According to, [14], human asset exercises are
regarded as an important component of Human
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
416
Volume 11, 2023
Assets, the Board, Representative Relations, and
Authoritative and Modern Brain science. According
to, [13], the concept of human asset the executives
(HRM) arose primarily as an affirmation of the
manner in which human resources should be
overseen by the administration for the company to
enjoy a long-term advantage over others. The study,
[15], likewise expressed that a business that does
HRMP like turn of events, preparing,
enrolment/determination, evaluation, pay
framework, balance between serious and fun
activities assortment, and movement organizing will
need to accomplish its objectives and foster
methodologies actually and can in like manner
execute game plans inside the affiliation. The core
strategies and procedures that are established and
used to ensure that the organization's human
resources contribute to the achievement of the
organization's goals through effective and efficient
recruitment/selection practice,
training/development, performance appraisal,
compensation, communication, variation in work-
life balance, and succession planning are all related
to, [15]. In spite of the staggering conceptualization
of HRMP. This study chose to embrace the meaning
of HRMP presented by, [15], because the definition
is current, far-reaching, and reasonable for this
work.
2.2 Performance Appraisal
As per, [16], it is difficult to find a particular
definition that includes all the dimensions of
performance appraisal so it is important to consider
the common acceptable features and elements of
performance appraisal. According to, [17],
performance appraisals (PA) have been used by
organizations to evaluate employees’ performance.
It has been argued that PA can be a powerful tool to
motivate employees towards achieving
organizational goals through its use in rewarding,
promoting, developing, and improving workforce
capabilities, [17], [18], opined that performance
appraisal is the judgment of an employee’s
performance in a job based on certain considerations
apart from productivity alone. This can also be
viewed as an attempt to analyze the activities of the
worker and all the related psychological or physical
characteristics or technical skills and behavior, to
identify the strengths and weaknesses, [19].
Performance appraisal measures variables such as
efficiency and effectiveness of job performance,
[20]. Performance appraisal also evaluates
employees’ productivity, job worth, consumer
satisfaction, invention, and workers' fulfillment on
the job, [20].
2.3 Work-Life Balance Variation
The study, [21], argued that a lone significance of
harmony among serious and fun exercises doesn't
exist and no such definition that would gather
comprehension of numerous social occasions exists.
Before long, they suggested that harmony among
serious and fun exercise practices implies one of the
going with: Care for dependents, flexible work
schedules, and leave for family or personal reasons
from the organization. The capacity of people,
paying little mind to progress in years or orientation,
to "get into a stream" that empowers them to adjust
the requests of work with different obligations and
exercises beyond work is the focal point of the idea
of balance between serious and fun activities, [22].
If a person can strike a balance between family,
friends, and responsibilities at work, [23], argues
that striking a balance between serious and fun
activities (WLB) is a condition of prosperity that
they should all strive for, [24], imparted that all
specialists ought to save a decision to rehearse
livelihoods that don't obstruct their ways to deal
with settling their life matters.
In the end, WLB incorporates changing work
plans so everybody, paying little mind to maturity,
race, or direction can find a musicality that engages
them even more to combine work and their various
commitments and objectives, [25]. Nowadays, WLB
is seen as a tremendous matter for the two chiefs
and employees that they need to deal with. It is even
clear that numerous work environment issues are
believed to be brought about by clashes among work
and family, [23].
2.4 Succession Planning
Progression arranging is a cognizant choice by an
association to cultivate and advance the persistent
improvement of workers and guarantee that key
positions keep up with some proportion of
steadiness, in this manner empowering an
association to accomplish business targets, [26].
Specifically, the study, [26], further expresses that
generally, progression arranging has at times
adopted a substitution strategy, frequently zeroing in
on leader-level positions. As indicated by, [27],
movement orchestrating is any work expected to
ensure the continued suitable execution of an
affiliation, division, division, or work pack by
making a plan for the new development,
replacement, and crucial usage of key people for a
long time. Change involves more than just replacing
key executives; rather, it centers on key talent pools,
regardless of authority level, whose performance
makes the organization viable in the commercial
center. Imperative capacity the chiefs embrace
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
417
Volume 11, 2023
assurance, improvement, and execution to see
potential and move a steady load of people up and
across the affiliation, [28]. As needs be
extraordinary movement organizing can result in to
augment in execution. [27], expressed that the goal
of progression arranging is to guarantee the
accessibility of proper HR to fill the empty position
screened by retirement, advancement, and the
renunciation of workers.
2.5 Employee Performance
The study, [29], says that many businesses use a
rating system called "employee performance" to
determine an employee's abilities and output. The
capacity of employees to carry out a task or a set of
duties and responsibilities is what is meant by
employee performance. Representatives are viewed
as powerful when they achieve standard depictions
and incapable when the work isn't achieved based
on behavior and performance, [30]. As indicated by,
[31], worker execution contains quality and amount
of results driven by individual or gathering battle
consummation. In other importance work execution
can be depicted as the capacity of people to
accomplish their separate work points, then live up
to their assumptions, accomplish benchmarks, or
achieve their authoritative objectives, [5]. Worker
execution epitomizes the entire conviction of the
representative about their lead and commitment to
the achievement of the association and pay
rehearses, execution assessment, and special
practices are determinants of worker execution, [1].
