Good Corporate Governance and Accounting Performance Affecting
the Profit Quality of Companies Listed on the Stock Exchange of
Thailand during the COVID-19 Pandemic
THANTIP SETAN
Bungphra Phitsanulok Commercial College, Institute of Vocational Education Northern Region 3,
Phitsanulok, 65000
THAILAND
PIYANAT THUNPUTTADOM
Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Rajamangala University of Technology Tawan-Ok,
Bangpra Campus, Sriracha District, Chon Buri, 20110
THAILAND
Abstract: - The objective of this research is to study the good corporate governance and accounting performance
affecting profit quality of companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The research methodology is multiple regression analysis used in the data analysis and the test of accounting
performance used as an intermediate variable according to the concept of [16]. The sample group consists of
companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand from 2018-2021. The data used in the study was a total of
2,604 data. The research results revealed that from the mediator variables before COVID-19 (2018-2019)
totalling 2 years, the good corporate governance scores have an influence on profit quality. The rate of return
on equity is some intermediate variable. It shows that a good corporate governance score has an influence on
accounting performance as measured by the return on equity ratio of the shareholders and profit quality.
However, the results of the test on the intermediate variable after COVID-19 (2020-2021) did not meet the test
criteria for good corporate governance influencing profit quality at the statistical significance level of 0.05.
Key-Words: - Good corporate governance, accounting performance, profit quality
Received: October 18, 2022. Revised: March 2, 2023. Accepted: March 25, 2023. Published: April 7, 2023.
1 Introduction
From the COVID-19 pandemic situation, the duties
of the Board in risk management are immediately
more intense, especially when encountering the
unexpected events affecting the business operations.
However, in reality, the Board should routinely
monitor risks in both normal and uncertain
circumstances, [12]. Listed companies are an
important mechanism to drive the country’s
economy in terms of income generation,
employment, and participation in social and
environmental care. Therefore, the Board of
Directors, management and departments within the
organization should play an important role in
promoting the organization to have good governance or
good corporate governance, [7], [1]. The organizations
with good governance will gain credibility, trust and
faith. Having good governance will help create the
motivation to work with the organization. The
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) tries to
promote this by rewarding listed companies on the
Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) with good
disclosure. The Thai Institute of Directors (IOD)
creates a tool to survey corporate governance of
listed companies and prepares a report of the survey
called the Corporate Governance Report (CGR).
The Stock Exchange of Thailand also grants the
award to companies that report compliance with
good corporate governance principles known as the
“SET Award”, [7].
Therefore, the researcher saw the importance of
Good corporate governance, [20]. The effective
corporate governance system is considered an
important foundation for listed companies, [10],
[11]. The corporate governance is the basis for
sustainable success. It has received attention and is
accepted by organizations around the world as a
factor that will make the business achieve its goals.
It can also build trust and confidence among
shareholders, investors, stakeholders, and all involved
parties as the tool to add value and sustainable
growth of the company. From the aforementioned
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
815
Volume 20, 2023
importance, the researcher, therefore, aims to study
good corporate governance and accounting
performance affecting the profit quality of
companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand
during the COVID-19 pandemic.
2 Literature Review
The researcher has reviewed the literature of foreign
and domestic research to be developed as the
research conceptual framework. The conceptual
framework shows the relationship between the
independent variables. The scores are measured by
good corporate governance. The intermediate
variables are measured from accounting performance.
The dependent variable is profit quality as detailed
below.
Independent variables: scores of good
corporate governance
In [21], the authors present a conceptual
framework for corporate governance. It is divided
into 2 categories; Category 1 Internal Governance
Mechanism and Category 2 External Governance
Mechanism. Moreover, the researcher studied the
criteria for the Corporate Governance Report of
Thai Listed Companies. The criteria used in
considering this project have been developed on the
basis of OECD Principles of Corporate Governance.
