Economic and Psychological Well-being in Pandemic Times
BESMIRA LAHI
Department of Psychology, University of New York Tirana,
ALBANIA
INES NURJA
Department of Economic and Finance, University of New York Tirana,
ALBANIA
Abstract: - The pervasive role of the COVID-19 pandemic in the economy and subjective well-being is the
focus of this research study. There is extensive evidence suggesting a relationship between psychological well-
being and income. In this study, we make use of data collected during the pandemic in the fall of 2021 from a
cross-sectional online survey of Albanian adults living and working in the country. This study examines the
association between average income level, age, civil status, and level of education with psychological well-
being during the pandemic. We examined the data through descriptive statistics and Chi-square tests. We
synthesize a wide range of information from the literature on well-being and economy and use the Wellbeing
Index as a standardized scale. According to the study's findings, income level is relatively related to happiness.
The general well-being of the population under investigation is below average. Young and single people have a
higher quality of life. In conclusion, economic and social variables are essential and related to psychological
well-being.
Key-Words: economic well-being, psychological well-being, social factors, incomes, level of education
Received: October 10, 2022. Revised: February 24, 2023. Accepted: March 15, 2023. Published: March 31, 2023.
1 Introduction
Referring to INSTAT statistics, the Albanian
population as of 2021 consisted of 2,793,592, and
the average age was 38.2 years, [28]. Therefore, this
research has targeted the adult population to
understand their psychological well-being and
economic concerns in contemporary times.
The literature review points us to studies
examining human well-being in four main domains:
education, health, living conditions, and economy,
[11]. Others believe there are various types of well-
being, but there are two dimensions of
psychological well-being: positive and negative
effects, [15]. In clinical terms, adult population
well-being refers to the presence of mental health;
according to Maslow, well-being refers to self-
actualization, and by Jung, well-being is the
fulfilment of individuation, [5]. Throughout a
literature review, well-being includes four other
domains, (i) orientations such as values, ideals, and
priorities; (ii) behaviors representing engagement in
different activities like parties, working groups, etc.;
(iii) experiences including feelings, emotions, and
meaning; and (iv) functioning, representing how
able, accomplished, healthy, and self-regulating the
individual is. The latter two, including experiences
and functioning, are named well-being outcomes,
and their meaning aligns with the concepts of well-
being used in this paper. Since it is not easy to
measure and identify well-being, it is essential to
study its short-term and long-term outcomes
referring to experiences and functioning, [13].
During the COVID-19 pandemic, we noticed
that the well-being agenda is so closely related to
healthy individuals versus easily contaminated ones
since stress and other psychological disorders may
affect the individuals' immunity. However,
economic well-being is far more than a concept
related to the health sector. There is an increasing
interest in considering well-being as an economic
and societal objective, [8]. Essentially, well-being
has swayed over the healthcare system, as "interest
in well-being as an economic and societal goal is
growing. The Roadmap for Wellbeing in the
Western Balkans 2021-2025 highlights the
importance of economy and well-being in the
European Programme of Work 2020-2025. "People
want authorities to guarantee their right to universal
access to quality care without fear of financial
hardship, effective protection against health
emergencies, and the ability to thrive in healthy
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
777
Volume 20, 2023
communities where public health actions and
appropriate public policies secure a better life in an
economy of wellbeing, [25]".
The Corona crisis has consequences for the
economy of Albania, likewise, other Western
Balkan countries, the recovery of whom will depend
on measures taken by the authorities, [22]. In many
cases, the well-being economy is "an alternative for
guiding policy development, [7].
Besides operationalizing wellbeing and describing
ways to measure it, it remains in the interest of
studies to use wellbeing data to further design
policies for a country. Some authors suggest that
"the science of wellbeing is theoretically, metrically,
and empirically ripe enough to complement
economic measures of prosperity for public policy,
[1]." The United Nations Sustainable Development
Goal No. 3 states that "ensuring healthy lives and
promoting well-being at all ages is essential to
sustainable development, [33]." Insights from
papers suggest that "to reposition economic growth,
especially the year-on-year increase in GDP, as a
means to an end, not as the end in itself, [2]" we
should aim to promote well-being.
The relationship between well-being and income
One of the paper's goals is to examine the
concepts of well-being and its connection to the
economy. Some researchers consider subjective
well-being a potential social indicator since
subjective outcomes influence social and economic
changes that influence the quality of life, [24].
Using the concepts of income and employment
triggers several social conditions like happiness and
well-being; therefore, we are interested in studying
their relationship.
Since subjective well-being empowers
productivity and physical and mental health but is
sensitive to economic changes, does that mean
money makes people happier? If yes, are we
expecting a higher level of psychological well-being
in people with relatively high-income levels? While
some evidence based on the relatively long (29)
years of this study indicates that: "psychological
well-being may reflect the accumulation of
socioeconomic advantage and disadvantage over
decades, [16], little is known concerning the
impact of the pandemic, individual's well-being and
economic issues in Albania. However, there is also
evidence that Albanian's socioeconomic level during
communism was moderately low; this status is
associated with lower psychological pressure and
stress. However, it seems reasonable to suggest that
patterns of economic outcomes could have an
impact on the population's feelings, functioning, and
well-being. (ii)Metrics of wellbeing. There are
different methods and psychometric scales used to
measure subjective well-being. Through the years,
studies have shown that diverse study methods and
scales report one common understanding: subjective
well-being is related to better health and longevity.
