A Photographic Approach
Studying the Orientation of the occlusal plane
of the Malaysian Population. A Proposal for an Orienting Device
LAITH MAHMOUD ABDULHADI AL-SAMAWI, HANAA ABBAS MOHAMMED, HUMAM
LAITH
Department of Prosthetic Dentistry
Mahsa University
Jalan SP 2, Bandar Saujana Putra, Selangor,
MALAYSIA
Abstract:- The occlusal plane is crucial in prosthodontic reconstructive treatment as it affects the most
important factors for the proper functioning of the artificial prostheses. The achievement of correct occlusal
plane position offers maximum aesthetic, phonetic, mastication, and patient’s satisfaction. An incorrectly
oriented occlusal plane interferes with denture stability and retention, in addition to more vital functions of the
teeth and oral cavity. This study used a photographic approach to determine the occlusal plane inclination in
relation to some anatomical references. 95 young volunteers of Mahsa University College, aged between 20
and 25 years, were selected for this study. The participants were selected according to specific inclusion
criteria. A standardized digital profile and front images were taken for each participant using a digital camera
that is fixed on a tripod with the fox bite plane placed on the occlusal surfaces of the maxillary teeth. The angle
amplitude of the reference planes in relation to the occlusal plane was measured using a digital protractor on the
screen display. The results revealed that the least mean angle difference was with the AT1, while higher
variability was found using the Frankfort plane. In addition, there were no significant differences between the
two genders or among the three ethnic groups. It is concluded that the photographic method can be used
successfully to study the occlusal plane, and the lowest point of the tragus is the best posterior reference point
to determine the ideal location of the occlusal plane.
Key-Words:- Orientation of the occlusal plane, Camper plane, Frankfort plane, Mandibular plane, Orienting
device
Received: November 23, 2023. Revised: April 11, 2024. Accepted: May 22, 2024. Published: June 26, 2024.
1 Introduction
The occlusal plane is “an imaginary surface that is
related anatomically to the cranium and that
theoretically touches the incisal edges of the incisors
and the tips of the occluding surfaces of the
posterior teeth. It is not a plane in the true sense of
the word but represents the mean curvature of the
surface” [1]. The height of the lower canine, which
nearly lines up with the mouth commissure,
determines it anteriorly, as does the height of the
retromolar pad, which defines it posteriorly. One of
the elements in both natural and artificial tooth
occlusion is the occlusal plane. It offers an
important role in oral and dental rehabilitation and is
essential for restoring the stomatognathic system's
function and aesthetics [2].
1.1 Reference and Anatomical Landmarks
In studying and analyzing the components of the
stomatognathic system, some references (anatomical
and imaginary) should be well defined to understand
the relation and configuration of the system when
rehabilitation of occlusion in edentulous patients is
addressed. Therefore, some important references are
defined in this section.
1.1.1 Frankfort plane
Is a horizontal plane established on the cranium by
joining the orbitale, which is the lowest point in the
margin of the bony orbit (the lowest point on the
inferior edge of the orbit) and the highest point in
the margin of the external auditory meatus (the
porion; the superior surface of the external auditory
meatus). In craniometry, the porion is identified as
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
116
Volume 3, 2024
the margin of the bony canal on the skull. This plane
is used as a reference for most of the anatomical
parts of the skull. It orients the skull parallel to the
horizontal plane. It forms a variable angle with the
occlusal plane (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1: Some facial landmarks and reference lines or
planes
P; porion, T; tragus, O; orbitale, A; ala of the nose,
1; lower limit of tragus, 2; middle point of tragus, 3;
upper limit of tragus,T-A; ala-tragus or Camper line,
P-O; Frankfort plane or line.
1.1.2 Camper’s line
A line from the lower border of the ala of the nose
to the upper border of the tragus of the ear. The
camper line becomes a plane when the imaginary
lines connect the two alae of the nose anteriorly and
the tragus posteriorly. Approximately, it is parallel
to the occlusal plane (Fig. 1).