It is an internationally accepted principle and has been
used as a framework for developing corporate
governance principles of other countries. This
includes corporate governance principles for listed
companies of the Stock Exchange of Thailand used
as a framework for consideration. It is divided into 5
sections, [7], as follows:
1. Rights of Shareholders
2. Equitable Treatment of Shareholders
3. Roles of Stakeholders
4. Disclosure and Transparency
5. Board Responsibilities
The researcher has applied all 5 categories of
good corporate governance principles as part of the
independent variables in this research. The
researcher has studied the corporate governance
report of the Thai Institute of Directors (IOD)
showing Corporate Governance Rating (CG Rating)
in order to develop good corporate governance in
the organization of Thailand. This will bring
benefits both in terms of providing information to
investors and improving the overall level of corporate
governance. The indicators of good corporate
governance, [7], for use in this research are divided
into 2 groups:
Group 0 = Group of Non-awarded Good
Corporate Governance refers to the companies listed
on the Stock Exchange of Thailand that received an
overall score of “N/A” (scores less than 50).
Group 1 = Good of Awarded Corporate
Governance refers to the companies listed on the
Stock Exchange of Thailand that received “Passed”
(scores of 50-59), “Fair” (scores of 60-69), “Good”
(scores of 70-79), “Very good” (scores of 80-89),
and “Excellent” (scores of 90-100).
Intermediate variable: Accounting performance:
In this research, the researcher has applied the idea of
[14] using the financial ratios and corporate
performance to predict business bankruptcy. It is an
analysis of past performance data in order to know
the different situations, [17]. In addition [2],
financial ratios are components of the model
reflecting the problems affected by each group of
companies. For the information obtained from the
financial statements for each accounting method
prepared by the entity, even in the same type of
business, there may be some differences, [8]. From
this situation, the ratio of working capital to total
assets, the ratio of retained earnings to total assets
and the net profit margin before interest and tax on
total assets, and the financial ratio are also important
tools to be used as variables to test the theory and
financial models in many cases such as a model for
estimating the credit rating of bonds and models to
predict the likelihood of financial problems, etc., [3],
[4].
Profitability Ratios is the ratio used to measure
the management efficiency in terms of profitability
such as increasing sales efficiency in cost control,
etc.
Return on Assets
Return on Assets = Earnings before Interest and
Tax/Total Assets*100
Return on assets is a ratio that indicates the
efficiency of a company in investing its assets to
generate returns. It is a value that represents the
profit that the company earns from all the assets that
the company uses to operate. The higher this ratio
is, the better value it will be. It measures the
profitability of all assets used by the business to
operate. It can yield returns from operations. If the
value is high, it indicates efficient use of assets as
well, [26]. This study measures profitability using
the return on assets, [29]. It was found that good
corporate governance affects the return on assets
and results in higher business value, [28].
Return on Equity
Return on Equity = Net Profit (Loss)/Shareholder’s
Equity*100
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
816
Volume 20, 2023
Return on Equity is the ratio used in the analysis to
measure the return on equity reflecting the
management ability to generate returns for the
shareholders who own the business, [32]. If this
ratio is higher, it will demonstrate efficiency in
making profits.
Dependent Variable: Profit Quality: Study the
profit quality of each company from the 2018-2021
financial statements of companies listed on the
Stock Exchange of Thailand.
From the previous review of the literature, it was
found that there are several techniques for assessing
the quality of profits. However, for this study, the
researcher was interested in studying the quality of
profit according to the concept. According to the
comparison between operating profit calculated on
an accrual basis and operating cash flow known as
the Quality of Earnings Index, it should be close to
one. It can be said that the quality profit level is the
ratio of cash flow from operations divided by
earnings before interest and income tax
depreciation. The amortization values must be equal
to one. If the ratio has deviated from one, it will be
regarded as quality profit, [9]. The quality of profit
will be studied according to the following model, [8].
| CPE Ratio it| = CFOit / EBITDAit (1)
(QOE) it = | CPE Ratio it| - 1 (2)
Research conceptual framework
Fig. 1: Conceptual framework of good corporate
governance and accounting performance affecting the
profit quality of companies listed on the Stock
Exchange of Thailand during the COVID-19
pandemic
3 Research Methodology
The researcher has formulated the research
hypotheses from the research conceptual framework
as a result of literature reviews, concepts, various
theories, and related research results. The research
conceptual framework demonstrates the relationship
between independent and dependent variables. The
independent variable is a good corporate governance
score. The intermediate variable is the accounting
performance. The dependent variable is the profit
quality as shown in Figure 1. The researcher sets the
research hypotheses as follows:
1st Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the profit
quality.