As the Covid-19 pandemic refers to a stressful
major event in life, studies acknowledge the effects
of these types of events on one's immunity.
However, sometimes, the effects of happiness and
well-being are unclear. In France, in 1998, the
national mortality rate from myocardial infarction in
French men decreased when they won the World
Cup in 1998, probably because of a national day off
work and the euphoria of a vital sports game, [4].
(iii) Others identify two forms of well-being:
feelings, named experienced well-being, and
evaluative well-being, related to how people
evaluate their life, [17].
The study shows a significant correlational
relationship between income and negative emotion,
[27]. Other studies have examined not only income
but financial capability on the individuals’
psychological health, reporting that having this high
capacity is essential, especially in times of
economic recessions when people feel anxious and
stressed about their financial well-being, [23]. We
have examined the impact of financial capability on
an individual's psychological health, independent of
the effects associated with income, financial
resources, and financial shocks more generally.
High financial capability is particularly crucial
during economic recessions when many people
experience anxiety and stress about their financial
well-being. Being financially capable, they can
manage their income, understand how to use credit
and debt effectively, have a solid internal locus of
control, and develop other abilities that yield
psychological benefits. Research suggests that
higher incomes may improve individuals' day-to-
day well-being, but there is no evidence of a well-
being plateau, [17].
Research considering that subjective well-being
affects health and longevity in healthy populations
is compelling; however, it needs further study, [9].
General well-being as a function of income and
education has been the research focus on a sample
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
778
Volume 20, 2023
of African-Americans and Caucasians at two points.
Research shows that the more educated groups are
happier than others and that income is a resource
that covaries with well-being, [10].
The relationship between well-being and age
The average life expectancies have increased by
30 years over the last century, yet our system has
failed to adapt to this reality, [18]. However, this
does not mean that with the rise of age, people are
happier, and there have continuously been
contradictions and discussions about the relationship
between these two variables, considering the degree
of satisfaction with life and longevity. Moreover, we
need to develop unique programs related to the issue
of the elderly, including local government,
psychologists and social workers, and health and
education secretaries as recipients of these
recommendations, [3].
Does well-being improve with age? Some
studies show that aged people living with their
family members are happier than others in residency
homes, [6]. The studies on ageism and
psychological well-being indicate that the increase
in age is a statistically significant predictor for
lowered psychological well-being in older adults.
When they feel proud of their age group, they do not
have negative feelings, consider age a positive
process, estimate their body system, and adapt to
their goals, [14]. Research conducted with the
elderly in Indonesia during the Covid-19 pandemic
shows that the elders use productive and religious
activities as main coping strategies, [12].
Meanwhile, other studies suggest that people's
economic situation and concerns about the economy
mostly correlate with subjective well-being in the
long and short term, [19]. A study conducted in
China in 2013 showed that "age was not always a
strong significant predictor of subjective well-
being," and authors suggested paying attention to
the specific contents of subjective well-being, [26].
In light of Covid-19 affecting the individuals'
responsibility in terms of power to cope with the
challenges emotionally and financially, it was
considered relevant to see the relationship between
age and reported psychological well-being during
the pandemic.
2 Problem Formulation
We consider personal category income and use
official statistical data on household income.
Regarding the income variable, as studies suggest,
low levels of household and reductions in household
income are associated with increased risk for
mental disorders, [20]" reflecting the lack of
psychological well-being. Well-being is measured
by how people experience it; intrinsic and extrinsic
values of subjective well-being are important and
affect the individuals' lives and those around them.
The objectives of this paper are as the
following: (i) to measure the general well-being of
the population (of this study) during the pandemic
times: (ii) to understand how is the relationship
between well-being and income during the
pandemic: (iii) to understand how is the relationship
between well-being and other socio-demographic
variables such as age, level of education and civil
status.
RQ1: What is the average well-being of people
living in pandemics in Albania?
RQ2: What is the relationship between well-being
and income during the pandemic?
RQ3: What is the relationship between well-being
and age, civil status, and levels of education during
the pandemic times?
2.1 Methodology
Research Design and Statistical analysis
A cross-sectional survey was conducted in the Fall
of 2021 in Albania through social media and
different networks to gather information from
potential respondents. The 212 respondents
provided consent before filling in the questionnaire.
We conducted the SPSS and the analysis of
descriptive statistics and Chi-square test statistical
analysis.
Instruments of measurement
The World Health Organization 5 Well-Being
Index (WHO-5)
We measured with a single self-report scale, the
"Well-being index" of the Psychiatric Research
Unit, whose Collaborating Centre in Mental Health
enquiring (version 1999) how respondents have
been feeling during the last two weeks, [29]. The
scale is standardized and translated into Albanian,
containing six declarations that respondents have to
rank from never (1) to all the time (6). The higher
the cumulative number of all declarations, the
higher the level of well-being. The psychometric
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
779
Volume 20, 2023
properties of the WHO-5 indicate validity. It is an
already standardized and translated instrument into
Albanian and 30 other languages.
