Regulation of the Digital Economy in Modern Conditions of
Competitiveness
KAMRAN ABDULLAYEV, MAHIR ABBASZADE, AYGUN ALİYEVA,
KONUL İBRAHIMOVA
Azerbaijan National Academy of Sciences, Baku,
AZERBAIJAN
Abstract: - The article is devoted to the main directions of regulation of the digital economy in the Republic of
Azerbaijan. In recent years, growth rates in the field of digital economy have been observed in all countries of
the world. Analysis shows that in international rating reports the Republic of Azerbaijan has been annually
increasing its economic position in terms of economic development indicators. All these processes are
positively influenced by factors such as the implementation of an effective economic policy in the country, the
development of a modern digital economy, and the stimulation of attracting foreign investment.
The development of the digital economy in globalizing world is considered one of the main priorities of
developed countries. However, as in other regional countries, there are certain problems in the development of
the digital economy, the introduction of ICT in all economic spheres, and the export of modern digital
technologies in the Republic of Azerbaijan.That is why it is important to regulate the digital economy in
Azerbaijan, taking into account international experience. The continuous reforms carried out in the Azerbaijan
on the basis of international experience in the field of digital economy are considered effective. The level of
development of the sphere of digitalization in the Republic of Azerbaijan, the output of products (services) in
the ICT sector and the volume of investments in fixed assets is not high compared to previous years. That is
why Azerbaijan's position in international reports on the digital economy is lower than of other countries in the
region.
The article analyzed the measures taken in the field of digital economy in the Republic of Azerbaijan, as
well as the existing problems in this area. The analysis shows that economic measures towards the development
of the digital economy should be continued.
Key-words: transport, economy, digital, investment, competition, information, sustainable development
Received: September 25, 2021. Revised: June 2, 2022. Accepted: June 21, 2022. Published: July 25, 2022.
1 Introduction
The process of digitization of the national economy
in the modern globalizing world is a new direction.
The process of preparing statistical reports,
determining international rating indicators in this
area has not yet been fully formed. These processes
create difficulties for conducting a wide range of
research in the field of digital economy [1]. The
development of digital technologies around the
world is one of the most pressing issues. So, in more
developed countries, the 4th industrial revolution is
underway. The industrial revolution includes the
process of automation, robotization, use of artificial
intelligence, the introduction of modern digital
technologies in economic sectors [2]. The modern
process of digitization is associated with the
development of technological infrastructure. This
also leads to the introduction and rapid development
of scientific innovations in economic fields. In
recent years, developed countries have been
implementing new measures in the direction of
digitalization. Nowadays, the use of digital
technologies is being discussed more. Especially
the digitalization of economic spheres and the
formation of a digital economy are the main prioity
[3].
In the conditions of modern globalization, the
process of digitization between the countries of the
world has a different level of development. All
countries of the world are collectively divided into
several groups according to the level of digitization .
Leaders in the field of digitalization are countries
such as South Korea, Denmark, Great Britain,
Switzerland and China [4]. The group of major
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.115
Kamran Abdullayev, Mahir Abbaszade,
Aygun Ali
yeva, Konul I
brahimova
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1289
Volume 19, 2022
developing countries in the field of digitization
includes Germany, the USA, Japan, India, and etc
[14]. For example, in the Republic of Azerbaijan,
which is considered one of the post-soviet countries,
serious measures are also being taken towards the
development of the digital economy (Skare,2021.
The Republic of Azerbaijan already faces such tasks
as achieving new goals in the development of the
digital economy. Thus, the digitalization of the
national economy, the formation of the digital
economy are among the main priorities for the
introduction of modern innovations in this area. The
Republic of Azerbaijan, located in the South
Caucasus, has all the opportunities for digitalization
of the national economy and sustainable
development of the digital economy. The Republic
of Azerbaijan has a favorable geographical location,
natural resources, as well as dynamically growing
human resources. In the latest World Bank report
“Doing Business 2019”, the Republic of Azerbaijan
entered the top ten most successful countries in
Europe and Central Asia. In all countries of the
world, the Republic of Azerbaijan was ranked 25th
among 190 countries by rating. Azerbaijan
Republic occupies a leading position in international
rankings is the successful continuation of the broad
reforms carried out in the country in the economic
and social spheres [12].