2nd Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences accounting
performance.
3rd Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the profit quality
through accounting turnover variables.
The research population consisted of companies
listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand in 7
industry groups; 1. Agriculture and food industry, 2.
Consumer goods, 3. Industrial products, 4. Real
estate and construction, 5. Resources, 6. Services, and 7.
Technology. According to the information from the
Thai Institute of Directors, the number of companies
listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand classified
by industry groups leads to the data presentation to
be analyzed for an overview using data of 651
companies between 2018 and 2021, totalling 4
years. The total number of data used in the study is
2,604 data as shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Comparison of companies that received
good corporate governance assessment scores and
did not receive good corporate governance
assessment scores from 2018 to 2021
Source: Thai Institute of Directors, 2022
From Table 1, for the announcement of the
results of the assessment of good corporate
governance (CGR), the Thai Institute of Directors
will announce the list of specific companies group
receiving good corporate governance award which
refers to companies listed on the Stock Exchange of
Thailand that received “passes” (scores of 50-59),
“fair” (scores of 60-69), “good” (scores of 70-79),
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
817
Volume 20, 2023
“very good” (scores of 80-89), and “excellent”
(scores of 90-100), respectively.
The researcher then realized the importance of
good corporate governance, [30], having the good
corporate governance scores to be considered an
important foundation for a listed company. In [10]
the authors said that corporate governance is the
basis for sustainable success that has received
attention and is accepted by organizations around
the world as a factor that will make businesses
achieve goals. It can also build trust and confidence
among shareholders, investors, stakeholders, all
involved parties as a tool to add value and
sustainable growth of the company. From the
aforementioned importance, the researcher therefore
aimed to study good corporate governance and
accounting performance affecting the profit quality
of companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand
during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Table 2. Thai names, English names, abbreviations of
variables and indicators
From Table 2, the researcher has developed the
research conceptual framework, good corporate
governance, and accounting performance affecting profit
quality of listed companies on the Stock Exchange
of Thailand during the COVID-19 pandemic. This is
studied through independent variables, scores from
the Corporate Governance Report (CGR) assessed by
the Thai Institute of Directors (IOD), intermediate
variables, accounting performance consisting of
Return on Asset (ROA) and Return on Equity
(ROE) and Quality of earnings index (QOE).
Table 3. Descriptive statistics of the variables used in
the study.
Table 3 presents the study of the baseline data of the
research study. The researcher conducted the study
according to the research conceptual framework
(Figure 1) arising from the literature review in order
to study good corporate governance and accounting
performance affecting the profit quality of
companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand
during the COVID-19 pandemic.
4 Research Results
Hypothesis testing
For the hypothesis testing, the researcher started
with Multiple Regression Analysis using all
analytical units from the sample. This is a method to
test the relationship between variables in case of
more than one independent variable and one
dependent variable, [22]. For the factor of good
corporate governance score and accounting
performance that influences profit quality of
companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand
for the hypothesis testing), the researcher began
with a Multiple Regression Analysis. In [16], the
idea was applied to use the set of regression variables
in testing the transmission of influence consisting of
regression of mediator variables on independent
variables, regression of the dependent variables on
the independent variables, and regression of the
dependent variables on the independent variables.
The estimated coefficients in each equation were
statistically tested and linked to the model of
transmission of influence. This was used to test the
mediator variable (Med) (Testing Mediation). The
influence was examined through 4-step regression
analysis based on the model as shown in Figure 2
and Table 5.
Fig. 2: Testing of transmitting influence
Whereas Step 1 Testing of variables X Y
Step 2 Testing of variables X M
Step 3 Testing of variables M Y
Step 4 Testing of variables X, M Y (shows
only the coefficients in the part X Y)
After completing 3 steps of checking the
influence, in Step 4, if it is found that in testing the
coefficients of the independent variable (c’), no
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
818
Volume 20, 2023
statistical significance was found, it shall be
considered that the mediator variables can pass the
absolute influence. However, if the found
coefficient of the independent variable (C’) has
statistical significance from the test but is less than
the coefficient of the independent variable (C), it
can be concluded that the mediator variables can
only partially transmit the influence.