1.1.3 Interpupillary line
An imaginary line that passes between the centers of
the pupils of the two eyes is parallel to the
horizontal plane. The anterior part of the maxillary
occlusal plane should be parallel to the
interpupillary line. It should be 2mm below the
upper lip line or smile line [2]. This line is
indispensable to validating the parallelism between
the anterior tooth edges and the eyes (Fig. 2).
1.1.4 The curve of Spee
It is the antero-posterior curve line that extends
from the tip of the lower canine and follows the
buccal cusps of the mandibular posterior teeth
(Fig. 3) [2].
1.1.5 The curve of Wilson
It is a mediolateral curve that touches the buccal
and lingual cusps of molars on both sides of the
dental arch (Fig. 4) [2].
Fig. 2: Interpupillary line
P; centre of the pupil of the eye
Fig. 3: Curve of Spee
Fig. 4: The curve of Wilson
1.1.6 The importance of the occlusal plane
Clinicians have recognized that the occlusal plane
should be at a right angle to the occlusal forces for
stability of the occlusion, head, and neck
musculature and the maximum benefits of occlusion
forces that minimize muscle fatigue and promote a
healthy functioning system [2], [3], [4]. The path of
mandibular closure depends on the head and
cervical neck postural angle and inclination and
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
117
Volume 3, 2024
should be perpendicular to the long axis of occlusal
forces produced by an optimal cervical posture and
an optimized mandibular closing path [3].
The inclination of the occlusal plane (IOP) is one of
the key factors governing occlusal balance. Studies
using cephalometrics have shown that the occlusal
plane inclination during craniofacial growth relative
to various facio-cranial reference lines varied in
anterior rotation during growth. The most
significant changes in the occlusal plane inclination
were from the maxillary base, Frankfort horizontal,
and cranial base reference lines. Small but
significant correlational changes have been reported
with these reference lines. It has also been reported
that no significant differences according to sexes
have been Occlusal plane inclination and angle are
important factors that harmonize the morphology
and function of the stomatognathic system [4].
It also influences the masticatory closing pattern in
the sagittal plane. Anterior convex closure patterns
dominate when the occlusal plane is inclined in the
anterior direction. In contrast, the majority of
posterior convex closure patterns were induced by
the posteriorly inclined occlusal plane. The
appearance of these types seemed to reflect a
harmonious relationship between the inclination of
the occlusal plane, tooth guidance, and other central
and peripheral controls. The correlation between the
inclination of the occlusal plane and masticatory
closing movement serves as a functional
background to the significance of the occlusal plane
inclination [5].
The determination of OP is an important step before
the construction of full-arch restorative, orthodontic,
and full-denture-type cases. Evaluating and
assessing the bilateral occlusal plane of the
maxillary arch for symmetry, balance, and form is
desirable to meet the demands of function and
appearance. The IOP often reflects occlusal
dysfunction along with often-associated periodontal
problems as well as temporomandibular
disorders. The determination of OP inclination has
been found to be valuable during the diagnostic and
rehabilitation treatment phases. It is the opinion of
many that the right- and left-side antero-posterior
OP angle should be evaluated before any major
treatment or rehabilitation program, whether
prosthetic or orthodontic, is undertaken.
It was reported that occlusal level alteration and
masticatory imbalance have effect on the cervical
spine. It may result in displacement of the cervical
spine; in contrast, a chopping or more vertical-type
closure pattern was observed predominately in cases
with an anterior inclining occlusal plane. The
importance of the inclination of the occlusal plane
during masticatory movement in the excursive
functional movement is much greater and of
significance through the closing phase, except near
the terminal intercuspal position. So, an anterior
occlusal plane inclination or slope is important and
significant in order to optimize the masticatory
function in prosthodontic replacements. In
contrast, a chopping or more vertical-type closure
pattern was observed predominately in cases with an
anterior inclining occlusal plane. So, an anterior
occlusal plane inclination or slope is important and
significant in order to optimize the masticatory
function in prosthodontic replacements.
1.1.7 General importance of OP in dentistry
During the tooth arrangement of artificial teeth, the
occlusal plane acts as a crucial guide for optimum
placement and inclination of the teeth on the denture
bases. It constitutes an important factor with the
other constituents of occlusion for occlusal harmony
during centric and eccentric mandibular movements.
