Structural Change and Employee Satisfaction of Privately-Owned Hotels in Nigeria
ROBERTS PRECIOUS, UMAR ABBAS IBRAHIM, FAIZA MAITALA,
CROSS OGOHI DANIEL
Department of Business Administration
Nile University of Nigeria
NIGERIA
Abstract - The hospitality industry in Nigeria is going through a process of transition due to the pandemic effect
of the coronavirus (Covid-19). A new policy has been given by the government as a result of coronavirus, which
required certain structural changes that demand employees to be more proactive and flexible to maintain efficiency
in operations. Thus, hotel organizations in Nigeria must be flexible to quickly react and adapt to internal and
external changes influencing their operation. Due to the close interaction between employees and customers,
there can be direct effects of the change process on customers' patronage when certain structural changes
occur. Therefore, this study examines structural change and its influence on employee satisfaction in selected
privately owned hotels in Abuja, Nigeria. A closed-ended questionnaire was administered to a sample of 397
employees online. A 5-point Likert scale was designed to capture and measure employees’ perceptions on variables
relating to structural change and employee satisfaction. Regression analysis was used to analyze the data and test
the hypothesis. Findings indicated that structural change significantly and positively influences employee
satisfaction. The study concludes that effective and efficient management of every change is very crucial for
organizational success and for enhanced positive employee attitude and behavior that translate into improved
operational efficiency.
Keywords: Structural Change Management, Organization Change Management, Employee Satisfaction,
Competition, Hospitality Industry.
Received: August 25, 2019. Revised: August 11, 2022. Accepted: September 3, 2022. Published: September 15, 2022.
1 Introduction association conditions and market circumstances is a
necessity for the separate association to have a
flourishing and practical structure for dealing with
the progressions really [15] [19]. In any case,
hierarchical change can be extremist and adjust the
manner in which an association works, or it could be
gradual and gradually alter the status quo done. This
might require viable plan and the executives of
another construction to man the change's
prerequisites.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1600
Volume 19, 2022
Because of the rising degree of contest in the worldwide
neighborliness industry, associations in this industry are
turning out to be more mindful of the need to work in
view of both inside and remotely evolving conditions.
Such a powerful pattern requires the association to be
more adaptable to be able to do fittingly adjusting to the
anticipated and anticipated changes. Such capacity
requires the responsibility of an association's workers.
Thus, particularly in the friendliness business, this takes
into account the unpredictable deals and the irregularity
of a transitory decent [1]. [2] affirm that different
outside powers could advance change in an association.
These incorporate the market circumstance of the
association or the spot that it possesses inside the
market; the innovation use example of the association;
administrative regulations, strategies, and guidelines;
general changes in the economy. Consequently, the
capacity to anticipate the occasions and to adjust to
The cordiality business is essential for the help business
and is involved significant sub-areas which incorporate
lodgings, inns, food and drink administration, the travel
industry, occasions, and transportation. These business
are delicated to both inner and outer natural changes to
stay cutthroat. The inn business which is the focal point
of this study is a portion inside the visitor spaces for
dozing [17]. Besides, it was accounted for that Nigeria's
solid economy through 2014 made the country a
practical and appealing business sector for global
financial backers, including worldwide lodging
brands [39]. A serious examination of the business
shows that the business contributed around 4.8% to
Nigeria's Gross Domestic Product in 2016 [20]. It
was additionally extended that the compound
yearly development in the area will be 7.0 percent
throughout the following five years, the biggest
extension of any country in five driving African
nations [39]. These have prompted more serious
rivalry in the cordiality business, which is clear
because of the development of numerous huge new
lodgings, prompting an issue of over-supply and
natural underlying change inside the association.
Subsequently, the undeniably developing contest
in the business had made even the leaders of the
business rethink their practices and recognize areas
of progress [32].
Hierarchical design change addresses something
novel and inherently obscure and dubious for the
association and its individuals, which might
disturb existing designs and cycles. Thus, it tends
to be communicated both as a chance to acquire
and as a gamble of misfortune and may include the
upgrade of errands and obligations that change
existing work content and climate in different
ways [12]. In any case, [50] called attention to that
when authoritative change is very much overseen
it guarantees the association's proceeded with
endurance. It can create a few advantages like
upgraded intensity, worked on monetary execution,
and higher client and worker fulfillment [26].
Moreover, because of dynamic changes around the
world, lodgings also will generally change their
primary equilibrium over the long run to squeeze
into the ongoing circumstance and simultaneously
keep up with apparent efficiency. While relative
change might be a steady encounter, information,
and mindfulness about large numbers of the basic
issues required inside the administration of such
change is normally ailing in those liable for its
encouraging [53]. Studies have laid out that it is
basic for any association working in a powerful
climate to decisively answer the dynamism of the
market and stay up with both the inner and outer
climate patterns [8] [10] [25]. Subsequently, the
essential key to any association's endurance under
the state of the serious climate requires a fruitful
change the executives execution, with workers
assuming a key part [52] [15].
Representatives are key partners in the
arrangement and advancement of any association
[1]. Hence, representatives as the human resources
of the association are a vital wellspring of
information and backing for the turn of events and
execution of a supportable change the executives
cycle in the association. It has been learned that
individuals assets are the primary justification
behind the endurance and development of
associations [37]. In this way, workers have the
abilities for thinking and they assume significant
parts by considerably adding to the flourishing or
in any case of associations. On this note, [4] think
that associations ought to consequently give basic
consideration to representatives to keep them
fulfilled. This is fundamental since worker
turnover is a basic issue of worry to chiefs and
partners, especially, in a period when the
association is confronting the requirement for a
basic change execution process [33] [35].
The inn business, a result of the neighborliness
area, is characterized by the connection between
the specialist organization, the actual help, and the
visitor, and is described by offering a scope of
administrations that incorporate the fulfillment of
physiological and mental necessities[42]. [5]
expressed that the critical element of the lodging
industry is the close to home relationship laid out
with clients, which calls for associations inside the
business to be more serious and for representatives
to make esteem in the turn of events and progress
of associations [5]. On this note, [47] call attention
to that since representatives' demeanor sets the
virtues of the lodging associations, bright workers
assume a significant part in the space of client care
and further developed deals as they are the one to
connect with the client every day.