Representative Execution is related to the amount of
result, nature of the result, idealness of result,
presence/participation at work, the productivity of
the work finished and adequacy of work finished,
[32]. Worker work execution is about the idealness,
adequacy, and proficiency in the fruition of errands
set out by a business to the representative. Likewise,
execution is an interaction where individuals from a
work environment add to the satisfaction of the
general target of the association, [33].
2.6 Empirical Review
2.6.1 Performance Appraisal and Employee
Performance
The study, [34], assessed the connection between
execution examination, worker support, expected set
of responsibilities, preparation/advancement,
remuneration/pay practices, and responsibility of
representatives in the financial business. A clear
examination configuration was taken on by the
review where 15 Business Banks were shrouded in
Nepal and an example of 525 was utilized. The
information acquired for the concentrate through the
survey was dissected utilizing elucidating
measurements, unwavering quality examination, and
relapse investigation. The investigation discovered
that presentation evaluation, pay/pay, preparation
and improvement, set of working responsibilities,
and representative support show a reasonable
positive relationship with all parts of worker
responsibility in Nepal Business Banks. The data
utilized in the examination was acquired through the
review strategy from essential sources in this way
the validity of the results depends on the individual
perception of the participants.
Additionally, [35], analyzed the idea of the
connection between execution examination and
representative maintenance in the Nigerian
protection industry; furthermore, to discover the
degree of the relationship between human assets,
board practices, and worker execution in the
Nigerian protection industry. The review took on an
illustrative overview research plan. The poll was
directed to an example size not set in stone from the
complete populace of 785 utilizing Taro Yamane's
example size assurance recipe and a straightforward
irregular testing procedure to choose the
respondents. The review utilized spellbinding
insights of mean, standard deviation, and fluctuation
and relationship investigation to break down
information. The investigation discovered that
presentation evaluation significantly affects worker
execution in the Nigerian protection industry. The
review neglected to make sense of the particular
Nigerian protection firms covered. In addition, the
study's data analysis consisted solely of mean,
standard deviation, and variance, as well as
correlation analysis, which prevented it from
evaluating the relationship between the variables
studied.
2.6.2 Work-Life Balance Variation and
Employee Performance
The study, [36], assessed the effect of human assets
the board rehearses (balance between serious and
fun activities variety, impetuses, preparing,
particular recruiting, and employer stability) on
representative execution. The review embraced a
study research plan. The review utilized an example
of 240 respondents from a populace of 300
representatives with the guide of irregular examining
procedures. Pearson's Connection and Various
Relapse tests were utilized to decide the strength as
well as the relationship of both the reliant and the
autonomous factors. The investigation discovered
that balance between fun and serious activities
variety has a confirmed relationship with worker
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
418
Volume 11, 2023
execution and can essentially make sense of
hierarchical execution. The review was finished in
Iraq and covered just the Service of Provincial
Districts and Water Assets in the Kurdistan locale.
Likewise, [23], directed a concentration on balance
between fun and serious activities builds and worker
work fulfillment: evidence from the investment
industry in Palestine. The design of the study was a
survey. The review covered 7 different speculation
organizations in Palestine and tested 502 workers.
The review used a poll as the instrument for
information assortment. The review utilized
unmistakable insights and different relapses to
dissect the information accumulated and test the
speculations. The investigation likewise discovered
that the Balance between fun and serious activities
affects representative work fulfillment in the
Palestinian venture area. In the study, not only were
work-life balance and employee job satisfaction
measured by one variable, but also by another.
2.6.3 Succession Planning and Employee
Performance
The study, [12], analyzed the impact of progression
anticipating worker execution in the Service of ICT,
Development, and Youth Undertakings in the
Nairobi City Region, Kenya. The review took on an
expressive exploration plan. The number of
inhabitants in the review comprised 332
administration faculty drawn from the Service of
ICT, Advancement, and Youth Issues out of which
175 were estimated to still be up in the air. The
review used a poll as the instrument for information
assortment. The information gathered for the review
was dissected utilizing clear measurements and
relapse examination. The investigation discovered
that progression arranging had areas of strength for a
huge impact on representative execution in the
Service of ICT, Development, and Youth Issues.
The review was not earnest on the populace utilized
as that probably won't be the genuine populace of
the Service of ICT, Development, and Youth Issues
in Nairobi City Region, Kenya.
Likewise, [30], decides the impact of vital
human assets the board practices and worker
maintenance in business banks in Nairobi, Kenya.
The review utilized progression intending to gauge
key human assets the executives rehearsed. The
review embraced an elucidating study research plan.
The example size utilized for the review contained
336 respondents including 42 high-level chiefs, 84
center-level supervisors, and 210 low-level directors
of business banks in Nairobi, Kenya. A poll was
utilized as the instrument for information
assortment. Various relapse examinations were
utilized to investigate the information accumulated.