This relationship of harmony (H) was described as
quints of Hanau. The factors include condylar
inclination (CG), incisal guidance (IG), occlusal
plane inclination (OP) , the compensating curve
(CC), and cuspal inclination (CI). This harmony (H)
is represented in equation:
H = CG x IG/OP x CI x CC [6].
1.1.8 Importance of OP in oral rehabilitation
The level and orientation of the occlusal plane are
the most important factors in prosthetic restorations.
In fact, the occlusal plane must ensure a perfect
distribution of occlusal forces on abutment teeth
during intercuspation, preserve prosthetic stability in
eccentric movements and contribute to restore
aesthetics and phonetics. Distortions in the occlusal
plane may be due to malpositioning of the
remaining teeth: versions, regressions, and rotations,
in addition to malformation of hard and soft tissues
in dentulous or edentulous areas. Restoring balance
may appear complicated, for it concerns the four
following factors: the sagittal orientation, the frontal
orientation and the occlusal curvature radius: frontal
(curve of Wilson) and sagittal (curve of Spee).
1.1.8.1 Stabilizing Role
The occlusal plane contributes to stabilizing the
removable prosthesis during centric as well as
during eccentric movements. During centric
relation, occlusal forces stabilize the complete
prosthesis when transmitted forces are perpendicular
to the abutment surface. During eccentric
movements, a bilaterally balanced occlusion
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
118
Volume 3, 2024
depends on an adequate orientation of the occlusal
plane.
1.1.8.2 Functional Role
Aesthetics; anterior upper and lower mal-positioned
teeth affect aesthetics. The position of incisal edges
could be corrected according to aesthetic criteria
and phonetic elements. However, the occlusal
correction of maxillary natural teeth should be
always carried out carefully without altering the
patient’s aesthetics. On the other hand, it is often
easier to correct the incisal edge of mandibular teeth
[ 7 ].
Phonetics; the arrangement of the anterior teeth will
affect phonetics as well as aesthetics. The proximity
of the upper and lower anterior teeth during
protrusive movements, for example, will determine
the 'c','s', and‘t’ sounds. The relationship between
the upper anterior teeth and the lip will affect the ‘f’
and ‘v’ sounds. As well as facilitating interpersonal
communication, there is a social expectation that
phonetic patterns will be affected in a specific way.
Thus, the absence of anterior teeth (anterior part of
the occlusal plane) can affect self-image as well as
speech [3],[ 4].
Excessive lateral deviation around posterior teeth to
develop socially acceptable speech patterns will
require adaptation of the jaw neuromuscular system.
Exceeding the physiological ‘adaptability’ of one or
more of these components may result in pain and
dysfunction. The length of incisors, the degree of
horizontal and vertical overlaps, the angle of
condylar inclination, and the curve of the occlusal
plane will influence anterior tooth approximation
during protrusion. These factors, except condylar
inclination, may be modified by restorative
procedures. Tooth form and tooth arrangement
should therefore ensure the absence of posterior
contacts during protrusive jaw movements, and this
will be facilitated by developing a correct occlusal
plane level and inclination. Thus, restorative
procedures, which influence phonetics, may also
affect the patient’s psychological and physiological
well-being [8].
The masticatory system as a whole forms a
functional unit, which consists of the dentition, the
periodontium, the jaws, the temporomandibular
joints, the muscles involved in moving the
mandible, the lip-cheek-tongue system, the salivary
system, and the neuromuscular and nutritive
(vascular) mechanisms involved in the maintenance
of proper function.
For tooth replacement, the most important factors
that have to be taken into account are the inclination
of the occlusal plane and the vertical distance.
A faulty orientation of the occlusal plane will
jeopardize interaction between the tongue and the
buccinator muscle. Where the occlusal plane is too
high, the tongue cannot rest on the lingual cusp of
the mandibular denture teeth and prevent its
displacement. There is also a tendency for the food
to accumulate in the buccal and lingual sulci [9].