The good corporate governance and the
accounting performance affect the profit quality
before COVID-19 (2018 2019)
1st Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the profit
quality.
2nd Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the accounting
performance.
3rd Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the profit quality
through accounting turnover variables.
Step 1: The good corporate governance score
influences the profit quality.
Step 2 : The good corporate governance score
influences the accounting performance.
Step 3: The accounting performance influences
the profit quality.
Step 4: The good corporate governance score
influences the profit quality through accounting
turnover variables.
Table 4. Testing of mediator variables before
COVID-19 (2018-2019)
*With statistical significance at the 0.05 level
Step 1: That the good corporate governance
score influences the profit quality means that if the
business has a good corporate governance score, it
will result in the company having good profit
quality.
Step 2: That the good corporate governance
score influences the accounting performance and is
measured by the return on assets and the return on
equity of shareholders. It was found that a good
corporate governance score had an influence on the
accounting performance measured from the return
on equity at a statistically significant level of 0.05.
For other variables, the p-value is overall greater
than 0.05.
Step 3: That the accounting performance which
is measured by the return on assets and return on
equity of shareholders influences the profit quality
shows that the accounting performance measured by
return on equity has an influence on profit quality at
a statistically significant level of 0.05. For other
variables, the p-value is overall greater than 0.05.
Step 4: That the good corporate governance
score influences the profit quality with the return on
equity of shareholders as a part of the mediator
variables shows that good corporate governance
scores have an influence on accounting performance
as measured by return on equity of shareholders and
profit quality.
The good corporate governance and the
accounting performance affect the profit quality
after COVID-19 (2020 -2 021)
1st Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the profit
quality.
2nd Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the accounting
performance.
3rd Research Hypothesis: The good corporate
governance score factor influences the profit quality
through accounting turnover variables.
Step 1: The good corporate governance score
influences the profit quality.
Step 2 : The good corporate governance score
influences the accounting performance.
Step 3: The accounting performance influences
the profit quality.
Step 4: The good corporate governance score
influences the profit quality through accounting
turnover variables.
Table 5 . Testing of mediator variables after
COVID-19 (2020-2021)
*With statistical significance at the 0.05 level
Step 1: That the good corporate governance
score influences the profit quality means that if the
business has a good corporate governance score, it
will result in the company having good profit
quality.
Step 2: That the good corporate governance
score influences the accounting performance and is
measured by the return on assets and the return on
equity of shareholders. It was found that a good
corporate governance score had an influence on the
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
819
Volume 20, 2023
accounting performance measured from the return
on equity at a statistically significant level of 0.05.
For other variables, the p-value is overall greater
than 0.05.
Step 3: That the accounting performance which
is measured by the return on assets and return on
equity of shareholders influences the profit quality
shows that the accounting performance has no
influence on profit quality at a statistically
significant level of 0.05. For other variables, the p-
value is overall greater than 0.05.
Step 4: No analysis was made as all mediator
variables did not meet the test conditions.
Table 6. Summary of test results for mediator
variables before COVID-19 (2018 2019) and after
COVID-19 (2020 2021)
Remarks: FM is Full mediation.
PM is Partial mediation
Test conditions are not met.
From Table 6, it was found that the test results of
mediator variables before COVID-19 (2018-2019)
totaling 2 years using the data from 2018 to 2019
can explain the analysis results that the independent
variable is the good corporate governance score.
The mediator variable is the accounting
performance which is measured by the return on
assets and the rate of return on equity. The
dependent variable was profit quality. It was found
that a good corporate governance score had an
influence on profit quality with the rate of return on
equity as partial mediation. It shows that the good
corporate governance score has an influence on
accounting performance as measured by the return
on equity ratio and profit quality. However, the
results of the mediator variable test after COVID-19
(2020-2021) using data from 2020 to 2021 did not
meet the testing conditions.