The discoveries from the review portrayed that
progression arranging affects worker maintenance in
business banks in Nairobi, Kenya. This has
prompted high staff turnover in most business
banks.
2.7 Theory: Human Capital Theory
The study, [37], hypothesis asserts that challenges
like globalization, an information-based economy,
and mechanical development have forced numerous
nations and organizations to look for better ways to
maintain an advantage, [38]. The standard technique
in labor monetary issues is said to see HR as a lot of
capacities or characteristics that work on an expert's
proficiency. As per, [39], the supply of useful
information and abilities moved by employees is
alluded to as human resources. The study, [40], adds
that the possibility of human resources is the blend
of human and capital on a semantic level. Due to the
human tendency to assume responsibility for all
financial activities, such as creation, utilization, and
exchange, in addition to the financial significance of
capital, the workplace ought to be designed to
accommodate workers' lives, [41]. In this capacity,
representatives' behavior ought to be evaluated.
Those who assume control over the assignment or
schedule of others when they are absent ought to be
clear. The speculation is appropriate to this
concentrate as it gets the elements used in this
survey.
3 Research Methodology
The objective of this study is to examine the effect
of human resource management practices on
employee performance of quoted commercial banks
in Nigeria. The review estimated human assets the
executives rehearse through execution assessment,
the balance between serious and fun activities
variety, and progression arranging, while
representative execution was estimated by work
execution. The plan of the review was a study. The
audit covered 13 referred to Business Banks in
Nigeria. The thirteen (13) referred to business banks
covered are Access Bank Plc, First Bank of Nigeria
Confined, First City Milestone Bank Limited,
Accreditation Trust Bank Plc, City Bank Plc, Polaris
Bank Confined, Commitment Bank Plc, Legitimate
Bank Plc, Joined Bank for Africa (UBA) PLC, Eco
Bank, Taj Bank, Wema Bank Plc and Pinnacle Bank
Plc. The choice was made for quoted commercial
banks in Nigeria because they have a higher value
and capital structure than unquoted banks.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
419
Volume 11, 2023
Moreover, this study focused on specialists in the
Division of HR (HR) so to speak. The HR office's
attention on its representatives is legitimate by the
way that experience and information on the
evaluation factors. Consequently, the number of
tenants in this study was depicted as dim, as there is
no power-appropriated record to get the expansive
outline of the staff of just the HR division of the
thirteen (13) referred to business banks in Nigeria.
Along these lines, the legitimization for naming the
population in this region as enigmatic rests on the
fact that it is essential for the way of life of the
banks not to reveal or release any information about
their representatives to an outsider. As a result, it is
difficult to determine the number of employees
working in the HR branch of the thirteen (13) cited
business banks in Nigeria.
Consequently, the sample size for this review
was determined using Cochran's (1963) example
size assurance recipe for determining a limitless or
obscure population. Cochran (1963) developed the
condition for an overall public that is huge or
preposterously gigantic or dim, to yield a delegate
test for degrees. n is the model size, Z2 is the
abscissa of the common curve that eliminates a
locale at the tails (1 - approaches the ideal level of
sureness, e.g., 95 percent), e is the ideal level of
precision, p is the surveyed degree of a
characteristic that is accessible in the general
population, and q is 1-p in Cochran's (1963) model
size recipe. The inspiration for Z is found in obvious
tables that contain the district under the typical
bend.
Consequently, for the motivations behind this
examination, Z2 is the Z esteem more than a 95%
certainty span, e is 5%, P is the populace size, and q
= 1-p = 1-0.6=0.4. The sample size for this study
was 481, in addition to the 30% attrition rate
suggested by, [42], [43]. Likewise, a solace testing
methodology was utilized to choose the survey
respondents. The review included an outline as the
instrument for information assortment. The
overview utilized was changed from made by, [43],
[44], [45], [46], [47], [48]. The review was
controlled in essentially a similar way. Cronbach
alpha was used to determine the instrument's
constant nature. A Cronbach's alpha worth more
noteworthy than 0.7 is satisfactory, [49]. 338 of the
481 copies of the controlled survey were huge for
the assessment, or 70% of the absolute coordinated
overview. Using SmartPLS 3.0 programming, the
data were analyzed using Partial Least Square
Hidden Condition Illustrating (PLS-SEM) after the
evaluation, [49]. The authenticity and reliability of
the actions were first totally found out before testing
the conjectured connections utilizing algorism and
bootstrapping procedures, [49]. The model for the
PLS-SEM is displayed underneath (Figure 1):
Fig. 1: Model Specification
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
3.1 Measurement of Variables
Independent variable: Performance evaluation,
work-life balance, and succession planning are
measures of human resource management practices.
Execution evaluation: The size of the execution
examination was adjusted from crafted by, [43],
[44]. Test things were: I partake consistently in
execution examinations; Performance Appraisal
results are the only criteria for promotions.
