The Impact of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on the Accounting System of
Saudi Companies
RANDA ABD ELHAMIED MOHAMMED HAMZA1, NASARELDEEN HAMED AHMED
ALNOR1*, EBRAHIM MOHAMMED AL-MATARI1,2, ZAKIA SEID BENZERROUK3,
ABDELWHAB MUSA ELGALI MOHAMED3, MOHAMED YOUCEF BENNACEUR1,
AHMED HESHAM MOAWED ELHEFNI3, MONA M. ELSHAABANY1
1Accounting Department, College of Business,
Jouf University,
SAUDI ARABIA
2Faculty of Commerce and Economics,
Amran University,
YEMEN
3Finance and Investment Department, College of Business,
Jouf University,
SAUDI ARABIA
*Corresponding Author
Abstract: - As a major player in the world market, Saudi Arabia has seen substantial adoption of artificial
intelligence AI) technology in its commercial environment. This study intends to thoroughly examine the
specific effects of AI on Saudi business accounting systems. This paper offers comprehensive knowledge of the
consequences of AI application in the accounting sector through a thorough examination of the body of existing
literature. It examines how traditional accounting methods are affected by AI-driven automation, data analysis,
and decision-making processes in the Saudi Arabian environment. The viewpoints and experiences of first-hand
participants in integrating AI into Saudi enterprises' accounting systems are provided by this study through a
survey distributed to important stakeholders, such as accounting professionals, technology specialists, and
business leaders. This study also emphasizes how incorporating AI technology into accounting procedures may
affect workforce dynamics, skill needs, and organizational structure as a whole. One of the most significant
research findings is the ability of AI to process enormous volumes of data quickly and accurately, allowing for
improved financial analysis, risk assessment, and forecasting. This facilitates wiser and more strategic business
decisions. AI also simplified accounting processes and decreased the need for human labor, saving Saudi
enterprises money. As a result, resource allocation was optimized and overall financial performance was
enhanced.
Key-Words: - Artificial intelligence (AI), accounting system, accounting, financial data, analysis, forecasting,
technology, integration, commercial environment, knowledge, Saudi Arabia.
Received: August 9, 2023. Revised: November 27, 2023. Accepted: December 26, 2023. Published: January 5, 2024.
1 Introduction
In a time of rapid technological development, the
integration of artificial intelligence (AI) has become
a game-changer for several companies worldwide,
[1]. The fast-growing economy of Saudi Arabia is
not immune to the impact of this revolution, [2], [3].
The incorporation of artificial intelligence (AI) has
sparked a paradigm change, especially in the field of
accounting, changing the traditional boundaries of
financial management and reporting for businesses
in the Kingdom, [4]. It is critical to examine the
complex effects of AI on Saudi Arabian enterprises'
accounting procedures, business processes, and
decision-making frameworks, as it continues to
transform the conventional accounting system, [5].
In addition to addressing the opportunities,
challenges, and potential changes reshaping the
accounting landscape in the Kingdom of Saudi
Arabia through the use of artificial intelligence
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
499
Volume 21, 2024
technologies, this study explores the profound
implications of artificial intelligence integration and
its impact on the accounting system, [6].
This study aims to evaluate how artificial
intelligence (AI) is currently being used in Saudi
companies' accounting systems and to determine the
extent of its adoption, [7]. In addition, the
advantages of incorporating artificial intelligence
(AI) into accounting procedures for Saudi
enterprises include cost-effectiveness, accuracy, and
efficiency, [8]. In addition, Saudi businesses
integrate artificial intelligence (AI) into their
accounting systems, considering cultural, legal, and
technical constraints, [9]. And analyze how the use
of artificial intelligence (AI) affects the duties and
responsibilities of accounting workers in Saudi
companies, noting any changes in the skills or job
tasks required of them, [10]. We examine the
financial effects of incorporating artificial
intelligence (AI) into the accounting systems of
Saudi businesses, considering revenue growth, cost
reductions, and return on investment, [11]. In
addition, the possible dangers of integrating
artificial intelligence (AI) with Saudi companies'
accounting systems include data security issues,
privacy issues, and moral ramifications, [12].
Further, stakeholders’ opinions, such as
management, staff, and clients, regarding the use of
artificial intelligence (AI) in Saudi companies'
accounting systems, [12]. To determine the best
techniques and approaches for integrating artificial
intelligence (AI) into accounting systems for Saudi
companies to address economic events while
considering ethical, regulatory, and technological
aspects, [13]. Our research offers suggestions for
improving the integration and application of
artificial intelligence (AI) in Saudi Arabian
enterprises' accounting systems, while accounting
for infrastructural needs, skill development
programs, and regulatory frameworks, [14]. We
conclude by projecting future artificial intelligence
(AI) trends and advancements that are anticipated to
influence Saudi enterprises' accounting systems and
offer proactive suggestions for innovation and
adaptation, [15].
Several advantages have resulted from the
incorporation of artificial intelligence (AI) into
accounting systems, which has completely changed
how financial data are handled, processed, and
evaluated, [16]. Artificial Intelligence reduces the
need for manual intervention by streamlining
repetitive operations such as data entry,
reconciliation, and reporting, [17]. This automation
reduces the possibility of human error while
simultaneously increasing efficiency, [18]. Large
datasets may be analyzed more accurately and
consistently using artificial intelligence (AI)
algorithms, reducing the possibility of errors in data
analysis and financial reports, [19]. This feature is
very important for preserving the accuracy of
financial records and guaranteeing adherence to
legal requirements, [20]. Artificial intelligence (AI)
makes it possible to handle and analyze data in real-
time, giving companies quick access to information
about their financial performance, [21]. This
capacity facilitates prompt decision-making and the
detection of possible hazards or opportunities,
which helps enhance strategic and well-informed
financial planning, [22]. Accounting systems using
artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities can find
trends and abnormalities in financial data, which can
be used to identify possible fraud or other financial
irregularities, [23]. Artificial Intelligence (AI) can
reduce the likelihood of fraudulent acts and offer
early warnings by continuously monitoring
transactions and financial activities, [24]. Artificial
intelligence (AI) can help firms become more
proactive and produce more accurate forecasts using
previous data to predict future financial trends and
results, [25]. Organizations can plan, allocate
resources wisely, and quickly adjust to changes in
the market thanks to this predictive skill, [26].