2 Literature Review
In modern economic conditions, both the
digitization of the national economy and the
development of the digital economy are impossible
without stable and safe branches of technological
infrastructure. At the same time, the creation of
digital products and services is impossible without
modern digital technologies [15]. The availability of
modern technological infrastructure is the basis of
the digitization process and the digital economy. In
recent years, the Internet of Things (IoT), 5G,
robotics, cybersecurity, and artificial intelligence
applications all over the world also require the
development of infrastructure. Providing internet
services in accordance with international standards
is impossible without constantly developing areas of
technological infrastructure [5]. The development of
communication services around the world is
expanding. In recent years, the number of users of
both mobile and broadband internet has been
growing in developing countries. In developed
countries, mobile operators annually make large
amounts of investments in technological
infrastructure [6].
For example, the British consulting company
"Analysis Mason", specializing in
telecommunications, media and technology, present
information that in 2014-2020 mobile operators
around the world will spend 300 billion US dollars
on the development of internet infrastructure [7].
According to the report of the International
Association of Mobile Operators GSMA - "The
Mobile Economy 2019", from 2018 to 2025, the
level of the Internet of Things (IoT) worldwide will
grow by 25 billion. This means that the number of
devices connected to the internet is growing all over
the world. During 2018-2025, the income of the
world's population from the internet will increase 4
times and amount to 1.1 trillion US dollars. In
addition, the development of digital and
technological infrastructure will lead to an increase
in the number of mobile internet users worldwide
(Samimi,2015). The prepared report shows that the
number of mobile internet users in 2018 amounted
to 3.6 billion. In 2025 this figure will be increseing
to 5 billion.
The improvement of international communication
services in the modern globalizing world leads to
the fact that internet services are in increasing
demand in the world every year. It is necessary to
improve the existing technological base, the
formation of a new technological infrastructure [8].
The Republic of Azerbaijan, which has been
dynamically developing in recent years among the
post-soviet countries, is also constantly
implementing economic and technical measures to
turn into a regional digital center. In the Republic of
Azerbaijan Digital Hub program is being
successfully implemented. The main Internet
provider of the Republic of Azerbaijan is
AzerTelecom. The main goals of AzerTelecom is to
create a technological infrastructure in accordance
with international standards. AzerTelecom is
creating a modern technological infrastructure both
within the country and abroad. For example, in
recent years, joint economic projects in this
direction have been implemented with the
Azerbaijan Railways Company. For this purpose,
main fiber-optic cable lines have been laid along the
protective strip of railway lines within the Republic
of Azerbaijan. As a result, in the direction of
North-South " established a network connection
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.115
Kamran Abdullayev, Mahir Abbaszade,
Aygun Ali
yeva, Konul I
brahimova
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1290
Volume 19, 2022
with the telecom operators of neighboring countries.
As part of the Digital Hub program, it is planned to
form a new digital historical Silk Road between
Europe and Asia. In the near future, it is planned to
lay a "Trans-Caspian highway" between Azerbaijan
and the Central Asian states along the bottom of the
Caspian Sea and the formation of an international
highway infrastructure. All this will make it possible
to create a regional data center in the Republic of
Azerbaijan in the near future and turn the country
into a center for international internet exchange.
“Azerbaijan Digital Hub“ program is a convenient
platform for the development of the digital
economy. This program will create new
opportunities for the development of technological
infrastructure in the Republic of Azerbaijan in the
near future [12]. These processes will allow in the
near future to increase the number of entrepreneurs
working in the field of digital business in the
Republic of Azerbaijan and export digital services
to neighboring regional states. All this will
eventually lead to the promotion of the Republic of
Azerbaijan in international rankings and an increase
in GDP several times. According to the latest
reports of the WEF, the development of the digital
economy has a huge impact on the country's GDP
growth. For example, the share of South Korea's
digital sector in GDP is 12%, the UK-7.1%, the
USA-7.4%, Finland-8.3%, Sweden-8.6% [9].
According to the latest data from the World
Economic Forum, in the next ten years, digital
platforms will account for up to 80% of the new
value that is formed in the national economy of
developed countries [15].
3 Methodology
The method of studying the statistical relationship
between one or several quantitative variables of a
dependent quantitative variable is called regression
analysis. The dependent variable in regression
analysis is called the resultant, and variable factors
are called predictors or explanatory variables. The
analysis shows that the linear regression model is
more widely used in the field of digital economy
development. The regression model can also be
used to analyze the impact of the digital economy
on other economic spheres. The predicted
correlation between 2 or more variables X and one
variable y is more often called linear regression.
The multilinear regression model in the field of
digital economy can be noted as follows (1):
Y= α 0 + α 1 *x1 + α 2 *x2 +...+ α k *x k +ε (1)
Here the variable y depends on the number of
variables X. ε is considered a random error.