An occlusal plane that is too low or too high could
lead to tongue and cheek biting and difficulty
swallowing as well [10].
2 Problem Formulation
The orientation of occlusal plane needs a fixed
reference or anatomical landmarks that ensure
fixity , repeatability and reliability for proper
reproduction. Therefore, due to the variability of the
references used and the complexity of the proposed
methods, this research was conducted to find an
easy, reliable method to teach and to apply in daily
practice in Malaysian people (Malay, Chinese, and
Indians). With the perpetual progress in artificial
intelligence and simulation models application in
medical, teaching and research fields, this work can
be included as a small routine to achieve a correct
OP when digital occlusal and oral rehabilitation
systems are designed for diagnosis and patient
treatment [11]. Usually, teeth replacement and
rehabilitation of edentulous patients are done either
using the classical manual method or the digital-
oriented technique. The next procedure after making
an impression of the residual ridges is to record the
maxillomandibular relationship. The record includes
the determination of the OP inclination, the
registration of vertical dimension height [12], the
recording of centric and eccentric relations, and
finally the arrangement of artificial teeth. Therefore,
a reliable reference landmark should be used to
transfer the maxillomandibular relationship to a
simulation dental device.
2.1 The gathering of data
Data were collected from MAHSA University
students. 95 healthy students aged 20–25 years
participated in the study. Ethical approval was
gained, and consent forms were signed. Each
participant had the following criteria: full, healthy
dentition; absence of attrition or extensive
restorations; absence of orthodontic treatment;
healthy temporomandibular joint.
The following anatomical landmarks were marked
on each participant's face (Fig. 1).
To ensure the reliability of the reference line
measurements on the patients using printed photos
or digital images, 30 patients were selected
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
119
Volume 3, 2024
randomly, and the reference points were marked off
on the face and then photographed using a digital
camera fixed to a tripod. Profile and frontal photos
were taken while the subject was sitting in an
upright position with his or her head supported
vertically by the head rest of the dental chair. The
distance, magnification, level, and height of the
camera were fixed (Fig. 5, Fig. 6).
Fig. 5: Profile imaging of the patient
Fig. 6: patient frontal photo-shooting
The anatomical landmarks that were used as
reference points were marked directly on the face
using different marking colors. Profile and front
photos were taken from a fixed distance and
position, while the Fox bite was fixed on the
occlusal surfaces and incisal edges of the maxillary
teeth, supported by the fingers of the examiners.
Thirty profile photos were printed on paper. Angle
measurements were done indirectly (on papers) and
directly (on the screen) for the same cases to check
the reliability of records by three examiners.
The decision was to do the photo analysis directly
on the personal computer screen after approving the
reliability and coincidence of the measurements on
the screen and the photos.
The reference landmarks that were marked on the
face (Fig. 1, Fig. 2) are:
Left and right orbitales (LO, RO)
Three locations on each ear tragus: lower, middle,
and upper (T1, T2, T3)
Lower border of the ala of the nose (A)
The reference planes and lines that were used in this
study are:
Frankfort plane (FP): from the upper border of the
tragus to the left orbitale
Ala-Tragus lines from three posterior reference
points on the tragus:
LAT1: left ala-tragus line from the lower border of
the tragus to the lower border of the ala of the nose
LAT2: left ala-tragus line from the middle border of
the tragus to the lower border of the ala of the nose
LAT3: left ala-tragus line from the upper border of
the tragus to the lower border of the ala of the nose
RAT1: right ala-tragus line from the lower border of
the tragus to the lower border of the ala of the nose
RAT2: right ala-tragus line from the middle border
of the tragus to the lower border of the ala of the
nose
RAT3: right ala-tragus line from the upper border of
the tragus to the lower border of the ala of the nose
Occlusal line on left side (LOP) and right side
(ROP):
All the information was transferred to the case sheet
designed for this study.
As mentioned before, three examiners analyzed the
photos and measured the angulation of each line or
plane in relation to references independently. The
results were compared to those on the computer
screen using digital ruler software (MB ruler) [13].
