The Impact of the Emerging Coronavirus (COVID-19) on E-Commerce in
the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
MEHDI ABID1, HOUCINE BENLARIA2, ZOUHEYR GHERAIA2
1Department of Finance and Investment, College of Business, Jouf University, Skaka,
SAUDI ARABIA
2Department of Business Management, College of Business, Jouf University, Skaka,
SAUDI ARABIA
Key-Words: - COVID-19, e-commerce, home quarantine, movement restriction, psychological anxiety, Saudi
Arabia
Received: July 4, 2021. Revised: February 15, 2022. Accepted: March 2, 2022. Published: March 17, 2022.
1 Introduction
Several challenges can be encountered when setting
up and implementing an e-commerce platform. When
setting up e-commerce portals, one of the main
difficulties encountered lies in the process of creating
a secure online payment platform. These challenges
are often technological "use of advanced encrypted
technologies", social "consumer education in the use
of online transaction sites" and related to payment
"limited number of online credit card users". In
addition, the United Nations Conference on Trade
and Development "UNCTAD" informs us about all
the factors that hinder the development of e-
commerce, which are in the form of economic, socio-
political and cognitive barriers. For UNCTAD, the
spread of the coronavirus is certainly above all a
public health emergency, but also a significant
economic threat.
The Chinese government soon announced the first
case of Coronavirus, this epidemic swept the world in
a short period not exceeding days, and it soon turned
into a pandemic. Most of the countries in the world
have successively announced the discovery of cases
among their citizens, which led most of the countries
of the world to take precautionary measures at
international airports for those coming from China at
the beginning. However, after a while, the
precautionary measures at these airports became
applicable to all air and sea travelers to and from any
country around the world by following the mandatory
thermal detection procedures for travelers.
Consequently, there was a kind of reservation
between the countries of the world that led to the
closing of the geographical borders between them.
After the pandemic has spread sweeping across the
world, in addition to its health effects, it has had an
economic impact on growth, as expectations indicate
that growth in the Middle East and Central Asia
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
825
Volume 19, 2022
Abstract: Despite the efforts of some governments to encourage online commerce during the pandemic, they have
encountered some obstacles when selling. Additionally, regulations that are not suitable for e-commerce can create
barriers for businesses. Although many of these challenges predate the outbreak of the virus, the current crisis and
the new role of e-commerce for consumers and businesses heightens the need for public action. This research aimed
to study the effects of the coronavirus pandemic on customer orientation in electronic commerce by understanding
the influence of precautionary measures (home quarantine, travel limits, anxiety, and psychological anxiety) on
electronic commerce (e-commerce). For this purpose, a questionnaire was distributed to a sample size of 492
individuals in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Further, to analyze the study data, the SEM structural equations method
was used via the Smart PLS. After analyzing and testing the hypotheses of the study, it was found that there is a
direct positive impact of the emerging coronavirus (COVID-19) on customer behavior toward e-commerce in Saudi
Arabia. There is a positive, direct effect of home quarantine on the orientation of individuals toward e-commerce.
Moreover, there is a positive, direct impact of movement restriction on the orientation of individuals toward e-
commerce. Finally, there is a positive, direct effect of psychological anxiety on the attitude of individuals toward e-
commerce.
region will decline from 1.2% in 2019 to 2.8% in
2020 [1]. The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia was also
affected by the Covid 19 pandemic, at the beginning
of March, attendance at workplaces in all ministries,
government and private institutions and institutions
was suspended, except in limited numbers and for
absolute necessity. All educational and training
institutions, including schools, universities, stadiums,
and sports centers, in addition to shops and
commercial centers, have been closed, with the
exception of health institutions, pharmacies and
supermarkets. This is part of the Saudi government's
efforts to control the spread of the infectious virus,
including stopping the export of all medical and
laboratory products, supplies, and equipment used to
detect or prevent the virus (Covid 19). In addition,
state revenues have been severely affected due to the
most affected energy sector, as oil prices have fallen
to levels not seen in more than 20 years by about
50%, which is considered one of the main sources of
fiscal revenues in the state. The financial sector was
also affected, as stock markets decreased by 20% to
30%, and expectations indicate the possibility of a
contraction in the real GDP in the oil-exporting
countries in North Africa, the Middle East and
Afghanistan by 4.2% for the year 2020. Also,
expectations indicate a 2.7% contraction in growth in
the GCC countries for the same year [1].