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has the potential to lower
operational expenses for firms by increasing overall
efficiency and automating jobs related to traditional
accounting processes, [27]. Businesses can devote
resources to other vital areas of growth and
innovation because of their potential for cost
savings, [28]. Finally, artificial intelligence (AI) can
provide individualized financial insights tailored to
the unique requirements of companies, [29].
Artificial Intelligence (AI)-powered accounting
systems can provide personalized recommendations
and tactics to maximize financial performance,
achieve company goals, and maximize value by
evaluating individual financial data and patterns,
[30].
Our research contributes to the literature in the field
of using artificial intelligence in accounting systems
and examines how traditional accounting operations
such as data entry, reconciliations, and financial
reporting are becoming automated by artificial
intelligence (AI), [27]. Analyze how this automation
affects accounting procedures' overall productivity,
accuracy, and efficiency, [31]. Third, we examined
the applications of artificial intelligence (AI) in risk
management and fraud detection, [32]. To examine
how well artificial intelligence (AI) systems detect
fraud and reduce financial risk in businesses, [33].
Fourth, we examine how artificial intelligence (AI)
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
500
Volume 21, 2024
might help with financial analysis and data-driven
decision-making, [34]. Examine how artificial
intelligence (AI)-driven tools and algorithms
improve accounting systems' financial insights,
predictions, and strategic planning, [35]. Fifth,
consider the moral ramifications of using artificial
intelligence (AI) in accounting software, [36].
Examine possible moral dilemmas about security,
privacy, and the ethical application of artificial
intelligence (AI) to financial decision-making, [37].
Six, examined how artificial intelligence (AI) is
changing the tasks and roles of financial
professionals, such as accountants, [38]. Examine
the talents and skills that are becoming increasingly
important in the context of artificial intelligence
(AI) integration and consider any possible effects on
the accounting industry, [39]. Seven, consider the
difficulties in implementing and adopting artificial
intelligence (AI) in accounting systems, [40].
Evaluate obstacles, including expenses, intricacy of
technology, and reluctance to modify, and suggest
approaches for effective incorporation and
acceptance, [41]. Eight studies examined how
integrating artificial intelligence (AI) into
accounting systems may affect compliance and
regulations, [36]. Examine how regulatory
frameworks change to allow artificial intelligence
(AI) to be used in compliance, auditing, and
financial reporting, [42]. To assess how artificial
intelligence (AI) affects accounting systems'
financial forecasting accuracy, [43]. Analyze how
well artificial intelligence (AI)--based financial
forecasting models perform compared to traditional
techniques and determine what influences increased
or decreased financial forecasting and planning
accuracy, [44]. Ten studies examine how artificial
intelligence (AI) improves accounting auditing
procedures and methods, [45]. To examine the use
of artificial intelligence (AI) to identify financial
irregularities during audit procedures and to uncover
anomalies and patterns, [46]. Finally, we examine
how artificial intelligence (AI) may affect an
organization's long-term financial accountability and
transparency, [47]. To examine how artificial
intelligence (AI) affects stakeholder trust in
accounting systems, corporate governance
procedures, and financial information disclosure,
[48].
2 Literature Review and Development
of Hypotheses
This study addresses the following main research
question: What is the impact of artificial intelligence
on companies’ accounting systems? This question is
divided into the following sub-questions: How does
the use of artificial intelligence in data analysis and
forecasting support the accounting system in Saudi
companies? How does the integration of artificial
intelligence in integration with other systems
support the accounting system in Saudi companies?
Many studies show that artificial intelligence (AI)
technologies have a favorable impact on accounting
and finance systems, [16], [23], [49], [50]. Some
previous studies have indicated that to manage
businesses in the rapidly evolving digital economy
and to identify the new skills and abilities that
accountants may need to acquire to stay relevant and
provide value, there is an urgent need for more
research, such as, [38].
The world economy has recently peaked, and to
sustain competitive advantages and additional
economic growth, businesses must implement the
newest artificial intelligence-based technology, [51].
This also holds for accounting systems, which are
driven by market forces to implement the newest
technology as well as the newest practices, [52].
This study, along with earlier research, examines
these prerequisites and seeks to help businesses and
sectors in this area, [53]. This is only possible if all
important parties, such as businesses, accountants,
academic institutions, and the government, are in
agreement, which is currently the case in Saudi
Arabia, [54].
2.1 Capacities for Forecasting and Data
Analysis
In the accounting industry, artificial intelligence
(AI) is used for data analysis and forecasting, [55].
Using artificial intelligence (AI), past data can be
analyzed to identify patterns and trends that can be
utilized to predict future financial performance. This
facilitates the creation of more precise forecasts and
well-informed business decisions, [56]. By
evaluating numerous scenarios and offering insights
into the possible effects of various tactics on a
company's financial health, artificial intelligence
(AI)--powered solutions can help with financial
planning, [29]. By examining financial data and
market movements, artificial intelligence (AI)
systems can evaluate risks, [57]. This allows
accountants to create efficient risk-management
plans and receive early alerts for possible financial
hazards, [58]. By reliably extracting data from
invoices, receipts, and other financial documents,
artificial intelligence (AI)-powered optical character
recognition (OCR) technology can reduce manual
data input errors and save time, [59]. Accounting
professionals can take proactive steps in real-time
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
501
Volume 21, 2024
using artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms to
discover trends and abnormalities in financial data
that may indicate fraud or other unexpected activity,
[60]. Accountants can gain important insights from
unstructured accounting data including emails,
published financial reports, and client conversations
using natural language processing (NLP). This
makes complicated financial paperwork easier to
understand and promotes improved decision-
making, [61]. Artificial intelligence (AI) can
evaluate past cost data, find places where costs may
be cut without sacrificing efficiency, and optimize
resource allocation to find cost-saving options, [62].
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has the potential to
mitigate non-compliance and related fines by
automatically monitoring transactions and financial
operations. This helps to ensure compliance with
accounting standards and regulations, [63]. Finally,
artificial intelligence (AI)-powered decision support
tools help accountants make well-informed data-
driven judgments by providing real-time insights
and recommendations based on complex financial
data, [64].