Balance between serious and fun activities
variety: The size of the balance between fun and
serious activities variety was adjusted from crafted
by, [47]. Test things are: My work gives personal
chance to take care of my family, My association
gives me a pass on to focus on and support my
wards, and Study/preparing leave permits me to get
some much-needed rest for study or preparing to
work on my self-awareness
Progression arranging: The size of progression
arranging was adjusted from crafted by, [45], [46].
Test things included: We have a system for
succession planning that is very clear. Our
association recognized the objective gathering for
the progression endeavors.
Dependent variable: Employee Performance,
estimated by Representative Work Execution. The
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
420
Volume 11, 2023
size of representative execution was adjusted from
crafted by, [43], [48]. Sample items were: I
adequately completed the assigned duties. I Fulfill
the responsibilities specified in the job description. I
perform tasks that are expected of me
4 Result and Discussion
Table 1. Descriptive Statistics of Dependent and
Independent Variables
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Performance Appraisal
0.143
0.045
Work-Life Balance
Variation
0.014
0.052
Succession Planning
0.313
0.069
Employee Performance
0.232
0.041
Source: Author’s computation SmartPLS Output, 2023
Table 1 above shows the way to deal with the
acting of the factors under study and gives the
quantifiable depiction of the components as
conveyed in the information gathered concerning
the mean and standard deviation. The mean possible
additions of the components with their particular
standard deviation values for the factors under study
are all under 1, correspondingly the opening
between the mean qualities and the standard
deviation values in the various cases isn't all near
anything and this shows that the information for the
factors are regularly and likewise dissipated. While
using the standard least square (OLS) backslide
method, the conventionality of the data is a concern;
regardless, while using the PLS-SEM method, this
speculation is supplanted and isn't an issue that
could hinder any further assessment or produce a
sort of inclination in the result, [49].
4.1 Discriminate Validity
Table 2. Heterotrait-Monotrait Ratio (HTMT)
Employee
Performance
Performance
Appraisal
Succession
Planning
Work-Life
Balance
Variation
0.544
0.298
0.338
0.303
0.394
0.212
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
Table 2 above shows the eventual outcomes of
the Heterotrait-Monotrait (HTMT) extent for the
elements used in this investigation which was used
to overview the different authenticity. From the
table, the results in all of the specific cases show
that values are under 0.9, this, in like manner,
exhibited that there is a setback of isolated
authenticity issues. That is, the result revealed that
everything is all set of isolated authenticity in all
specific cases as suggested by, [50]. Isolate
authenticity issues are accessible when HTMT
values are higher than 0.90 for hidden models, [50].
4.2 Measurement Model Evaluation
The convergent validity was used to evaluate the
measurement model using convergent validity.
Convergent validity is determined by examining the
factor loadings, composite reliability, and average
variance extracted (AVE), [51]. All the constructs
used in this study have achieved acceptable factor
loadings of above 0.6, as a result, no construct was
deleted from the analysis; the composite reliability
(CR) of all the constructs was above 0.7 and the
Average variance extracted (AVE) were all above
0.5 as recommended by, [49]. The above is depicted
in Figure 2 and Table 3 (Appendix).
Fig. 2: Measurement model of the study constructs
and indicators.
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
4.3 Co-linearity Test
A co-linearity test was led to guarantee the shortfall
of multi-linearity which could prompt predisposition
in the outcomes. This was surveyed through the
change expansion factors (VIF). When in doubt,
VIF values shouldn't surpass 5 to show the shortfall
of multi co-linearity, [49]. Table 4 displays the co-
linearity test's conclusion:
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
421
Volume 11, 2023
Table 4. Statistics on Co-linearity (Variance
Inflation Factor (VIF)
Variables
VIF
Performance Appraisal
1.253
Work-Life Balance
1.118
Succession Planning
1.172
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
From the Table 4, the Change Expansion
Element (VIF) upsides of 1.253, 1.118, and 1.172
for every one of the separate cases showed that the
informative factors do not exceptionally correspond.
These, consequently, show the shortfall of multi-co-
linearity among the autonomous factors utilized
since exists only when the VIF Value is greater than
5. The Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) was used to
evaluate the co-linearity of the formative indicators.
All the VIF values were less than 5 indicating the
absence of critical co-linearity issues among the
indicators of formatively measured constructs, [49],
[51].
Table 5. Model Goodness of Fit (GoF) Summary
Saturated Model
Estimated Model
SRMR
0.055
0.055
d_ULS
0.624
0.624
d_G
2.574
2.574
Chi-Square
2,464.032
2,464.032
NFI
0.696
0.696
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
The model's goodness of fit result can be seen in
Table 5. A spin-off of the need to approve the PLS
model, there is a need to survey the integrity of the
spasm of the model as recommended by, [49]. The
standardized root means square residuals (SRMR)
were used in this study. The decision of this file
depended on the way that the SRMR gives without a
doubt the fit measure where a worth of zero
demonstrates an ideal fit. The review embraced,
[52], the idea that a worth of under 0.08 addresses a
solid match while applying SRMR for model
decency of fit. According to, [52],
recommendations, the study's SRMR value of 0.055
is less than 0.08, indicating the model's fitness, [51].