2.2 Data analysis
Descriptive statistics were used to explore the
features of the sample (composition, standard
deviation, mean age and angle, variance, maximum
and minimum records, and normal distribution).
Inter-examiner reliability tests were performed
using Pearson correlation for the three examiners
who calculated the angle variability of the lines and
planes in relation to the occlusal plane on the photos
and computer screen independently. The difference
between right and left side records in relation to sex
and ethnicity was tested using paired t-tests. The
fixity of each reference line was tested in relation to
the occlusal plane using the coefficient of variability
to advise on the best one for clinical daily use.
3 Problem Solutions
3.1 Reliability of the measurements
3.1.1 Inter-examiner reliability
Three examiners measured a group of data
independently to ensure the reliability and precision
of the measurements. The results were highly
positive at p<.001, Table 1, Table 2.
1 examiner
2 examiner
P=.996*
-
P=.972**
P=.971***
*Significant, (DF = 28), p<.001, (2-tailed)
**Significant, (DF = 28), p<.001, (2-tailed)
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
120
Volume 3, 2024
***Significant, (DF = 28),p<.001,(2-tailed)
Table 1. The inter-examiner reliability of the 3
examiners for LAT1 records. P; Pearson correlation
Table 2. The inter-examiner reliability of the 3
examiners for LAT2 records. P; Pearson correlation
3.1.2 Inter-media reliability
The angles between some assigned reference planes
or lines were recorded on the computer monitor
using software (MB-Ruler), and on printed
photographs manually, and they were compared to
estimate the dependability by three examiners. The
results were linear, highly significant, and positive
(P = 0.995, DF = 28, at p<.001), Fig. 7.
Fig. 7: Inter-media Reliability for records on paper
and computer monitor
3.2 The composition of the sample
The sample was composed of 33 Malays, 32
Chinese, and 30 Indians (Fig. 8).
Fig. 8: Ethnic composition, C; Chinese, I; Indians,
M; Malays
While, for the gender composition of the sample, the
females constitute two times the males.
(Fig. 9).
Fig. 9: Gender inclusion of the sample
F; females, M; males
3.3 The other features of the sample
3.3.1 The mean angle between the OP and
reference lines on the two facial sides in relation
to gender
The mean angles between the different reference
lines, the occlusal plane on the two sides of the face
and the Frankfort plane are shown in Table 3 . No
statistical difference was found between the males
and females on the two facial sides.
32
30
33
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
C I M
Ethnic groups composition of the sample
65
30
0
50
100
F M
Gender composition of the sample
1 examiner
2 examiner
2 examiner
P=.935**
-
3 examiner
P=.982**
P=.919**
*Significant, ( DF= 28), p<.001, (2 -tailed)
**Significant, ( DF= 28), p<.001, (2 -tailed)
***Significant, ( DF= 28), p<.001, (2 -tailed)
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
121
Volume 3, 2024
Table 3. The records of the differences in angle
degrees between the occlusal plane and different
reference lines on the two sides of the face in males
and females
G;gender, N;number, M.A; mean angle, P-val.; p-
value, RAT1-ROP; right lower ala tragus line-right
occlusal plane, RAT2-ROP; right middle ala-tragus
line-right occlusal plane, RAT3-ROP; right upper
ala-tragus line-right occlusal plane, ROP-FP; right
occlusal plane-Frankfort plane, LAT1-LOP; left
lower ala tragus line-left occlusal plane, LAT2-
LOP; left middle ala-tragus line-left occlusal plane,
LAT3; left upper ala-tragus line-left occlusal plane,
LOP-FP; left occlusal plane-Frankfort plane.
3.3.2 The mean angle between the OP and RL in
relation to ethnic groups of the sample
The differences between the records on the right and
left sides of the face were not significant at p<0.00
for the different ethnic groups (Table 4).