Many previous studies have concluded that
artificial intelligence has a positive impact on data
analysis and forecasting in the field of accounting
[43], [65]. Based on the above discussion, we can
assume the following hypothesis:
H1: Artificial intelligence (AI) supports Capacities
for forecasting and data analysis.
2.2 Using AI to Integrate Accounting
Systems with Other Systems
To facilitate more precise and efficient financial
operations, artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly
being utilized to combine accounting systems with
other systems, [66]. Artificial intelligence (AI) can
be used to automatically consolidate and integrate
data from many sources, including customer
relationship management (CRM), enterprise
resource planning (ERP), and other operational
systems, [67]. Artificial Intelligence (AI) can map
and normalize data from several formats using
machine learning techniques, [68]. This ensures
smooth system interoperability and integration.
Optical character recognition (OCR) and natural
language processing (NLP) technologies powered
by artificial intelligence (AI) can automate data
entry processes, thereby reducing the need for
human data input, [59]. This simplifies the
integration of accounting data with other systems,
[69]. The AI's ability to continuously process and
analyze financial data makes real-time reporting and
analysis possible, [70]. Organizations can obtain
real-time insights into financial patterns, anomalies,
and key performance indicators (KPIs) by
combining accounting systems with artificial
intelligence (AI)-powered analytics tools. This
allows for more informed decision-making and
strategy formulation, [71]. By examining and
recognizing patterns and trends in past financial
data, artificial intelligence (AI) can increase
forecasting accuracy, [72]. Organizations can
forecast future financial results more accurately by
integrating accounting systems with artificial
intelligence (AI)--powered predictive analytics
tools. This allows them to plan and make well-
informed financial decisions, [73]. Artificial
intelligence (AI) can assist in the early detection of
any fraudulent activity by detecting anomalies and
suspicious activities in financial transactions, [74].
Through the integration of artificial intelligence
(AI)-driven fraud-detection systems with accounting
systems, entities can optimize their risk-mitigation
strategies and guarantee the accuracy and safety of
fiscal information, [63]. Finally, artificial
intelligence (AI) can automate regular accounting
workflows and operations, including financial
closing procedures, invoice processing, and
reconciliation, [75]. Organizations can increase
operational efficiency, decrease errors, and free
critical personnel for more strategic and value-added
work by integrating artificial intelligence (AI)-
driven automation technologies with accounting
systems, [64].
The results of previous studies have shown that
artificial intelligence is used in integration with
other systems, such as, [55], [66], [76]. In light of
the above discussion, writers can make the
following assumption:
H1: Artificial intelligence (AI) supports accounting
data analysis and forecasting.
3 Methodology
This study used a survey design with a sample of the
study population to evaluate the hypotheses. The
sample members provided data on accountants,
auditors, and employees of the Saudi companies. A
useful research technique for gathering information
and suggestions from subject matter experts is a
survey, [77]. We employed online forms to
administer structured questionnaires. The
questionnaire was meticulously crafted to ensure
that it efficiently gathered the required data when
performing the survey. To make it easier to
evaluate, a set of closed-ended questions was used
in this process. There were closed-ended, five-point
questions.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
502
Volume 21, 2024
3.1 Measure
There were two sections in the research
questionnaire: information on demographics was
included in the first part, and the second section
included the dependent variable, which is the
accounting system in Saudi Arabian companies, as
well as the first and second axes of the study, which
are the use of artificial intelligence in forecasting
and data analysis in accounting and in integrating
the accounting system with other systems,
respectively. It was ensured that the questions in the
questionnaire were precise, short, and pertinent to
the variables under investigation. We also
considered potential replies and ensured that they
accurately collected the data required for analysis.
Furthermore, the questionnaire was logically
arranged to make it easier for respondents to
complete.
3.2 Procedures for Data Gathering and
Sampling Design
A total of 213 accountants, auditors, and employees
of Saudi businesses comprised our sample, and data
were gathered and distributed via Google Forms.
Given that the study was conducted in English, the
questionnaire was translated into language
following the recommendations of earlier research,
[78], [79]. The questionnaire was initially created in
Arabic to evaluate the instrument's validity and
reliability among respondents who were originally
from the Arab world. To allow for the generality of
the study's findings, a simple random sampling
procedure was used to select a sample of desired
respondents. Specifically, after random selection,
213 out of 375 issued questionnaires— 56.8% of the
total) were returned. The completed surveys were
discarded, and those that remained were utilized for
the data analysis phase.
4 Data Analysis and Findings
Using an SPSS version 22 program and a basic
linear regression model, the applied portion of this
study aims to investigate and quantify the effects of
a well-balanced interaction between artificial
intelligence and the accounting system in Saudi
Arabian enterprises, [3], [80]. Statistical program
SPSS version for the Social Sciences version 22 was
used to analyze the data. Descriptive and inferential
statistics were used to examine the questionnaire
data. Analysis of Descriptive Data. Alludes to
information explaining pertinent phenomena.
Quantitative information obtained from the
respondents was coded and assessed using “the
Statistical Package for Social Sciences” (SPSS
version 22). Descriptive and inferential statistics
were used to analyze the data. Several marks were
awarded for closed-answer questions. The
descriptive statistics included means, frequencies,
percentages, and inferential statistics. Pearson’s
advantage correlation and regression analyses were
performed to ascertain the effect of artificial
intelligence on the accounting system of Saudi
businesses.
Data Collection: Relevant information was
acquired regarding the questions or problems under
investigation. they are making use of a survey. The
data were cleansed to guarantee dependability and
accuracy. As a vital tool in research and decision-
making, statistical analysis provides an impartial,
methodical way to examine and understand data.
They are crucial in many fields such as scientific
research, corporate data analytics, and
policymaking.
4.1 Frequencies and Descriptive Statistics
The findings of a survey with 213 participants are
shown in Table 1 in the study sample, which was
classified into seven groups based on the
demographic information of the sample, which
included gender, experience, age, qualification, job
level, specialty, and professional qualification. Panel
A shows the gender distribution of the sample. From
the data analyzed, it is clear that out of a total of 213
individuals, 184 were male (86.4% of the total) and
29 were female (13.6% of the total). Panel B
displays the age distribution of the people in Panel
B. The age group with the greatest number of
participants (105, 49.3%) was between 36 and 45
years. Those who are 46 to 60 years old come next,
making up 54 people (25.4% of the total). Then
came the group of people aged 25 to 35, which
comprised 48 people (22.5% of the total). After
those four persons, or 1.9% of the total, were older
than 60. Two people, or 0.9% of the total, were
under 25 years old, coming in last.