5 Discussion
Testing mediator variables in accounting
performance which is measured by the return on
assets and return on equity have the objective to
study the good corporate governance and accounting
performance that affects the profit quality of the
company listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand
during the COVID-19 epidemic. According to the
study of data analysis, good corporate governance
scores influence profit quality in both the mediator
variable test before COVID-19 (2018-2019) and the
mediator variable test after COVID-19 (2020-2021).
It showed that if the business has a good corporate
governance score, it will result in the company
having good profit quality including from past
research. The findings are consistent with the
research of [23] finding that having good corporate
governance results in higher company performance.
The research by [18] found that companies with a
high Gov-Score of Corporate Governance will gain
the profits from operations with high corporate
value and payouts to shareholders. Meanwhile, the
companies with a low Gov-Score of corporate
governance will gain low profit from operations,
enterprise value, and payouts to shareholders. [24]
research found that there is a positive correlation
between corporate governance and corporate value
as measured by Tobins Q. Good corporate
governance can lead to higher company values. The
research of [19] found that companies with good
corporate governance will increase their value as
well. The research of [15] found that the influence
of good corporate governance on corporate value
revealed that companies with good corporate
governance have a positive impact on corporate
value. In [25], the authors revealed that good
corporate governance has significant relation in the
same direction as the price of ordinary shares of the
company. In [27], the authors found that the
governance of the proportion of independent
directors and the business size had positive
correlation with earnings per share. In [33], the
authors found that corporate governance
mechanisms regarding the position of President and
Chief Executive Officer. The number of meetings of
the Board of Directors has a negative impact on
company performance. In [34], the authors found
that corporate governance has positive correlation with
company performance. In [31], the authors studied
the impact of good corporate governance on
company performance as empirical evidence of the
Coronavirus crisis. The research findings are
inconsistent with the research of [13] finding no
correlation between corporate governance index and
corporate value.
At the same time, the good corporate governance
score factor influences accounting performance.
This is measured by the return on assets and the
return on equity and it was found that the good corporate
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
820
Volume 20, 2023
governance score had an influence on the accounting
performance measured from the return on equity at a
statistically significant level of 0 . 0 5 . For other
variables, the p-value was overall greater than 0.05.
For the test of mediator variables, it was found that
the accounting performance which was measured by
the return on equity [5], [6] requires the
dissemination of Financial Ratios for the investors
to use as information for making investment
decisions. It is the mediator variable between good
corporate governance score and profit quality during
the mediator variable test before COVID-19 (2018-
2019). However, during the mediator variable test
after COVID-19 (2020-2021), the testing conditions
were not met.
6 Conclusion
According to the results of this research, the
researcher has some recommendations for
companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand
in preparation or even risk management and
business adaptation in the event of various crises
such as the recent COVID-19 crisis. This includes
promoting concrete practices, promoting good
corporate governance by the regulatory body in the
capital market development of Thailand. The
regulatory agencies should pay attention and
encourage the companies listed on the Stock
Exchange of Thailand to comply with the
approaches for good corporate governance to be
more rigorous and international. This can increase
clarity in principles rather than just form, including
preparedness for coping, adaptation, or even finding
the ways to prove that it actually works or not. This
can also build confidence among those who are
interested in investing both domestically and
internationally.
This is contributed to individual authors for the
creation as suggested by the researcher for listed
companies in the Stock Exchange of Thailand. It
can be applied as a guideline for implementation to
promote good corporate governance by the
regulatory body in the capital market development
of Thailand. Regulatory agencies should pay
attention as well as promoting companies listed on
the Stock Exchange of Thailand to comply with
good corporate governance guidelines more
stringently and internationally. The clarity of
principles can be increased rather than specific
forms. The ways can be found to prove whether
there is a practice or not. The confidence can be
built among those who are interested in investing in
the country and abroad in order to plan to fix the
financial failure of the company, for example, in the
COVID-19 situation or to avoid being affected at a
minimum level. The investors should carefully
consider the company’s financial ratios before
investing.