4.4 Structural Model and Hypotheses Testing
Fig. 3: Structural Model and Hypotheses Testing
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
Figure 3 and Table 6 shows the aftereffects of
the review. The standard beta and the comparing t-
values were utilized in surveying the primary model
in this review. This was finished through the
bootstrapping system. The bootstrapping result from
the Brilliant PLS uncovers that the way coefficient
of execution evaluation and worker execution (PFA-
>EMP) is positive and measurably huge with a beta
(β) worth of 0.447 (45%), t-worth of 7.760 and a p-
worth of 0.000 -esteem = 0.447, t-esteem = 7.760
and p-esteem = 0.000). This outcome has given
adequate ground to dismissing the invalid
speculation which expresses that PFA affects the
EMP of cited business banks in Nigeria.
Consequently, this invalid speculation is dismissed.
This has demonstrated that the connection between
PFA and EMP is positive and huge at 0.05 critical
levels. This suggests that Nigeria's quoted
commercial banks' PFA practices harm employee
performance.
The speculation for the progression arranging
and representative execution (SUP->EMP) is
positive and measurably huge with a beta (β) worth
of 0.119 (12 percent), with a t-value of 2.214 and a
p-value of 0.027 (-value = 0.119, t-value = 2.214,
and p-value = 0.027). This outcome has given
adequate ground to dismissing the invalid
speculation which expresses that SUP significantly
affects the EMP of cited business banks in Nigeria.
Along these lines, this invalid speculation is
dismissed. At 0.05 significance levels, this
demonstrates that the relationship between SUP and
EMP is positive and significant. This suggests that
SUP practice by cited business banks in Nigeria
ginger the exhibition of their workers as anyone else
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
422
Volume 11, 2023
or strategy to succeed the ongoing one is
guaranteed.
The speculation for balance between serious and
fun activities variety and worker execution (WLB-
>EMP), the bootstrapping result from the Shrewd
PLS uncovers that the way coefficient of WLB and
EMP is positive and critical with a beta (β) worth of
0.099 (10%) with t-worth of 1.859 and its relating p-
worth of 0.064 - regard = 0.099, t-regard = 1.859
and p-regard = 0.064). This result has not given
satisfactory ground for excusing this invalid
hypothesis which communicates that WLB
genuinely influences the EMP of referred to
business banks in Nigeria. Subsequently, the invalid
hypothesis is recognized. The connection between
WLB and EMP is positive, yet at p 0.05, it is
inconsequential. This proposes that Nigeria's cited
business banks' balance between serious and fun
activities variety practice is advantageous, yet not
critical enough to further develop representative
execution.
The R2 shows the farsighted meaning of the
model. The R2 shows the change in the dependent
variable as figured out by the free factors. The result
shows an R2 worth of 0.295 (30%) accounted by the
judicious elements on the standard variable of the
model. That is, the coefficient of assurance (R2) of
0.295 demonstrates that the joined impacts of
execution evaluation, progression arranging, and
balance between serious and fun activities variety
represent roughly 30% of the variety in worker
execution of cited business banks in Nigeria, while
different elements or factors excluded from this
study represent the leftover 70%.
From the outcome in Table 6 and the
examination, the investigation discovered that
presentation evaluation meaningfully affects worker
execution of cited business banks in Nigeria. The
finding of this study is in concurrence with the
discoveries of, [34], [35], who in their examinations
found that exhibition evaluation affects worker
execution.
The study also found that quoted commercial
banks in Nigeria's employee performance is
positively and significantly impacted by succession
planning. The finding of this study is
simultaneousness with the disclosures of, [12], [23],
who in their assessments found that movement
organizing influences specialist execution.
However, the study found that employee
performance at Nigeria's listed commercial banks is
positively affected, but not significantly, by
variations in work-life balance. This finding
conflicts with the revelations of, [12], [36], who in
their assessments found that harmony among serious
and fun exercises assortment altogether influences
delegate execution. This could be a consequence of
the differentiation in their assessment region as their
assessments were driven in the Kurdistan locale
Palestinian endeavor region independently.
5 Conclusion and Recommendations
This study analyzed the impact of looks at the
impact of human assets the board rehearses
(estimated by execution evaluation, balance between
fun and serious activities variety and progression
anticipating) worker execution of cited business
banks in Nigeria. From the discoveries of this
review, it is presumed that presentation examination
and progression arranging emphatically and
essentially impact worker execution of cited
business banks in Nigeria. While the balance
between fun and serious activities variety
emphatically yet irrelevantly impacts the
representative execution of cited business banks in
Nigeria
In light of the discoveries and end drawn from
this review, that's what the review suggests:
i. Quoted commercial banks in Nigeria should
continue to improve their performance evaluations
by providing employees with regular feedback or by
communicating each performance evaluation to
them and rewarding them accordingly. Doing so
will increase employee competition.
ii. Cited business banks in Nigeria ought to enhance
their balance between fun and serious activities
variety practice via abstaining from clashing the
functioning hours with representatives' hours to
have successful worker obligation to their positions.
iii. Cited business banks in Nigeria ought to keep on
enhancing their progression arranging practice like
filling the opportunities and planning for an
adjustment of administration to continue to have
successful workers that will be fit to be committed
and work on their general execution.