Relative Income
The relative income of respondents was a self-
declared data gathered throughout the survey. The
declarations varied from the lowest payment to the
higher taxed one.
Controlling variables
Some socio-demographic variables, including age,
gender, and educational level, were gathered and
used to conduct the analysis.
3 Problem Solution
3.1 General well-being during the Pandemic
Considering that the pandemic times compromised
life in different dimensions, researchers were
interested to see the implication of the Covid-19
pandemic time in the Albanian population, whose
economy is rather sensitive. Respondents evaluated
their psychological well-being by referring to their
feelings during the last two weeks. This evaluation
ranged from 1-No time, the lowest score, to 6-All of
the time, the highest score. A high score would
show a high quality of life with a range between 5
(minimum level) to 30 (highest level of
psychological well-being). If we refer to the
instrument’s items, responses rank between 3- 4;
specifically, respondents have been feeling
moderately cheerful, active, fresh, and relatively
filled with interest.
Table 1. Descriptive Statistics on Wellbeing Index
During the last
week, I have:
N
M
in
Mea
n
Std.
Deviat
ion
Been cheerful and
in good spirits
212
1
3.27
1.31
Been active and
vigorous
211
1
3.28
1.343
Woken up feeling
fresh
212
1
3.1
1.414
My daily life is
filled with interests
212
1
3.73
1.521
Been calmed and
relaxed
212
1
3.14
1.334
Table 1.1. Descriptive Statistics
N
Mi
n
Max
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Wellbeing
Index
211
5.0
30.0
16.49
5.92
Valid N
(listwise)
211
Through 212 responses, we see that the average
level of well-being is 16.49. We analyze that
subjective well-being is in the medium range:
people have been feeling somehow good during the
pandemic times.
3.2 Wellbeing and Grouped Revenues
In this section of our study, we aim to see how the
psychological well-being of individuals refers to
economic well-being. Firstly, we observe how the
economic situation has changed in Albanian
families over the last months, and we identify how
the distribution of revenues per level of education is.
Table 2. Change in the financial situation of your
family in the last 12 months
It has
worsen
ed
It has
worsen
ed
very
much
Has
improv
ed
Has
improv
ed
very
much
I do
not
know
Until
40.000
ALL
32.20%
5.60%
8.90%
1.10%
10.00
%
40.000
-
60.000
ALL
40.70%
6.80%
10.20
%
0.00%
3.40%
60.000
-
95.000
ALL
22.90%
0.00%
8.60%
0.00%
0.00%
Over
95.000
ALL
14.30%
0.00%
14.30
%
10.70
%
3.60%
Total
30.70%
4.20%
9.90%
1.90%
5.70%
Chi-Square Tests
Value
df
Asymptotic
Significance
(2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square
34.366a
15
0.003
Likelihood Ratio
34.25
15
0.003
Linear-by-Linear
Association
4.754
1
0.029
N of Valid Cases
212
13 cells (54.2%) have an expected count of less than
5. The minimum expected count is .53.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
780
Volume 20, 2023
The Chi-square tests analyzed the relationship
between grouped revenues and the perception that
the economic situation has changed during the last
year. As a result of the Chi-square analysis, we
conclude that the more the income increases, the
more individuals perceive that their situation has
worsened. The individuals with the lowest incomes
have perceived the deterioration of their economic
conditions during Covid-19. On the other hand,
individuals with the highest incomes are more stable
in their financial situation in their families. Incomes
affect a lot of individuals' perceptions regarding
their economic state; that is especially sensitive to
individuals with low incomes.
Raise of economic problems during the pandemic
We analyzed how the grouped revenues are
distributed among the population under study,
referring to their level of education. Table 2.1.
shows individuals holding a university degree, 50%
of the cases are to 40.000 ALL/342 Euro, as per the
exchange rate of the Albanian Bank, where 1
Euro=116.9 ALL, reported on November 15th,
2022), with minimum monthly salary, [31].
Table 2.1. Grouped revenues within the level of
education
Educational
level
Until
40.000
ALL
40.000-
60.000
ALL
60.000-
95.000
ALL
Over
95.000
ALL
High School
60.0%
26.7%
3.3%
10.0%
Post-
university
16.0%
32.0%
36.0%
16.0%
University
48.5%
26.5%
12.1%
12.9%
Total
42.5%
27.8%
16.5%
13.2%
They feel underestimated and not motivated
because they are not well paid. Only 13% of the
individuals with a university level of education
receive a high salary category. The post-university
level of education has a good income level;
therefore, even the average psychological well-
being index is higher in this category. Meanwhile,
for the high school category, the distribution of the
revenues is in line with the level of education they
have received. 60% of the high school level
category have the minimum income level (until
40.000 ALL/month). The 10% of the high school
category has the highest monthly salary level.