Panel C shows the distribution of qualifications
within each research group. There were 125
bachelors, or 58.7% of the total, making up the
largest group. A master's degree was obtained from
50 people (23.5% of the total). Doctorate doctors
came next, accounting for 33 people (15.5% of the
total). Higher diplomas were held by 4 people, or
1.9% of the total). Diplomas came next: one person
(0.5% of the total). And nobody else exists. The
frequency and percentage distribution of various
professional certifications in this panel are shown in
Panel D. A substantial portion of the sample (178,
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
503
Volume 21, 2024
83.6% of the total) did not have fellowships. Then
came the others, where 13 people, or 6.1% of the
total were present. The American Fellowship came
next, with eight members (3.8% of the total) in that
group. The seven recipients of the British
Fellowship and the Arab Fellowship together
accounted for 3.3% of the total for each.
Data on the distribution of sample members by
specialization are shown in Panel E. There were 117
people (54.9%) with accounting specializations,
making up the majority. Banking sciences came
next, with 41 people (19.2%) in this field. In the
field of business administration, there were 28
participants (13.1%). Others came next and
numbered 16 people (7.5%). Finally, information
technology was found in 11 participants (5.2%). The
information displays the frequency and percentage
breakdown of workers in Panel F’s job positions. Of
the sampled members, 142 worked as accountants,
accounting for 58.2% of the workforce. The cashier
department, which employed 47 people and
represented 19.3% of the sample, followed. The
next in line was the department head, with 31
workers (12.7% of the sample) working there. There
was another with 15 workers, or 6.1% of the sample,
in that one. Lastly, the general manager/above
employed nine people and thus made up 3.7% of the
sample. Data are broken down by years of
experience in Panel G. 29.6 Of the participants, 29.6
%, or 63 people, had five–ten years of experience. A
total of 23.9% of the participants (51 individuals)
with 11–15 years of experience came next. Then
came 48 participants, or 22.5% of the total, who had
fewer than five years of experience. 16.4% of the
participants (35 individuals) with 16–20 years of
experience came next. Finally, 16.5% of participants
had more than 20 years of experience.
Table 1. Frequencies and percentage
Panel: A
Gender
Frequency
Percentage
Male
184
86.4
Female
29
13.6
Total
213
100.0
Panel: B
Age
Frequency
Percentage
Less than 25 years old
2
0.9
From 25 – 35 years old
48
22.5
From 36 – 45 years old
105
49.3
From 46 – 60 years old
54
25.4
Above 60 years old
4
1.9
Total
213
100.0
Panel: C
Qualification
Frequency
Percentage
Diploma
1
0.5
Bachelor
125
58.7
Postgraduate Diploma
4
1.9
Master
50
23.5
PhD
33
15.5
Other
0
0.0
Total
213
100.0
Panel: D
Professional Qualification
Frequency
Percentage
Other
13
6.1
Nothing
178
83.6
American Fellowship
8
3.8
British Fellowship
7
3.3
Arab Fellowship
7
3.3
Total
213
100.0
Panel: E
Major
Frequency
Percentage
Other
16
7.5
Business Administration
28
13.1
Information Technology
11
5.2
Banking Sciences
41
19.2
Accounting
117
54.9
Total
213
100.0
Panel: F
Job level
Frequency
Percentage
Other
33
15.5
Department Manager
14
6.6
General Manager/ or above
130
61.0
Accountant
36
16.9
Total
213
100.0
Panel: G
Experience
Frequency
Percentage
Above 20 years
16
7.5
From 16-20 years
35
16.4
From 11-15 years
51
23.9
From 5-10 years
63
29.6
Less than 5 years
48
22.5
Total
213
100.0
As shown in Table 2, all the means of the
variables obtained a high degree of agreement
greater than 3.900 and low standard deviations of
0.869, 0.853, and 1.191.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
504
Volume 21, 2024
Table 2. Descriptive statistics of the variable’s
indicators
Indicators
Mean
Std. Deviation
FDA1
3.967
1.034
FDA2
3.991
0.942
FDA3
4.127
0.936
FDA4
4.019
1.000
FDA5
3.986
1.012
Weighted Mean
4.019
Weighted Std. Deviation
0.869
Indicators
Mean
Std. Deviation
IWOS1
4.033
1.052
IWOS2
4.202
0.896
IWOS3
3.911
1.188
IWOS4
3.972
1.055
IWOS5
4.056
1.164
Weighted Mean
4.061
Weighted Std. Deviation
0.853
Indicators
Mean
Std. Deviation
AIS1
3.995
1.180
AIS2
3.925
1.219
AIS3
3.808
1.265
AIS4
3.939
1.198
AIS5
3.920
1.232
Weighted Mean
3.901
Weighted Std. Deviation
1.191
4.2 Reliability Indicator and Internal
Consistency Reliability
Two terms frequently used in the field of research,
particularly in the social sciences, to evaluate the
stability and consistency of measurements or
instruments used in data gathering are internal
consistency reliability and reliability indicators.
These ideas assist researchers in assessing the
trustworthiness and dependability of study
outcomes. The reliability study's findings show that
the research instrument is a reliable predictor of the
attitudes and views Saudi enterprises have about
artificial intelligence and the accounting system.
The factor loadings for several items show that each
one is a strong indicator of the underlying construct
it was intended to evaluate, with high factor
loadings and statistically significant F values. The
impact of artificial intelligence on Saudi enterprises,
as indicated by Cronbach's alpha, has similarly high
internal consistency reliability, indicating a high
degree of consistency among the various parts in
evaluating these constructions. Saudi companies'
accounting system artificial intelligence has strong
composite reliability values, bolstering the tool's
trustworthiness.