Basically, fulfilled representatives in the help
business are vital to the development and outcome of
associations [37]. In the occasion of the inn business
in Nigeria, worker responsibility, turnover rate, and
representative execution are arising as the most
critical test for the administration of representatives
in the short term [34]. These difficulties are driven
by the worries of steadfastness of representatives,
hierarchical rebuilding, and high rivalry for worker
maintenance. On this note, [46] assert that
inspecting representative work fulfillment has been a
persistent practice among inn or administration
industry specialists. The vital reason for the rehashed
consideration given to this idea is its basic worth to
the changing lodging business climate across the
globe. Thus, the idea turns into a main issue for each
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1601
Volume 19, 2022
inn proprietor today in Nigeria [37]. Associations
genuinely must put more accentuation on workers as
a critical boundary of estimating execution, to
accomplish an upper hand, as this comprises the
genuine resources of each and every association and
assumes a huge part in making generally hierarchical
progress [11].
Subsequently, lodging organizations, especially those
in Abuja Nigeria, are no special case for a large
portion of the conditions raised previously.
Consequently, clearly accomplishing functional
proficiency in the business requires a powerful and
proficient primary administration framework that
will guarantee better variation toward expanding the
advantages of the change cycle. It depends on the
prior data that this study inspected underlying change
the board and its impact on representatives'
fulfillment as a develop of hierarchical execution in
chose lodgings in Abuja, Nigeria.
This study is required in light of the fact that despite
the fact that many examinations researched the
connection between authoritative change and
hierarchical results, especially in regards to
representative execution, notwithstanding, not very
many investigations have been led to report the
impact of the board of primary change in improving
workers' fulfillment, according to the viewpoints of
cutting edge workers in the area that was designated
in this review. Hence, the review is fundamentally
worried about elucidating the sort of association
between the executives of primary change and
workers' fulfillment in the lodging industry
associations, inside Nigeria's business climate
setting.
2 Problem Formulation
Change has turned into the living organ of each and
every significant association, similarly as it has
forever been a typical quality of human existence
[21] [40] [51]. Because of data and correspondence
innovation headway combined with expanding
democratization of economies and progression across
the globe, the pace of progress that business
associations face keeps on expanding an ever
increasing number of over the most recent fifty years
[36] [51].
An association structure addresses how the
undertakings and sub-errands expected to execute a
technique are organized inside an association [22].
[11] depicted the underlying change as changing the
association's upward deterioration or flat separation,
power distribution, and level of formalization. The
construction of the association demonstrates the
nature and way of human and social connections
inside the association, thus, endeavors to change the
design which perpetually influences these
connections might be opposed by the concerned
partners. Underlying changes include significant
changes in the administration progressive system,
group association, and the obligations ascribed to
various offices, representatives, or groups. These
progressions frequently cross-over with individuals
driven changes as they straightforwardly influence
the vast majority of workers.
The design is an authority arrangement of the
obligation and the power relations of an association
[11]. Thusly, authoritative primary change includes
adjustment of the idea of the gig, like the expected
set of responsibilities and job liabilities, and updating
the arrangement of divisions or specialty units inside
an association
[16].
2.1 Concept of Structural Change
Underlying changes could likewise be impacted by
changes in the association's administration pecking
order, levels of leadership, the board frameworks,
and regulatory methods. Conditions that require
primary change could incorporate consolidations and
acquisitions, changes on the lookout, work
duplication, and strategy changes [26].
As per [28], underlying change inside an association
may be started by interior or outer variables to the
association. Subsequently, viable and effective
change the executives requests the association's
capacity to perceive what causes underlying change
inside and without an association [26]. This can
assist the board with setting up better change the
executives and utilize strategies that would keep the
association on the way to development [27].
. Temporary hierarchical design change is more
perplexing and requires an adjustment of
jobs/obligations, power bases, and frameworks like
opening another plant in another area, where more
definite preparation and mastery are required.
Groundbreaking authoritative design change requires
updating the whole association, particularly the
crucial convictions and standards, to adjust to
worldwide business interest [51].
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1602
Volume 19, 2022
As per [43], there are six components of designs
which incorporate work specialization; association
hierarchy of leadership; a range of control; authority,
and obligation; centralization and decentralization;
and departmentalization. It suggests, subsequently,
that adjustments of the construction of an association
might remember modification for power connections,
coordination instruments, work plan, level of
centralization, and other comparable primary factors.
Moreover, it has been guided out that change toward
how the organization carries on with work can
animate primary changes. In the event that the
organization was utilized to divisions being
independent, a change to a concentrated approach to
carrying on with work would naturally produce
changes in the organization structure [26].
Compelling authoritative construction is fundamental
for an association going through change since,
supposing that there are defects in the design it will
influence correspondence stream [51]. Hierarchical
design empowers an association to have normal
perspectives and missions as they radiate from a
solitary point guaranteeing there are no contentions
of orders and smooth data stream [51]. Changes in
hierarchical design will impact how associations
capability overall and how representatives play out
their undertakings and work processes. Conditions
that could require the requirement for hierarchical
primary change incorporate consolidations and
acquisitions, evasion of occupation duplication,
changes in the market interest, cycle or strategy
changes, and others. In any case, underlying change
in an association ought to conform to the vision,
goals, and in general business technique of the
association, combined with the basic approaches and
standards of the association, drivers of progress, and
the ecological reality to ensure a positive outcome.