In light of this current situation, information and
communication technology plays the largest role in
the modern production process, and with the
multiplication of human knowledge, the global
economy has turned into a knowledge-based
economy [2]. Where the key to this knowledge was
the development of technology, which in turn led to
the emergence of other methods of trade that differ
from traditional trade. E-commerce emerged that was
characterized by saving time and effort and easy
access to local and foreign markets, and also helped
economic growth and improve exports and
production.
E-commerce has become among the fastest growing
sectors in the global economy, and its role has
emerged in recent years [3]. In light of the Corona
pandemic, this role has emerged clearly. E-commerce
has become an aid to the business sector to mitigate
the effects of this pandemic. The restrictions imposed
in light of this pandemic have also affected consumer
buying behavior, as many consumers have directed to
use different e-commerce channels to meet their
multiple needs, and it should be noted that
government decisions to combat the Corona
pandemic have contributed significantly to this trend
[4].
The importance of the study stems from the
importance of the topic being researched, as this
study deals with the impact of the (Covid-19)
pandemic on the growth of e-commerce in the
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and its contribution to
reducing infection from (Covid-19) by reducing the
cases of mixing, which were among the most
prominent preventive means to limit the spread of
infection among the public. In addition to that, the
main role that electronic commerce plays in general
in economic growth and limiting the effects of the
pandemic through its advantages and its close
relationship with the digital economy, which is one
of the pillars of the Kingdom's 2030 vision. So the
current study seeks to shed light on the extent of the
impact of the pandemic (Covid-19) on the growth of
e-commerce in the Kingdom, and the role it plays in
contributing to mitigating the health and economic
effects of the (Covid-19) pandemic. In light of this,
the study problem was identified in the following
main question.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section
1 provides the literature review. Section 2 presents
an overview of the impact of the Corona pandemic
on consumer behavior and e-commerce. Section 3
discusses the main models and econometric
methodology. Section 4 discusses the empirical
results of the estimations. Section 5 concludes with a
summary of the findings and policy implications.
2 Problem Formulation
The purpose of this study was to answer the
following question: What is the impact of the
COVID-19 pandemic on electronic commerce (e-
commerce) in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia?
3 Literature review and Hypothesis
Development
In this section, we try to present some previous
literature for this research. The impacts of the
emerging corona virus (Covid-19) on e-commerce
have constituted an important subject for researchers.
[5] determined the e-commerce trends in coronavirus
predicament as well as how imminent progress in e-
commerce that might affect consumer behavior in
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
826
Volume 19, 2022
future. They examined that e-commerce grew due to
coronavirus. E-commerce is become a substitute
source and considered top in this condition, and e-
retailers provide goods that usually consumers
bought in superstore traditionally. [6] study the effect
of the coronavirus on e-commerce. Most of the kits
are made in China and hence the reliability is
remarkable. With the effect of the coronavirus, all
shipping processes are increased, which has
increased the e-commerce growth of the country and
the state. The research paper here describes the
impact of the corona virus on India's online
commerce. On the analysis, they found that online
businesses are increased due to this pandemic
disease. [7] indicates that as quarantining
considerably restricts recreational opportunities, the
importance of hedonic motives for remaining
activities, such as online shopping, increases. This
appears to reflect changes in the behavior of
consumers moving from offline to online shopping.
They also show that as people spend more time at
home, brands have responded by switching from
offline media to online shopping. Thus, we propose
the following hypothesis:
HP1: There is a positive relationship between home
quarantine on customer behavior toward e-
commerce.
[8] investigated the effects of Coronavirus spread on
stock markets. Coronavirus spread has been
measured by cumulative cases, new cases,
cumulative deaths and new deaths. This has been
applied on the worst 6 countries (according to
number of cumulative cases), on daily basis over the
period from March 1, 2020 till April 10, 2020.
Coronavirus spread has been measured by numbers
per million of population, while stock market return
is measured by Δ in stock market index. They results
indicate that stock market return seems to be
sensitive to Coronavirus cases more than deaths, and
to Coronavirus cumulative indicators more than new
ones. Besides, robustness check confirms the
negative effect of Coronavirus spread on stock
market return for China, France, Germany and Spain.
However, these effects haven’t been confirmed for
Italy and United States. [9] studied the impact of the
coronavirus on the online business of Malaysia. On
analyzing it has found that online businesses are
seriously hampered due to this pandemic disease.
The results showed that since the maximum number
of products comes from China and the maximum
industries are closed, which means that there is no
import and export of the product. We therefore posit
the following hypothesis:
HP2: There is a positive relationship between
movement restriction and customer behavior toward
e-commerce.