Then, Chi-square analyzed the association between
the level of education and perceptions about the rise
of economic problems compared with two years
ago.
Table 2.2. Crosstabulation: Perceptions on
economic problems compared with two years ago as
per the educational level
Educatio
nal level
I
Disagr
ee
I
agree
Neutr
al
I
disagr
ee
I
totall
y
Agre
e
High
School
3.40%
51.70
%
20.70
%
6.90
%
17.20
%
Post-
universit
y level
4.00%
62.00
%
12.00
%
2.00
%
20.00
%
Universi
ty level
2.40%
55.10
%
17.30
%
3.10
%
22.00
%
Total
2.90%
56.30
%
16.50
%
3.40
%
20.90
%
Chi-Square Tests
Value
df
Asymptotic
Significance
(2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square
3.406a
8
0.906
Likelihood Ratio
3.246
8
0.918
Covid-19 times reflects more economic
problems in comparison with two years ago. Despite
the level of education, all groups reflect concern
regarding their economic situation; roughly 77% of
the individuals have perceived more economic
problems. Only 6.3% of them perceived that they
did not have economic problems. The people who
present the most serious economic problems are the
people who belong to post-university education in
82% of the cases. Our data suggests there is no
relationship between individuals’ perception about
the economy and their levels of education.
Then, we referred to the official data from
INSTAT aiming to see how the economic situation
for the Albanian population has been over the last
few years; following these data, as presented in
table 3 below, 43% of the Albanian population lives
with a minimum salary of up to 40.000 ALL,
corresponding approximately to 342 Euro. Referring
to the table below, 23% of the employed population
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
781
Volume 20, 2023
has an average monthly salary of 60.000-95.000
ALL, corresponding to 513-812.6 Euro, [34]. This
data shows that Albanians' salaries are shrinking,
and every increase in price affects their everyday
living.
Table 3. Distribution of employee contributors by
average gross monthly wage intervals by Groupings
wage, Type and Quarter
2021-
2
2021-
3
2021-
4
2022-
1
2022-
2
Total
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
Up to the
minimum
wage
33.5
33.3
29.9
21.1
23.0
Minimum
wage -
40.000
ALL
16.1
16.1
17.0
23.3
20.0
40.001-
50.000
ALL
11.0
11.1
11.4
13.6
14.0
50.001-
60.000
ALL
7.8
8.0
7.8
8.7
8.8
60.001-
95.000
ALL
22.4
22.4
23.0
23.5
23.8
95.001-
120.000
ALL
4.0
4.0
4.7
4.3
4.5
Over
120.000
ALL
5.2
5.2
6.2
5.5
5.9
Source:INSTAT:
http://databaza.instat.gov.al/pxweb/sq/DST/START__PK
P__PTM/PTM031/table/tableViewLayout1/
3.3 Consumer Price and Its Relation to the
Average Indicator
Aiming to see the relationship between the
Consumer Price and its average indicator, referring
to the official sources from INSTAT Albania, we
gathered the following data:
(a) The economic well-being of Albanian
families per month in 2021, referring to the Annual
Change of Consumer Price Index from INSTAT
official sources, table 4 as below, [32]. Albanian
families use 41,3% of the overall budget for food
and non-alcoholic beverages. The data shows that
every cost increase affects the Albanian family
budget because most of them use this budget for
food and non-alcoholic drinks. In these moments,
every inflation rise directly influences the well-
being of Albanians as it brings them to survival
mode. Table 4 refers to the household budget
consumption of the leading 12 consumer groups.
According to the data, the Albanian budget has
changed drastically from 6% to over 14.6%, and this
rise will continue.
Table 4. Household budget structure by the leading
12 groups
Main
consumer
groups
2021
2020
2019
2018**
Food and non-
alcoholic
beverages
41.3
41.6
41.3
44.7
Alcoholic
beverages,
tobacco
3.8
3.7
3.7
3.4
Clothing and
footwear
4.6
4.6
5.2
4.2
Housing, water,
electricity, gas,
and other fuels
10.0
10.0
10.1
10.3
Furnishing,
household
equipment, etc.
6.8
6.9
6.7
6.3
Health
5.4
5.4
4.3
4.1
Transport
6.3
6.2
5.9
6.6
Communication
3.9
3.7
3.7
3.5
Recreation and
Culture
2.8
2.8
3.8
2.6
Education
3.3
3.1
3.1
3.0
Restaurants and
hotels
5.5
5.6
4.9
4.6
Miscellaneous
goods and
services
6.2
6.3
7.3
6.7
Total
100
100
100
100
Source: INSTAT official statistics on Household Budget
Survey: http://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/social-
condition/household-budget-survey/#tab2
(b) The distribution of household consumption
expenditures by deciles reports that approximately
90% of the households have 83.9 % of the total
consumption per month. It indicated a monthly
average consumption expenditure per household of
70,788 ALL; meanwhile, the other 10th percent of
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
782
Volume 20, 2023
households spend 16.1 % of the total consumption
with an average consumption expenditure per
household of 122,242 ALL, [35].