References:
[1] Akpa V. O., Akinlabi B. H., Magaji N.
(2019).Work-Life Balance and Employee
Performance: A Study of Selected Deposit
Money Banks in Lagos State, Nigeria. The
Journal of Social Sciences Research, 5(12),
pp.1787-1795.
https://doi.org/10.32861/jssr.512.1787.1795
[2] Olaoye C. O., Afolalu A., B. (2020). Effect of
human capital accounting on earning per share
of equity owners of deposit money banks in
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
423
Volume 11, 2023
Nigeria. African Journal of Business
Management, 14(11), pp.485-497.
DOI:10.5897/AJBM2020.9008.
[3] Awoyemi S. O., Akinfolarin M. O. (2018).
Impact of Human Resource Management on
Employees’ Sustainability Development In
Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria. International Journal Of
Innovative Research & Development, 7(10),
pp.28-37.
DOI: 10.24940/ijird/2018/v7/i10/OCT18014
[4] Wege L. G., Ngige C. D., Dieli O. J. (2019).
Human Resource Management (Hrm) and
Organizational Performance In Nigeria.
International Journal of Management and
Entrepreneurship (IJME), 1(1), pp.52-67.
https://ijmecoou.org/index.php/ijme/article/do
wnload/4/5/
[5] Islam M. S., Sarker J., Islam M. M. (2018).
Influence of HRM practices on employee job
satisfaction: Evidence from private
commercial banks in Bangladesh, Global
Journal of Management and Business
Research: An Administration and
Management, 18(3), pp.18-22.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/336
133731
[6] Miranda N., Fernando W.R.P.K. (2020) The
Impact of Human Resource Management
Practices of the Managers on Perceived
Organizational Performance-A Study on
Ceylon Fisheries Corporation in Sri Lanka.
Open Access Library Journal, 7: e7034.
https://doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1107034
[7] Al-Abbadi L.H.M. (2018). Impact of human
resources management practices on
organizational commitment of the employees
of commercial banks in Jordan. Global
Journal of Management and Business
Research: An Administration and
Management, 18(4), pp.12-21.
[8] Afriyie E. O., Twumasi A., Sarpong E.,
Darko L. O. (2020). The Effect of
Compensation on Employees’ Performance: A
Case of a Technical University in Ghana.
International Journal of Managerial Studies
and Research (IJMSR), 8(6), pp.44-54.
http://dx.doi.org/10.20431/2349-
0349.0806005
[9] Sajjad H. (2017). The impact of HRM on
organizational performance: evidence from
selective service sectors of Bangladesh.
International Journal of Human Resources
Management, 6(3), pp.1-14.
[10] Kasau M. G., (2017). Work-Life Balance and
Employee Performance in the Ministry of
Finance and Economic Planning Kitui County
Government, Kenya (A Master’s Degree
Project: Kenyatta University).
[11] Oaya Z. C. T., Ogbu O. J., Remilekun O. G.
(2017). Impact of Recruitment and Selection
Strategy on Employees’ Performance: A
Study of Three Selected Manufacturing
Companies in Nigeria. International Journal
of Innovation and Economic Development,
3(3), pp.32-42. DOI: 10.18775/Ijied.1849-
7551-7020.2015.33.2003.
[12] Rotich J. L., Kiiru D. (2021). Effect of
succession planning on employee
performance in the Ministry of ICT,
Innovation And Youth Affairs in Nairobi City
County, Kenya. International Academic
Journal of Human Resource and Business
Administration, 3(10), pp.112-128.
https://iajournals.org/articles/iajhrba_v3_i10_
112_128.pdf
[13] Al-safadi Y., Altahat S. (2020) Human
Resource Management Practices and
Employee Performance: The Role of Job
Satisfaction Journal of Asian Finance,
Economics and Business, 8 (1); pp.519-529.
[14] Chahar B., Hatwal V. (2018). Human resource
management practices and their impact on
employee engagement and performance
OPUS, 9(1), pp.17-36.
[15] Nguyen D. T., Ha V. D., Dang T. T. N.
(2020). The impact of human resource
management activities on compatibility and
work results. Journal of Asian Finance,
Economics, and Business, 7(9), pp.621-629.
[16] Murphy K., Cleveland J. N., Hanscom M. E.
(2019). Performance Appraisal and
Management. Asian Academy of Management
Journal, 20 (2), pp.103-126.
DOI:10.4135/9781506352886.
[17] Al-Jedaia Y., Mehrez A. (2020). The effect of
performance appraisal on job performance in
the governmental sector: The mediating role
of motivation. Management Science Letters
10 (2020), pp.2077-2088.
DOI: 10.5267/j.msl.2020.2.003.
[18] Ebiasuode A., Onuoha B. C., Nwede I. G.