Consumers are very concerned about the impact of
COVID-19, both on health and the economy. People
react in different ways and have different attitudes,
behaviors and buying habits [10]. All over the world,
people are afraid as they struggle to adjust to a new
normal. Fear rises as people reflect on what this crisis
means for them, but more importantly, what it means
for their family, friends and society in general.
Consumers are responding to the crisis in various
ways. Some people feel anxious and worried, which
encourages compulsive purchases of basic and
hygiene products. At the other extreme, some
consumers remain indifferent to the pandemic and
continue to operate as usual, despite
recommendations from government and healthcare
professionals [11]. Consumer Staples companies will
need to understand the reaction of their own
consumers and develop personalized marketing
strategies accordingly. The days of universal
marketing are over. Consumers fear the economic
impact of COVID-19 more than their health.
Therefore, we hypothesise that:
HP3: There is a positive relationship between
psychological anxiety and customer behavior toward
e-commerce.
[12] investigated the effects of the spread of COVID-
19 on global ecommerce companies, where the five
largest e-commerce companies in the world were
chosen in terms of revenues and market value, and
they were as follows: American Amazon, Chinese
Alibaba, Japanese Rakuten, German Zalando, United
kingdom ASOS, has been measuring the prevalence
of corona virus by "cumulative infections" and
"cumulative deaths" on a daily basis. Besides, it is
measured through the values of both the "new corona
virus cases" and the "new corona virus deaths" daily,
the dependent variable reflects the response of the
global e-commerce market to the impact of the
spread of the corona virus and is measured by the
daily returns of the shares of ecommerce companies
to the global financial markets. This was applied on a
daily basis from 15 March 2020 to 25 May 2020. The
results indicates that the percentage of the effect of
coronavirus spread varied from one company to
another, depending on the country to which it
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
827
Volume 19, 2022
belonged, where the American company Amazon and
the United kingdom company ASOS were the
cumulative cases of infection are the most influential
and this is consistent with that they are the most
affected countries of the coronavirus during the
period of research, and the Chinese company Alibaba
and Rakuten company Japanese “Corona virus cases”
were the most influential in their share price returns,
and the German company Zalando was the most
influential variable “cumulative deaths”.
[13] investigate the factors that affect consumer’s
online shopping behavior. The study results suggest
that consumers’ online shopping behavior is being
affected by several factors like demographic factors,
social factors, consumer online shopping experience,
knowledge of using internet and computer, website
design, social media, situational factors, facilitating
conditions, product characteristics, sales promotional
scheme, payment option, delivery of goods and after
sales services plays an important role in online
shopping. We therefore propose the following
hypothesis:
HP4: There is a positive relationship between
sample's views regarding COVID-19 preventive
measures and demographic variables.
The use of demographics by researchers in the online
shopping literature is common, however, they are
typically constructed as either moderators or control
factors. Little attention has been given to explicitly
modelling the predictive utility of demographics. [14]
studies the impact of nine demographics, six social
connectedness measures and five prior online
experience variables on consumers actual online
purchases. A large and representative data set was
used. The results show that a model on the basis
demographic data alone explains 22.6% of the
variance in the consumers ’overall online shopping
behavior. The model's utility increased to 45.4% once
social connectedness and prior internet experience
were added to the model. Furthermore, analyzing 14
online product categories, we found that the
predictive power of demographic variables is product
specific. Overall, the results strongly support the use
by practitioners of demographics as powerful
predictors for direct targeting of online shoppers.
Prior research examining the effect of gender on
willingness to shop online revealed that men are
more likely to conduct online transactions than
women ([15]; [16]; [17]). There are some studies
where opposing, or mixed, conclusions were
reported; however, these appear to be exceptions to
the general pattern, such as the purchase of clothing
by women ([18]; [19]). Several explanations have
been advanced in the literature for the gender
differences including risk perception a general
attitude towards technology [20] and differences in
role specializations ([21]; [22]). Perhaps, the most
widely investigated reason is that women appear to
be more concerned with risk associated with e-
commerce than their men counterparts ([23]; [24];
[25]). Therefore, we propose the following
hypothesis:
HP5: There is a positive relationship between
sample's views regarding e-commerce and
demographic variables.