References:
[1] Ditkaew, K., & Pitchayatheeranat, L., The
Essential Principles of Corporate Governance,
Journal of the Federation of Accounting
Professions, Vol. 3 No.8, 2021, pp. 65 68.
[2] Nakprasit, C., Chaisupha, J., Amma, P., &
Utha, S., Probability of Bankruptcy of Listed
Companies in the Stock Exchange of Thailand
in the Covid-19 Situation: A Comparative Case
Study of Industrial Group, Manufacturing and
Service Industry Group, Journal of
Rajamangala University of Technology Isan,
Humanities and Social Sciences, Vol. 9 No.1,
2022, pp 41-52.
[3] Stock Exchange of Thailand. Analysis of
Financial Statements Bangkok: Amarin
Printing and Publishing, 2005.
[4] Stock Exchange of Thailand. How Useful Is
CG Rating? (Online)” Accessed from:
http://www.tsi-
thailand.org/images/stories/TSI2012_Investor/
Articles/TSI-Article_Inv_EQ_105.pdf, 18th
January], 2013.
[5] Stock Exchange of Thailand . Manual Guides
(Online). Accessed from:
https://www.set.or.th/th/market/files/SET_For
mula_Glossary_Jun2015.pdf, 18th January],
2015.
[6] Stock Exchange of Thailand. Stock Valuation
(Online). Accessed from:
https://www.set.or.th/education/th/begin/stock_
content05.pdf, 31st December], 2015.
[7] Stock Exchange of Thailand. Corporate
Governance or Governance (Online). Accessed
from:
https://www.setsustainability.com/page/corpora
te-governance, 31st August], 2022.
[8] Khumsap, P., Analysis of Financial Statements,
12th edition. Bangkok, Thammasat University
Press, 2012.
[9] Thummanont, T., Have you known creative
accounting and profit quality? 1st edition.
Bangkok, Ionic Intertrade Resources, 2000.
[10] Srijanpetch, S., Business Ethics and Corporate
Governance.Journal of Business Administration,
Vol.32, No. 123, 2009, pp.1 6.
[11] Srijanpetch, S., The Essential Principles of
Corporate Governance, Journal of Business
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
821
Volume 20, 2023
Administration, Vol.35, No. 133, 2012, pp. 1 4.
[12] Thai Institute of Directors. Corporate
Governance Report of Thai Listed Companies
(online). Available from: http://www.thai-
iod.com/th/projects-2-detail. .asp?id=309, 30th
September], 2022.
[13] Albassam, W.M., Corporate Governance,
Voluntary Disclosure and Financial
Performance: An Empirical Analysis of Saudi
Listed Firms Using A Mixed-Methods Research
Design, Doctor of Philosophy in Accountancy,
University of Glasgow, 2014.
[14] Altman, E., Financial Ratios, Discriminant
Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate
Bankruptcy. Journal of Finance, Vol. 23,
1968, pp. 589-609.
[15] Ammann, M., Oesch. D., & Schmid, M.,
Corporate Governance and Firm Value:
International evidence. Journal of Empirical
Finance, Vol. 18, No.1, 2011, pp 36-55.
[16] Baron, R.M., & Kenny, D.A., The moderator-
mediator variable distinction in social
psychological research: Conceptual, Strategic
and statistical considerations. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology, Vol. 51,
No. 6, 1986, pp 1173-1182.
[17] Brigham, E.F., & Ehrhardt, M.C., Financial
Management Theory and practice (11 th ed.),
New York: Thomson South-Western, 2005.
[18] Brown, L.D., & Caylor, M.L., Corporate
Governance and Firm Performance, Georgia
State University, 2004.
[19] Brown, L.D., & Caylor, M.L., Corporate
governance and firm valuation, Journal of
Accounting and Public Policy, Vol. 25, 2006,
pp. 409-434.
[20] Chatchawanchanchanakij, P., Arpornpisal, C.,
& Jermsittiparsert, K., The Role of Corporate
Governance in Creation a Capable Supply
Chain: A Case of Indonesian Tin Industry,
International Journal of Supply Chain
Management, Vol.8, No.3, 2019, pp. 854-864.