Factor loadings less than 0.6 are frequently
employed as thresholds for items that can be
eliminated because they do not significantly
contribute to the measurement of the underlying
construct, [81]. Eliminating indicators with low
factor loadings can enhance the construct validity of
the measurement tool and dependability of the
factor solution's dependability, [82]. Otherwise, if
the validity and reliability rates of these variables
are less than 0.6, it is possible that they will not be
able to effectively direct the researcher to the core of
the relationship that you are trying to evaluate.
An indicator was excluded from the study if the
factor loadings were less than 0.6. By doing this, we
can raise the general quality of the measuring tool
and guarantee that the remaining indicators provide
a more accurate and consistent assessment of the
underlying concept.
Generally accepted reliability thresholds state
that internal consistency reliability is considered
acceptable if Cronbach's alpha value is at least 0.7,
[83]. The results of the analysis showed in Table 3
that with a value of 0.892 and 0.781, respectively,
both for using artificial intelligence in data analysis
and forecasting, and the use of artificial intelligence
in integration with other systems possess Cronbach's
alpha values far higher than this threshold.
Likewise, composite reliability values of 0.9 or
greater are thought to indicate a trustworthy
measure of the construct, [84]. With a value of
0.966 for the accounting system, composite
reliability values were displayed within this cutoff.
In summary, these findings offer strong
evidence in favor of the validity of the research tool
employed to gauge participants' attitudes and
opinions regarding the advancement of artificial
intelligence and its potential effects on the system.
High composite reliability values, good factor
loadings, statistically significant p-values, and good
internal consistency reliability show that the
instrument can assess these constructs in a
legitimate and trustworthy way.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
505
Volume 21, 2024
Table 3. Reliability indicator and Internal
consistency reliability
N of Items
Cronbach's
Alpha
Hotelling's T-
Squared
F
Sig
Capacities for
forecasting and
data analysis
5
.892
12.278
3.026
.000
Using IA to
integrate
accounting
systems with
other systems
5
.781
31.332
7.722
.000
Accounting
system
5
.966
18.915
4.662
.001
4.3 Discriminant Validity
This analysis is considered to represent the second
type of construct validity. Discriminant validity is
usually used to determine the extent to which the
research variables are related by analyzing all
possible correlations between the variables, [85].
Table 4 displays the average variance extracted
(AVE) for the two variables. Artificial intelligence
has an impact on Saudi business accounting
systems. The percentage of variance in a given
construct that can be explained by the metrics used
to evaluate it is represented by the commonly used
AVE index of construct-dependability. For a single
construct, an AVE of 0.5 or higher, is deemed
appropriate based on accepted threshold values [86],
proving that the indicators measure the construct
accurately.
Table 4. Average Variance Extracted
(AVE)
Capacities for forecasting and data analysis
.754
Using IA to integrate accounting systems
with other systems
.727
Accounting system
.1.419
4.4 Correlation Coefficient
The correlation coefficient was used to measure the
linear relationship between the strength and
direction of the two variables. A correlation value of
1 indicates a completely positive correlation, which
means that if one measure increases, the other
measure increases proportionately. It typically
ranges from -1 to +1. A correlation coefficient of -1
denotes a perfect negative link, meaning that when
one measure increases, the other decreases
accordingly. Furthermore, a nearly zero correlation
score indicates little to no linear relationship
between the variables.
Correlation coefficient interpretation also
requires careful consideration of the study
objectives and the data context. To obtain
significant conclusions, a correlation analysis should
be performed in conjunction with other statistical
methods and research methodologies. Correlation
analysis is a useful tool for understanding
relationships between variables. Table 5 presents the
correlation coefficients.
Table 5. Correlation coefficient
Correlations
CP
HCD
OC
Capacities for
forecasting and data
analysis
Pearson
Correlation
1
.622**
.116
Sig.
.000
.001
Using IA to integrate
accounting systems
with other systems
Pearson
Correlation
1
.424**
Sig.
.000
Accounting system
Pearson
Correlation
1
Sig.
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level
4.5 Hypotheses Testing Result
H1: Artificial intelligence (AI) supports Capacities
for forecasting and data analysis.
The hypothesis Capacities for forecasting and data
analysis -> Accounting system” was endorsed by
the regression analysis findings. A beta coefficient
(β) of -0.331 indicates that there is a strong positive
relationship between the use of artificial intelligence
in data analysis and forecasting and the accounting
system in Saudi companies. The standard deviation
(STDEV) of 0.107 indicates that the variance in the
use of artificial intelligence in data analysis and
forecasting is low, while the T-statistics of -3.094
and the Sig values of 0.000 indicate that the
relationship between the use of artificial intelligence
in data analysis and forecasting and the accounting
system in Saudi companies is significant.
H1: Artificial intelligence (AI) supports accounting
data analysis and forecasting.
The hypothesis “Using IA to integrate accounting
systems with other systems -> Accounting system”
was affirmed in light of the regression analysis
findings. A beta coefficient (β) of 0.802 indicates
that the application of artificial intelligence to data
analysis and forecasting is strongly positively
correlated with the accounting system of Saudi
companies. A standard deviation (STDEV) of 0.109
indicates that the variance in the use of artificial
intelligence in data analysis and forecasting is low,
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
506
Volume 21, 2024
whereas the P value of 0.000 and the T statistic of
38.683 show that there is a statistically significant
relationship between the use of AI in data analysis
and forecasting.
In addition, in Table 6, the R2 value of 0.715
indicates that 71.5% of the variance in the
accounting system in Saudi companies can be
explained through the use of artificial intelligence in
data analysis and forecasting, and the use of
artificial intelligence in integration with other
systems, which indicates the suitability of the
model. The f values represent 28.814 confidence
intervals for the beta coefficient and offer a rough
approximation of the range of the conceivable beta
coefficient values.
Table 6. Hypotheses Testing
Hypothesis
β
STDEV
T
R
R2
F
Sig.
Capacities for
forecasting and
data analysis ->
Accounting
system
-.331
.107
-3.094
.464a
.715
28.814
.000b
Using IA to
integrate
accounting
systems with
other systems ->
Accounting
system
.802
.109
7.351
5 Discussion, Conclusion, Implication
of Study
The primary goal of this study is to investigate how
artificial intelligence affects Saudi Arabian
enterprises' accounting systems. After data
collection from Saudi enterprises, a model was
constructed and analyzed using SPSS-22 software.