Ethn; ethnicity, No; number, SD; standard deviation
M; Malays, C; Chinese, I; Indians
RAT1-ROP; right lower ala tragus line-right
occlusal plane, RAT2-ROP; right middle ala-tragus
line-right- occlusal plane, RAT3-ROP; right upper
ala-tragus line- right occlusal plane, ROP-FP; right
occlusal plane-Frankfort plane, LAT1-LOP; left
lower ala-tragus line-left occlusal plane, LAT2-
LOP; left middle ala-tragus line-left occlusal plane,
LAT3; left upper ala-tragus line- left occlusal plane,
LOP-FP; left occlusal plane-Frankfort plane.
3.3.3 Records comparison on the two sides of the
face for the whole sample
The statistical analysis of the mean records on the
two sides of the face for the whole sample, showed
no difference except for the angle between the
occlusal plane to Frankfort plane, Table 5.
Table 5. Difference between the mean records on
right and left sides of the face in different ethnic
groups for the whole sample.RS; right side,LS; left
side,
Angles
G
N
M.A
SD±
P- val
RAT1-
ROP
M
30
-0.58
3.79
.856
F
65
-0.42
4.54
RAT2-
ROP
M
30
1.64
4.02
.456
F
65
2.31
4.65
RAT3-
ROP
M
30
4.08
4.67
.334
F
65
5.02
4.41
ROP-FP
M
30
9.63
4.23
.355
F
65
8.68
4.80
LAT1-
LOP
M
30
0.36
4.47
.255
F
65
-0.82
5.02
LAT2-
LOP
M
30
2.41
4.04
.796
F
65
2.16
4.67
LAT3-
LOP
M
30
4.83
4.92
4.64
.97
F
65
4.87
LOP-FP
M
30
10.44
3.98
.577
F
65
10.96
5.09
Angles
Ethn
No
Mean
SD±
RAT1-ROP
M
33
0.63
3.9
I
30
-1.30
4.7
C
32
-0.82
4.2
RAT2-ROP
M
33
3.15
4.0
I
30
2.01
4.8
C
32
1.09
4.3
RAT3-ROP
M
33
6.27
4.0
I
30
3.99
4.4
C
32
3.80
4.8
ROP-FP
M
33
8.31
4.3
I
30
8.22
4.9
C
32
10.39
4.5
LAT1-LOP
M
33
0.71
3.7
I
30
-1.14
5.6
C
32
-0.98
5.1
LAT2-LOP
M
33
3.15
4.0
I
30
2.08
5.2
C
32
1.26
4.2
LAT3-LOP
M
33
6.17
4.2
I
30
4.84
5.4
C
32
3.52
4.3
LOP-FP
M
33
9.83
4.3
I
30
10.08
5.5
C
32
12.46
4.2
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
122
Volume 3, 2024
Table 4. The mean angles between occlusal plane
and reference lines in relation to ethnic groups in the
sample
RS
P value
LS
P- value
M \ I
.08
M\ I
.124
I \ C
.66
I\ C
.907
M \ C
.154
M \ C
.130
M; Malays, I; Indians, C; Chinese
3.3.4 The variability of the mean angle
measurements for the whole sample (right and
left sides)
The coefficient of variability between the sample
records of the OP in relation to the reference lines
and plane is shown in Table 1. The least variable
record was OP to FP; hence, the Frankfort plane
may be considered the most reliable and least
variable reference when used to orient the occlusal
plane compared to the Camper line (Table 6).
Table 6 The variability coefficient of the used
reference lines and plane in relation to occlusal
plane
Mn; minimum record, Mx; maximum record, M;
mean record, SD; standard deviation, CV;
coefficient of variability
AT1; ala-tragus lower point, AT2; ala-tragus middle
point, AT3; ala-tragus upper point,OP-FP; occlusal
plane-Frankfort plane.
3.4 Discussion
Data collection and measurements on soft tissues
were impossible due to the mobility of the skin and
underlying tissues; therefore, the photographic
technique provides the best precision and is risk-free
due to the radiation hazards when radiography is
used, as in many research studies. In addition, the
repeatability and precision of records were excellent
and within tolerable variability. The results showed
that no difference is estimated for most of the
records on the face profiles (right and left), due to
gender and ethnic group. These findings may
support the hypothesis that the occlusal plane is
affected mainly by occlusion components rather
than anatomical factors. The only reference that
showed less variability is the Frankfort plane.