[21] Gillan, S.L., Recent Developments in
Corporate Governance: An Overview, Journal
of Corporate Finance, Vol . 12, 2006, pp. 381-
402.
[22] Hair, J. F., Jr., Anderson, R.E., & Tatham, R.
L., Black, W.C., Multivariate data analysis
with readings (4th ed.), Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall, 1995.
[23] Klapper, L.F., & Love, I., Corporate
Governance, Investor Protection, and
Performance in Emerging Markets., The World
Bank Development Research Group Finance,
Vol. 2818, 2002, pp. 2-32.
[24] Limpaphayom, P., & Connelly, J.T., Corporate
Governance in Thailand, Thai Institute of
Directors Association, 2004.
[25] Malik, S.U., Relationship between Corporate
Governance Score and Stock Prices: Evidence
from KSE 30 Index Companies, [Online].
Available
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract
_id=1989875 (24 October 2012), 2012.
[26] Nakprasit, C., & Rattanayong, P., Earnings
Quality, Corporate Governance Structure and
Corporate Social Performance of
Manufacturing Companies Listed on the Stock
Exchange of Thailand, PSAKU International
Journal of Interdisciplinary Research, Vol.8,
No.2, 2019, pp. 109-122.
[27] Pasopa, P., The Relationship between
Corporate Governance and Performance
Measures of Companies Listed in The Stock
Exchange of Thailand’s SET100, Asian
Administration and Management Review,
Vol. 1, No.1, 2018, pp. 66-75.
[28] Peerapongpipath, P., & Hensawang, S., The
Influence of Institutional Shareholdings on
Corporate Governance: Empirical Evidences of
the Listed Companies on the Stock Exchange
of Thailand in the SET 100, Asian
Administration and Management Review,
Vol.2, No.1, 2019 , pp. 150-161.
[29] Puangyanee, S., Yaowapanee, P.,
Duangsawang, K., & Jermsittiparsert, K., The
Influence of the Shareholding Structure on
Economic Performance through Good
Corporate Governance of Listed Companies in
the Stock Exchange of Thailand, International
Journal of Innovation, Creativity and Change,
Vol.7, No.8, 2019, pp. 166-133.
[30] Sabsombat, N., The Relationship between
Other Comprehensive Income and Earnings
Management: Evidence from the Stock
Exchange of Thailand, Asian Administration
and Management Review, Vol. 2, No.1, 2019,
pp. 162-176.
[31] Saleh F.A. KHATIB, Abdul-Naser Ibrahim
NOUR., The Impact of Corporate Governance
on Firm Performance During The COVID-19
Pandemic: Evidence from Malaysia, Journal of
Asian Finance, Economic and Business, Vol. 8,
No.2, 2021, pp. 943-952.
[32] Sriyakul, T., Jermsittiparsert, K.,
Joemsittiprasert, W., & Pamornmast, C.,
Comparative Analysis of Stability and Bank
Earnings: A Study of Indonesian Islamic and
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
822
Volume 20, 2023
Conventional Banking Firms, International
Journal of Innovation, Creativity and Change,
Vol.10, No. 1, 2019, pp. 335-351.
[33] Thunputtadom, P., Pongsupatt, T., Srijunpetch,
S., Sincharoonsak, T., Chuaychoo, M., &
Bosakoranut, S., The Impact of Corporate
Governance on Operational Performance of
Listed Companies in the Stock Exchange of
Thailand. Asian Administration and
Management Review, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2018, pp.
84-93.
[34] Tunpornchai, W. & Hensawang, S., Effects of
Corporate Social Responsibility and Corporate
Governance on Firm Value: Empirical
Evidences of the Listed Companies on the
Stock Exchange of Thailand in the SET100,
PSAKU International Journal of
Interdisciplinary Research, Vol. 7, No. 1, 2018,
pp. 161-170.
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
-Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtdom carried out
the simulation and the optimization.
-Thantip Setan has organized and executed the
experiments of Section 4.
-Thantip Setan was responsible for the Statistics.
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
No funding was received for conducting this study.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflict of interest to declare
that is relevant to the content of this article.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.75
Thantip Setan, Piyanat Thunputtadom
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
823
Volume 20, 2023