WSEAS Review Form

Information about Reviewer (you)

Your academic and contact information

*Select Academic Title

*Email (only one email)

*First Name (Use only Latin Alphabet. Do not use extended latin alphabets)

*Last Name (Use only Latin Alphabet. Do not use extended latin alphabets)

*Academic Address (Only: University, Town, Country)

0 / 138 characters

Information about Paper

Identify the manuscript you are reviewing

*ID Number of the Paper

*Select Title of the Journal

*Title of the Paper

Your Review for the Paper

Please provide detailed comments and answer each review question

*Comments and Remarks (minimum 500 characters)

500 characters remaining

Have the authors published some papers recently in this area in the last 5 years? (Check with Google Scholar) YES NO

*References

Do the authors use references in the WSEAS format, i.e. [1], [2], [3], [4], ...? We do not allow references in the form (Authors' name, Year). Are the references relevant and do they match the in-text citations? If Reference [n] appears in the reference list, [n] must also be cited inside the main text. The Abstract must not contain connections to references.

Is the abstract thoroughly written? Does it represent the main text of the article? YES NO

Is the organisation (logical flow, use of headings) outstanding? YES NO

Is the subject matter presented in a comprehensive manner? YES NO

*Does the paper contain direction for future research and recommendations?

Is the English language appropriate? YES NO

*Are the Sections and their Paragraphs well and clearly written? Which Sections and Paragraphs need extensions and clarifications? Please specify.

*Which mathematical equations or theorems need clarifications or extensions? Are the mathematical theorems accompanied by proper numerical examples? Please specify.

*For Experimental Work: Do you believe that these experiments were really held? With what equipment and where? Are they accompanied by photos, tables and other documentation?

*For Articles in Biomedical, Financial and Social Sciences, have the authors carried out and included the appropriate statistical tests, such as t-test and Chi Square?

*What simulation, statistics, experiments or experimental analysis need extension and more clarification? In which paragraphs?

*Are the Figures and Tables duly illustrated and presented inside the text? Are they connected with the main text of the article?

*Do the authors use abbreviations without the necessary explanations? If the authors use the abbreviation GOT, what does GOT stand for?

Propose other colleagues that might review this paper

Final Recommendation Accepted after minor revision Accepted after major revision Rejected

Verification & Submission

Complete the security calculation before sending the review

Security calculation: 4 + 3 = ?

Please verify your answers before submitting the review.