As the association structure is typically settled after
the business procedure has been supported, it helps
characterizes the progressive levels and quantities of
representatives expected to accomplish the technique
[45]. Thusly, authoritative underlying methodology
focusses on working on hierarchical and
representative execution by changing announcing
lines, rebuilding specialty units, and surveying work
jobs [16]. In spite of the fact that, it's undeniably true
that change is a cycle and it is vital for head down its
path, in any case, workers may be hesitant to
acknowledge it readily [51]. [24] focused on that
representatives have sensations of stress,
apprehension, and absence of certainty when the
association changes like rebuilding, cutting back, and
as well as consolidating. This could result in either
representative becoming incited by attempting to
satisfy more than one supervisor, or workers tracking
down ways of utilizing contradicting sees by
numerous chiefs to get what the representative
necessities [26].
2.2 Concept of Employee Job Satisfaction
The idea of worker fulfillment is one of the most
explored develops of HRM principally in light of the
fact that it is fundamental to the people who are keen
on representative execution and authoritative results
[37][18][44]. As indicated by [49], representative
work fulfillment is a conventional idea, which could
be portrayed according to a conduct point of view.
Subsequently, individual or hierarchical way of
behaving is accepted to be objective coordinated;
consequently, every human activity has an essential
inspiration and most activities are a work to expand
fulfillment by satisfying different inspirations.
The idea is portrayed by [49] as a pleasurable close
to home state coming about because of the evaluation
of one's occupation as accomplishing as working
with the accomplishment of one's work esteem. It is
utilized to anticipate the ways of behaving of
representatives which incorporate worker turnover
and its expectation, confidence, and representatives'
obligation to the acknowledgment of hierarchical
objectives and targets [13]. Worker work fulfillment
is alluded to as a representative's pride and
accomplishment at work.
Worker work fulfillment midway centered around
the inside condition of satisfaction or uneasiness
around one's work [34]. It has been learned that
fulfilled workers are basic resources for the
association. Fulfilled representatives will generally
be more dedicated to their work, take part more
vigorously, decidedly, and really in business related
exercises, and are less inclined to leave the
association [2]. Likewise, representative work
fulfillment is viewed as a significant mark of how
workers feel about their positions and an indicator of
work ways of behaving like hierarchical citizenship,
truancy, turnover, and generally speaking position
execution [31] [6].
By and large, the idea of representative work
fulfillment incorporates natural and outward
fulfillment at work [13]. Characteristic work
fulfillment is a close to home express that a
representative gets from the gig obligations
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1603
Volume 19, 2022
participated in and recreating the demeanor of the
representative towards undertakings of the gig. It is
explicitly depicted as the degree to which
representatives are supported because of reasons
other than monetary inspiration (for example
sensations of increased confidence, individual
achievement, and self-awareness) [37].
Consequently, inherent work fulfillment is the
regular fulfillment that a representative procures
while playing out the errand and encountering the
sensations of such achievements [37]. Alternately,
outward work fulfillment alludes to the profound
express that a singular representative gets from the
prizes associated with one's errand that is constrained
by the association, as well as his companions, or
bosses [13][38].
In light of Maslow's hypothesis, representative work
fulfillment has been moved toward by certain
analysts from the viewpoint of need satisfaction [7].
As per [48], the idea means a capability that is
emphatically connected with how much one's very
own requirements are satisfied in the gig
circumstance. [49] view it as workers' close to home
state with respect to the gig, taking into account what
they expected and what they received in return. This
means that a worker with low assumptions can be
more happy with a specific occupation than
somebody who has exclusive requirements. In this
manner, on the off chance that a representative's
assumptions are met or surpassed by the gig, such a
worker will be blissful and happy with the gig [7].
Representative work fulfillment covers five parts of
the gig like management, pay, the actual work,
advancement valuable open doors, and work
associates [37]. As per [47], the workplace is a
significant determinant of occupation fulfillment. In
this manner, a decent workplace and great working
circumstances will prompt work fulfillment, as well
as assist in expanding representative with working
execution, productivity, consumer loyalty as well as
maintenance. Workers' fulfillment is a huge middle
person between what an association makes accessible
to clients and how representatives in that specific
association convey the help [3]. This is significant on
the grounds that, in this serious and globalized time,
each association is hoping to track down ways of
carrying more worth to the administrations it works
on the nature of its administrations. Additionally,
accomplishing authoritative targets rely upon
representative work fulfillment, which thusly impacts
the endurance, achievement, and development, as
well as upgrading the exhibition and expanding the
nature of work in such associations [30].
It is basic to take note of that few strategies and
scales have been created to quantify work fulfillment
[23] [49]. These incorporate rating scales, Job
Descriptive Index, Minnesota Satisfaction
Questionnaire, Critical Incidence, Interview, and
Action Tendencies. In any case, the most normally
utilized are the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire
and Job Description Index [14]. Minnesota
fulfillment poll and set of working responsibilities
file is a paper-pencil kind of survey and can be
executed both separately and in a gathering, yet it
doesn't think about sex contrasts [14]. The Job
Description Index is one of the most broadly
involved strategies for estimating position
fulfillment. This is on the grounds that it is a
straightforward and effectively pertinent technique.
The estimation of solidarity and shortcoming inside
each variable is a sign with respect to which field
improvement and changes are important.
Customarily, work fulfillment is estimated by
utilizing general logical exploration techniques like a
poll. This study utilized a survey in estimating
position fulfillment.
Strikingly, representative work fulfillment has been
concentrated on both as a free and a reliant variable.
As an autonomous variable, work fulfillment makes
sense of results like execution, non-appearance, and
turnover [41]. In this review, representative work
fulfillment is placed as a reliant variable impacted by
underlying change in lodging associations. Hence,
the review proposed the speculation that:
H0: Structural change significantly affects worker
fulfillment
Calculated Framework
A calculated structure is a portrayal of the
relationship that sub-exist between the factors
recognized in a review. Accordingly, the factors for
this study are interrelated as displayed in figure 1.