N. (2017). Human resource management
practices and organisational innovation in
banks in Bayelsa State. International. Journal
of Advanced Academic Research | Social &
Management Sciences, 3 (8), pp.82-110.
[19] Abozed O. A., M., Salem S. F. (2020). Impact
of human resource practices on employee
performance: Evidence from Libyan
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
424
Volume 11, 2023
Commercial Banks. International Journal of
Business Society, 4 (1), pp.1-8.
[20] Mohammad Akhtar Sushil, (2018). Strategic
performance management system in the
uncertain business environment: An empirical
study of the Indian oil industry. Business
Process Management Journal, 24(4), pp.923-
942.
[21] Pattusamy M., Jacob J. (2016). Testing the
mediation of work-family balance in the
relationship between work-family conflict and
job and family satisfaction. South African
Journal of Psychology, 46(2), pp.218-231.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0081246315608527.
[22] Spagnoli P., Caetano A., Santos S. C. (2016).
Satisfaction with job aspects: Do patterns
change over time? Journal of Business
Research, 65(5), pp.609-616.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2011.02.048.
[23] Khoury M., M. (2021). Work-Life Balance
Constructs and Job Satisfaction: Evidence
from the Palestinian Investment Sector.
International Business Research, 14(2),
pp.12-28. DOI:10.5539/ibr.v14n2p13.
[24] Yadav R. K., Dabhade N. (2014). Work-life
balance and job satisfaction among the
working women of banking and education
sector-A comparative study. International
Letters of Social and Humanistic Sciences, 21,
pp.181-201.
https://doi.org/10.18052/www.scipress.com/I
LSHS.21.181
[25] Ola O., John W., Simeon O., Mutiu O. (2019).
Impact of Work-Life Balance on the Social
Life of Workers Living in Lagos Metropolitan
Borders. Annuals of Contemporary
Development in Management & HR, 1(2),
pp.51-53.
[26] Ali Z., Mehreen A. (2018). Understanding
succession planning as a combating strategy
for turnover intentions. Journal of Advances
in Management Research,
https://doi.org/10.1108/ JAMR-09-2018-0076.
[27] Debicki B., Matherne C., Kellermans F.,
Chrisman J. (2019). Family Businesses
Research in the New Millennium: An
Overview of the Who, the Where, the What,
and the Why. Family Businesses Review,
22(2), 151.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0894486509333598.
[28] Friedrich S., Wahba M. (2021). The effect of
human resource management (HRM) on
organizational effectiveness through the
employee's Personal Traits as a mediator in
EPC Company. Proceedings of The 5th
International Conference on Business,
Management and Economics.
https://www.dpublication.com/abstract-of-5th-
icbmeconf/e26-325/.
[29] Khan M. A., Khurshid S. (2017). Workplace
stress and employee wellbeing: Case of health
care staff in UAE. European Scientific
Journal, 13(5), pp.217-26.
[30] Nyaema W. R., Wambua D. P. (2019).
Strategic Human Resource Management
Practices And Employee Retention and
Performance in Commercial Banks In Nairobi
City County, Kenya. Journal of Human
Resource and Leadership, 4(2), pp.73-89.
https://Www.Iprjb.Org/Journals/Index.Php/JH
RL/Article/View/936
[31] Rizwan M., Waseem A., Waseem S., A.
(2014). Antecedents of Job Stress and its
Impact on Job Performance and Job
Satisfaction. International Journal of
Learning and Development 4(2).
DOI:10.5296/ijld.v4i2.6097.
[32] Nwata U. P., Umoh G. I., Amah E. (2016).
Internal organisational communication and
employee performance in selected banks in
Port Harcourt. International Journal of Novel
Research in Humanities and Social Sciences,
3(3), pp.86-95.
[33] Karim R., Islam M. W., Rashid H. (2019).
How organizational training affects employee
performance: A case on Bangladesh private
banking sector. International Journal of
Entrepreneurial Research, pp.1-6.
[34] Parajuli D., Shrestha P. (2021). Human
resource management practices and employee
commitment in the banking industry.
International Journal of Management (IJM),
12(1); pp.767-776.
DOI: 10.34218/IJM.12.1.2021.067.
[35] Chukwuka E. J., Nwakoby N. P. (2018).
Effect of Human Resource Management
Practices on Employee Retention and
Performance in Nigerian Insurance Industry.
World Journal of Research and Review
(WJRR), 6(4), pp.27-41.
[36] Anwar G., Abdullah N., N. (2021). The
impact of Human resource management
practice on Organizational performance.
International Journal of Engineering,
Business and Management (IJEBM), 5(1),
pp.33-47.
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.22161/ijebm.5.1.4.
[37] Becker G. S. (1993). Human Capital: A
Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with
Special Reference to Education (3rd ed.).
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
425
Volume 11, 2023
Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
http://dx.doi.org/10.7208/chicago/978022604
1223.001.0001
[38] Kwon D. (2009). Human capital and its
measurement. Paper presented at the 3rd
OECD World Forum on Statistics, Knowledge
and Policy. Charting Progress, Building
Visions, Improving Life, Busan, Korea,
pp.27-30.