Table 5. The monthly average consumption
expenditures of households and the deciles ratio of
10/90
2017
2018
Monthly
average
consumpti
on
expenditur
es of
households
Mean
househo
ld
size
Monthly
average
consumpti
on
expenditur
es of
households
Mean
househo
ld
Size
10% of
Households
(with the
highest
expenditure
s)
152,079
2.6
122,242
2.1
90% of the
rest of the
Households
64,659
3.9
70,788
3.8
Average
consumptio
n
expenditure
73,400
3.7
75,935
3.7
The ratio
10/90
2.4
1.7
Source: INSTAT official statistics
http://www.instat.gov.al/media/6322/hbs_2018_.pdf
Data, as reported by INSTAT, shows that: "In 2018,
the average consumption expenditures by deciles
have a decrease of 19.6 pct in the average
consumption expenditures for the 10th pct with the
highest expenditures and an increase of 9.5 pct for
the remaining 90th pct of households compared with
the year 2017; as a result, the ratio of the deciles in
2018, for this indicator showed a decrease in the
inequality from 2.4 to 1.7, compared to 2017, [35].
(c) Another indicator showing that the crises
will seriously impact Albania, affecting well-being,
is the distribution of consumption expenditure in
Albania. "At Risk of Poverty or Social Exclusion
refers to the individuals at risk of poverty or
severely materially deprived or living in a
household with very low work intensity," as
reported by INSTAT. Table 6 below shows a
distinctive inequity, [40].
Table 6. The leading Indicators of Risk of Poverty
and Social Exclusion, 2017-2020
Indicators
2017
2018
2019
2020
At the risk of
poverty rate (%)
23,7
23,4
23,0
21,8
Severe material
deprivation (%)
41,1
38,3
37,1
34,7
Very low work
intensity (%)
14,4
13,3
12,4
11,6
At the risk of
poverty or social
exclusion
(AROPE) (%)
51,8
49,0
46,2
43,4
Source: Official INSTAT data
http://www.instat.gov.al/media/9409/income-and-living-
condition-silc2020final.pdf
These findings suggest that economic well-
being is a crucial variable in the Covid-19 pandemic
situation in Albania.
3.4 Wellbeing and Age Category
We aim to see and understand the relationship
between well-being and age during the pandemic.
Our findings show that the age category with the
highest level of well-being is the youth category
(Mean=16.9% for the 18-24 years old; Mean=16.46
for the 25-34 years old). The younger individuals
are, the better their quality of life is. The more
individuals over 55 years old (Mean=14 for 55-64
years old; for the category 65-70 is 11), the lower
their psychological well-being is, showing that
quality of life and happiness decreases with aging.
Our findings suggest that these categories did not
feel good during the pandemic; moreover, they are
the most vulnerable ages for infection.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
783
Volume 20, 2023
Table 7. Descriptive Statistics on Wellbeing Index
and age
Age
categ
ory:
N
Mini
mum
Maxi
mum
Mea
n
Std.
Deviat
ion
18-24
Wellb
eing
Index
11
4
5
30
16.9
386
6.554
45
25-34
Wellb
eing
Index
50
9
30
16.4
6
4.982
46
35-44
Wellb
eing
Index
30
8
27
15.6
333
5.041
1
45-54
Wellb
eing
Index
11
8
25
16
4.795
83
55-64
Wellb
eing
Index
5
8
25
14
7.314
37
65-70
Wellb
eing
Index
1
11
11
11
.
The highest level of well-being is reported from
the age category 18-24, with an average well-being
index of 16.93, followed by the 25-34 age category
showing an average psychological well-being index
of 16,46. From the young middle ages to old ages,
the decrease in psychological well-being is quite
distinctive. The psychological well-being index
drops to 11 (clearly below the medium level) in the
retirement category of 65+, reporting that they have
not been feeling good.
3.5 Wellbeing and Level of Education
Regarding the level of education, results show that
even though in all measurements, the well-being
level is moderate; however, it does not refer to being
happy or very happy. They are indicating in our
example the high school educational level
(Mean=17.6), which reflects better well-being and
positive perception in comparison with the
university (Mean=16) and post-university level
(Mean=16.9).
Table 8. The average well-being indicator refers to
the level of education
Educat
ional
Level
N
Mini
mum
Maxi
mum
Mea
n
Std.
Devi
ation
High
school
level
Wellb
eing
Index
2
9
7
30
17.6
552
6.607
77
Post
univer
sity
level
Wellb
eing
Index
5
0
5
30
16.9
4
6.014
98
Univer
sity
level
Wellb
eing
Index
1
3
2
5
30
16.0
682
5.724
19
In our results, their psychological well-being is
positive despite their economic level since their
expectations about their economic situation align
with reality.
3.6. Wellbeing and Civil Status
Results show that the happiest as per civil status is
the single individuals; accordingly, the single
individuals representing 61% of the population of
the study, have better well-being (Mean=15.57) than
others being married with children (Mean=15.9) or
without children (Mean=15). Findings show that
individuals with a partner have a higher level of
well-being than others. Meanwhile, divorced and, or
widowed individuals have the lowest average well-
being (Mean=10).