The autonomous variable is primary change as seen
in the chose lodging associations, while the reliant
variable boundaries on association execution result
estimated by worker fulfillment. Consequently, the
connection between the reliant and free factors is
addressed in figure 1 underneath
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1604
Volume 19, 2022
Fig. 1: Conceptual Framework
Source: Developed from literature, 2022
3 Methodology
The essential focal point of this study is to examine
the adequacy of primary change in impacting worker
fulfillment in exclusive lodgings in Abuja, Nigeria.
The review is exploratory and hence utilized an
overview research plan to inspect the impact of a free
factor on the reliant variable. The overview research
methodology was thought of as reasonable for
clarifying respondents' viewpoints and perspectives
towards the accomplishment of the examination
objective. The topographical area of this study was
Abuja, the government capital domain of Nigeria.
The number of inhabitants in the review, in this way,
comprises of all the bleeding edge staff of enrolled
exclusive lodgings in Abuja, Nigeria. Nonetheless,
ten inns were intentionally chosen for the review.
They incorporate Grand Cubana Hotel, Protea Hotel
Asokoro, Chelsea Hotel, The Envoy Hotel, Fraser
Suites, Corinthia Villa Hotel and Suites, Hawthorn
Suites by Wyndham, and Royalton Hotels, BON
Hotel Grand Tower, and Mediterranean Hotel. The
chose lodgings are domiciled inside Abuja and its
city and they were deliberately chosen in light of a
comparative extent of activity and characterization of
capability. In this way, 300 and 97 (397) staff was
arbitrarily chosen utilizing [9] example size
assurance equation. The example size appropriation
is portrayed in table 1
Table 1. Sample Population of Hotel Staff
Source: Survey, 2022
Essential information was gathered using close-
finished polls controlled. The information gathered
were estimated utilizing a 5-point Likert scale going
from 1 point for "unequivocally conflict" to 5
focuses for "emphatically concur". This empowered
the respondents to communicate the degree to which
they concur or contradict a specific assertion about
the exploration objective. The review utilizes
Cronbach's Alpha (α) test as an unwavering quality
test. The coefficient was viewed as 0.821 (table 2),
which shows that the dependability is OK.
Table 2. Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
Cronbach's Alpha
Based on
Standardized
Items
N of Items
N
0.838
0.821
10
397
Source: Author’s Computation, 2022
The reaction pace of the survey regulated showed
that a sum of 397 duplicates of the poll were given
and were totally returned. The outcome of the return
rate is on the grounds that it was given on the web
and sufficient chances were given to the staff to go
through the poll and return at their advantageous
time. The polls were suitably observed upon
organization. The reactions from the poll were coded
and placed into SPSS and used to dissect the
information involving clear measurements for the
factors, OLS relapse examination with a pre-model
demonstrative test, displaying, and the post-model
symptomatic test to decide the degree to which
primary change as a free factor could make sense of
the varieties in representative fulfillment. The huge
worth assisted with deciding the meaning of the
connection between the autonomous variable and the
reliant variable, while the coefficient of assurance
(R2) uncovered how well the free factor could
foresee the reliant variable. Durbwin-Watson insights
was utilized to test the presence or nonattendance of
sequential connection. To take out the presence of
sequential relationship, the weighted normal of the
poll reaction was acquired for the assessment.
The model detail follows the laid out reasonable
system. Worker fulfillment addresses the reliant
variable while the free factor is primary change. The
functional model for the review is portrayed beneath;
𝑌
𝑖= 𝜑0+ 𝜑1𝑋1,𝑖𝜇𝑖
Where;
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1605
Volume 19, 2022
𝑌
𝑖 represents a measure of employee satisfaction
𝑋1, I stands for structural change
𝜑1 is the parameter to be estimated
𝜑0 stands for the constant
𝜇𝑖 stands for the white noise error term
4 Results and Discussion
Analysis of Respondents’ Demographic Data
Table 3. Respondents' Demographic Data
Demographic
Characteristic
Frequency
Percentage
Gender: Female
Male
Total
241
156
397
60.65
39.35
100.00
AGE: 18-25yrs
26-35yrs
36-45yrs
46 and
above
Total
75
139
140
43
397
18.89
35.01
35.26
10.83
100.00
Educational
Qualification:
N.C.E/OND
H.N.D/ B.Sc.
M.Sc/MBA or
Equivalent
Ph.D
Total
136
176
72
13
397
34.26
44.33
18.14
3.27
100.0
Department:
Front Desk Officer
Customer Care
House Keeping
Service Unit
Others
Total
88
52
105
90
62
397
22.17
13.1
26.45
22.67
15.61
100.0
Working
experience:
1-5years
6-10years
11-15years
16-20years
21years-above
Total
62
83
104
94
54
397
15.62
20.91
26.2
23.67
13.60
100.0
Source: Field Survey, 2022
Table 3 showed the segment circulation of the
respondents in view of the return rate on the quantity
of surveys controlled in rates. It shows that 60.65%
of the respondents were females while 39.35 % of
the respondents were guys. This places that the staff
of the inn area in Nigeria was for the most part
females. The age dispersion of the respondents
showed that most of the clients of the lodging area in
Nigeria were inside the dynamic financial age with
the scope of 18-45years old enough. This
summarized to 89.16% of the complete example. The
dissemination of the respondents by schooling
capability places that most of the respondents were
taught and could in this way uninhibitedly articulate
their thoughts without help. The circulation of the
respondents in light of working division shows that
front work area officials comprise 22.17% (88);
client care was 13.1% (52); housekeeping was
26.45% (105); administration units 22.67% (90) and
others not recorded in the agenda 15.61% (62). These
address the common classification of staff
straightforwardly associated with the everyday
running of the lodging association in Nigeria. The
conveyance of the respondents in view of how long
every respondent has functioned in the particular
association uncovered the functioning experience of
the respondents. The point was to be aware assuming
the respondents had adequate information on the
tasks of the association to give sufficient data about
the business as usual of the associations they address.
The outcomes show that 15.62% (62) of the
respondents had worked with the firm for 1-5years;
20.91% (83) of the respondents had worked with the
firm for 6-10years; 26.2% (104) had worked with the
firm for 11-15years; 23.67% (94) had working
experience of 16-20years; 13.60% (54) had working
experience of 21years or more.