[39] Gao N., Gill K. J., Schmidt L. T., Pratt C. W.
(2010). The application of human capital
theory in vocational rehabilitation for
individuals with mental illness. Journal of
Vocational Rehabilitation, 32(1), pp.25-33.
[40] Boldizzon, F. (2008). Means and ends: The
idea of capital in the West: New York.
Palgrave MacMillan. 1500-1970.
[41] Mutua J. M., Kinyili J., Arasa R. (2017).
Assessing the Influence of Human Resource
Management Practices on Employee
Performance in the Health Sector In
Machakos County, Kenya. International
Journal of Economics, Commerce and
Management, 4(10), pp.282-322.
[42] Singh A. S., Masuku M. B. (2013).
Fundamental of applied research and
sampling techniques. Int J Med Appl Sci, 2(4),
pp.123-124
[43] Alsafadi Y., Altahat, S. (2021). Human
Resource Management Practices and
Employee Performance: The Role of Job
Satisfaction. / Journal of Asian Finance,
Economics and Business, 8 (1), pp.519-529.
DOI: 10.13106/jafeb.2021.vol8.no1.519
[44] Cook J., Crossman A. (2004). Satisfaction
with performance appraisal system: A study
of role perceptions. Journal of Managerial
Psychology, 19, pp.526541
[45] Rosenwald R., Wendell L. M. (2013).
Succession Planning Questionnaire
[46] Rothwell W. J. (2012), Effective Succession
Planning: Ensuring Leadership Continuity and
Building Talent from Within, 2nd ed.,
AMACOM, New York, NY.
[47] Obiageli O. L., Uzochukwu O. C., Ngozi,
C.D. (2015). Work Life Balance and
Employee Performance in Selected
Commercial Banks In Lagos State. European
Journal of Research and Reflection in
Management Sciences, 3(4). pp.62-78
[48] Williams L. J., Anderson S. E. (1991). Job
satisfaction and organizational commitment as
predictors of organizational citizenship and
in-role behaviours. Journal of Management,
17(3), pp.601617.
[49] Hair J. F., Hult G.T.M., Ringle C.M., Sarstedt,
M. (2017), A primer on Partial least squares
structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM),
Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
[50] Henseler J., Dijkstra T. K., Sarstedt M.,
Ringle C. M., Diamantopoulos A., Straub D.
W., Ketchen D. J., Hair J. F., Hult G. T. M.,
Calantone R. J. (2015). Common beliefs and
reality about partial least squares: Comments
on Rönkkö & Evermann
(2013). Organizational Research Methods,
17(2), pp.182-209.
[51] Ringle C. M., Wende S., Becker J.-M. (2019).
"SmartPLS 3." Boenningstedt: SmartPLS
GmbH, http://www.smartpls.com
[52] Hu L.-t., Bentler P. M. (1998). Fit indices in
covariance structure modelling: Sensitivity to
under parameterized model
misspecification. PsychologicalMethods, 3(4),
pp.424-453. https://doi.org/10.1037/1082-
989X.3.4.424
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
426
Volume 11, 2023
APPENDIX
Table 3. Convergent Validity
Variables
Indicators
Loadings
Cronbach's
alpha
Composite
Reliability
Average Variance
Extracted (AVE)
Performance Appraisal
PFA1
0.935
0.966
0.974
0.882
PFA2
0.938
PFA3
0.960
PFA4
0.953
PFA5
0.908
0.766
Work-Life Balance Variation
WLB1
0.938
0.923
0.942
WLB2
0.873
WLB3
0.839
WLB4
0.783
WLB5
0.933
Succession Planning
SUP1
0.825
0.890
0.919
0.695
SUP2
0.730
SUP3
0.797
SUP4
0.914
SUP5
0.890
Employee Performance
EMP1
0.854
0.942
0.956
0.812
EMP2
0.952
EMP3
0.883
EMP4
0.864
EMP5
0.948
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
Table 6. Results of the Structural Model Analysis (Hypotheses Testing)
Hypotheses
Relationship
Beta (β)
Standard Error
T Statistics
P value
Decision
R2
Adj. R2
HO1
PFA->EMP
0.044
0.058
7.760
0.000
Rejected
0.295
0.288
HO2
SUP-> EMP
0.119
0.054
2.214
0.027
Rejected
HO3
WLB->
EMP
0.099
0.053
1.859
0.064
Accepted
Source: SmartPLS Output, 2023
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
427
Volume 11, 2023
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
- Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu carried out the
conceptualization and the manuscript preparation.
- Cross Ogohi Daniel supervised the entire study.
- Hadiza Saidu Abubakar was responsible for the
Statistics.
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
This research received no specific grant from any
funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-
for-profit organizations.
Conflict of Interests
The authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on COMPUTER RESEARCH
DOI: 10.37394/232018.2023.11.37
Maryam Ma’aruf Yakubu,
Hadiza Saidu Abubakar, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2415-1521
428
Volume 11, 2023