Therefore, this plane is considered the best approved
reference to locate the occlusal plane during
rehabilitation procedures in completely and partially
edentulous patients and to resolve
temporomandibular problems associated with faulty
occlusion. The results were applied to design a
simple device that uses the Frankfort plane as a
reference (Fig. 10). The device consists of two
plastic straps or rulers and two ear pieces of 10mm
diameter to locate the porion inside the external
auditory meatus. A horizontal metallic or plastic bar
attaches to the lateral straps and the ear pieces and is
equipped with an anterior nasal extension to fix the
device to the correct place on the face and form the
Frankfort plane. The lateral straps are adjustable to
fit the face parallel to the Frankfort plane. A camper
plane or ala-tragus line is used in oral
restoration that offers more freedom or less
precision, like total rehabilitation. The tooth form
and tooth arrangement should therefore ensure the
absence of posterior contacts during protrusive jaw
movements, and this will be facilitated by
developing a correct occlusal plane level and
inclination. Thus, restorative procedures, which
influence phonetics, may also affect the patient’s
psychological and physiological well-being [14].
Rehabilitation of oral cavity procedures and practice
should be carried out continuously to enhance the
quality of the offered treatment service [15], [16],
and [17].A simulation model can profit from this
outcome in total oral rehabilitation procedures like
digital construction of complete dentures [18],
implant-supported dentures [19], and orthodontic
diagnosis [20].
Fig.10: The proposed device for recording Occlusal
plane
4 Conclusion
Studying the occlusal plane with a digital camera
and computer offers safer, easier, and more accurate
Angle
No
Mn
Mx
M
SD±
CV%
AT1-OP
95
-11
+13
-0.41
4.56
1112
AT2-OP
95
-7
+16
+2.25
4.51
200
AT3-OP
95
-9
+17
+4.75
4.61
97
OP-FP
95
-3
+21
+10.2
4.53
44
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
123
Volume 3, 2024
recording.The ala tragus line, or Camper line,
running between the lower border of the ala of the
nose and the inferior border of the tragus showed
the least mean difference angle (-0.41 degree) to the
occlusal plane. In return, this small mean difference
does not confirm its use as a suitable reference for
establishing a new OP, like in cases with fully
edentulous arches, due to increased variability. The
high variability of CP disproves its use for occlusal
plane orientation in clinical situations that imply
more precise and less inconsistent errors.On the
other hand, the mean angle between the Frankfort
plane and the occlusal plane was +10.2 degrees,
which showed less variability during the recording
of OP. As a reference, the Frankfort plane offers the
least variability and more repeatability among the
studied references (Camper plane) at different
starting points; therefore, we support the use of the
Frankfort plane to study and record the occlusal
plane in any future research. The outcome of this
study was that a new recording device
was designed for this purpose.A simple device was
described to record and establish the occlusal plane
in daily practice, using the Frankfort plane as a
reference.Generally, no significant difference was
estimated between the males and females and the
three ethnic groups of Malaysians for the whole
record.In the future, research work is proposed to
reveal the effect of changing the inclination of the
occlusal plane anterioposteriorly as well as laterally
on the teeth and bone supporting the artificial
replacement using the mathematical method.
References:
[1] (Glossary of prosthodontic terms, 2005)
[2] Abdulhadi LM, Designing Removable Partial
Denture According To Bioprotective Principles
(Reka Bentuk Dentur Sebahagian Boleh
Tanggal Prinsip Bioperlindungan), PBM, 2015.
[3] Dawson P, Functional Occlusion: From TMJ to
Smile Design, Kindle edition, 1st ed, 2006.
[4] Okuda T, A clinical study on occlusal plane in
relation with orofacial morphology and
stomatognathic function, Osaka Daigaku
Shigaku Zasshi,Vol. 35, No. 1, 1990, pp. 369-
99
[5] Ogawa T. et al , Correlation between
inclination of occlusal plane and masticatory
movement, Journal of Dentistry, Vol. 26, No.
2,1998, pp. 105–112.