Measurable Indices of Questionnaire
In light of the review factors, the survey depended on
two portions of inquiries, each section containing
five inquiries addressing a variable as demonstrated
in table 4.2 and 4.3 separately.
Table 4. Percentage Analysis for Structural Change
Items
5
4
3
2
1
I have a positive
attitude that
supports new
leadership in our
team or
department.
189
(47.65)
141
(35.74)
9
(2.17)
22
(5.42)
36
(9.03)
Implementing a
new structural
policy can result
in employee
resistance
175
(44.04)
185
(46.57)
4
(1.08)
14
(3.61)
18
(4.69)
Change in
organizational
193
(48.65)
150
(37.74)
2
(2.17)
18
(4.42)
28
(7.03)
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1606
Volume 19, 2022
structure would
enhance
employee
performance at
the organization.
Change instills
confidence in
employees
regarding the
management’s
ability to lead the
organization and
make good
business
decisions.
191
(48.04)
181
(45.57)
8
(2.08)
6
(1.62)
11
(2.69)
A corporate
structure that
embraces change
tends to remain
dynamic in the
marketplace.
171
(42.96)
191
(48.01)
6
(1.44)
17
(4.33)
13
(3.24)
Source: Field Survey, 2022
Table 4 portrays an examination of the respondent's
discernment concerning issues connected with
underlying change as the free factor. The primary
thing in the table shows that 83.39% of the
respondents certified that they have an uplifting
outlook that upholds new initiative in the group or
division; 2.7% of the respondents were uncertain and
1445% conflicted. The subsequent thing uncovered
that 90.61% of the respondents confirmed that
carrying out another primary strategy can bring about
worker obstruction; 1.8% of the respondents were
unsure; 8.3% of the respondents differ that executing
another approach can bring about representative
opposition. The third thing in the set table
demonstrates that 85.78% of the respondents support
that adjustment of authoritative construction would
improve representative execution at their inn; 2.17%
of the respondents were unsure; 11.45% of the
respondents differ that adjustment of hierarchical
design would upgrade worker execution at their
lodging. The fourth thing in the table places that
93.61% of the respondents affirmed that change
imparts trust in workers with respect to the
administration's capacity to lead the association and
settle on great business choices; 2.08% of the
respondents were unsure; 4.31% of the respondents
differ that change imparts trust in representatives in
regards to the administration's capacity to lead the
association and pursue great business choices.
Finally, the fifth thing shows that 90.97% of the
respondents confirmed that a corporate construction
that embraces change will in general stay dynamic in
the commercial center; 1.44% of the respondents
were unsure, and 7.57% of the respondents differ that
a corporate design that embraces change will in
general stay dynamic in the commercial center.
Table 5. Percentage Analysis for Employee Job
Satisfaction
Items
5
4
3
2
1
I am currently
happy about my
job
156
(39.35)
158
(39.71)
29
(7.22)
36
(9.03)
19
(4.69)
I will like not to
quit if a new
system does not
suit me
145
(36.46)
172
(43.32)
22
(5.42)
33
(8.30)
26
(6.49)
I prefer to stay to
learn about any
new system
introduced than
quit my job.
158
(39.71)
174
(44.04)
14
(3.61)
36
(9.03)
14
(3.61)
I am less
worrisome when
a new system is
implemented.
191
(48.01)
172
(43.32)
17
(4.25)
12
(2.94)
6
(1.48)
I would love to
recommend my
job to the people
in my social
circle
175
(44.04)
163
(41.16)
27
(6.86)
20
(5.05)
11
(2.89)
Source: Field Survey, 2022
Table 5 uncovers an investigation of the respondent's
impression of issues connected with worker
fulfillment as the reliant variable. The primary thing
shows that 79.06% of the respondents affirmed that
they were blissful about their work; 7.22% of the
respondents were unsure; 13.72% of the respondents
differ that they were as of now cheerful about their
work. The subsequent thing sets that 79.78% of the
respondents affirmed that they wouldn't leave their
place of employment regardless of whether another
framework suit them; 5.42% of the respondents were
uncertain, and 14.79% of the respondents differ that
they wouldn't stop in the event that another
framework doesn't exactly measure up for them. The
third thing in the table portrays that 83.03% of the
respondents affirmed that they would like to remain
to find out about any new framework presented than
quit their jobs;3.61% of the respondents were unsure,
and 12.64% of the respondents conflicted. The fourth
thing shows that 91.33% of the respondents assert
that they were less troubling when another
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1607
Volume 19, 2022
framework is executed; 4.25% of the respondents
were uncertain, and 28.51% of the respondents
clashed. The fifth thing in the table shows that 85.2%
of the respondents avowed that they love couldn't
imagine anything better than to prescribe their
responsibilities to individuals in their group of
friends; 6.86% of the respondents were uncertain,
and 7.94% of the respondents conflicted.
Engaging Statistics
The review directed the elucidating measurements
with the outcomes posted in Table 4.4 uncover the
outline insights of the applicable factors remembered
for the examination.
Table 6. Descriptive Statistics
Variables
X1
Y1
N
397
397
Range
2.37
1.80
Minimum
3.30
3.20
Maximum
5.00
5.00
Sum
1463.78
1441.00
Mean
4.5039
4.4338
Std. Deviation
0.38563
0.43909
Variance
0.149
0.193
Skewness
-1.031
-1.069
Kurtosis
2.267
1.477
Note: X1-Structural Change; Y1- Employee’s job
satisfaction
Source: Author’s Computation, 2022
The dependent variable is employees’ satisfaction
(Y1) which had reported Range, Minimum,
Maximum, Sum, Mean, Standard Deviation,
Variance, Skewness, and Kurtosis values 2.37, 3.30,
5.00, 1463.78, 4.5039, 0.38563, 0.149, -1.031, and
2.267 respectively. The independent variable is
structural change with reported Range, Minimum,
Maximum, Sum, Mean, Standard Deviation,
Variance, Skewness, and Kurtosis worth of 1.80,
3.20, 5.00, 1441.00, 4.4338, 0.43909, 0.193, - 1.069,
and 1.477 individually. These portray that the factors
are statically well fitted for the model.