Table 9. The average well-being indicator refers to
the civil status
Civil Status
N
Min.
Max.
Mean
Co-living
partner
Well
being
Index
7
13
25
18.5714
Single
Well
being
Index
128
5
30
16.8672
Engaged
Well
being
Index
4
14
19
16.5
Married with
children
Well
being
Index
55
8
30
15.9455
Married
without
children
Well
being
Index
15
8
23
15.1333
Others
(divorced,
widowed)
Well
being
Index
2
10
11
10.5
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
784
Volume 20, 2023
4 Discussion
While we discuss the psychological and economic
domains in the context of well-being, little research
is investigating this perspective during the Covid-19
pandemic in Albania. A non-EU country with a
delicate economy adhering and targeting the UN
SDG to ensure healthy lives and promote well-being
for all, at all ages (SDG, goal nr 3), [30], [36]. This
article may be considered a decent contribution to
the growing evidence on the relationship between
psychological well-being and economic well-being,
which is seen not only at the individual level but
also at a country and broader level.
This research included data from the second
wave of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2021 in Albania,
which covered a sample of 212 adults, were part of
this research. The data analysis carried out through
SPSS, through descriptive and qualitative chi-square
tests were analyzed and then further integrated with
official sources of information from INSTAT.
Recent studies show that the Chi-Square statistic is
commonly used for testing relationships between
categorical variables [37], [38],[39].
There is much to discuss regarding the need for
good physical and psychological health and, on the
other hand, a good economy. The key results
revealed that the most important features of
psychological well-being for the Albanian
population during the pandemic were the income
level (economic situation) and the age group of
people.
Firstly, a general evaluation of the
psychological well-being index was investigated by
reporting a modest level of experience and
functioning in people. These individuals reported
having felt somehow good, with an average level of
life satisfaction; moreover, the relation between
subjective well-being and the economy needs
further investigation. The annual Change of
Consumer Price Index from INSTAT official
sources shows that Albanian families use 41,3% of
the overall budget for food and non-alcoholic
beverages. The Albanians' salaries are low, leading
them to be in survival mode in most cases. The
household consumption expenditures by deciles
report that approximately 90% of the households
have 83.9 pct of the total consumption per month,
which is relatively high; moreover, indicators of
Risk of Poverty and Social Exclusion, 2017-2020
show that there is evident inequity in Albania.
Referring to the reviewed literature, the economy of
Western Balkan countries depends on the measures
taken by the authorities, but since the country was
earlier hit by the Earthquake of November 2019 and
soon after, by the Covid-19 pandemic, this was not
easy to manage the well-being of the country.
Secondly, in light of these crises, the Albanian
family's economic situation targets the surviving
domains of food and non-alcoholic beverages. This
perspective of survival does not allow individuals to
be feeling very good. It instead increases their
worries and insecurities about their life and the
economy. Chi-square tests showed that perceptions
about the rise of economic problems are positive
and refer to levels of education, whose grouped
revenues were part of the analysis. The university
level of education represents more economic issues
and worries. According to our results, economic
well-being needs to be seriously considered for
subjective well-being, affecting health and
longevity, as the study reports.
Thirdly, subjective well-being is affected by
age, which differs from the individuals 'social status.
The younger individuals are and the more they have
positive subjective well-being. It may be related to
their economic potential to work and be financially
rewarded. From mid-life to retirement,
psychological well-being drops due to economic
force, retirement, and losing people in life. In this
perspective, psychological well-being is related to
economic well-being too. The existing literature
reports that “interest is growing in well-being as an
economic and societal objective", [8].
Limitations: Findings generates from a database
with random respondents, not conventional ones;
however, findings cannot be generalized to the
whole population. The findings are relevant for the
timeframe gathered; however, they could be
valuable sources to estimate well-being and its
relationship with other socio-demographic and
income variables and anticipate how these
mechanisms work in crises and difficulties to
prevent and for further care. Regardless of these
limitations, this research provides suggestions about
the effect of the economic and social variables on
the quality of life as in crises, psychological
disturbances arise. Moreover, the financial level's
impact on psychological well-being is significant
since it affects mental health; therefore, a well-being
agenda implemented through its policies in our
country with continuous economic flows is needed.
This study contributes to the identification of an
existing pattern between psychological and
economic well-being in Albania. Further
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
785
Volume 20, 2023
measurements of well-being should be used to
contribute to public sector policies.
5 Conclusion
This research paper represents findings deriving
from descriptive and qualitative analysis from a
database referring to Albanian adults' perceptions
gathered during the pandemic when limitations were
still in place and the Omicron wave had captured the
country. The important statistical data from the
official sources of INSTAT added important
information to this paper which aims to understand
the well-being of the Albanian population, referring
to their quality of life and happiness. For this
purpose, we used socio-demographic variables to
see their relationship with the overall well-being
index. The findings show that the general well-being
index is under the average value. The Albanian
adults report they do not have good well-being
during the pandemic, their quality of life is not
good, and they are not happy. Although the
literature majorly suggests that the rise in incomes is
associated with the rise in well-being, our findings
show that during the pandemic, incomes are
relatively significant only for the middle class who
belong to the revenue category. Group ages who
reflect the higher level of well-being are the
youngsters who are happier than the other age
groups. The level of education whose average well-
being means is higher than the high school level of
education. Regarding family arrangements and
commitments, the civil status category reporting the
higher average mean of well-being is a single
category.