4 Methodology
The study sample consists of 492 individuals over the
age of 18 years. The research sample was determined
based on an objective sampling method, which relied
on the testing of individuals who had the information
needed by the researcher. An initial questionnaire
was prepared for use in the collection of data and
information. The questionnaire was submitted to the
arbitrators to test its suitability for all data. It was
modified at the discretion of the arbitrators.
The questionnaire was divided into three parts:
The first section consisted of the personal data of
the sample population and had six items.
The second section dealt with variables that
express COVID-19 and was divided into three axes:
Home quarantine, which consisted of six
items.
Restriction on movement, which consisted of
five items.
Psychological anxiety, which consisted of
four items.
The third section concerned the dependent
variable that expresses e-commerce and
consisted of six items.
A 5-point Likert scale was used in the questionnaire
(5-strongly agree, 4-agree, 3-neutral, 2-disagree, 1-
strongly disagree). There is no missing data because
all of the questions on the Google form were needed.
The A-Priori sample size calculator was used in the
analysis for structural equation modeling (SEM)
(Soper, 2020). The required information includes 0.5
expected effect sizes (Cohen's d), 95% desired
statistical power level, and 0.05 likelihood level. For
all effect sizes, the sample size required is 176, 88,
212, and 106, respectively. The study's sample size of
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
828
Volume 19, 2022
492 met the requirements for adequately representing
the total population.
5 Results
5.1 Assessment of Measurements Model
Convergent Validity
To analyze the study data and test the validity of the
hypotheses, we used one of the most effective
statistical tools: PLS-SEM modeling of structural
equations [26].
The process of checking the quality and conformity
of the measurement model is the first essential step,
as the calculation of the following indicators was
used: Cronbach’s Alpha, composite reliability (CR),
and average variance extracted (AVE).
Table 1. Results of Measurements Model: Convergent Validity
Through Table 1, it is clear that all the outer loadings
recorded good one-dimensional indicators so that
those latent variables became expressed in measured
variables consistent with them. We also note that the
values of the Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient for all the
study variables were greater than 0.6, which is the
minimum requirement. Further, the lowest value for
Cronbach’s Alpha is for the e-commerce variable
(0.829). This indicates the validity and reliability of
the questionnaire.
Furthermore, the CR value for all variables exceeded
0.7, which is the minimum requirement. The lowest
value recorded was for the e-commerce variable
(0.874), while the CR value for the rest of the
variables exceeded 0.9. The AVE values for all study
variables exceeded the required minimum, which is
0.5.
All previous indicators are indicative of the quality
and conformity of the measurement model.
5.2 Discriminant Validity Test
In the first step, the one-dimensional evaluation of
the latent variables was carried out and the measured
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
829
Volume 19, 2022
variables were filtered to measure those variables
well and honestly.
After assessing the validity of the variables of the
measurement model and making the necessary
adjustments, the second step was carried out. This
step assessed the validity of the differentiation of the
path model in which the FornellLarcker criterion
was analyzed, as shown in the following table.
Table 2. Results of Latent Variable Correlations
Constructs
E-commerce
Home
quarantine
Psychological
anxiety
E-commerce
0.732
Home quarantine
0.527
0.796
Movement restriction
0.586
0.739
Psychological anxiety
0.562
0.707
0.863
According to Table 2, the values of the validity of the
differentiation of the study variables indicated their
differentiation from each other and there was no
intersection between them. Each variable represented
itself, meaning that the square root of the AVE for
any latent variable was greater than the value of its
correlation with other latent variables 𝐴𝑉𝐸(𝑋)>
𝐶𝑂𝑉(𝑋, 𝑌).
Therefore, it can be said that the model was more
valid for differentiation than other possible
constructions. Besides, cross-load coefficients were
analyzed with external load factors for each latent
variable, as shown in the following table.
Table 3. Results of Discriminant Validity: Cross Loadings
Items
Constructs
Home
quarantine
Movement
restriction
Psychological
anxiety
E-commerce
H1
Home quarantine
(0.798)
0.531
0.586
0.310
H2
(0.822)
0.540
0.554
0.357
H3
(0.853)
0.602
0.630
0.265
H4
(0.715)
0.577
0.492
0.323
H5
(0.792)
0.616
0.546
0.502
H6
(0.791)
0.629
0.567
0.476
M1
Movement
restriction
0.594
(0.788)
0.526
0.410
M2
0.562
(0.794)
0.547
0.405
M3
0.474
(0.721)
0.492
0.328
M4
0.733
(0.831)
0.668
0.356
M5
0.477
(0.748)
0.551
0.482
P1
Psychologic
al anxiety
0.580
0.620
(0.847)
0.354
P2
0.609
0.610
(0.882)
0.488
P3
0.573
0.622
(0.853)
0.260
P4
0.678
0.634
(0.871)
0.323
E1
E-commerce
0.310
0.410
0.354
(0.736)
E2
0.357
0.405
0.488
(0.704)
E3
0.265
0.328
0.260
(0.675)
E4
0.323
0.356
0.323
(0.727)
E5
0.502
0.482
0.474
(0.747)
E6
0.476
0.533
0.486
(0.799)
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
830
Volume 19, 2022
Table 3 shows that all the items of the study had a
high level of saturation on the underlying variables.