Speculation Testing
The assessed relapse was utilized to test the
speculation to find out the impact of innovation
change on consumer loyalty in regards to chosen
lodgings in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT),
Nigeria
Table 4.5 presents an outline of the consequences of
the Regression Analysis on the impact of primary
change on representative work fulfillment.
Table 7. Regression Analysis of the Influence
of Structural Change on Employee Job Satisfaction
Variable
B
Std. Error
t-stat
sig.
(Constant)
-0.027
0.245
-0.112
0.911
Structural
Change
0.389
0.070
5.574
0.000
Employee
Satisfaction
0.617
0.454
1.446
0.012
R-Square
0.591
Durbin-Watson
2.46
Adjusted R-
square
0.580
a. Dependent Variable: Employee Job Satisfaction
b. Predictors: (Constant), Structural Change
Source: Author’s Computation, 2022
Table 7 is the relapse result on the impact of primary
change on worker work fulfillment. It portrays that
the R-Square is 0.591 and the Adjusted R-Square is
0.580 which isn't excessively far separated implying
that the R-square can be depended on. This suggests
that underlying change (the free factor) impacts
worker work fulfillment (subordinate variable) by
more than 50%. This is generally excellent in
choosing the decency of fit for the model,
consequently, the relapse model ended up being
extremely valuable for making expectations. The
Durbin-Watson of 2.46 suggests that there is no issue
of sequential connection and multicollinearity in the
model.
Further, the coefficient for underlying change is
0.389 and measurably huge at one percent. This is to
say, a rate ascend in underlying change will cause a
38.9% expansion in worker fulfillment, taking
everything into account. Hence, (H01): There is no
huge impact of underlying change on representative
work fulfillment in friendliness associations in
Abuja, Nigeria is thus dismissed.
4.1 Discussion of the Findings
This study assesses underlying change and its overall
impact on representative work fulfillment in 3-5 star
lodgings in Nigeria. Underlying change was
portrayed to address the explorative variable and its
overall impact on worker work fulfillment as the
reliant variable was assessed by testing the
speculation planned in accordance with the review's
principal objective, which was broke down utilizing
relapse examination, to show up at a convincing
finding for the review. This assisted with depicting
the meaning of the aftereffects of the examination in
the radiance of what was at that point had some
significant awareness of the exploration issue being
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1608
Volume 19, 2022
researched and to additionally make sense of any
new grasping that arose as a ramifications of the
review discoveries.
The aftereffects of the segment examination of the
respondents show that respondents have adequate
schooling and experience, and were of good age and
conjugal status remaining to give inside and out data
so as accomplish the review's goal. Constantly,
clearly most of the respondents had an exceptionally
strong instructive foundation subsequently setting
them in the best situation to offer the right responses
to the different inquiries contained in the survey.
This as a result improves the legitimacy of the
discoveries.
Discoveries from the trial of speculation uncovered
that underlying change is a positive and critical
indicator of representative work fulfillment in
lodgings in Nigeria. The R-square worth was
portrayed to be 0.591 (59.1%) which suggests that a
59.1% fluctuation change in worker work fulfillment
in inn associations in Nigeria could be made sense of
by a unit change in primary change at a 95%
certainty level. This depicted that supervisors of inn
associations in Nigeria ought to focus more exertion
and assets on affecting positive changes to
hierarchical construction to additional impact
representative work fulfillment as a key execution
boundary in the lodging business (Yang and Campos,
2020). This is couple with the discoveries of [28]
[29] who laid out that adjustments of the lodging
climate, inn offices, and pay separately
fundamentally impact the functional results of inn
association, like consumer loyalty, among different
elements. Also, the ramifications of this outcome was
that fitting execution of hierarchical underlying
changes in the inn association, which especially
channel towards further developing representative
work fulfillment would additionally assist lodging
with staffing to comprehend the expected work
rehearses, approaches, methodology, assets,
regulations, client support, and specialized data
expected to propel their separate association's
seriousness in the unstable neighborliness industry.
This will accordingly work with representatives'
capacity to take care of their responsibilities better;
work with thought age which is vital for building
client trust and upgrades work information towards
further developed assistance productivity; help
representatives on working on decisive reasoning
towards fitness improvement over help conveyance,
and assist the association with offering reliably
fantastic assistance.
5 Conclusion
The compelling and proficient administration of each
and every change is extremely essential for
hierarchical achievement and for improved positive
worker mentality and conduct that convert into
expanded work fulfillment for representatives. The
review laid out the viability of underlying change as
a device for essentially impacting the fulfillment of
workers in the inn business in Nigeria. Hence, proper
execution of underlying change is thus important to
animate great work ways of behaving and drives that
permit the representatives to invest more energy in
their given errands and work cycles of their different
divisions of the inn association. This is clear as the
resultant impact would make the representatives
more dynamic and consequently useful. This means
that successful and proficient execution of primary
changes in lodging association would guarantee that
assets are coordinated towards the exact fulfillment
of administration productivity in the association, by
permitting workers to foster a specific range of
abilities towards accomplishing vocation movement
objectives and consequently fills in as inspiration for
representatives towards gaining new capacities
expected for the accomplishment of the in general
hierarchical objectives.
The goal of worker work fulfillment and its overall
effect on authoritative execution is exceptionally
definitive in the lodging business in Nigeria.
Expanded workers' presentation will improve the
quality and fittingness of administration render to inn
clients in Nigeria. Thusly, the connection between a
few elements of primary change the executives and
representative work fulfillment uncovered that the
viability of any hierarchical change in the inn
business depends significantly on the demeanor of
inn representatives.