These two hypotheses were supported by the
statistical results, which showed that the
development of artificial intelligence in data
analysis and forecasting, as well as its integration
with other systems, as assumed in the first and
second hypotheses, has a significant positive impact
on the accounting system of Saudi companies (B -
0.331 0.802, t -3.094 7.351), at a significance
level of 0.000. This outcome was consistent with the
findings of other studies. Our research indicates that
AI can automate monotonous processes, such as
data input, reconciliation, and report preparation,
freeing up accountants to work on more intricate
and analytical roles. This may result in increased
productivity and decreased human error.
This study and other studies have numerous
contributions that can be considered. One of the
contributions that did not receive appropriate
scholarly attention was the analysis of how artificial
intelligence (AI) affected Saudi Arabian enterprises'
accounting systems. This study could be interpreted
as a request for additional research on this impact,
which has been endorsed. However, the impact of
Artificial intelligence's (AI) impact on corporate
accounting systems has received little attention in
the conceptual and descriptive literature. This is one
of the few empirical studies that explicitly address
the effect of artificial intelligence (AI) on Saudi
enterprises' accounting systems. Using techniques
such as cost-benefit analysis, moderating factors,
causation and correlation, measurement and metrics,
and case studies, this study contributes in this way.
Ascertain how Artificial intelligence (AI) and
affects Saudi corporations' accounting systems.
6 Limitation of Study and Future
Suggestions
Although this study provides a wealth of insightful
information and important discoveries, further
research is required in several areas. The benefit of
this research is that using artificial intelligence can
have a major and favorable impact on a company's
accounting system. Large volumes of data can be
processed quickly and reliably, thereby improving
forecasting, risk assessment, and financial analysis.
Making more thoughtful and calculated business
decisions can thus benefit from this. Artificial
intelligence-based corporate accounting solutions
are also effective. Since this study concentrated on
the direct connection, future research should
concentrate on other variables that can improve and
clarify the artificial intelligence and accounting
system relationship of Saudi enterprises as
moderators and mediators. Other academics may
choose to conduct equivalent research in developing
nations and examine similarities and differences.
Finally, to detect dynamic shifts in the relationships
between variables over time, future research may
validate the findings of this study by employing a
longitudinal research approach.
References:
[1] Kumar, R., Machine learning and cognition in
enterprises: business intelligence
transformed. 2017: Apress.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
507
Volume 21, 2024
[2] Hussain, Z., Saudi Arabia in a multipolar
world: Changing dynamics. 2016: Routledge.
[3] Houcine, B., et al., Analysis of the
Relationship between Domestic Savings and
Domestic Investment in Saudi Arabia.
WSEAS Transactions on Business and
Economics, 2023. 20: p. 2077 - 2088.
[4] Abad-Segura, E. and M.-D. González-Zamar,
Research analysis on emerging technologies
in corporate accounting. Mathematics, 2020.
8(9): p. 1589.
[5] Abdelhalim, A.M., How management
accounting practices integrate with big data
analytics and its impact on corporate
sustainability. Journal of Financial Reporting
and Accounting, 2023.
[6] Saponaro, M., et al. Challenges and
opportunities of artificial intelligence in the
fashion world. IEEE.
[7] Mohammad, S.J., et al., How artificial
intelligence changes the future of accounting
industry. International Journal of Economics
and Business Administration, 2020. 8(3): p.
478-488.
[8] Madkhali, A. and S.T.M. Sithole, Exploring
the role of information technology in
supporting sustainability efforts in Saudi
Arabia. Sustainability, 2023. 15(16): p.
12375.
[9] Rajagopal, N.K., et al., Future of business
culture: an artificial intelligence-driven
digital framework for organization decision-
making process. Complexity, 2022. 2022: p.
1-14.
[10] Rkein, H., et al., Impact of Automation on
Accounting Profession and Employability: A
Qualitative Assessment from Lebanon. Saudi
Journal of Business Management, 2019. 4(2):
p. 372-385.
[11] Basri, W., Examining the impact of artificial
intelligence (AI)-assisted social media
marketing on the performance of small and
medium enterprises: toward effective business
management in the Saudi Arabian context.
International Journal of Computational
Intelligence Systems, 2020. 13(1): p. 142.
[12] Baabdullah, A.M., et al., SMEs and artificial
intelligence (AI): Antecedents and
consequences of AI-based B2B practices.
Industrial Marketing Management, 2021. 98:
p. 255-270.
[13] Almaiah, M.A., et al., Measuring institutions’
adoption of artificial intelligence applications
in online learning environments: Integrating
the innovation diffusion theory with
technology adoption rate. Electronics, 2022.
11(20): p. 3291.
[14] Alotaibi, N.S. and A.H. Alshehri, Prospers
and Obstacles in Using Artificial Intelligence
in Saudi Arabia Higher Education
InstitutionsThe Potential of AI-Based
Learning Outcomes. Sustainability, 2023.
15(13): p. 10723.
[15] Mancini, D., R. Lombardi, and M. Tavana,
Four research pathways for understanding
the role of smart technologies in accounting.
Meditari Accountancy Research, 2021. 29(5):
p. 1041-1062.
[16] Lee, C.S. and F.P. Tajudeen, Usage and
impact of artificial intelligence on
accounting: Evidence from Malaysian
organisations. Asian Journal of Business and
Accounting, 2020. 13(1).
[17] Pierre, K., et al. Applications of artificial
intelligence in the radiology roundtrip:
Process Streamlining, workflow optimization,
and beyond. Elsevier.
[18] Parasuraman, R., et al., Monitoring of
automated systems, in Automation and human
performance. 2018, CRC Press. p. 91-115.
[19] Hariri, R.H., E.M. Fredericks, and K.M.
Bowers, Uncertainty in big data analytics:
survey, opportunities, and challenges. Journal
of Big Data, 2019. 6(1): p. 1-16.
[20] De Mingo, A.C. and A. Cerrillo-i-Martínez,
Improving records management to promote
transparency and prevent corruption.
International journal of information
management, 2018. 38(1): p. 256-261.
[21] Wamba-Taguimdje, S.-L., et al., Influence of
artificial intelligence (AI) on firm
performance: the business value of AI-based
transformation projects. Business Process
Management Journal, 2020. 26(7): p. 1893-
1924.