The description of the dependence of Y on a linear
model with 2 variables is defined as follows (2):
Y = α 0 + α 1* x1 + α 2 * x2 + ε (2)
Regression analysis is very closely related to
correlation analysis. Correlation analysis determines
the direction and density of interaction between
quantitative variables.
In regression analysis, the form of dependence
between quantitative variables is determined. In
fact, both methods study the same connection. In
practice, correlation analysis precedes regression
analysis. Having proved the existence of the
relationship by the method of correlation analysis,
the form of this interaction can be expressed using
regression analysis.
4 Result and Analysis
The recent economic reforms and important
programs implemented by the public and private
sectors. The “Strategic Roadmap" adopted in the
Republic of Azerbaijan, state programs for the
development of ICT are among the main activities
carried out in this direction. The Republic of
Azerbaijan, which has the status of the main energy
and transport center of the region, will be able to
develop its economy and become the digital center
of the region among the post-soviet countries in the
near future, using the available economic resources.
Developing countries are also constantly
developing and implementing new economic
programs, strategies, strategic roadmaps for the
implementation of the digitalization process. In
addition, citizens of developing countries are
increasingly using digital technologies.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.115
Kamran Abdullayev, Mahir Abbaszade,
Aygun Ali
yeva, Konul I
brahimova
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1291
Volume 19, 2022
Fig. 1: The position of the Republic of Azerbaijan
among the countries of the world on the e-
Government Development Index and e-participation
index in recent years
Source: http://ec.europa.eu
The analysis shows that in recent years,
Azerbaijan's position among 193 countries on the e-
Government Development Index and e-Participation
Index has changed. In 2020, the Azerbaijan ranked
73rd in the Electronic Participation Index.
According to the E-Government Development
Index, in 2020 Azerbaijan was in 70th place.
(Figure 1). The analysis shows that in 2020,
compared to 2012, there was a decrease in both
indicators.
Fig. 2: Global Digital Competitiveness Ranking by
Selected Countries (2021)
Source : https://www.imd.org/
In the world ranking of digital competitiveness,
the United States was ranked 1st, Sweden - 3rd,
Singapore - 5th, Turkey - 48th. Other post-soviet
countries such as Estonia was on the 25th place,
Kazakhstan - on the 37th, Russia - on the 42nd,
Turkey -on the 48th, Ukraine - on the 54th. It should
be noted that serious progress has been made in
these countries in implementing sustainable
measures for the development of the digital
economy (Figure 2).
Table 1. Production in ICT sector of Azerbaijan
(mln. manats (AZN)) and investments by İCT
entreprises (mln. manats, 1 USD=1.70 AZN)
Source: www.stat.gov.az
Azerbaijan Republic has undergone serious
changes in indicators for the production of products
(services). İn comparison with 2017-2019, in 2020,
the volume of output of products (services) in the
field of ICT increased to 2315.2 mln. manats. In
2020, investments in the ICT enterprices decreased
compared to previous years (2019) achived to
177.2 million manats (AZN) (Table 1) . Analysis of
statistical data shows that the production of ICT
products increased in the Republic of Azerbaijan in
2017-2020. At the same time, in 2017-2019, the
volume of investments in enterprises operating in
the field of ICT increased. Only in 2020 this
indicator decreased. The main reason for this is the
negative impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the
national economy of Azerbaijan
70 70
56
68
96
83
73 79
47
77
89
68
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2020 2018 2016 2014 2012 2010
E-government development index
E-participation index
12345
25 32 37 42 48 54
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.115
Kamran Abdullayev, Mahir Abbaszade,
Aygun Ali
yeva, Konul I
brahimova
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1292
Volume 19, 2022
Fig. 3: Correlation between production in ICT
sector and investments by ICT entreprises
In recent years, we can determine the trend line and
correlation between the production of ICT
enterprises in the Republic of Azerbaijan and
investment in ICT enterprises in recent years
(Figure 3). Graphically, this interaction is a
regression model expressed by the equation
Y=130,64 ln(x)+11,373. Coefficient of
determination R2= 0.7658. This indicates a close
regression relationship between the two indicators.
Correlation coefficient R = 0.87. This indicates a
high correlation between the two measures.
5 Disscusion
The increase in the number of mobile devices of
citizens in all countries of the world, the global
expansion of social networks, the storage of all data
in cloud technologies, the increase in the number of
regional data centers once again confirm the
accelerating processes of digitization [9].