References:
[1] Adriana, A.D., Simona-Andreea, A., Andreea,
P., &Ionut, C., (2020). Work flexibility, job
satisfaction, and job performance among
Romanian employees—implications for
sustainable human resource management.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1609
Volume 19, 2022
Sustainability, 12(6086), 1-53.
doi:10.3390/su12156086
[2] Agarwal, R., &Ferratt, T. W. (2001). Crafting
an HR strategy to meet the need for IT
workers. Communications of the ACM,
44(7), 58-64.
[3] Alireza, T., Zahra, S. & Hossein, T. (2013).
How employees’ satisfaction affects quality
and profitability in the service industry. A case
of Malaysian major shopping centers.
Advances in Business-Related Scientific
Research Journal (ABSRJ), 4(1), 13-25
[4] Anuar, B. H. (2011). The relationship between
job satisfaction and job performance among
employees in the Tradewinds group of
companies. A Master's Dissertation was
submitted in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the degree of Master of
Human Resource Management, Centre for
Graduate Studies, Open for Graduate Studies,
Open University, Malaysia.
[5] Ariffin, A. (2013). Generic dimensionality of
hospitality in the hotel industry: A host-guest
relationship perspective. International Journal
of Hospitality Management, 35, 171- 179.
Doi: 10.1016/j.ijhm.2013.06.002
[6] Atteia, M., (2016). Employees’ Satisfaction: Is
it an Antecedent of Customers’ Satisfaction:
An Empirical Study on the Five and Four
Star Hotels in the Kingdom of Bahrain.
Journal of Marketing and Consumer Research,
22, 103-115
[7] Bello, M.B. & Bello, Y.O. (2021). Job
satisfaction and employees' turnover in the
hotel industry: Evidence from Lagos state
Nigeria. Journal of Tourism Theory and
Research, 7(1), 32-43. Doi:
https://doi.org/10.24288/jttr.844747
[8] Civelek, M., Ključnikov, A., Dobrovič, J.,
&Hudáková, M. (2016). A model of
measurement of the quality of business
environment in SME segment. Journal of
international studies, 9(2), 90-102.
[9] Cochran, W. G. (1977). Sampling techniques.
(3rd ed.). New York: John Wiley and Sons.
[10] Dobrovič, J. Gombár, M., Benková, E., &
Edmonds, J. (2016). Managing successful
change. Industrial and Commercial Training,
43(6), 349-353.
[11] Ebongkeng, H. (2018). Organizational change
and performance case study: African
Financial Company SOFINA, S.A,
Cameroon. Thesis of Centria University of
Applied Science Business Management
[12] Fløvik, L., Knardahl, S. & Christensen, J.O.
(2019). The effect of organizational changes on
the psychosocial work environment: changes
in psychological and social working conditions
following organizational changes. Frontier in
Psychology, 10(2845),1-18.
doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02845
[13] Frye, W.D. (2012). An examination of job
satisfaction of hotel front office managers
according to extrinsic, intrinsic, and general
motivational factors. International
Journal of Business and Social Science,
3(18), 40-52.
[14] Aziri, B. (2011). Job satisfaction: a literature
review. Management research and practice,
3(4), 77-86
[15] Gibbons, J. P., Forman, S., Keogh, P., Curtin,
P., Kiely, R., O’Leary, G., & O’Byrne, J.
(2020). Crisis Change Management During
COVID-19 in the Elective Orthopaedic
Hospital: Easing the Trauma Burden of
Acute Hospitals. The Surgeon.
[16] Gibson, J. L., Ivancevich, J. M., Donnelly, J.
H., & Konopaske, R., (2012). Organization-
Behaviors, structure, processes (14th ed.).
New York: McGraw-Hill
[17] Hayes, D.K., &Ninemeier, J.D., (2007). Hotel
operation management Industries. Prentice-
Hall, KS, U.S.A.
[18] Halil, Z., İrfan, K., & Selman, T., (2012). A
casual analysis of employee satisfaction and
performance: A field study in the finance
sector. International Journal of Business and
Management Studies,4(2), 31-42
[19] Ján, D., & Veronika, T. (2017). Examination
of factors affecting the implementation of
organizational changes. Journal of
Competitiveness, 9(4), 5
[20] Jumia Travel (2017). Nigeria Hospitality
Report, 2016. Accessed at
https://travel.jumia.com/engb/ hospitality-
report-Nigeria on 12/12/2017
[21] Jun Hao, M &Yazdanifard, R., (2015). How
Effective Leadership can Facilitate Change in
Organizations through Improvement and
Innovation? Global Journal of Management
and Business Research: A Administration
and Management, 15(9),
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1610
Volume 19, 2022
[22] Kazmi, A., (2002). Business policy and
strategic management (2nd ed.). TATA,
McGraw Hill:
[23] Khalifa, M. &Troung, Q. (2010). The
relationship between employee perceptions of
equity and job satisfaction in the Egyptian
Private Universities. Eurasian journal of
business and economics, 3(5), 135-150
[24] Khosa, Z.M., Rehman, Z.U., Asad, A., Bilal,
M.A., & Hussain, N., (2015). The Impact of
Organizational Change on the Employee’s
Performance in the Banking Sector of
Pakistan. Journal of Business and
Management,17(3), 54-61
[25] Korauš, A., Dobrovič, J., Rajnoha, R.,
&Brezina, I. (2017). The safety risks related to
bank cards and cyber attacks. Journal of
Security and Sustainability Issues, 6(4), 563-
574.
[26] Kwizera, M., Olutayo, K. O., Irau, F.,
Wandiba, A., Patricia, A., &Bayo, I. (2019).
Effect of Organizational Change on Employee
Performance among selected Commercial
Banks in Bujumbura, Burundi. East African
Scholars Journal of Economics, Business,
and Management, 2(4)
[27] Lin, W. T., & Liu, Y. (2012). Successor
Characteristics, Organisational Slack, and
Change in the Degree of Firm
Internationalisation. International Business
Review, 21(1), 89-101.