[22] World Health, O., Strategic toolkit for
assessing risks: a comprehensive toolkit for
all-hazards health emergency risk assessment.
2021.
[23] Zemankova, A. Artificial intelligence in audit
and accounting: development, current trends,
opportunities and threats-literature review.
IEEE.
[24] Yu, T.R. and X. Song, Big Data and Artificial
Intelligence in the Banking Industry, in
Handbook of Financial Econometrics,
Mathematics, Statistics, and Machine
learning. 2021, World Scientific. p. 4025-
4041.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
508
Volume 21, 2024
[25] Bharadiya, J.P., Machine Learning and AI in
Business Intelligence: Trends and
Opportunities. International Journal of
Computer (IJC), 2023. 48(1): p. 123-134.
[26] Tighe, S., Rethinking Strategy: How to
anticipate the future, slow down change, and
improve decision making. 2019: John Wiley
& Sons.
[27] Kaya, C.T., M. Türkyılmaz, and B. Birol,
Impact of RPA technologies on accounting
systems. Muhasebe ve Finansman Dergisi,
2019(82).
[28] Tantalo, C. and R.L. Priem, Value creation
through stakeholder synergy. Strategic
management journal, 2016. 37(2): p. 314-329.
[29] Dwivedi, Y.K., et al., Artificial Intelligence
(AI): Multidisciplinary perspectives on
emerging challenges, opportunities, and
agenda for research, practice and policy.
International Journal of Information
Management, 2021. 57: p. 101994.
[30] Ng, C. and J. Alarcon, Artificial intelligence
in accounting: Practical applications. 2020:
Routledge.
[31] Fernandez, D. and A. Aman, Impacts of
robotic process automation on global
accounting services. Asian Journal of
Accounting & Governance, 2018. 9.
[32] Aziz, S. and M. Dowling, Machine learning
and AI for risk management. Disrupting
finance: FinTech and strategy in the 21st
century, 2019: p. 33-50.
[33] Vesna, B.A., Challenges of financial risk
management: AI applications. Management:
Journal of Sustainable Business and
Management Solutions in Emerging
Economies, 2021. 26(3): p. 27-34.
[34] Marda, V., Artificial intelligence policy in
India: a framework for engaging the limits of
data-driven decision-making. Philosophical
Transactions of the Royal Society A:
Mathematical, Physical and Engineering
Sciences, 2018. 376(2133): p. 20180087.
[35] Lehner, O.M., et al., Artificial Intelligence-
driven Accounting (AIDA). Artificial
Intelligence in Accounting: Organisational
and Ethical Implications, 2022: p. 2.
[36] Munoko, I., H.L. Brown-Liburd, and M.
Vasarhelyi, The ethical implications of using
artificial intelligence in auditing. Journal of
Business Ethics, 2020. 167: p. 209-234.
[37] Du, S. and C. Xie, Paradoxes of artificial
intelligence in consumer markets: Ethical
challenges and opportunities. Journal of
Business Research, 2021. 129: p. 961-974.
[38] Moll, J. and O. Yigitbasioglu, The role of
internet-related technologies in shaping the
work of accountants: New directions for
accounting research. The British accounting
review, 2019. 51(6): p. 100833.
[39] Zhang, Y., et al., The impact of artificial
intelligence and blockchain on the accounting
profession. Ieee Access, 2020. 8: p. 110461-
110477.
[40] Gotthardt, M., et al., Current state and
challenges in the implementation of smart
robotic process automation in accounting and
auditing. ACRN Journal of Finance and Risk
Perspectives, 2020.
[41] Lee, C. and J.F. Coughlin, PERSPECTIVE:
Older adults' adoption of technology: an
integrated approach to identifying
determinants and barriers. Journal of Product
Innovation Management, 2015. 32(5): p. 747-
759.
[42] Jauhiainen, T. and O.M. Lehner, Good
Governance of AI and Big Data Processes in
Accounting and Auditing, in Artificial
Intelligence in Accounting. 2022, Routledge.
p. 119-181.
[43] Losbichler, H. and O.M. Lehner, Limits of
artificial intelligence in controlling and the
ways forward: a call for future accounting
research. Journal of Applied Accounting
Research, 2021. 22(2): p. 365-382.
[44] Wei, N., et al., Conventional models and
artificial intelligence-based models for energy
consumption forecasting: A review. Journal of
Petroleum Science and Engineering, 2019.
181: p. 106187.
[45] Issa, H., T. Sun, and M.A. Vasarhelyi,
Research ideas for artificial intelligence in
auditing: The formalization of audit and
workforce supplementation. Journal of
Emerging Technologies in Accounting, 2016.
13(2): p. 1-20.
[46] Lokanan, M., V. Tran, and N.H. Vuong,
Detecting anomalies in financial statements
using machine learning algorithm: The case
of Vietnamese listed firms. Asian Journal of
Accounting Research, 2019. 4(2): p. 181-201.
[47] Larsson, S. and F. Heintz, Transparency in
artificial intelligence. Internet Policy Review,
2020. 9(2).
[48] Manita, R., et al., The digital transformation
of external audit and its impact on corporate
governance. Technological Forecasting and
Social Change, 2020. 150: p. 119751.
[49] Berdiyeva, O., M.U. Islam, and M. Saeedi,
Artificial intelligence in accounting and
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
509
Volume 21, 2024
finance: Meta-analysis. International Business
Review, 2021. 3(1): p. 56-79.
[50] Vărzaru, A.A., Assessing artificial
intelligence technology acceptance in
managerial accounting. Electronics, 2022.
11(14): p. 2256.
[51] Ahmad, T., et al., Artificial intelligence in
sustainable energy industry: Status Quo,
challenges and opportunities. Journal of
Cleaner Production, 2021. 289: p. 125834.
[52] Alles, M.G., Drivers of the use and
facilitators and obstacles of the evolution of
big data by the audit profession. Accounting
horizons, 2015. 29(2): p. 439-449.
[53] Hastig, G.M. and M.S. Sodhi, Blockchain for
supply chain traceability: Business
requirements and critical success factors.
Production and Operations Management,
2020. 29(4): p. 935-954.
[54] Mihret, D.G., M.N. Alshareef, and A.