Further, the linkage of the items with the latent
variables exceeded the minimum, which is the value
of 0.7, as some items were excluded due to the low
level of their saturation on the underlying variables.
Fig. 1: Research Framework
It is observed in the figure above that the cross-
loading coefficients for each latent variable with the
same variable were higher than the cross-loading
coefficients for the rest of the other latent variables,
which, in total, exceeded the value of 0.7. This is an
indication of the quality of the structure of the
measurement model.
The measurement evaluation takes into account
composite reliability, average variance derived (AVE
= convergent validity), outer loadings, Cronbach's
alpha, and discriminant validity. The internal quality
reliability value, Cronbach's alpha, and composite
reliability should all be greater than 0.70.
5.3 Assessment of Structural Model
To evaluate the quality of the structural model, we
used the R-Squared measure, which shows the
predictive strength of the model in the study sample
and also explains the interpretation of the external
latent constructs for the amount of variance in the
dependent variable.
[27] suggested that the value of R2 that is above 0.67
is considered high, while values ranging between
0.33 to 0.67 are moderate and those between 0.19 to
0.33 are weak. Furthermore, any R2 values of less
than 0.19 are unacceptable. [28] proposed an R2
value of 0.10 as the minimum acceptable level.
Furthermore, the F-Squared measure was used to
denote the effect of each independent variable on the
dependent variable. According to Cohen (1988), if
the F2 is above 0.35, the size of the effect is
considered to be large.
The Q2 scale, which measures the predictive power
of the study model outside of the research sample,
was also used. According to [29], this value must be
greater than zero. When the model predicts
dependent latent variables outside of the study
sample, it then has sufficient predictive relevance.
[30]. The values of all previous measures are shown
in Table 4.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
831
Volume 19, 2022
Table 4. R-Squared, F-Squared, and Q² of the Endogenous Latent Variables
Constructs
R-Squared
F-Squared
E-commerce
0.388
0.195
/
Home quarantine
0.385
Movement restriction
/
/
0.523
Psychological anxiety
0.461
Note. Source: Prepared by researchers using Smart PLS outputs.
Figure 1 and Table 4 represent that the R2 value for
the estimated equation is 0.388. This means that all
these variables (home quarantine, movement
restriction, and psychological anxiety) were able to
explain more than 38.8% of the variance in e-
commerce.
Further, it was observed that the F-Squared values
of all endogenous latent variables were greater than
35%, which is the minimum. The largest was 52.3%
for the movement restriction variable and the lowest
was 38.5% for the home quarantine variable. This
indicates that the variables in question affect the
dependent variable.
Concerning the values of Q2, values greater than
zero were defined for all endogenous latent
variables, indicating the prediction of dependent
latent variables outside the research sample.
Table 5. Results of Goodness-of-Fit
Saturated Model
Estimated Model
SRMR
0.073
0.168
d_ULS
1.244
6.536
d_G
0.398
0.635
Chi-Square
1127.485
1560.076
NFI
0.817
0.747
According to the goodness-of-fit indicators shown
in Table 5, the proposed model has a high standard.
The goodness-of-fit indicator also recorded a value
of 0.4541, which is greater than 0.36 and is the
minimum [31].
5.4 Testing Study Hypotheses
Hypotheses HP1, HP2, and HP3 were tested using
the SmartPLS program. Hypotheses HP4 and HP5
were tested using the SPSS 23 program, as shown in
the Table 6.
Table 6. Path Coefficient of the Research Hypotheses
Hypotheses
Relationship
Std.Beta
Std. Error
T-Values
P-Values
Decision
HP1
Home quarantine ->
E-commerce
0.527
0.033
15.876
0.000
Supported**
HP2
Movement restriction
-> E-commerce
0.586
0.026
22.057
0.000
Supported**
HP3
Psychological anxiety
-> E-commerce
0.562
0.039
15.221
0.000
Supported**
Note. Significant at P** = < 0.01, p* < 0.05. Source: Prepared by researchers using SmartPLS outputs.