According to the annual final reports compiled
by the European Union, the volume of the European
digital transformation market in 2018 reached 256
billion USA Dollars. In the next 10 years, this
indicator is projected to increase by 2 times. The
countries of the European Union occupy the third
place worldwide in the procurement of
transformational technologies. The first places
among all countries in the world in this area are
occupied by the United States and the Chinese state
[15].
According to the reports of the world famous
companies IDC (International Data Corporation)
and Citrix, which are considered the world's
leading companies are constantly developing cloud
technologies, quickly switching to innovative digital
technologies [16]. At the same time, they are
completely updating their network infrastructure. It
should be noted that Citrix specializes in creating
innovative computer networks, developing new
technological programs around the world [10]. The
annual reports of IDC and Seagate, which are
considered the largest technology companies in the
world, note that as a result of digitalization and the
creation of digital content in today's globalizing
world, the volume of data collected on basic,
peripheral and end-user devices is growing rapidly.
In 2018 the volume of the global data sphere
amounted to 33 zettabytes. In addition, it is
predicted that by 2025 the volume of the global data
sphere will increase 5 times and amount to 175
zettabytes. Among all countries of the world, China
is considered one of the fastest growing countries in
the implementation of cloud solutions. China
accounts for the fastest growth in the global
information sphere in recent years [17].The
development of the digital economy in a globalizing
world creates favorable opportunities for consumers,
states and modern societies. Different countries are
implementing important measures to create a digital
economy, expand digitization, and introduce high
technologies [18]. For example, the state of
Singapore adopted its "Smart Nation" concept in
2014. Local business structures and experts took
part in the implementation of this concept.
The concept of "Smart Nation", implemented by
the government of Singapore, provides for the use
of digital technologies in the daily lives of all
citizens of the country. It also contributes to
improving the quality of life of the country's
citizens. Small, medium and large companies are
also actively involved in the implementation of the
Smart Nation concept in Singapore [11]. As for the
global development of digital technologies, China
has made great strides in this area. For example, in
recent years, China has achieved the integration of
traditional industries with digital industry in its
Internet Plus program for the development of the
digital economy [13].
For developed and developing countries around
the world, the formation of a digital economy is one
of the main priorities. The digitalization processes
0
170,2
183,7
294,7
177,2
y = 130,64ln(x) + 11,373
R² = 0,7658
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
0 2 4 6 8
Production in ICT sector, mln. manats
(AZN)
Investments directed to fixed capital
by ICT entreprises, mln.manats (AZN)
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.115
Kamran Abdullayev, Mahir Abbaszade,
Aygun Ali
yeva, Konul I
brahimova
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1293
Volume 19, 2022
already underway in most states and create
favorable opportunities for the Republic of
Azerbaijan. Thus, in the conditions of the 4th
Industrial Revolution (Industry 4.0), the Republic of
Azerbaijan correctly uses its geographical location,
rich natural resources and human resources. To this
end, the latest innovative trends in the field of ICT
are being introduced in the country. The
development of the digital economy in the Republic
of Azerbaijan and the use of modern digital
technologies ensure sustainable economic
development.
6 Conclusions
In recent years, the Republic of Azerbaijan has
been implementing important economic and
political measures aimed at the formation of the
digital market infrastructure and the sustainable
development of the ICT sector. The main goal here
is to ensure the transformation of the Republic of
Azerbaijan into a regional digital center. The
Digital Hub program of the Republic of
Azerbaijan will ensure digitalization and
development of the digital economy in the country.
İn the coming years, it is planned to lay a 300-400
km long fiber-optic cable trunk line along the
bottom of the Caspian Sea between the Republic of
Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan, the development of the
Digital Silk Road corridor between Europe and
Asia. In addition, the coordination of networks of
regional states on the territory of the Republic of
Azerbaijan will be carried out [12]. The
implementation of the “Digital Hub” program will
expand digital ties between Azerbaijan and the
countries of Central Asia. As a result, Russia's
economic influence on these countries in the digital
sphere will be completely eliminated.
The implementation of the new Digital Hub
program in the Republic of Azerbaijan will
enhance its role in the One Belt, One Road
initiative project, which is considered an
international program of China. Republic of
Azerbaijan will have a great influence on the
transformation of this project into the main
telecommunications corridor between the countries
of Europe and Asia.
The expansion of the digitalization process in
the Republic of Azerbaijan includes the creation of
a new technological infrastructure in the field of
ICT, the renewal of the existing technological
infrastructure and the introduction of new
innovative technologies. The main basis for the
creation of a digital economy in the country is the
expansion of the scope of information and
communication technologies. It should be noted
that the basis of the ICT infrastructure is broadband
access to the international Internet. Broadband
access requires the organization of a 4-5G mobile
network across the country using a full fiber optic
cable and satellite communications.