[6] Won-Suk O., Berna S., Sun-Yung BH., Quint
Described as a Formula to Quantify Balanced
Occlusion, Compendium of Continuous
Education in Dentistry,Vol.41,No.2, pp. e1-e8
[7] Al-Samawi LM, Al-Ani M, Homam L, The
effect of some parameters on natural occlusion
in different ethnicities, WSEAS Transactions on
International Journal of Applied Sciences &
Development, Vol.2, 2023, pp. 1-11.
[8] Iven K., Robert G., Occlusion and clinical
practice: an evidence-based approach. Elsevier
Health Sciences, 2004,
[9] Nissan J, et al , Relationship between occlusal
plane determinants and craniofacial structures
Journal of Oral Rehabilitation, Vol. 30, 2003,
pp. 587-91
[10] Monteith, B.D., A cephalometric method to
determine the angulation of the occlusal plane
in edentulous patients, Journal of Prosthetic
Dentistry,Vol. 54, No.1, 1985, pp. 81-7.
[11] Nevena J., Dragan S., Oral rehabilitation of a
patient using a digital protocol, Journal of
Dentistry,Vol. 121, No.6, 2022, pp. 24.
[12] Manabu K., Maiko I., Toshio A., Shunsuke M.,
Digital impression and jaw relation record for
the fabrication of CAD/CAM custom
tray,Journal of Prosthodontic Research, Vol.
62, No. 4, 2018, pp. 509-513
[13] MB rulerhttps://www.markus-bader.de/MB-
Ruler/for Chrome.php.
[14] Ash MM, Occlusion: reflections on science and
clinical reality, Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry,
Vol., 90, No. 4, 2003 , pp. 373-84
[15] Al-Samawi LM, Al-Ani HA, Laith H, The
Effect of Some Parameters on Natural
Occlusion in Different Ethnicities,
International Journal of Applied Sciences &
Development International Journal of Applied
Sciences & Development, Vol. 2, 2023, pp. 1-
11.
[16] Al-Samawi, LM ,Al-Ani H, laith H, A
mathematical method to calculate the vertical
dimension for fully edentulous malaysians
patients, Wseas Transactions On Biology and
Biomedicine, Vol. 20, 2023, pp. 33-37.
[17] Abdulhadi L.M, Mohammed H.A,
Mathematical method to calculate the central
incisor form using face records and vice versa,
International Journal of Biology and
Biomedical Engineering, Vol.6, No. 1, 2012,
pp. 9-14.
[18] George K., Theodoros T., Ioannis K., et al.,
Complete denture digital workflow: Combining
basic principles with a CAD-CAM approach,
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
124
Volume 3, 2024
The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry,Vol. 127,
No. 4, 2022, pp. 550-555
[19] Ferhan E.,Gulfem E., Isil C., Suleyman B.,
Implant-supported hybrid prosthesis:
Conventional treatment method for borderline
cases, European Journal of Dentistry,Vol. 9,
No. 3, 2015, pp. 442–448.
[20] Stelian-Mihai-Sever P., Mihaela Jana Ț.,
Dragoș Laurențiu P. et al., Modeling and
Simulating an Orthodontic System Using
Virtual Methods, Diagnostics, Vol.12,
No.1296, 2022, pp. 1-21.
Contribution of Individual Authors to the
Creation of a Scientific Article (Ghostwriting
Policy)
Laith Al-Samawi, Hanaa Al-Ani carried out the
planning, guidance, supervision, data analysis, and
writing the manuscript.
Humam has participated in data collection and
supervision of the examiners.
Follow: www.wseas.org/multimedia/contributor-
role-instruction.pdf
Sources of Funding for Research Presented in a
Scientific Article or Scientific Article Itself
No funding was received for conducting this study.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare
that are relevant to the content of this article.
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(Attribution 4.0 International, CC BY 4.0)
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en
_US
International Journal of Applied Sciences & Development
DOI: 10.37394/232029.2024.3.10
Laith Mahmoud Abdulhadi Al-Samawi,
Hanaa Abbas Mohammed, Humam Laith
E-ISSN: 2945-0454
125
Volume 3, 2024