Acknowledgments:
The authors are thankful to the editor and the
reviewers, who contribute to improving this article
by providing valuable comments regarding its
quality and presentation.
References:
[1] Adler A, Seligman M. E. P, Using wellbeing
for public policy: Theory, measurement, and
recommendations, International Journal of
Wellbeing, Vol. 6, No. 1, 2016, pp.17.
[2] Allin P, Official Statistics and the Politics of
Sustainable Development, WSEAS
Transactions on Environment And
Development, Vol. 13, 2017, pp.51.
[3] Tascón A, Vargas P.A.F, Luz J, Jizela J.L,
Lozano J.M, Peñaranda D, The Longevity in
A Population of a Country in Development,
WSEAS Transactions On Environment And
Development, Vol.14, 2018, pp.691.
[4] Berthier F, Boulay F, Lower myocardial
infarction mortality in French men the day
France won the 1998 World Cup of football,
Heart, Vol. 89, No.5, 2003, pp. 555556.
[5] Carol D. Ryff, Psychological well-being in
adult life, Current directions in Psychological
Science, Vol. 4, 1995, pp. 99-104.
[6] Chaudhary Sh, Srivastava Sk, Happiness and
ageing: a comparative study, Journal of
Psychology Savannah, Ga., Vol. 55, 2018,
pp.108-113.
[7] Costume L, Sutton P, Mortensen LF,
Kubiszewski I, Costanza R, Trebeck K,
Pulselli FM, Giannetti BF, Fioramonti L,
Overcoming the Myths of Mainstream
Economics to Enable a New Wellbeing
Economy, Sustainability, Vol. 11, No. 16,
2019, pp.4374.
[8] Cylus J, Smith PC, The economy of well-
being: What is it and what are the implications
for
health?, British Medical Journal, Vol. 369,
2020, pp.1-4.
[9] Diener E, Chan M, Happy People Live
Longer: Subjective Well-Being Contributes to
Health and Longevity, Applied psychology:
health and well-being, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2011,
pp.143.
[10] Diener E, Diener M, The relationship between
income and subjective well-being: "Relative
or absolute?", Social Indicators Research: An
International and Interdisciplinary Journal
for Quality-of-Life Measurement, Vol. 28, No.
3, 1993, pp.195-223.
[11] Haq R, Zia U, Multidimensional Wellbeing:
An Index of Quality of Life in a Developing
Economy, Social Indicators Research, Vol.
114, 2013, pp. 9971012.
[12] Herodian H, Suwarti S, Estria S. R,
Consortium Psychiatricum, Psychological
Wellbeing, and Psychological Distress in the
Elderly during the COVID-19 Pandemic, Vol.
3, No. 2, 2022, pp.93.
[13] Huta Veronika, An overview of hedonic and
eudaimonic well-being concepts, In L.
Reinecke & M. B. Oliver (Eds.), Handbook of
media use and well-being, Routledge, 2015
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
786
Volume 20, 2023
[14] Kang H, Kim H. Ageism and Psychological
Well-Being Among Older Adults: A
Systematic Review, Gerontology and
Geriatric Medicine, Vol. 8, 2022, pp.1-22.
[15] M. Powell Lawton (1983) The varieties of
wellbeing, Experimental Aging
Research, Vol. 9, No. 2, 1983, pp. 65-72.
[16] Kaplan GA, Shema SJ, Leite CM,
Socioeconomic determinants of psychological
well-being: the role of income, income
change, and income sources during 29 years,
Ann Epidemiol. Vol. 18, No. 7, 2018, pp.531-
537.
[17] Killingsworth M A, Experienced well-being
rises with income, even above $75,000 per
year, Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences, Vol. 118, No. 4, 2021, pp.1-16.
[18] Kim ES, Tkatch R, Martin D, MacLeod S,
Sandy L, Yeh C. Resilient Aging:
Psychological Well-Being and Social Well-
Being as Targets for the Promotion of Healthy
Aging, Gerontology and Geriatric Medicine,
Vol. 7, 2021, pp.1-12.
[19] Moro-Egido, Al., Navarro M, Sánchez A,
Changes in Subjective Well-Being Over
Time: Economic and Social Resources do
Matter, Journal of Happiness Studies, Vol. 23,
2022, pp.20-22.
[20] Sareen J, Afifi TO, McMillan KA,
Asmundson GJG, Relationship Between
Household Income and Mental Disorders:
Findings From a Population-Based
Longitudinal Study, Arch Gen Psychiatry,
Vol. 68, No. 4, 2011, pp.419-427.
[21] Stefaniak AR, Blaxton JM, Bergeman CS.