It is evident from Table 6 that the first hypothesis
was confirmed by the following: (influence
coefficient = 0.527, t-values = 15,876, P-values =
0.000). It can, therefore, be said that there was a
positive, direct, statistically significant effect of
home quarantine on the orientation of individuals
toward e-commerce.
The second hypothesis was confirmed by the
following: (influence coefficient = 0.586, T-values =
22.057, P-values = 0.000). It can therefore be said
that there was a positive, direct, statistically
significant impact of movement restriction on the
orientation of individuals toward e-commerce.
The third hypothesis was confirmed by the
following: (influence coefficient = 0.562, T-values =
15.221, P-values = 0.000). From this, it can be said
that there was a positive, direct, statistically
significant effect of psychological anxiety on the
attitude of individuals toward e-commerce.
To confirm the previous results, the results of the
bootstrap shown in the following table can be
indicated.
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
832
Volume 19, 2022
Table 7. Results of Confidence Intervals: Bootstrap
Hypotheses
Relationship
Original Sample (O)
Mean.Boot
2.5%
97.5%
HP1
Home quarantine -> E-
commerce
0.527
0.533
0.473
0.594
HP2
Movement restriction ->
E-commerce
0.586
0.590
0.538
0.637
HP3
Psychological anxiety ->
E-commerce
0.562
0.563
0.479
0.640
Note. Source: Prepared by researchers using SmartPLS outputs.
Table 7 shows that the lower and upper bounds were
positive for the bootstrap value for all three
hypotheses, which did not contain the effect equal to
zero. Therefore, it is confirmed that the research
hypotheses are accepted, indicating that there was a
positive impact of COVID-19 on e-commerce in
Saudi Arabia.
Table 4 represent that the R2 value for the estimated
equation is 0.388. This means that all these variables
(home quarantine, movement restriction, and
psychological anxiety) were able to explain more
than 38.8% of the variance in e-commerce.
The variables (home quarantine, movement
restriction, and psychological anxiety) have been
able to explain more than 38% of the variance in e-
commerce.
6 Discussion
The results of the hypothesis test were accepted, and
the most important results from Table 6 are as
follows:
There is a positive, direct, statistically
significant effect of home quarantine on the
orientation of individuals toward e-commerce.
There is a positive, direct, statistically
significant impact of movement restriction on the
orientation of individuals toward e-commerce.
There is a positive, direct, statistically
significant effect of psychological anxiety on the
attitude of individuals toward e-commerce.
We predict that if COVID-19 persists, and even
after its end, electronic trade in Saudi Arabia will
rise by more than 50%. As a result, the coronavirus
pandemic has positively affected e-commerce by
gaining unprecedented government support and
consumer orientation, which has led to a significant
increase in demand.
Since the movement restriction and home quarantine
measures were implemented in March 2020, the use
of electronic shopping has become the best option
for Saudi Arabian customers to fulfill all their
needs. This has contributed to a substantial rise in
customer payments in Saudi Arabia, which have
risen by 15% in March 2020 relative to February
2020 and by 239% relative to March 2019. This is
confirmed by the results of the study.
The psychological anxiety of contracting COVID-
19 and the lack of certain products have contributed
to the behavior of storing products and purchasing
more than the normal need due to a fear of such
products not being available at a later date. The
Ministry of Commerce has released a study
describing the increased demand for nutritional,
pharmaceuticals, personal care, sports, and
entertainment products.
Our empirical result is in line with 2 for the case of
Indian and not compatible with that of 9 for the case
of Malysia. However, this work has probably biased
results because of the econometric technique used
(SPSS). To remedy this shortcoming, we used a
more robust technique to study the impact of
COVID-19 on e-commerce.
7 Conclusion
In light of these ambiguous conditions that
humanity is going through, e-commerce is a
glimmer of hope that store owners cling to in their
various fields and cultures, and the boom in
electronic shopping on the Internet is nothing but an
opportunity to obtain a grant from the depths of
ordeal. Although no medicament has been
discovered to recover from infection with the
Coronavirus (Covid 19) until now, where the
electronic stores may be considered as a
medicament that will save millions of markets and
shops from loss and bankruptcy. This paper attempts
to investigate the impact of Coronavirus spread on
E-Commerce in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Using a survey, the results prove that the spread of
the Corona virus has resulted in a boom in remote
work in general, and electronic commerce in
particular, after logging out from the typical method
adopted in the labor market (attendance at the
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
833
Volume 19, 2022
workplace), so everyone has resorted to electronic
services and new tools that allow them to adapt to
The exceptional circumstances prevailing today,
which made technology and internet sector
companies the biggest beneficiaries of this
pandemic, not to mention the emergence of a real
revolution around remote work.