[28] Lozano, R., Nummert, B., &Ceulemans, K.
(2016). Elucidating the Relationship between
Sustainability Reporting and Organisational
Change Management for Sustainability.
Journal of Cleaner Production,125, 168-188.
[29] Ju-Chun, C. (2015). The impact of change
management on employee satisfaction and
engagement. International Journal of Social,
Behavioral, Educational, Economic, Business
and Industrial Engineering, 9(5), 1680–1685
[30] Muhammad, S., Mushtaq, A., Muhammad, Q.,
Momal, M., Amber, F., &Hummayoun, N.
(2013). Impact of employee’s job
satisfaction on organizational performance.
European Journal of Business and
Management, 5(5), 166-171.
[31] Muguongo, M., Muguna, A. T. &Muriithi, D.
K. (2015). Effects of compensation on job
satisfaction among secondary school teachers
in Maara Sub-County of Tharaka- Nithi
County, Kenya. Journal of Human Resource
Management, 3(6), 47-59.
[32] Namrita, K. & Bhawana, B., (2019).
Contextual and Task Performance: Do
Demographic and Organizational variables
matter? Rajagiri Management Journal, 13(2),
30-42
[33] Narkhede, P. (2014). Employee turnover in
hospitality industries: A study of service staff.
Journal of International Management
Science, 4-8. DOI: 10.5958/0973-
9343.2014.01230.7.
[34] Oki, E. O. (2014). The Impact of Employee
Retention on Customer Satisfaction in the
Nigerian Service Organizations (A Study of
Some Selected Hotels in JOS, Plateau
State). International Journal of Managerial
Studies and Research (IJMSR),2(9), 140- 154
[35] Oladele, O. P., Yakibi, A. A., Akinruwa, T. E.
& Ajayi, O. M. (2019). Influence of
Facilities on Customer Patronage among
Selected Hotels in Southwest, Nigeria.
Academy of Strategic Management Journal,
18(1)
[36] Olajide, O. T., (2014). Change Management
and its Effects on Organizational Performance
of Nigerian Telecoms Industries: Empirical
Insight from Airtel Nigeria. International
Journal of Humanities Social Sciences and
Education (IJHSSE), 1(11), 170-179
[37] Onyebu, C.M., &Omotayo, O. A. (2017).
Employee job satisfaction and organizational
performance insight from selected hotels in
Lagos Nigeria. Arabian Journal of
Business and Management Review (Kuwait
Chapter), 6(10), 48-60. DOI:
10.12816/0039071
[38] Pepe, M. (2010). The impact of extrinsic
motivational dissatisfiers on employee level of
job satisfaction and commitment resulting in
the intent to turnover. Journal of Business &
Economics Research, 8(9), 99-107.
[39] PwC (2017). Hotels outlook: 2017-2021 (7th
ed.). South Africa: PwC
[40] Rajiv, R. T. & Shalini, S., (2018). From
resistance to readiness: the role of mediating
variables. Journal of Organizational Change
Management, 31(1), 230-247. DOI
10.1108/JOCM-06-2017-0237
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1611
Volume 19, 2022
[41] Ramayah, T. &Nasurdin, A. M. (2006).
Integrating importance into the relationship
between job satisfaction and commitment: A
conceptual model. The ICFAI. Journal of
organizational behavior, 5(2), 20-27
[42] Revés, P. (2011). Evolução e perspectivas das
necessidades de formaçãoturística e
hoteleirana região do Alentejo. Tese de
Mestradonãopublicada, Universidade Lusófona
de Humanidades e Tecnologias, Lisboa.
[43] Robbins, S. P., (2001). Organizational
behaviors (9th Edn.). Pearson Education, India
[44] Sledge, S., Miles, A., &Coppage, S. (2008).
What role does culture play? A look at
motivation and job satisfaction among hotel
workers in Brazil. International Journal of
Human Resource Management, 19; 1667-1682.
Doi: 10.1080/09585190802295157.
[45] Romanescu, M.L. (2016). Change
management and its effects on organization.
Annals of the Constantin Brâncuşi” University
of Târgu Jiu, Economy Series, Issue 5/2016
[46] Rouf, A.M. & Riyaz, A.R. (2016). Impact of
employee job satisfaction on organizational
performance: An empirical study. International
Journal of Scientific Research, 5(6), 549-
551.
[47] Satpathy, I., Mishra. S., & Mohapatra, M.
(2014). Employee job satisfaction: a review of
the literature. International Journal of
Multidisciplinary Research in Social &
Management Science, 2(4), 71-74.
[48] Simatwa, E. M. W. (2011). Job satisfaction and
dissatisfaction among teachers in Kenya.
Kenya Journal of Education Planning
Economics and Management, 3(3), 114- 123.
[49] Thiagaraj, D. & Thangaswamy, A. (2017). The
theoretical concept of job satisfaction-a study.
International Journal of Research-
Granthaalayah, 5(6), 464-470.
https://doi.org/10.29121/granthaalayah.v5.i6.
2017.2057.
[50] Vemeulen, F., Puranam, P., & Gulati, R.
(2012). Change for Change’s Sake. Harvard
Business Review, 88(6), 71-76.
[51] Wanza, L., &Nkuraru, J. K., (2016). Influence
of Change Management on Employee
Performance: A Case of University of
Eldoret, Kenya. International Journal of
Business and Social Science, 7(4), 190-199
[52] Yalçiner, S. (2021). Employees’ Perception on
Change Management in Educational
Institutions. Revista Argentina de
ClínicaPsicológica, 30(2), 95-102. DOI:
10.24205/03276716.2020.4009
[53] Kamugisha, S., (2013). The Effects of Change
Management in an Organization: A Case Study
of National University of Rwanda (NUR).
Wyno Journal of Management & Business
Studies,1(1), 1-18.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.144
Roberts Precious, Umar Abbas Ibrahim,
Faiza Maitala, Cross Ogohi Daniel
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1612
Volume 19, 2022