Bazhair, Accounting professionalization and
the state: The case of Saudi Arabia. Critical
Perspectives on Accounting, 2017. 45: p. 29-
47.
[55] Sutton, S.G., M. Holt, and V. Arnold, “The
reports of my death are greatly
exaggerated”—Artificial intelligence research
in accounting. International Journal of
Accounting Information Systems, 2016. 22: p.
60-73.
[56] Bharadiya, J.P., The role of machine learning
in transforming business intelligence.
International Journal of Computing and
Artificial Intelligence, 2023. 4(1): p. 16-24.
[57] Xie, M. Development of artificial intelligence
and effects on financial system. IOP
Publishing.
[58] Kaplan, R.S. and A. Mikes, Risk
managementThe revealing hand. Journal of
Applied Corporate Finance, 2016. 28(1): p. 8-
18.
[59] Baviskar, D., et al., Efficient automated
processing of the unstructured documents
using artificial intelligence: A systematic
literature review and future directions. IEEE
Access, 2021. 9: p. 72894-72936.
[60] Goh, C., et al., Charting the future of
accountancy with AI. 2019.
[61] Dash, B., Information Extraction from
Unstructured Big Data: A Case Study of Deep
Natural Language Processing in Fintech.
2022.
[62] Lee, J., et al., Intelligent maintenance systems
and predictive manufacturing. Journal of
Manufacturing Science and Engineering,
2020. 142(11): p. 110805.
[63] Aziz, L.A.-R. and Y. Andriansyah, The Role
Artificial Intelligence in Modern Banking: An
Exploration of AI-Driven Approaches for
Enhanced Fraud Prevention, Risk
Management, and Regulatory Compliance.
Reviews of Contemporary Business
Analytics, 2023. 6(1): p. 110-132.
[64] Peng, Y., et al., Riding the Waves of Artificial
Intelligence in Advancing Accounting and Its
Implications for Sustainable Development
Goals. Sustainability, 2023. 15(19): p. 14165.
[65] Bose, S., S.K. Dey, and S. Bhattacharjee, Big
data, data analytics and artificial intelligence
in accounting: An overview. Handbook of Big
Data Research Methods: 0, 2023: p. 32.
[66] Saleh, M.M.A., et al., Artificial intelligence
(AI) and the impact of enhancing the
consistency and interpretation of financial
statement in the classified hotels in aqaba,
Jordan. Academy of Strategic Management
Journal, 2021. 20(3): p. 1-18.
[67] Yathiraju, N., Investigating the use of an
Artificial Intelligence Model in an ERP
Cloud-Based System. International Journal of
Electrical, Electronics and Computers, 2022.
7(2): p. 1-26.
[68] Gupta, R., et al., Artificial intelligence to deep
learning: machine intelligence approach for
drug discovery. Molecular diversity, 2021. 25:
p. 1315-1360.
[69] Zhang, D., et al., PhyloSuite: An integrated
and scalable desktop platform for streamlined
molecular sequence data management and
evolutionary phylogenetics studies. Molecular
ecology resources, 2020. 20(1): p. 348-355.
[70] Cangemi, M.P. and P. Taylor, Harnessing
artificial intelligence to deliver real-time
intelligence and business process
improvements. Edpacs, 2018. 57(4): p. 1-6.
[71] Kulkarni, P.A., Advanced Analytics Driven
Financial Management: An Innovative
Approach to Financial Planning & Analysis.
[72] Lu, Y., Artificial intelligence: a survey on
evolution, models, applications and future
trends. Journal of Management Analytics,
2019. 6(1): p. 1-29.
[73] Fernandes Marques da Fonte, P.,
Transformative Technologies and Techniques
in Innovation and Financial Management.
2023.
[74] Choi, D. and K. Lee, An artificial intelligence
approach to financial fraud detection under
IoT environment: A survey and
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
510
Volume 21, 2024
implementation. Security and Communication
Networks, 2018. 2018.
[75] Anagnoste, S. Robotic Automation Process
The operating system for the digital
enterprise.
[76] Pannu, A., Artificial intelligence and its
application in different areas. Artificial
Intelligence, 2015. 4(10): p. 79-84.
[77] Ikart, E.M., Survey questionnaire survey
pretesting method: An evaluation of survey
questionnaire via expert reviews technique.
Asian Journal of Social Science Studies, 2019.
4(2): p. 1.
[78] Breslin, J.E.B., The Trials of Mark Rothko.
Representations, 1986: p. 1-41.
[79] Benzerrouk, Z.S., et al., The effect of the
banking supervision on anti-money
laundering. Humanities and Social Sciences
Letters, 2023. 11(4): p. 399-415.
[80] Alnor, N.H.A., et al., The Effect of Developing
Human Capabilities on the Company's
Performance through Developing the
Company's Capabilities. WSEAS
Transactions on Business and Economics,
2023. 21: p. 95-108,
[81] Maskey, R., J. Fei, and H.-O. Nguyen, Use of
exploratory factor analysis in maritime
research. The Asian journal of shipping and
logistics, 2018. 34(2): p. 91-111.
[82] Prudon, P., Confirmatory factor analysis as a
tool in research using questionnaires: a
critique. Comprehensive Psychology, 2015. 4:
p. 03-CP.
[83] Taber, K.S., The use of Cronbach’s alpha
when developing and reporting research
instruments in science education. Research in
science education, 2018. 48: p. 1273-1296.
[84] Chin, R.W.A., et al., Investigating validity
evidence of the Malay translation of the
Copenhagen Burnout Inventory. Journal of
Taibah University Medical Sciences, 2018.
13(1): p. 1-9.
[85] Voorhees, C.M., et al., Discriminant validity
testing in marketing: an analysis, causes for
concern, and proposed remedies. Journal of
the academy of marketing science, 2016. 44:
p. 119-134.
[86] Asmelash, A.G. and S. Kumar, Assessing
progress of tourism sustainability: Developing
and validating sustainability indicators.
Tourism Management, 2019. 71: p. 67-83.
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
The authors made equal contributions to the current
study from the conceptualization of the problem to
the conclusion and solution.
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
No funding was received for conducting this study.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2024.21.42
Randa Abd Elhamied Mohammed Hamza,
Nasareldeen Hamed Ahmed Alnor et al.
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
511
Volume 21, 2024