E-commerce has become a tangible reality in the
world, and this supports the information and
communication technology revolution that has
resonated in all aspects of life. The following are
some of the proposals directed at developing and
increasing the volume of e-commerce in the
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, whether during the crisis
or even after the end of the crisis, so that this
becomes an approach that the state adopts to
compensate for part of the negative effects of the
Corona virus on the Saudi economy on the one hand
and to develop and raise e-commerce revenues and
their contribution to national income from, on the
other hand. The following are the most important
proposed actions and measures: (i) Developing the
national strategy for e-commerce and emphasizing
its concept and adopting its activities and pillars at
the Kingdom's level; (ii) Adopting the national
digital identity and smart card for every citizen; (iii)
Encouraging all banks to establish a sophisticated
banking system that accepts electronic commercial
transactions and adopting electronic payment
systems; (iv) Developing information security
software and enhancing the protection of bank data
and protecting electronic transactions between all
electronic transactions; and (v) Developing stores
and stores websites and establishing a simplified
policy for refunding or exchanging products.
The world is changing, and a person must change
with it in order to survive. According to some
forecasts, the future of e-commerce will develop. It
is expected that in the next few years, e-commerce
investors will acquire more customers, and the
market will impose more modern and sophisticated
mechanisms and methods, and everyone who wants
to stay in the market will have to keep pace with
modern trends to meet not only the requirements of
the market but the requirements of the entire era.
Acknowledgments:
The authors extend their appreciation to the
Deanship of Scientific Research at Jouf University
for funding this work through research grant No
(DSR-2021-04-0312).
References:
[1] IMF Report. (2020). Regional Economic
Outlook: The Middle East and Central
Asia.
[2] Nakhate, S. B., & Jain, N. (2020). The
effect of coronavirus on e-commerce.
Studies in Indian Place Names, 40(68),
516518.
[3] Bhatti, A., Akram, H., Basit, H. M., Khan,
A. U., Naqvi, S. M. R., & Bilal, M.
(2020). E-commerce trends during
COVID-19 pandemic. International
Journal of Future Generation
Communication and Networking, 13(2),
14491452.
[4] Karimi-Zarchi, M., Neamatzadeh,
H.,Dastgheib, S., Abbasi, H., Mirjalili,
S.,& Behforouz, A. et al. (2020).
VerticalTransmission of Coronavirus
Disease 19(COVID-19) from Infected
PregnantMothers to Neonates: A Review.
FetalAnd Pediatric Pathology, 1-5.
[5] Bhatti, A., Akram, H., Basit, H. M., Khan,
A. U., Naqvi, S. M. R., & Bilal, M.
(2020). E-commerce trends during
COVID-19 pandemic. International
Journal of Future Generation
Communication and Networking, 13(2),
14491452.
[6] Nakhate, S. B., & Jain, N. (2020). The
effect of coronavirus on e-commerce.
Studies in Indian Place Names, 40(68),
516518.
[7] Koch, J., Frommever, B., Schewe, G.,
2020. Online Shopping Motives during
the COVID-19 PandemicLessons from
the Crisis. Sustainability, 12(24), 10247.
[8] Alber, N. (2020). The effect of
coronavirus spread on stock markets: The
case of the worst 6 countries. SSRN.
https://ssrn.com/abstract=3578080
[9] Hasanat, M.W., Hoque, A., Shikha, F.A.,
Anwar, M., Hamid, A.B.A.,Tat, H.H.,
2020. The Impact of Coronavirus (Covid-
19) on E-Business in Malaysia. Asian
Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies, Vol.
3, No. 1.
[10] Li, C.-Y. 2019. How social commerce
constructs influence customers’ social
shopping intention? An empirical study of
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
834
Volume 19, 2022
a social commerce website. Technol.
Forecast. Soc. Chang. 144, 282294.
[11] Loxton, M.; Truskett, R.; Scarf, B.;
Sindone, L.; Baldry, G.; Zhao, Y. 2020.