Age Differences in Types and Perceptions of
Daily Stress, The International Journal of
Aging and Human Development, Vol. 94,
2022.
[22] Svrtinov G.V, Trajkovska G.O, Kacarski M.E,
Koleva B, The impact of Covid-19 on
Western Balkans economies, Journal of
Economics, Vol. 5, No. 2, 2020, pp.1-12.
[23] Taylor M, Jenkins S, Sacker A, Financial
capability, income, and psychological
wellbeing, Research Paper in Economics, No.
18, 2011, pp. 22-23.
[24] Tay, L., Kuykendall, L., Diener, E,
Satisfaction, and Happiness The Bright Side
of Quality of Life, Global Handbook of
Quality of Life, Springer.
[25] WHO Regional Office for Europe, Roadmap
for health and well-being in the Western
Balkans (20212025): European Programme
of Work (20202025) “United Action for
Better Health, 2021.
[26] Xing Z, Huang L, The Relationship Between
Age and Subjective Well-Being: Evidence
from Five Capital Cities in Mainland China,
The Social Indicators Research, Vol. 117, No.
3, 2014, pp.743756.
[27] Yu Z, Chen L, Income and Well-Being:
Relative Income and Absolute Income
Weaken Negative Emotion, but Only Relative
Income Improves Positive Emotion, Frontiers
Psychology, Vol. 7, 2012, pp. 1-6.
[28] Institute of Statistics, ‘Albanians’ population’,
2022. [Online]. Available:
http://www.instat.gov.al/media/9828/popullsia
-me-1-janar-2022_final-15-04-2022.pdf.
[Accessed: 20 Oct. 2022].
[29] Psychiatric Research Unit, WHO 5 indexes
of Wellbeing’, [Online].
Available: https://www.psykiatri-
regionh.dk/who-
5/Documents/WHO5_Albanian.pdf.
[Accessed: 10 Sept. 2021].
[30] United Nations, ‘Sustainable Development
Goals’, [Online]. Available:
https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/h
ealth/. [Accessed: 10 April 2022].
[31] Bank of Albania, ‘Official exchange rate’,
[Online]. Available:
https://www.bankofalbania.org/Tregjet/Kursi_
zyrtar_i_kembimit/.
[Accessed: 15 Nov. 2022].
[32] Institute of Statistics, ‘Household Budget
Survey’, [Online]. Available:
http://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/social-
condition/household-budget-survey/#tab2.
[Accessed: 1 Oct. 2022].
[33] Council of Europe, ‘3 Ensure healthy lives
and promote well-being for all at all ages’,
[Online]. Available:
https://www.coe.int/en/web/un-agenda-
2030/goal-3. [Accessed: 10 Sept. 2022].
[34] Institute of Statistics, Distribution of
contributory employees according to average
gross monthly salary intervals according to
Salary Groupings, Variable and Quarter’,
2022. [Online]. Available:
http://databaza.instat.gov.al/pxweb/sq/DST/S
TART__PKP__PTM/PTM031/.
[Accessed: 10 Sept. 2022].
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
787
Volume 20, 2023
[35] Institute of Statistics, ‘Household Budget
Survey 2018’, 2019. [Online].
Available:
http://www.instat.gov.al/media/6322/hbs_201
8_.pdf. [Accessed: 10 Sept. 2022].
[36] World Health Organization, ‘Targets of
Sustainable Development Goals’, [Online].
Available: https://www.who.int/europe/about-
us/our-work/sustainable-development-
goals/targets-of-
sustainable-development-goal-3.
[Accessed: 15 Sept. 2022].
[37] Statistics Solution, ‘Using Chi-Square
Statistic in Research’, [Online]. Available:
https://www.statisticssolutions.com/free-
resources/directory-of-statistical-
analyses/using-chi-square-
statistic-in-research/.
[Accessed: 18 Sept. 2022].
[38] Kent State University libraries, ‘SPSS
tutorials: chi-square test of independence’,
[Online]. Available:
https://libguides.library.kent.edu/spss/chisquar
e . [Accessed: 20 Aug. 2022].
[39] University of Southhampton, ‘Chi Square’,
[Online]. Available:
https://www.southampton.ac.uk/passs/full_tim
e_education/bivariate_analysis/chi_square.pag
e. [Accessed: 20 Aug. 2022].
[40] Institute of Statistics, ‘Income and Living
Conditions in Albania, 2020’, [Online].
Available:
http://www.instat.gov.al/media/9409/income-
and-living-condition-silc2020final.pdf.
[Accessed: 20 Sept. 2022].
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
-Besmira Lahi carried out the conceptualization,
methodology, project administration, resources,
supervision, visualization, and writing.
-Ines Nurja is responsible for data curation, formal
analysis, investigation, software, writing, review,
and editing.
Both authors discussed the results and contributed to
the manuscript.
Sources of funding for research presented in a
scientific article or scientific article itself
This research did not receive any funding.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflict of interest to declare
that is relevant to the content of this article.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2023.20.72
Besmira Lahi, Ines Nurja
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
788
Volume 20, 2023