In general, based on the analysis conducted, we
considers to implement the following measures to
ensure the development of the digital economy in
the Republic of Azerbaijan :
- continuous implementation of economic measures
towards the development of the digital economy in
the country;
- expansion of opportunities for the use of modern
digital technologies in all spheres of the national
economy;
- at the state level, state support for modern ICT
smart innovative projects for the development of
the digital economy should be continued;
- the state should stimulate the attraction of
domestic and foreign investments in the activities
of companies that produce and export innovative
ICT products to all sectors of the national
economy;
- continuation of joint cooperation with developed
countries (USA, South Korea, Japan, etc.) in the
direction development of the digital economy;
- Azerbaijan Republic should adopt new state
programs for the development of the digital
economy;
- stimulating the attraction of local and foreign
investment flows to increase the volume of
production of products and services in the field of
modern ICT and etc.
References:
[1] Bukht R., Conceptualizing and Measuring the
Digital Economy. International Organizations
Research Journal, 2018, volume 13(2): pp.143
172.
[2] Kim, B., Virtual Field Experiments for a digital
economy: A new research methodology for
exploring an information economy, Decision
Support System, volume 32(1), 2002, pp. 215
231.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.115
Kamran Abdullayev, Mahir Abbaszade,
Aygun Ali
yeva, Konul I
brahimova
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1294
Volume 19, 2022
[3] Zhang P., The essence of digital economy and
its development logic. Economist, volume 35,
2019, pp.2533.
[4] Qian L., Research on the Cooperation of Green
economy and Digital economy in stimulus
Policy . Southwest Finance, volume 12, (2020),
pp. 313.
[5] Kristoffersen, E., The smart circular economy:
A digital-enabled circular strategies framework
for manufacturing companies. Journal of
Business Research, volume 25, 2020, pp. 241
261.
[6] Skare M., (2021) A dynamic panel study on
digitalization and firm’s agility: What drives
agility in advanced economies 20092018,
Technological Forecasting and Social Change,
volume 163, pp.255-265
[7] Wang, G.M., Human Capital difference and
income inequality in the era of Digital
economybased on PIAAC Micro data . Social
Science Research, 2020, pp. 97107.
[8] Kim J. Infrastructure of the digital economy:
Some empirical findings with the case of Korea
. Technological Forecasting and Social Change,
volume 73(4), 2004, pp. 377389.
[9] Ying, W. Digitalization and decentralization
driving transactive energy Internet: Key
technologies and infrastructures. International
Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems,
volume 126, 2021, pp.106.
[10] Jiao Y., Digital economy empowers the
transformation of manufacturing industry: from
value reshaping to value creation . Economist,
volume (06), 2020, pp. 8794.
[11] Ghosh A., How does banking sector
globalization affect economic growth?.
International Review of Economics & Finance,
volume 48, 2017, pp.8397.
[12] “Digital Silk Way” project presented at
international conference “Turkmentel 2021”
AzerTelecom News [Electronic resource //
https://www.azertelecom.az/en/]
[13] Curran, D., Risk, innovation, and democracy
in the digital economy. European Journal of
Sociology Theory, 21(2) 2018, pp.207-226.
[14] Dewan, S., Information technology and
productivity: Evidence from country-level data.
Management Science, 46, 2000, pp.548562.
[15] Fernández, P. A., Is sustainable economic
development possible thanks to the deployment
of ICT? Sustainability, 11(22), 2019, pp.63.
[16] Habibi, F. Digitalization, education and
economic growth: A comparative analysis of
Middle East and OECD countries, Technology
in Society, 63, 2020, pp.1-9.
[17] Hofman, A. Information and communication
technologies and their impact in the
economic growth of Latin America, 19902013.
Telecommunications Policy, 40(5),2016,
pp.485501.
[18] Manyika, J., The great Transformer:
The impact of internet on Economic growth and
Prosperity. Mckisey Global institute, 2011,
pp.255.
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
-Kamran Abdullayev: Data curation and resources,
formal analysis,
- Mahir Abbaszade: investigation,
- Aygun Aliyeva: methodology,
- Konul Ibrahimova: discussion, conclusion,
literature review
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
Paid for only by the authors.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.115
Kamran Abdullayev, Mahir Abbaszade,
Aygun Ali
yeva, Konul I
brahimova
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
1295
Volume 19, 2022