Consumer Behaviour during Crises:
Preliminary Research on How
Coronavirus Has Manifested Consumer
Panic Buying, Herd Mentality, Changing
Discretionary Spending and the Role of
the Media in Influencing Behaviour.
JRFM, 13, 166.
[12] Abdelrhim, M., & Elsayed, A. (2020). The
effect of COVID-19 spread on the e-
commerce market: The case of the 5
largest e-commerce companies in the
world. SSRN.
https://ssrn.com/abstract=3621166.
[13] Pandey, A., & Parmar, J. (2019). Factors
affecting consumer’s online shopping
buying behavior. In Proceedings of 10th
International Conference on Digital
Strategies for Organizational Success.
[14] Naseri, M.B., Greg Elliott, G.,2011. Role
of demographics, social connectedness
and prior internet experience in adoption
of online shopping: Applications for direct
marketing. Journal of Targeting,
Measurement and Analysis for Marketing,
19(2), 69-84.
[15] Brown , M . , Pope , N .and Voges , K .(
2003 ) Buying or browsing? An
exploration of shopping orientations and
online purchase intention . European
Journal of Marketing 37 (11/12): 1666
1684 .
[16] Donthu , N .and Garcia , A .( 1999 ) The
internet shopper . Journal of Advertising
Research 39 (3): 52 58.
[17] Kim , E . Y .and Kim , Y . K .( 2004 )
Predicting online purchase intention for
clothing products . European Journal of
Marketing 38 (7): 883 897
[18] Goldsmith , R . E .and Flynn , L . R .(
2005 ) Bricks, clicks, and pix: Apparel
buyers ’use of stores, internet, and
catalogs compared . International Journal
of Retail &Distribution Management 33
(4) : 271 283.
[19] Bhatnagar , A . , Misra , S .and Rao , H .
R .( 2000 ) On risk, convenience, and
internet shopping behavior .
Communications of the ACM 43 (11): 98
105.
[20] Brunner , C .and Bennett , D .( 1997 )
Technology and gender: Differences in
masculine and feminine views . NASSP
Bulletin 81 (592): 46 52 .
[21] Dholakia , R . R .and Chiang , K . P .(
2003 ) Shoppers in cyberspace: Are they
from Venus or Mars and does it matter .
Journal of Consumer Psychology 13 (1/2)
: 171 176.
[22] Firat , A . F .and Dholakia , N .( 1998 )
Consuming People: From Political
Economy to Theatres of Consumption.
London: Routledge.
[23] Lightner , N . J . , Yenisey , M . M . ,
Ozok , A . A .and Salvendy , G . ( 2002 )
Shopping behaviour and preferences in e-
commerce of Turkish and American
University students: Implications from
cross-cultural design . Behaviour
&Information Technology 21 (6) : 373
385 .
[24] Bartel-Sheehan , K .( 1999 ) An
investigation of gender differences in on-
line privacy concerns and resultant
behaviours . Journal of Interactive
Marketing 13 (4) : 24 38 .
[25] Kolsaker , A .and Payne , C .( 2002 )
Engendering trust in e-commerce: A study
of gender-based concerns . Marketing
Intelligence &Planning 20 (4) : 206 214
.
[26] Tenenhaus, M., Amato, S., & Esposito
Vinzi, V. (2004). A global goodness-of-fit
index for PLS structural equation
modelling. In Proceedings of the XLII SIS
Scientific Meeting (Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 739
742).
[27] Chin, W. W. (1998). The partial least
squares approach to structural equation
modeling. Modern methods for business
research, 295(2), 295e336.
[28] Falk, R.F. and Miller, N.B. (1992) A
Primer for Soft Modeling. University of
Akron Press, Akron.
[29] Croutsche, J. J. (2002). Étude des relations
de causalité: Utilisation des modèles
d'équations structurelles (approche
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
835
Volume 19, 2022
méthodologique). La Revue des Sciences
de Gestion: Direction et Gestion, (198),
81.
[30] Fernandes, V. (2012). En quoi l'approche
PLS est-elle une méthode a (re)-découvrir
pour les chercheurs en management?
Management, 15(1), 102123.
[31] Wetzels, M., Odekerken-Schröder, G., &
Van Oppen, C. (2009). Using PLS path
modeling for assessing.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on BUSINESS and ECONOMICS
DOI: 10.37394/23207.2022.19.72
Mehdi Abid, Houcine Benlaria, Zouheyr Gheraia
E-ISSN: 2224-2899
836
Volume 19, 2022